- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Premier Insurance Co. Ltd. Madras And Others, v. The Davanagere Cotton Mills Ltd. And Others,
Structured Summary of the Opinion: Kapila Textile Mills — Sale Confirmation Appeals
Factual and Procedural Background
In a public auction held on 18-6-1960 the Kapila Textile Mills (the "Mills") were sold to Devanagere Cotton Mills for Rs. 15,25,000/-. The sale was made subject to confirmation by the High Court, and the Hon'ble Company Judge, Sadasivayya J., confirmed the sale by order dated 15-7-1960. Two appeals were filed challenging that confirmation. The appellants contended that the sale price was grossly inadequate, relying in part on the Mills' 1956 balance sheet which showed a book value of Rs. 44,45,163, and on other valuations and opinions suggesting the auction price was far below realisable value.
Relevant factual details relied upon in the appeals include:
- The Committee of Inspection unanimously resolved that the highest bid of Rs. 15,25,000/- was grossly low.
- One Committee member, Shri B.K. Murthy (technical qualifications stated), gave an opinion entitled to consideration.
- The Official Liquidator stated the highest bid was rather too low.
- The Textile Commissioner had valued the Mills in 1957 at Rs. 25,00,000/-.
- The Mills had secured and unsecured creditors; secured creditors included Mysore Bank (now State Bank of Mysore) owed over Rs. 2 lakhs, Government dues (taxes), provident fund and wages; after satisfying secured claims, little remained for unsecured creditors.
- Advertisement for the auction: published in nine newspapers and journals, but only one insertion in each; only three parties bid.
- Highest competing bids noted: Sri Veerabhadrachettiar Rs. 11,50,000/-, Government of Mysore Rs. 15,20,000/-, and the successful purchaser Rs. 15,25,000/-.
Both Judges (Mir Iqbal Hussain, J. and Hegde, J.) heard the appeals together and rendered a common judgment allowing the appeals and setting aside the sale subject to specified conditions, addressing both the substantive issue of adequacy of the sale price and a procedural objection to the High Court's jurisdiction to entertain the appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the confirmation of the sale of the Kapila Textile Mills should be set aside on the ground that the sale price realized at the auction was grossly inadequate and the sale process (including publicity) was insufficient.
- Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to hear the appeals from an order of a single Judge (the Company Judge) in Company matters — specifically, the contention that no appeal lies because Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act requires a notification by the State Government enabling appeals from single-judge original Company matters, contrasted with Section 483 of the Indian Companies Act which provides a substantive right of appeal.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The sale price of Rs. 15,25,000/- is grossly inadequate and far below the realisable value of the property; the 1956 balance sheet shows a book value of Rs. 44,45,163, which supports the contention of inadequacy (though the judgment notes balance-sheet figures should be taken with reservation).
- The Committee of Inspection unanimously considered the highest bid to be grossly low.
- There was insufficient publicity for the auction — although advertisements appeared in nine papers, there was only a single insertion in each and the appellants contended that more insertions would have been necessary to attract wider bidding.
- The inadequacy of the realized amount would leave hardly any sum to pay unsecured creditors after secured claims (including bank, government, provident fund, wages) were met; this prejudice to unsecured creditors was a ground for not confirming the sale.
Respondent (Auction Purchaser)'s Arguments
- The learned advocate for the respondent auction purchaser (Sri Narasimha Murthy) argued that this Court had no jurisdiction to sit in appeal over orders of the Hon'ble Company Judge, relying on Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act and the absence of any State Government notification permitting such appeals.
- The respondent also submitted that the purchaser had incurred expenses in making the purchase, including borrowing at interest rates between 6½% and 7½%, and that it would be just and equitable for him to be compensated if the sale were set aside.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bachharaj Factories Ltd. v. Hirjee Mills Ltd., (S) AIR 1955 Bom 355 | Authority for the proposition that the first part of the relevant Companies Act provision confers a substantive right of appeal from orders of a Company Judge, and that the procedural part does not cut down that substantive right; procedural requirements relate only to forum and manner. | The court relied on this decision (Chagla, C.J.'s reasoning) to hold that Section 483 of the Indian Companies Act confers a substantive right of appeal and that the procedural requirement in Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act (and the need for a notification) did not oust the Court's power to hear appeals; thus the objection to maintainability was overruled. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis addressed two linked strands: (A) the adequacy of the sale price and propriety of confirmation; and (B) the jurisdictional objection to the entertainability of the appeals.
