- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
C. Lakshmiah Setty, v. Guruswamy Aradhya And Another,
Factual and Procedural Background
The case arises from proceedings under Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiff (the decree-holder) had obtained a decree against defendant 1 (the judgment-debtor) and had certain properties attached on November 4, 1957 as belonging to defendant 1. Defendant 2 presented a claim under Rule 58 of Order XXI on June 7, 1958, asserting that the property had been sold to him by defendant 1 and his father on May 8, 1935. The claim was allowed on September 30, 1961. The plaintiff thereafter instituted a suit under Rule 63 of Order XXI on November 23, 1961 for the establishment of the title of the judgment-debtor (defendant 1) to the attached property; in that suit defendant 1 was the judgment-debtor and defendant 2 was the successful claimant in the claim proceedings.
During the pendency of the suit, defendant 1 paid the decree-holder the amount due under the decree (thereby satisfying the decree). Defendant 1 then applied to the Munsiff for transposition as a co-plaintiff so that he could continue the suit (on the theory that the plaintiff could no longer continue it after his decree had been satisfied). The Munsiff permitted the transposition. Defendant 2 challenged the correctness of that order by way of revision petition. The revisional court dismissed the revision petition and ordered that the costs of the revision petition be costs in the cause.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, after the judgment-debtor has satisfied the decree-holder by payment, the judgment-debtor can be transposed as a co-plaintiff to continue a suit instituted by the decree-holder under Rule 63 of Order XXI for the establishment of the judgment-debtor's title to attached property.
- Whether the omission by the judgment-debtor to institute his own suit under Rule 63 within the statutory period precludes him from being permitted transposition as a co-plaintiff in the decree-holder's suit.
- Whether permitting transposition would defeat any valuable right of the successful claimant (defendant 2), particularly where the claimant's remedy against the judgment-debtor may have become time-barred.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant 2's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Venkatanarasimiah)
- Once the plaintiff's decree was satisfied by defendant 1 paying the decree-holder, the suit could no longer be continued either by the plaintiff or by anyone else.
- Defendant 1 should have brought his own suit under Rule 63 of Order XXI within the statutory period; because he did not, he cannot continue the plaintiff's suit by being transposed as co-plaintiff.
- The transposition would defeat a valuable right of defendant 2 because any suit that defendant 1 might institute against defendant 2 is now time-barred; reliance was placed on Jarao Kunwar v. Bhagwan Kunwar (AIR 1921 All 184).
- Implicitly, once the decree-holder's personal interest is satisfied (decree paid), the basis for the decree-holder's suit to establish the judgment-debtor's title falls away and thus the suit cannot be continued by others.
Positions of Plaintiff / Judgment-Debtor (as reflected in the record)
- The plaintiff (decree-holder) had instituted the Rule 63 suit to establish that the attached property belonged to defendant 1 (the judgment-debtor) and not to the claimant (defendant 2), thereby seeking to realize his decree.
- Defendant 1 (the judgment-debtor) paid the decree to the decree-holder and applied for transposition as co-plaintiff so that he might continue the suit once the plaintiff could not do so after his decree was satisfied. The Munsiff granted the transposition.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhupendra Narayan Sinha v. Rajeswar Prosad Bhakat, 58 Ind App 228; AIR 1931 PC 162 | The Court's power under Order I Rule 10 (now Order 1 Rule 10) to add pro forma defendants as co-plaintiffs to remedy technical defects so as to enable a complete adjudication and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. | The court relied on this authority to justify transposition: adding the judgment-debtor as co-plaintiff is an appropriate remedy to permit a complete adjudication where technicalities (here, the plaintiff's inability to continue after satisfaction of the decree) would otherwise prevent adjudication on the merits. |
| Jarao Kunwar v. Bhagwan Kunwar, AIR 1921 All 184 | Principle that a person who could have instituted his own suit but has missed the limitation period cannot necessarily be allowed to step into another person's suit where the decree sought by the original plaintiff was solely for the plaintiff's own benefit (and the proposed substitute would obtain no benefit). | The court distinguished this authority: in Jarao Kunwar the proposed substitute would gain nothing from the original plaintiff's decree, whereas in the present case the decree sought by the plaintiff would have equally benefited defendant 1; therefore the principle in Jarao Kunwar did not apply to prevent transposition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through a series of logically connected points grounded in the text of Order XXI and Order I Rule 10:
- The court observed that an order under Rule 60 of Order XXI allowing a claimant's claim has the effect of adjudicating that the property is not the property of the judgment-debtor and, unless challenged by a suit under Rule 63 within the statutory period, that adjudication becomes conclusive even as against the judgment-debtor if he was a party to the claim proceedings.
