Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Canara Industrial And Banking Syndicate Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Mysore.

Karnataka High Court
Jul 6, 1962
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Hegde, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from references under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, where the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (Bombay Bench “B”) referred two questions of law concerning: (1) the validity of initiation of proceedings under section 34(1) to reassess the assessment year 1954-55; and (2) whether interest on Mysore Durbar Securities was rightly held chargeable to super-tax for assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57.

Relevant facts set out by the Tribunal: The Government of Mysore had earlier issued Durbar Securities (1930–1946) and, under State law and notifications, interest on those securities had been treated as partially exempt. Under section 60(1) of the Income-tax Act, Central Government notifications could make exemptions; Notification No. 878-F dated 21 March 1922 expressly exempted interest on Mysore Durbar Securities (total exemption). After the 1939 amendment (section 60(3)), the Central Government issued Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5 July 1954 which modified the earlier exemption by directing that interest on Mysore Durbar Securities be included in total income and be exempt from income-tax but not from super-tax, effective for assessments subsequent to the year ending 31 March 1954 (i.e., for assessment year 1954-55 onwards).

The original assessment for 1954-55 was completed on 31 July 1954, in which the Income-tax Officer did not take the disputed interest into account (in accordance with the 1922 notification). Subsequently, after the 1954 notification, a notice under section 34(1) was issued on 7 December 1956; reassessment was completed on 26 January 1957, treating the interest as included in total income and exempt only from income-tax (i.e., super-taxable). The Income-tax Officer in the 1956-57 assessment treated the income similarly.

The assessee appealed to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner (who rejected contentions for the years 1954-55 and 1956-57 in orders dated 23 June 1957 and 25 July 1957 respectively). The Tribunal dismissed the appeals by a consolidated order dated 23 April 1960 and referred two questions of law to the High Court under section 66(1).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether initiation of action under section 34(1) for the purposes of making reassessment for the assessment year 1954-55 had been validly made?
  2. Whether interest on Mysore Durbar Securities had been rightly held to be chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act for the assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The Income-tax Officer who made the original assessment on 31 July 1954 already had Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5 July 1954 before him and yet decided the assessment in a way favourable to the assessee; therefore, initiation of proceedings under section 34(1) was not justified.
  • The 5 July 1954 notification could only operate from its date of publication and could not deprive the assessee of exemption for income earned prior to that date (i.e., the assessee claimed the notification lacked retrospective effect for the period before 5 July 1954).
  • Under the proviso to section 8 of the Income-tax Act, the Central Government should have required the State Government (Mysore) to pay tax on that interest income instead of withdrawing the exemption in the manner adopted.
  • On equity and the terms of issue of the securities, the assessee contended that rights conferred at issuance could not be denied until the securities matured; thus, the interest should remain exempt for tax and super-tax purposes.
  • For assessment year 1956-57, the assessee further argued that the Explanation to section 9 should not have been applied to this interest and that the tax on this interest should be chargeable on the State Government under the proviso to section 8 (thus disputing application of super-tax to that interest).