A. Adequacy of the Sale Price and Confirmation
- The primary consideration in deciding whether to confirm a sale under the Companies Act is whether the Court is satisfied that the price fetched is adequate. The court emphasized this principal consideration.
- On the facts, several factors pointed to inadequacy of the price realized:
- The book value on the 1956 balance sheet (Rs. 44,45,163) suggested a much higher valuation, though the court noted balance-sheet figures should be regarded with reservation and do not alone determine market value.
- The Committee of Inspection had unanimously reported the highest bid to be grossly low; one member (B.K. Murthy) had relevant technical qualifications and his opinion was treated as entitled to weight.
- The Official Liquidator expressed that the bid was too low, and the Textile Commissioner had valued the Mills in 1957 at Rs. 25,00,000/-.
- There were only three bidders at the auction despite publicity: Veerabhadrachettiar (Rs. 11,50,000), Government of Mysore (Rs. 15,20,000), and the successful purchaser (Rs. 15,25,000). This limited competitive interest, and the fact that only one insertion was made in each of nine papers, suggested insufficient publicity and an inadequate market test.
- Paying secured creditors (bank, government dues, provident fund, wages) would likely exhaust the sale proceeds, leaving little or nothing for unsecured creditors; this potential harm to unsecured creditors weighed against confirmation.
- Taking all circumstances together, the court concluded that the sale price was inadequate and that the sale should be set aside and a resale conducted. The court also considered that there was no realistic prospect of the bid going down if re-auctioned, and that secured creditors would be interested in maintaining or raising the bid on re-auction.
B. Jurisdictional/Procedural Objection
- The respondent argued that Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act precluded the High Court sitting in division or single-judge appeals absent a Government notification published in the official Gazette enabling appeals from single judges in original Company matters.
- The court rejected that contention. It reasoned that:
- Section 483 of the Indian Companies Act provides that appeals from orders in winding-up lie to "the same Court" in the same manner and subject to same conditions as appeals in ordinary jurisdiction — thereby giving a substantive right of appeal.
- The procedural requirements (about manner and forum) do not abrogate the substantive right of appeal; they are procedural in nature. The Bombay High Court decision in Bachharaj Factories Ltd. v. Hirjee Mills Ltd. was cited for this interpretation.
- The High Court's own Rules (Rule 1, Chapter III, cl. (2)) provide that where original jurisdiction is exercised by a single Judge, any appeal allowed by law shall be heard by a Bench consisting of not less than two other Judges. Those Rules were made and published with the consent of the State Government and so, in substance, satisfy the procedural expectation of Section 13.
- On these bases the court held that appeals under Section 483 were maintainable before a Bench as provided by the High Court Rules and that the procedural objection to jurisdiction was without force.
C. Remedies, Conditions and Compensation Ordered
- The court ordered that the sale be set aside and a resale conducted, but only on certain conditions:
- The appellants would meet the expenses for conducting a fresh sale and would deposit Rs. 2,000/- with the Official Liquidator within a week; that sum to be paid in moiety by both appellants as per a joint memo filed.
- The appellants were to ensure more extensive publicity: publications in two issues and, if possible, more prominent placements in the nine newspapers and journals previously used.
- The auction-purchaser (respondent) was entitled to a refund of the bid amount and to the interest accrued on the amount realised from the auction which the Official Liquidator had invested in the State Bank of Mysore; additionally, the appellant Premier Insurance Company would pay Rs. 6,000/- to the auction-purchaser towards loss of interest within a week as per the joint memo.
- The amount of Rs. 8,000/- (sum of the Rs. 2,000 deposit and Rs. 6,000 contribution) would be a charge on the assets of the Company subject to any prior charges made during liquidation and to the claims of secured creditors.