- It was acknowledged (and not disputed by defendant 2's counsel) that because defendant 1 was a party to the claim proceedings and the claim was allowed, defendant 1 would be bound by that adjudication unless he instituted a suit under Rule 63 within the statutory period.
- The court emphasized that suits under Rule 63 could be brought by either the decree-holder (to realize his decree by sale of the attached property) or by the judgment-debtor (if he was a party to the claim proceedings) to challenge the claim allowance.
- Because the plaintiff (decree-holder) had instituted the Rule 63 suit, defendant 1 reasonably did not institute his own suit; the plaintiff's suit was intended to serve the same purpose and would have benefitted defendant 1 had it succeeded.
- When defendant 1 subsequently satisfied the decree-holder by payment, the plaintiff effectively had no reason to continue the suit; the court reasoned that technical consequences of that event should not prevent adjudication of the substantive right where the judgment-debtor has a legitimate interest in doing so.
- The court rejected the submission that the judgment-debtor's omission to bring his own suit (within the period of limitation) barred him from being transposed to continue the plaintiff's suit. The court held that, in the circumstances, it would be unreasonable to deny continuation by the judgment-debtor when the plaintiff's suit had been brought for the very purpose that also served the judgment-debtor's interests.
- The court invoked Order I Rule 10 (as expounded in Bhupendra Narayan Sinha) to stress that the court has power to permit transposition of parties to remedy technical defects and to ensure a complete adjudication and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings; applying that principle, transposition was an appropriate remedy here.
- The court distinguished Jarao Kunwar on the ground that in that case the proposed substituting party would have derived no benefit from the plaintiff's suit, whereas in the present matter the decree sought by the plaintiff would have equally benefited defendant 1; thus the Allahabad decision did not govern the present situation.
- On these bases the revisional court found no reason to disturb the order of transposition made by the Munsiff and dismissed the revision petition.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court's final decision was to dismiss the revision petition and to uphold the order of transposition made by the Munsiff. The core ruling is: Revision dismissed.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The order transposing defendant 1 (the judgment-debtor) as co-plaintiff stands, and he is permitted to continue the suit brought under Rule 63 of Order XXI which had been commenced by the decree-holder. The revision challenging that transposition was dismissed.
- Costs: The costs of the revision petition were ordered to be costs in the cause and to abide the eventual result.
- Broader precedent: The opinion relies on existing authorities (including Bhupendra Narayan Sinha) to justify transposition under procedural power in Order I Rule 10 to secure complete adjudication; the court distinguished a prior decision relied upon by defendant 2 (Jarao Kunwar) as inapplicable on its facts. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new principle beyond its application to the facts before the court.
1. In a suit brought under Rule 63 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure, by the decree-holder for the establishment of the title of his judgment-debtor, the judgment-debtor during the pendency of the suit very unwisely paid the decree-holder and satisfied his debt, and, after having done so, he asked the Court to transpose him as a co-plaintiff so that he might continue the suit which the decree-holder could no longer continue. This transposition having been permitted by the Court below, the successful claimant against whom the suit was instituted questions the correctness of the order of transposition.