Revenue's/Respondent's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The Central Government's Notification No. 39 (I.T) of 5 July 1954 expressly provided that interest on Mysore Durbar Securities be included in total income and be exempt only from income-tax but not from super-tax; therefore, the notification authorized treating the interest as chargeable to super-tax.
  • The initiation of proceedings under section 34(1)(b) was justified because subsequent awareness (or discovery of the true meaning) of Notification No. 39 (I.T) constituted "information" within the meaning of section 34(1)(b); additionally, the Tribunal found in probability that the original officer was unaware of the notification when making the first assessment.
  • The Tribunal and the High Court relied on existing judicial interpretation (notably Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh) to support a broad meaning of "information" and "escaped" in section 34(1)(b), permitting reassessment when part of the income has escaped assessment even if a return was filed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax (Supreme Court) Interpreted the words "information" and "escaped" in section 34(1)(b): "information" may include information as to the true view of the law as well as facts; "escaped" may include income not assessed owing to error even when a return was submitted. The Court held that the present case falls within the sweep of that decision and relied on its broad interpretation to conclude that subsequent knowledge or corrected understanding about Notification No. 39 (I.T) constituted "information" permitting action under section 34(1)(b).
Nachiappa Chettiar v. Commissioner of Income-tax (Madras High Court) Confirmed that under section 60 the Government of India can, by notification, deal with exemptions relating to income-tax or super-tax or both. The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that Notification No. 39 (I.T) could validly deal with super-tax (i.e., exclude the interest from income-tax but not from super-tax).
Appanna v. State of Coorg (Bench of this Court) Addressed a point on retrospective effect of government action (as applied by the Court in its reasoning). The Court noted this decision as being contrary to the assessee's contention on retrospectivity (though the point was not directly referred for opinion), and stated that the decision is against the contention urged by the assessee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court approached the matter in two linked parts: (A) the scope and competence to initiate proceedings under section 34(1)(b) for reassessment of the 1954-55 assessment, and (B) whether the interest on Mysore Durbar Securities was chargeable to super-tax for the two contested years.

A. Competence to initiate proceedings under section 34(1)(b)

  1. The Court observed that it was not established on the record whether the Income-tax Officer (ITO) who made the original assessment on 31 July 1954 had Notification No. 39 (I.T) before him at that time. The Tribunal considered that the ITO was probably unaware of that notification.
  2. The Court noted that it is the revenue's burden to establish that the conditions in section 34(1)(b) are satisfied before reopening an assessment. However, based on the material before the Court, the Tribunal's conclusion (that the ITO was probably unaware) could not be held to be unwarranted.
  3. The Court further considered whether a later realization or corrected understanding of the legal effect of a notification (even if the notification had been physically before the ITO but misunderstood) could constitute "information" under section 34(1)(b). The Court held that such a failure to understand the true implication of a notification at one stage and a correct understanding at a later stage does constitute "information" within the ratio of Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh.
  4. The Court relied on the broad interpretation in Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh: "information" can include information as to the true and correct view of the law; "escape" can include assessable income that was not taxed because of an erroneous assessment despite a return having been filed. On these principles the Court concluded the case fell within that decision's sweep and justified initiation under section 34(1)(b).
  5. The Court also considered a passage in Maharaj Kumar (paragraph 18) where the Supreme Court had left open the narrower question whether an officer could act merely on a change of mind without external information; the present Court distinguished that uncertainty by treating corrected understanding of a notification as qualifying "information".

B. Chargeability of interest to super-tax

  1. The Court observed that Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5 July 1954 expressly provided that interest on Mysore Durbar Securities should be included in total income and exempt only from income-tax and not from super-tax. As a result, the notification itself indicated the interest was chargeable to super-tax.
  2. The Court relied on Nachiappa Chettiar (Madras High Court) to confirm that under section 60 the Government can by notification deal with exemptions relating to income-tax or super-tax or both; this supported the view that the Central Government could validly direct that interest be subject to super-tax.
  3. Although the assessee raised a point about the retrospective application of the notification (i.e., whether it could be applied to income earned before 5 July 1954), the Court observed that this point was not referred for its opinion and therefore need not be decided in the reference; the Court nevertheless mentioned Appanna v. State of Coorg as opposed to the assessee on that issue.

Based on the foregoing, the Court concluded that initiation under section 34(1) had been validly made and that the interest was rightly held chargeable to super-tax for the cited assessment years.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Both questions referred were answered against the assessee and in favour of the department.

  • On point No. 1: The Court held that initiation of action under section 34(1) for the purposes of making reassessment for the assessment year 1954-55 had been validly made.
  • On point No. 2: The Court held that interest on Mysore Durbar Securities had been rightly held to be chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act for assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The reassessment under section 34(1) stands as valid; the inclusion of the disputed interest in total income for the purpose of super-tax is upheld.
  • The decision upholds the application of Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5 July 1954 in treating the interest as exempt only from income-tax and not from super-tax for the relevant assessment years.
  • The Court awarded an advocate's fee of Rs. 250.

