Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Haunsabai v. Balakrishna Krishna Badiger .

Karnataka High Court
Feb 13, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petitioner, wife of the respondent, filed a petition under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code claiming maintenance from her husband on grounds of ill-treatment, being driven out of the house, and refusal to maintain her despite sufficient means. She also alleged that the respondent had taken another wife. The petitioner claimed Rs. 150 per month as maintenance. The respondent denied these allegations, contended that the petitioner had left voluntarily to her parents' house, and offered to maintain her if she lived with him. The trial Magistrate found that the respondent neglected to maintain the petitioner and had sufficient means, awarding Rs. 75 per month maintenance. Both parties filed revision petitions before the Sessions Judge, who allowed the respondent’s revision petition, setting aside the Magistrate’s order and dismissing the petitioner’s revision. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present revision before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sessions Judge erred in reappraising the evidence and reversing the trial Magistrate’s finding on maintenance.
  2. Whether the petitioner was required to aver and prove that she was unable to maintain herself under Section 125(1)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Sessions Judge wrongly interfered with the Magistrate’s order on reappraisal of evidence.
  • The maintenance amount awarded by the Magistrate was grossly inadequate given the rise in cost of living and should be at least Rs. 150 per month.
  • The omission to aver inability to maintain herself should not be a ground to reject the petition, as the purpose of Section 125 is to provide a speedy remedy to wives unable to maintain themselves and prevent vagrancy.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The Sessions Judge rightly reappraised the evidence because the Magistrate’s appreciation was perfunctory and capricious.
  • The petitioner failed to aver or prove that she was unable to maintain herself, which is a necessary condition under Section 125.
  • The petitioner’s allegations of ill-treatment and second marriage were not substantiated by credible evidence.
  • The petitioner had no justifiable reason to refuse to live with the respondent, who offered to maintain her.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sri Manmohan Singh…Applicant; v. Smt. Mahindra Kaur…Opp. Party. Maintenance allowance under Section 125(1)(a) can only be granted if the wife is unable to maintain herself. Supported the principle that maintenance is not automatic upon neglect but contingent on inability of wife to maintain herself; the Court relied on this to hold the petition failed for lack of such averment and proof.
Zubedabi v. Abdul Khader Wife must positively aver inability to maintain herself in addition to husband's neglect and sufficient means. Reinforced the requirement of positive averment and proof of inability to maintain oneself; the Court applied this standard in dismissing the petition.
Abdulmunaf v. Salima Interpretation of the word "unable" in Section 125(1)(a) does not exclude maintenance if wife refuses to earn; the remedy is to prevent vagrancy. The Court distinguished this precedent, noting it did not address the necessity of averment and proof of inability and thus was not applicable to the legal issue before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the evidence and found the trial Magistrate’s findings to be perfunctory and based largely on hearsay, especially regarding the alleged second marriage and ill-treatment. The Magistrate did not record definite findings on these crucial issues. The Sessions Judge was justified in reappraising the evidence and recording fresh findings that the petitioner failed to prove cruelty, neglect, or the second marriage. The respondent’s offer to maintain the petitioner if she lived with him was undisputed, and the petitioner had no justifiable reason to refuse cohabitation.

Furthermore, the Court emphasized the statutory requirement under Section 125(1)(a) Cr.P.C. that maintenance is only payable to a wife who is unable to maintain herself. The petitioner neither averred this inability in her petition nor substantiated it through evidence. The Court rejected the petitioner’s argument that this requirement was immaterial, holding that the Legislature’s insertion of “unable to maintain” was deliberate and significant. The Court noted that while the purpose of Section 125 is to provide a speedy remedy and prevent vagrancy, the legal conditions must be fulfilled. The Court distinguished the petitioner’s cited precedent as not addressing the present issue of the necessity of averment and proof of inability to maintain oneself.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision is to dismiss the revision petition.

The direct effect is that the order of the Sessions Judge allowing the respondent’s revision petition and setting aside the Magistrate’s maintenance order is upheld. The petitioner’s claim for maintenance fails due to lack of proof of inability to maintain herself and absence of credible evidence of ill-treatment or second marriage. No new precedent is established; the decision reinforces the legal requirement that a wife claiming maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. must aver and prove her inability to maintain herself.

Show all summary ...

Patil, J.:— Being aggrieved by the order dated 16th November, 1978 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Belgaum, in Cr. Revisional Petition No. 25/1978 setting aside the order dated 3rd July 1978, passed by the Principal Munsiff and J.M.F.C Hukeri, in Misc. Petition No. 75/76, wife of the respondent has filed this revision.