2. After the decree was made against the defendant 1 in a suit brought by the plaintiff in the suit out of which this revision petition arises, he got certain properties attached on November 4, 1957, stating that those properties belonged to defendant 1. Defendant 2 presented a claim under Rule 58 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure on June 7, 1958, and his allegation was that the property had been sold to him by defendant 1 and his father, as long ago as on May 8, 1935. On September 30, 1961, that claim was allowed. On November 23, 1961, the plaintiff brought his suit under Rule 63 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure. Defendant 1 in that suit was the judgment-debtor and defendant 2 was the successful claimant.
3. Sometime during the pendency of this suit, defendant 1 paid to the decree-holder the amount due to him under his decree, and, having done that, he asked the Munsiff in whose Court the suit was pending, for his transposition as co-plaintiff. The Munsiff permitted transposition and defendant 2 questions it.
4. Mr. Venkatanarasimiah the learned Advocate for defendant 2 asks me to say that once the plaintiff's decree was satisfied by the payment of the amount of the decree by defendant 1 to him, the suit could no longer be continued either by the plaintiff or by anyone else. Defendant 1 who, according to Mr. Venkatanarasimiah, in order to overcome the effect of the order made in the claim case, should have brought his own suit under Rule 63 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure but did not, could not continue the suit brought by the decree-holder whose only purpose was the establishment of his own right to proceed against the property as the property of the judgment-debtor. If by reason of his decree having been satisfied by payment it was no longer necessary for the plaintiff to establish the judgment-debtor's title to the property attached for that purpose, it was urged that defendant 1 against whom the order in the claim case had become conclusive by reason of his not having instituted a suit within the statutory period, could not continue the suit brought by the plantiff.
5. Now, it is, I think, perfectly plain that if an order is made under Rule 60 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure and that order is one by which the claim is allowed, the meaning of that order is that the property could not be attached or proceeded against as the property of the judgment-debtor. It is this adjudication which becomes conclusive unless a suit is brought under Rule 63 or Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure within the statutory period. That suit, it is obvious, could be brought not only by the decree-holder who wished to realise his decree by the sale of the attached property, but also by the judgment-debtor if he was a party to the proceedings in which the adjudication was made.
6. Mr. Venkatanarasimiah does not dispute that if the judgment-debtor was a party to the proceedings relating to the claim and an order was made that the property was the property of the claimant, the judgment-debtor is as much affected by the adjudication as the decree-holder and that, if the judgment-debtor did not bring a suit in spite of his having been a party to the claim proceedings, the adjudication in the claim case would be conclusive even as against him.
7. Now, in this case, it is not disputed that defendant 1 who was the judgment-debtor was also a party to the proceedings relating to the claim petition. If in those proceedings it was held that the property was the property of defendant 2 and not the property of defendant 1, if defendant 1 did not bring a suit within the statutory period under Rule 63 of Order XXI of the Code, he would be precluded from contending that the order made in the claim case does not bind him. But the plaintiff who had obtained the attachment of the property felt as much dissatisfied with the order made allowing the claim as the judgment-debtor was since the effect of the order allowing the claim was to release the property from attachment. So it was that he brought his suit for the establishment of his right to proceed against the attached property which he could do only on the hypothesis that the property belonged to the judgment-debtor and not to the claimant.
8. So, in the situation, the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor could have both instituted independent suits. But if only one of them instituted a suit as in the present case and the other did not, could it be said that if for some reason the person who instituted the suit cannot continue it, the other, although he is a party to the suit, cannot take charge of the suit from the stage at which it was interupted and continue it? Now the reason why the plaintiff in this case cannot continue his suit is that there is no longer any reason for him to pursue his endeavour for the establishment of the judgment-debtor's title to the attached property.
9. It may be that the judgment-debtor himself did not bring his own suit within the period of limitation but the obvious reason why he did not do so was that the plaintiff himself had brought the suit for the very same purpose for which he could have himself brought one. If by reason of a subsequent event, it was not necessary or possible for the plaintiff to continue his suit. I fail to understand why the judgment-debtor who is defendant 1 cannot ask for his own transposition as co-plaintiff so that he might continue the suit which for the technical reason that the decree has been satisfied cannot be continued by the plaintiff.