Holding and Implications
CORE HOLDING: APPEALS ALLOWED; SALE SET ASIDE AND RESALE ORDERED, subject to conditions described by the Court (deposit of Rs. 2,000 by appellants, refund and interest to auction-purchaser, payment of Rs. 6,000 by Premier Insurance, enhanced publicity for resale).
Implications and direct consequences:
- The confirmation of the original sale to Devanagere Cotton Mills is set aside; a resale is to be held under enhanced publicity and at the expense of the appellants (deposit to be made), with conditions to protect the auction-purchaser's financial position (refund, interest, specified compensation).
- Amounts ordered (deposit and compensation) will form a charge on the Company's assets subject to prior charges and secured creditors' claims.
- The court rejected the maintainability objection based on Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act and upheld the availability of an appeal under Section 483 of the Indian Companies Act, relying on the High Court Rules and the cited precedent.
- As to costs of the appeal, the court ordered that each party should bear their own costs of this appeal.
The opinion does not purport to establish or announce any sweeping new principle beyond the application of established tests (adequacy of price, protection of unsecured creditors, and interpretation of appeal rights under S.483 in conjunction with procedural provisions and High Court Rules). The decision's immediate effect is limited to setting aside the sale in this matter and prescribing conditions for a resale.
Orders and Further Procedure
- The appeals were allowed in the manner indicated; the sale was set aside subject to the stated conditions. The parties were ordered to take the procedural steps and deposits within one week from the date of the judgment where specified. The case was listed to "Call for further orders on 23-8-1960."
If Information Was Not Available
All sections of this summary contain only information expressly presented in the provided opinion. No additional facts, dates or reasoning beyond those appearing in the opinion have been added.
Mir Iqbal Hussain, J.:— Aggrieved by the order confirming the sale of the Kapila Textile Mills, two appeals have been filed. As both of them deal with the same matter a common judgment is given in respect of both the appeals.
2. In a public auction held on 18-6-1960 the Kaplia Textile Mills (hereinafter called for the sake of convenience ‘the Mills’) were sold for a sum of Rs. 15,25,000/-, the highest bidder being the Devanagere Cotton Mills (hereinafter called the purchasers) One of the important conditions of the sale was that it was subject to the confirmation by the High Court, but the said Court is not bound to accept the highest bid. Hence the question of confirmation of the sale came up for consideration before the Hon'ble Company Judge, Sadasivayya J., who confirmed the said sale as per order dated 15-7-1960. The gravamen of the charge of the appellants is that the sale price is grossly inadequate — far below the realisable value of the property put up for sale. In support of their contention they urge that the book value as indicated by the balance sheet of the said Mills of 1956 is Rs. 44,45,163. This value should be taken with some reservation and one cannot gather a true picture of the price from the figures given in the balance sheet. Even otherwise, there are a few other circumstances which impel us to hold that the price fetched at the auction is inadequate. The Committee of Inspection has unanimously resolved that the highest bid of Rs. 15,25,000/- is grossly low and has no relation to the value of the property put up for sale.
3. One of the members of this Committee as is evident from the records is Shri B.K Murthy, B.E, (Mech.) M.Sc (Tech.) who was the former principal of the Technological Institute, Bangalore and Director of Textiles. His opinion therefore is entitled to great consideration. Even the Official Liquidator appointed by this Court has, in unmistakable terms stated that the highest bid realised is rather too low. The Textile Commissioner appointed by the Government of Mysore it is urged has valued these Mills in the year 1957 at Rs. 25,00,000. Taking into consideration all these factors we consider that there is much force in the contention of the appellants that the price realised at the auction is inadequate and low.
4. The Mills have two sets of creditors (1) the secured creditors (2) the unsecured creditors. In the former category are the Mysore Bank (now the State Bank of Mysore) to whom a sum of over 2 lakhs is due, the Government of Mysore to whom amounts are due in respect of taxes etc. Then there are the dues in respect of Provident Fund and wages due to the labourers etc., of the Mills. If the amounts due to the above is deducted from the amount realised from the sale, there will be hardly any amount left to pay even a small part of the debts, to the unsecured creditors. In fact, if the sale is confirmed they will be hard hit. This is again another consideration for not confirming the highest bid at the sale.