Broader implications: The opinion applies and follows prior judicial interpretations (notably Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh and Nachiappa Chettiar) in construing the scope of "information" under section 34(1)(b) and the power of the Government under section 60 to tailor exemptions; the opinion does not purport to create a novel precedent beyond applying those authorities to the facts before it.

Questions answered: Against the assessee.

Show all summary ...

Hegde, J.:— In this reference, under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (Bombay Bench “B”) has referred two questions of law for our opinion. They are:

“(1) Whether initiation of action under section 34(1) for the purposes of making reassessment for the assessment year 1954-55 has been validly made?

(2) Whether interest on Mysore Durbar Securities has been rightly held to be chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act for the assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57?”

2. The facts of the case as disclosed by the statement of the case submitted by the Tribunal to the extent relevant for our present purpose reads as follows:

These two reference applications arise out of the reassessments made upon the assessee, a public company, for the assessment year 1954-55 by taking recourse to the provision's of section 34 and the original assessment made upon it for the assessment year 1956-57. The corresponding previous years are the calendar years 1953 and 1955. The dispute between the assessee company and the department is in regard to the levy of corporation tax, more popularly known as super-tax, on income derived by the assessee company from Mysore Durbar Securities. The relevant facts relating to the said issue are these.

3. The Government of the erstwhile Indian State of Mysore issued certain Durbar Securities between 1930 and 1946. There was in force the State income-tax law. The said Government issued notifications directing that the interest income derived from these securities was to be included in the computation of total income of an assessee for the purpose of determining the rate applicable to the taxable income. In other words, such interest income was partially exempt.

4. Section 60(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act empowered the Governor-General in Council (subsequently changed to the Central Government) to make exemptions, etc., and the material portion of it (with verbal changes made subsequently) stands as follows:

“60. (1) The Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, make an exemption, reduction in rate or other modification, in respect of income-tax in favour of any class of income, or in regard to the whole or any part of the income of any class of persons.”

5. Sub-section (3) of section 60 was added by the Indian Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1939, and it stands as follows:

“60. (3) After the commencement of the Indian Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1939, the power conferred by sub-section (1) shall not be exercisable except for the purpose of rescinding an exemption, reduction or modification already made.”

6. The said Amendment Act came into force with effect from April 1, 1939.

7. In exercise of the powers conferred by section 60(1), Notification No. 878-F (Income-tax) dated 21st March, 1922, was made. It provided as follows:

“The following classes of income shall be exempt from the tax payable under the said Act and they shall not be taken into account in determining the total income or salary of an assessee for the purpose of the said Act…

(27) The interest on Mysore Durbar Securities.”

8. The effect of this notification was that the interest on Mysore Durbar Securities was totally exempt under the Indian Income-tax Act in the hands of the holder of Mysore Durbar Securities, i.e, interest was neither included in the total income for the purposes of the rate applicable to the taxable income nor was it taxed either to income-tax or to super-tax. It will be further observed that this exemption went much further than a partial exemption granted by the Mysore Durbar itself.

9. In exercise of the powers conferred upon it by section 60(3), the Central Government by its Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5th July, 1954, modified the said exemption and provided that interest on Mysore Durbar Securities shall be included in the total income and shall be exempt from income-tax but not from super-tax. The said notification also provided that it will have effect “for the purpose of making any assessment subsequent to the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1954”, i.e, for the assessment year 1954-55 and subsequent thereto.