10. I am not impressed by the submission made by Mr. Venkatanarasimhiah that the omission on the part of the judgment-debtor to bring his own suit within the period of limitation precludes him from his transposition as co-plaintifi. The suit brought by the plaintiff, it is clear, had for its purpose the establishment of the judgment-debtor's title and if the judgment-debtor found that the plaintiff had embarked upon that endeavour and therefore did not bring his own suit, it would be extremely unreasonable for anyone to suggest that endeavour which could not be continued by the plaintiff should not be continued by the judgment-debtor. It should not, in my opinion, make any difference that the judgment-debtor did not bring his own suit which was quite unnecessary in the circumstances since the plaintiff's success in the suit brought by him would also enure to his own benefit. That the plaintiff's suit was really a suit in the result of which both the plaintiff and defendant 1 were equally interested cannot be gainsaid.
11. If the suit had continued and it had ended in its dismissal, it is plain that even if the plaintiff did not appeal from that decree, defendant 1 could have preferred his own appeal and it would have been not possible for anyone to contend that defendant 1 could not appeal from that decree. Indeed, Mr. Venkatanarasimhiah himself did not contest the correctness of the proposition that, in a situation like that the judgment-debtor would have been as much entitled to appeal as the plaintiff himself. Then again, if the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor had both brought independent suits, and each of them was a defendant in the other suit, what is incontrovertible is that the decision in one of those two suits would bring the bar of res judicata to the trial of the same issues in the other suit. It is thus manifest that the proposition that defendant 1 was an utter stranger to the suit brought by the plaintiff but was only a proforma, defendant and could not therefore seek transposition if the plaintiff cannot proceed with the suit, should not commend itself to me.
12. Now, the very purpose of Rule 10(2) of Order 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure is to confer power on the Court to make transpositions to enable adjudications in situations where by reason of technicalities such as the one which has sprung up in the case before me, they cannot be made in favour of the person who originally commenced the suit that is the correct way of understanding that statutory provision was pointed out by their Lordships of the Privy Council in Bhupendra Narayan Sinha v. Rajeswar Prosad Bhakat, 58 Ind App 228 : (AIR 1931 PC 162), where at p. 238 of the report (Ind App): (at p. 165 of AIR), Sir George Lowndes observed—
“The pro forma defendants asked that a decree should be passed in favour of the appellant. If there was a technical objection to this, the Court clearly had power at any stage of the proceedings to remedy the defect under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code by adding the pro forma defendants as co-plaintiffs with the appellant. Such a course should, in their Lordships opinion, always be adopted where it is necessary for a complete adjudication upon the questions involved in the suit and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings”.
13. The submission made by Mr. Venkatanarasimhiah that the transposition would defeat a valuable right in defendant 2 against whom the suit which might now be instituted by defendant 1 has become time barred does not appeal to me. The decision in Jarao Kunwar v. Bhagwan Kunwar, AIR 1921 All 184, on which Mr. Venkatanarasimiah placed reliance was a case before roe. That was a case in which A sued B to recover a sum of money and impleaded C who contended that he and not A was entitled to the money. C applied that he should be allowed to continue the suit for plaintiff instead of A. That application was refused on the ground that the suit which C could have brought against B had become time barred by the time C made his application. The principle underlying the decision in that case can have no application to the case before me since the decree sought by A in the suit in the Allahabad decision, AIR 1921 All 184 was a decree for his own benefit from which C could have derived no benefit to himself, whereas in the present case, the decree which the plaintiff wished to obtain in his own favour was a decree which had as much use to the plaintiff as it had for defendant 1. I see, therefore, no reason to disturb the order made by the Court below and this revision petition is dismissed.
14. The costs of this revision petition will be costs in the cause and will abide the eventual result.
BH/VGW/V.B.B
Revision dismissed.
Alert