5. No adverse comment is made regarding the conduct of the sale. The appellants, however, content themselves by urging that the publication is not sufficient. No doubt publicity is given regarding the auction of the mills in nine newspapers and journals. Only one insertion is made in each of them. It is urged on behalf of the appellants that more than one advertisement would be necessary. Though the cost of advertisement would be fairly high, it would be in the interest of the creditors that as wide a publicity as possible is given in the leading newspapers and journals. Though a number of enquiries were received by the Official Liquidator, only three parties bid at this auction.
6. The highest bid of Sri Veerabhadrachettiar was Rs. 11,50,000/-, while the Government of Mysore's highest bid was of Rs. 15,20,000/-. The highest bid of the respondents, Davangere Cotton Mills is Rs. 5,000/- more than that of the Government. This indicates lack of sufficient bidders at the auction. All these circumstances impel us to conclude that a resale should be held.
7. It is urged by Sri Narasimha Murthy, the learned advocate appearing for the respondent auction purchasers that this Court has no jurisdiction to sit in appeal over the orders of the Hon'ble Company Judge. Reliance is placed on S. 13 of the Mysore High Court Act which runs as follows:
“Appeals against references regarding, and applications for revision of judgments, decrees, orders or sentences passed by a Judge of the High Court, in the exercise of the original Civil and Criminal jurisdiction conferred upon it under S. 12 or vested in it under any law for the time being in force, shall, when allowed by law, be heard either by a Bench consisting of two other Judges of the High Court or, by the Full Bench of the said Court, as the State Government may, by notification published in the official Gazette, from time to time direct.”
8. It is however, admitted by the learned counsel that the Original jurisdiction in Company matters has been exercised by a Judge of this Court sitting singly, but he contends that there is no notification of the State Government published in the official Gazette empowering an appeal therefrom. This contention is without force. Under the Rules of this High Court as per cl. (2) of R. 1 in Ch. III:
“Where any original jurisdiction conferred on the High Court by any law for the time being in force is exercised by a single Judge of the High Court any appeal or other proceeding when allowed by any such law directed against any judgment, decree, order or sentence made or passed by such single Judge shall be heard and determined by a Bench consisting of not less than two other Judges of the High Court or such number of other Judges as the law may require or specify.”
9. Per contra it is argued on behalf of the appellants that S. 483 of the Indian Companies Act gives inherent power of appeal. That section runs as follows:
“Appeals from any order made or decision given, in the matter of the winding up of a company by the Court shall lie to the same Court to which, in the same manner in which, and subject to the same conditions under which, appeals lie from any order or decision of the Court in cases within its ordinary jurisdiction.”
10. Company matters are decided by this Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction conferred upon it by the Companies Act. If so, an appeal ‘shall’ lie to the same Court. In other words, a substantive right of appeal is given to the parties. The later portions viz., ‘In the same manner in which and subject to the same conditions under which’ are only the procedural part thereof. These latter which are only procedural in nature can in no way abrogate or diminish the powers of appeal given under the substantive part of the section. Hence the objection raised by Sri Narasimha Murthy is without substance.
11. This view is supported by the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Bachharaj Factories Ltd. v. Hirjee Mills Ltd., reported in (S) AIR 1955 Bom 355. His Lordship Chagla, C.J, delivering the judgment has stated as follows:
“The first part of S. 202 (section dealing with appeals under the old law) confers substantive right upon a party aggrieved by an order made or a decision given by a Company Judge in winding up. The second part of S. 202 does not in any way cut down or impair the substantive right already conferred by the first part of S. 202. The second part which deals with the manner and the conditions in which an appeal may be preferred only refers to the procedural aspect of an appeal and the forum to which the appeal would lie.”
12. It is agreed by the appellants that they should meet the expenses to be incurred for conducting a fresh sale. It is advisable, as stated above, that there should be publications in two issues and if possible, in more prominent places in nine newspapers and journals. For costs of so advertising and other incidental expenses the appellants will have to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,000/- with the Official Liquidator within a week from this date. This sum will be paid in moiety by both the appellants as per the joint memo filed this day. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the respondent-auction-purchaser that his client has incurred expenses during the purchase and in particular, has borrowed large sums of money by paying interest; at rates ranging from 6½ to 7½ per cent.