10. The original assessment for the assessment year 1954-55 was completed by the Income-tax Officer on 31st July, 1954. In computing the said assessment, the Income-tax Officer did not take into consideration the interest received by the assessee on Mysore Durbar Securities, In other words, he acted upon the Notification No. 878-F (Income-tax) of 21st March, 1922. Obviously, he acted in completing this assessment as he did in ignorance of the latter Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5th July, 1954. In all probability, he was quite unaware of the said notification. It is, however, alleged by the assessee that the said notification was before the Income-tax Officer when he made the assessment on 31st July, 1954, and that he did not choose to act upon it. Uufortunately, no finding on this disputed fact has been given either by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner or the Tribunal. Hence, we would reproduce the reasons recorded by the Income-tax Officer in making his proposal to the Commissioner for initiating action under section 34. It is as follows:

“(Note: We wanted to reproduce the reasons recorded by the Income-tax Officer; but the Income-tax Officer's file was ‘lost’ during transit from Udipi to Bombay in connection with this reference application. Proposal on the record of the Commissioner's file could not also be secured since the relevant file was misplaced in his office and was being traced. The department will produce a copy of the said proposal if the relevant papers are traced by the time the matter came up for hearing before the High Court.)”

11. After securing the Commissioner's notification, a notice under section 34(1) was served on the assessee on December 7, 1956. In response thereto, a return was made on January 9, 1957, and the Income-tax. Officer completed the assessment on January 26, 1957. In completing the reassessment, the Income-tax Officer included certain sum in the total income and exempted it only from income-tax but not from super-tax in view of the Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated 5th July, 1954.

12. In the course of the original assessment for 1956-57, the Income-tax Officer treated the said income, viz., interest from certain Mysore Durbar Securities, in the same manner as he did in the reassessment proceedings for the assessment year 1954-55.

13. Being aggrieved, the matter was taken in appeal to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner for the years 1954-55 and 1956-57. For the assessment year 1954-55, the assessee challenged the initiation of action under section 34 on the ground that when the Income-tax Officer made the original assessment on July 31, 1954, he had before him the Notification No. 39 (I.T) and hence action under section 34 was not justifiable. Another contention taken before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was that the said Notification No. 39 (I.T) could not deprive the assessee of his right to exemption since it could come into effect only from its date of publication, i.e, 5th July, 1954. The third contention raised before him was that, having regard to the second proviso to section 8 of the Income-tax Act, the Central Government should have asked the concerned State Government, i.e, the Mysore State, to pay tax on the said interest income instead of withdrawing the exemption in the manner it did. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner rejected all the three contentions by his order dated June 23, 1957. Copy of the said order for the assessment year 1954-55 is marked annexure “A” and forms part of the case.

14. Coming to the appeal for the assessment year 1956-57, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, by his order of July 25, 1957 (incidentally the same Appellate Assistant Commissioner passed this order who disposed of the assessee's appeal for the assessment year 1954-55), disposed of the assessee's contention by observing as follows:

“Levy of super-tax on interest receivable on securities issued by the Mysore and Hyderabad Governments:

For the reasons stated by me in my order in I.T.A No. 890/56-57 dated June 23, 1957, the contention of the appellant cannot be sustained.”

15. Being aggrieved by the decisions given by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, the assessee brought the matters in appeal to the Tribunal. Having regard to certain allegations made in the statement of facts, enclosed with the applications made under section 66(1), we find it desirable to reproduce the actual and relevant written grounds of appeal:

“1954-55:

(1) The Appellate Assistant Commissioner in construing that the notification dated 5th July, 1954, could have retrospective effect on the assessment of 1954-55 and holding that the rights of holders of Mysore Durbar Securities, could, by notification, be denied.

(2) In view of the clear inducement offered at the time of the issue of these securities, the appellant contends that such rights cannot, on principles of equity and justice, be denied till the maturity of these securities;

(3) Without prejudice to the above contention, the appellant submits that the. Income-tax Officer was in possession of the notification at the time of the assessment and could have then applied his mind to this. The Income-tax Officer was not right in reopening the assessment relying on section 34(1)(b).”