2. The revision petitioner, wife of the respondent, made a petition under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code claiming maintenance from the respondent, her husband, on the ground that he had ill-treated and driven out of the house and refused to maintain her in spite of being possessed of sufficient means to provide the maintenance. She also alleged, the respondent, her husband, had taken another wife in marriage. She claimed Rs. 150/- per month as maintenance.

3. Respondent denied all these allegations and further contended the petitioner had gone to her parents house on her own and had not returned. He also offered to maintain her if she lived with him. Regarding the amount of maintenance claimed, he contended, it was exhorbitant.

4. At the hearing of the petition, the petitioner examined herself as P.W 1. She also examined her father as P.W 2 and one Basappa as P.W 3 and another Rajasekaragouda, Police Patil as P.W 4. Respondent examined himself as D.W 1 and Hussain Saheb as D.W 2.

5. On the basis of the evidence before him, the learned Magistrate held, not only respondent had neglected and refused to maintain the petitioner, but he had sufficient means to provide maintenance. He negatived the stand taken by respondent and ordered to pay maintenance rate of Rs. 75/- per month from the date of the order. Questioning the correctness of the said order, both the respondent and the petitioner preferred revision petitions before the Sessions Judge. The petitioner herein filed Criminal Revision Petition No. 40 of 1978 and the respondent filed Cr. Rev. Petn. No. 25 of 1978. The learned II Additional Sessions Judge to whom the revision petitions were made over for disposal heard the two revisions simultaneously and by a common judgment and order he allowed the revision petition No. 25/7% preferred by the respondent and dismissed the petition No. 40/78 preferred by the petitioner. Being aggrieved the wife has come in revision to this court.

6. Mr. Thipperudrappa, learned Counselr appearing for the Petitioner argued, the learned Sessions Judge was wrong in inter-fearing with the order made by the Magistrate on reappraisal of the evidence and the order made fay the Sessions Judge, therefore, deserved to be set aside. He also submitted the amount of maintenance as awarded by the Magistrate was grossly inadequate and taking into consideration the rise of cost, at least minimum Rs. 150/- par month were necessary for bare maintenance of the wile and the same deserved to be awarded. As against that, Mr. B.V Deshpande, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent argued; though ordinarily the revisional court will be slow to interfere with the order made by the Magistrate, but if the appreciation of the evidence is perfunctory and capricious, it is competent for the Sessions Judge to reapprise the evidence and the appreciation of the evidence by the Magistrate being perfunctory, the Section Judge had committed no error or illegality by reappraing the evidence and therefore the order passed by the Sessions Judge did not call for any interference. He also argued, the Devision was liable to fail on another ground namely, that the petitioner had neither averred in her petitioner adduced any evidence worth the name to show that she was unable to maintain herself.

7. In view of these contentions, the question that requires to be considered is whether Sessions Judge had committed are error by reapprising the evidence and reversing the finding of the Trial Magistrate.

As rightly pointed out by Mr. Deshpaade even a outside glance is sufficient to show that the learned Magistrate recorded no definite finding about the illtreatment as alleged by the petitioner. He did not record any definite finding about the alleged second marriage. Though the petitioner alleged ill-treatment by her husband, excepting her bare say, there was no evidence worth the name adduced to show that she was ever ill-treated. A new ground of ill-treatment was tried to be made out at the enquiry by saying that the mother-in-law of the petitioner was a woman of bad character and she being in the keeping of one Basappa Pavadi, was compelling the petitioner to serve her paramour. This was not the allegation made in the petition. Here again, excepting her bare say, there was;no evidence. The evidence on the other hand showed, while Basappa Pavadi was aged about 90 years. It is mother-in-law of the petitioner was aged about 75 years. It is rather unimaginable that, at such an advanced age there would be anything like the one suggested, by the petitioner. The petition admittedly, did not attend the second marriage of her husband. She was unable to say how she came to know of the second marriage and who told her about is. None of the other witnesses examined on behalf of the petitioner state about the factum, of marriage. However, accepting the hearsay evidence, the learned Magistrate proceeded to observe:

“Though the second marriage was pot conclusively proved by the petitioner, the circumstances will justify to show that a teacher who is serving in the villages who has lead marital life only for 20 days after his marriage since 1969 is it ever possible for him to live abanding his wife for so many years?”

It is nobody's case that the second marriage, was performed stealthily; the Magistrate, however; proceeded to observe:

“It is very difficult to prove the second marriage because such marriages will be celebrated or performed stealthily and nobody will support such type of marriage.”