13. It is just and equitable that he should be compensated suitably. The Official Liquidator has invested the amount realised at the auction in the State Bank of Mysore. The interest so realised on the principal as well as on the amount of interest which have thus been invested in the State Bank of Mysore by the Official Liquidator will be paid to the auction-purchaser. Besides he will be entitled to the refund of the bid amount as well. The appellant Premier Insurance Company (Appellants in M.A 128/1960) will pay an extra sum of Rs. 6000/- to the auction-purchaser towards loss of interest within a week from this date as per the joint memo. The sale is set aside subject to these conditions. The amount of Rs. 8,000/- will be a charge on the assets of the Company subject to (1) any prior charge made during the liquidation proceedings; (2) the claims of the secured creditors.
14. Taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that the sale should be set aside and these appeals allowed. As regards costs, however, we order that under the circumstances of the case each party should bear their own costs of this appeal.
15. Call for further orders on 23-8-1960.
Hegde, J.:—
16. I had the benefit of going through the order prepared by my learned brother. I agree with that order, but I would like to add a few words.
17. In deciding whether the sale held should be confirmed or not, the primary consideration is whether the Court is satisfied that the price fetched is adequate. This is also the view taken in the decided cases read to us at the time of the hearing. Taking into account the book value of the property sold, valuation made by the experts in the recent past, the quality of the machinery as well as its availability in the market, there are good reasons to think that the price fetched is not adequate. It is pointed out to us that the sale in question had not been adequately advertised. The method and manner of advertisement was decided upon after consultation with the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
18. Hence it cannot be said that there was any omission on the part of the Official Liquidator. But that aspect, is not relevant for our purpose. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants appear to be right in their contention that it would have been proper to have advertised the sale by making more than one insertion in the papers concerned. No doubt this is being wise after the event. We are mindful of the fact that we should not lightly refuse to confirm a sale on inadequate grounds and thus deprive the bidder, the fruits of his bid made in pursuance of an order of this Court. We are equally, if not more, anxious to protect the interest of the creditors, particularly the unsecured creditors.
19. In the circumstance of this case we are convinced that there is no chance of the bid going down if the property is re-auctioned. The amount realised from the auction held is just sufficient to pay off the secured creditors and the secured creditors (particularly the State of Mysore) are interested in seeing that the bid does not go below the mark reached on the last occasion.
20. I agree with my learned brother that the contention of Sri V.L Narasimha Murthy, challenging the maintainability of the appeal is without force. Section 483 of the Indian Companies Act provides for an appeal against every order passed or decision made by the Court in the exercise of its ordinary jurisdiction. The order under appeal is one such.
21. The next question is how to implement the provision, providing for an appeal. Section 13 of the Mysore High Court Act, says that appeals against decrees, orders or sentences passed by a Judge of the High Court, in the exercise of the original civil and criminal jurisdiction conferred upon the High Court under S. 12 or vested in it under any law for the time being in force, shall, when allowed by law, be heard either by a Bench consisting of two other Judges of the High Court or by the Full Bench of the said Court as the State Government may by notification published in the official Gazette, from time to time direct. Sri Narasimha Murthy, the learned counsel for the auction-purchaser naturally makes much of the fact that the State Government has not published any notification as required by that section (S. 13). But the Rules framed by this Court and published in the official Gazette do provide (under R. 1 cl. (2) of those Rules) that a Bench of two Judges shall hear all appeals coming within the scope of S. 13 of the Mysore High Court Act. These Rules were made and published with the consent of the State Government. Therefore in substance, if not in form, they may be considered as having been published by the Government by notification in the official Gazette. The true scope of S. 483 of the Indian Companies Act, if I may say so with respect, is as laid down by Chagla C.J, in the case of (S) AIR 1955 Bom 355.
22. In the result, these appeals are allowed in the manner indicated in the leading judgment delivered by my learned brother.
JD/K.S.B
Appeals allowed.
Alert