“1956-57:

(3) Interest on State Government Securities— Rs. 79,182:

The learned Income-tax Officer has relied on the statement in Appeal No. 890/56-57 (1954-55). This is not right, as the facts and principles are not the same in each of these cases. The appellant submits that in view of the clear inducements offered to the subscribers of these securities at the time of issue, the interest can be added to the income only for purposes of arriving at the total world income and not for taxation either for income-tax or super-tax (corporation tax). The appellant has to state that the provisions of the Explanation to section 9 of the Indian Income-tax Act should not have been applied to this interest and that the tax on this interest is chargeable at the hands of the State Government under proviso 3 of section 8 of the same Act. The appellant contends that such rights as are forming the terms of the notification of issue of securities and were conferred by the notification in force at the time of issue cannot on the principle of equity and justice be denied to the holders of such securities till their maturity, and hence the appellant seeks full relief in respect of the above sum of Rs. 79,182.”

16. These two appeals were disposed of by the Tribunal by its consolidated order made on 23rd April, 1960. A copy of the said order is marked annexure “B” and forms part of the case. For the reasons given by it in paragraph 9 of the said order, it rejected the assessee's contention in regard to the invalidity of initiation of action under section 34(1). In doing this, it relied upon the Supreme Court decision in the case of Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh1.

17. Going into the merits of the contention raised for the two years, the Tribunal mentioned the contentions in the following words:

“(1) Firstly, it is argued that the notification can deprive the appellant's right to the exemption if at all only from 5th July, 1954, and not from a prior date (vide paragraph 11 of annexure “B”).

(2) The validity of the notification is also attacked on another ground, viz., that instead of rescinding the exemption by means of the aforesaid notification (i.e, Notification No. 39 (I.T) of 5th July, 1954—CLP), the Central Government should have asked the concerned State Government to pay the taxes pursuant to the third (sic) proviso to section 8”. (The reference is presumably to the second proviso).

18. It rejected both these contentions for the reasons given by it in its order (annexure “B”). But now the assessee requires the Tribunal to refer to the High Court the following questions:

Assessment year 1954-55

“(a) Whether the notice under section 34(1)(b) and the proceedings thereunder are valid?

(b) If the answer to the first question is in the affirmative, whether the interest on Mysore Durbar Securities held by the assessee or any of them was chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act?”

Assessment year 1956-57

“(a) Whether the exemption in respect of the income from Mysore Durbar Securities can be modified or deleted so as to prejudicially affect the rights of the assessee.

(b) Whether the treatment of the income from Mysore Durbar Securities in the hands of the assessee by the income-tax authorities is correct?”

19. In our opinion, on the facts of the case, the following questions of law arise:

“(i) Whether initiation of action under section 34(1) for the purposes of making reassessment for the assessment year 1954-55 has been validly made?

(ii) Whether interest on Mysore Durbar Securities has been rightly held to be chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, for assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57?”

20. Sri T. Krishna Rao, the learned counsel for the assessee, did not press the second question formulated above. The relevant notification clearly shows that exemption given is only in respect of income-tax and not super-tax. In fact that notification directs that the interest income derived from the Durbar Securities must be included in the computation of the total income of the assessee. As observed by the Madras High Court in Nachiappa Chettiar v. Commissioner of Income-tax, in the matter of any exemption under section 60 of the Income-tax Act, the Government of India can by notification deal with income-tax or super-tax or with both.

21. But the more important question is whether the Income-tax Officer had competence to initiate proceedings under section 34(1). It is urged on behalf of the assessee that the Income-tax Officer did not act in consequence of any information. According to the assessee, even at the time of the assessment, the Income-tax Officer had before him the Notification No. 39 (I.T) dated July 5, 1954; but he thought that on a true interpretation of that notification, the disputed income is exempt from tax. Hence, it was not open to his successor to take action under section 34(1)(b). There is no material on record to show whether the Income-tax Officer had knowledge of the aforesaid notification at the time of the assessment or not. The Tribunal has opined that, in all probability, he was quite unaware of that notification. Though it is for the revenue to establish that the conditions laid down in section 34(1)(b) are satisfied before taking action under that provision, on the material before us, we are unable to hold that the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal is an unwarranted one. If the Income-tax Officer was unaware of the notification in question, his subsequent information about that notification is certainly an “information”, within the meaning of the expression found in section 34(1)(b).