Since the appreciation of evidence by the Magistrate was perfunctory and capricious and the finding regarding the second marriage on the basis of which mainly the Magistrate proceeded to make an order for maintenance was based on hearsay evidence, the learned Sessions Judge was perfectly justified in reapprising the evidence and recordings his own finding both on the question of cruelty and the alleged second marriage. He has found the petitioner had failed to prove the alleged cruelty and neglect and refusal on the part of the husband-respondent. He has also found the petitioner had failed to prove, the second marriage, as alleged. There is no denial of the fact that the respondent also offered to maintain, the petitioner, if she lived with him. The petitioner, having failed to prove the second marriage as alleged by her and there being not any evidence to show the respondent was, living with any woman by name Shantha, there wire no justifiable reasons for the petitioner to refuse to live with him. Therefore, the Sessions Judge was perfectly right in allowing the revision petition and dismissing the petition for maintenance filed by the petitioner-herein.

8. As rightly pointed out by Mr. B.V Deshpande, the revision of the petitioner has also to fail for the simple reason that the petitioner neither averred nor adduced any evidence worth the name to show that she was unable to maintain herself.

9. Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides for a speedy remedy regarding the maintenance to a wife, who is unable to maintain herself. The expressions used in clause (a) of Sub-Sec. (1) of Section 125 make it clear that if a husband having sufficient means neglects or refused to maintain his wife who is unable to maintain herself then the Magistrate of the First Class may, upon proof of such neglect or refusal, would order the person so neglected or refusing, to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of his wife. The expressions “unable to maintain” have been introduced in the amended provisions of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973. Such expressions were not used in the corresponding Section 488 of the old Cr. P.C In Sri Manmohan Singh…Applicant; v. Smt. Mahindra Kaur…Opp. Party.(1) pointing out the difference and departure from Section 488 Cr. P.C 1898 and the provisions of Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure, 1973, the Allahabad High Court has held under Section 125(1)(a) the maintenance allowance cannot be granted to every wife who is neglected by her husband or whose husband refused to maintain her but it can only be granted to a wife who is unable to maintain herself. Since the petitioner in the said case did not allege in her petition that she was unable to maintain, it was held the order made by the Court below deserved to be set aside on that ground.

In Zubedabi v. Abdul Khader(2) this Court also took a similar view, and held:

“Where the wife claims maintenance under Sec. 125, she must positively aver in her petition that she is unable to maintain herself in addition to the facts that her husband has sufficient means to maintain her and that he has neglected to maintain her.”

Mr. Thipperudrappa, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner referred to a decision in Abdulmunaf v. Salima(3) of this Court and argued, attachment of the word ‘unable’ to the-word ‘wife’ in Section 125(1)(a) of the new Code did not make any difference. All that was intended by use of such expression was that a speedy remedy was available to the wife who is unable to maintain herself to prevent vagrancy. Therefore, the fact that the petitioner did not aver in the petition that she was unable to maintain herself, and did not state so in her evidence, is no ground to reject the petition.

10. It appears, the decision relied upon by Mr. Thipperudrappa has no bearing on the question of law as now raised in this case. Such a convention as raised in this revision did not arise for consideration there. The contention advanced there was the wife was educated SSLC, healthy and able bodied woman, but was refusing to work and it had therefore to be presumed that she was able to maintain herself. Considering that contention, Nesargi, J., observed: “when the object of the two provisions, i.e, in the two Codes is the same, I am of opinion that the attachment of the word ‘unable’ to the word ‘wife’ in Sec. 125(1)(3) of the new Code does not make any difference. It only means that the speedy remedy is available to a wife who is “unable to maintain herself” so that there should be prevention of vagrancy.’

Proceeding further, his Lordship also further observed:

“The fact that she has refused to earn for herself may be taken into consideration while considering the quantum of maintenance that the husband is liable to contribute towards her maintenance, as is the view expressed by the Supreme Court. But, merely because she refused to earn, it does not mean that she is not at all entitled to maintenance when the clear terms of Sec. 125(1)(a) of the new Code read with Explanation (b) to Sec. 125(1)(a) are looked into.”

The question as raised now in this revision did not arise for consideration there whether it was necessary for the wife to aver positively and prove that she was unable to maintain herself as contemplated under Sec. 125(1)(a) of the new Code.

11. It cannot also be said that the expressions ‘unable to maintain’ used by the Legislature in its wisdom were superfluous or they wore of no importance as was tried to be maintained by Mr. Thipperudrappa. I do not think the Legislature would have unnecessarily used such expression whan they were not in the old Code. In view of the various social measures and the changed conditions of the society, the Legislature in its wisdom has probably thought it necessary that maintenance to a wife as provided under Sec. 125 Cr. P.C should be provided only to a wife who is unable to maintain herself or has no sufficient means to maintain herself. The law as it stands has to be enforced, though it may in some cases work hardship on the wives. The petitioner-herein having failed to aver positively in her petition and substantiate it from the witness box that she was unable to maintain herself, the petition will have to fail.

12. In the result and for the reasons stated above, the revision is liable to be dismissed and it is accoadingly dismissed.