22. Assuming that the Income-tax Officer had the relevant notification before him but he either did not read it or was unable to understand its implications and later either by himself or with the assistance of others, he became aware of its true meaning, can that be said to be an “information” empowering him to take action under section 34(1)(b). The words “information” and “escaped” have been widely interpreted in Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax. Therein their Lordships held that if the word “information” in its plain grammatical meaning includes information as to facts as well as information as to the State of the law, it would be unreasonable to limit it to information as to the facts on the extraneous consideration that some cases of assessment which need to be revised or rectified on the ground of mistake of law may conceivably be covered by sections 33B and 35; the word “information” in section 34(1)(b) includes information as to the true and correct view of the law. Their Lordships further observed, judging by the dictionary meaning alone, it would be difficult to confine the meaning of the word “escape” in section 34(1)(b) only to cases where no return has been submitted by the assessee; even if the assessee has submitted a return of his income, cases may well occur where the whole of the income has not been assessed and such part of the income as has not been assessed can well be regarded as having escaped assessment; there is no justification for holding that cases of income escaping assessment must always be cases where income has not been assessed owing to inadvertence or oversight or owing to the fact that no return has been submitted; even in a case where a return has been submitted, if the Income-tax Officer erroneously fails to tax a part of assessable income, it is a case where the said part of the income has escaped assessment.

23. We have no doubt that the present case falls within the sweep of this decision. But, our attention was invited to certain observations found in paragraph 18 of the judgment of the Supreme Court. The relevant passage reads thus:

“It appears that, in construing the scope and effect of the provisions of section 34, the High Courts have had occasion to decide whether it would be open to the Income-tax Officer to take action under section 34 on the ground that he thinks that his original decision in making the order of assessment was wrong without any fresh information from an external source or whether the successor of the Income-tax Officer can act under section 34 on the ground that the order of assessment passed by his predecessor was erroneous, and divergent views have been expressed on this point. Mr. Rajagopala Sastri, for the respondent, suggested that under the provisions of section 34 as amended in 1948, it would be open to the Income-tax Officer to act under the said section even if he merely changed his mind without any information from an external source and came to the conclusion that, in a particular case, he had erroneously allowed an asses-see's income to escape assessment. We do not propose to express any opinion on this point in the present appeal.”

24. We are told that the present case comes within the controversy which was left undecided by the Supreme Court. We are not clear that it is so. In our opinion, a failure to understand the true implication of any particular notification at one stage and a correct understanding of the same at a later stage, does constitute an “information” falling within the ratio of the decision above referred to.

25. Lastly, it was urged by Sri T. Krishna Rao that the notification dated July 5, 1954, being not retrospective in effect could not have been applied for the assessment year 1954-55; at any rate it was ineffective in respect of the income earned between April 1, 1954, and July 4, 1954. This is not a point referred for our opinion and hence there is no need to deal with the same. But we may incidentally mention that this point is covered by a decision of a Bench of this court in Appanna v. State of Coorg and that decision is against the contention urged by Sri T. Krishna Rao.

26. In the result, we answer both the questions referred for our opinion against the assessee and in favour of the department. On point No. 1 our answer is that the initiation of action under section 34(1) for the purposes of making reassessment for the assessment year 1954-55 had been validly made, and on point No. 2, the interest on Mysore Durbar Securities had been rightly held to be chargeable to super-tax under the Indian Income-tax Act for the assessment years 1954-55 and 1956-57. Advocate's fee Rs. 250.

27. Questions answered against the assessee.