Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mangalore Chemicals ... v. Deputy Commissioner ...

Karnataka High Court
Aug 14, 1990
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd. (Writ Petition)

Factual and Procedural Background

Petitioner: Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd., Bangalore (a company incorporated in 1971 and in production from 15 March 1976).

The petitioner challenged a letter of demand dated 3 November 1978 (annexure R), followed by a demand in Form 5 (annexure S) and a further assessment/notice (annexure T). The notices threatened action under provisions of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act (including sub-section (3) of section 13 and reference to sub-section (2) of section 13 for penalty). The formal demands included a sum of Rs. 19,08,364.90 as specified in annexure R.

The petitioner sought (a) writ of certiorari (or similar writ) to quash annexures R, S and T and associated assessments dated 20 August 1979 and 20 January 1980 as illegal and ultra vires, and (b) writ of mandamus (or similar) directing respondents 1–3 to grant and continue concession/adjustment of sales tax on raw materials in accordance with Government Orders (exhibits A and B) and the petitioner's applications (exhibits F, H and J).

The matter reached a Division Bench following a direction issued in 1987 by a learned single Judge in the context of earlier decisions (Writ Petition No. 939 of 1980 and Writ Petition No. 373 of 1977). The Bench noted that no specific reference under section 9 of the Karnataka High Court Act was located referring the matter to a Division Bench.

Background on statutory instruments: A Government notification dated 30 June 1969 (exhibit A) purportedly entitled certain new industrial units to sales tax benefits; a subsequent notification dated 11 August 1975 (exhibit B) prescribed procedure (including annual application and requirement of prior permission to withhold payment of sales tax) for claiming refunds/withholding; a later notification dated 12 January 1977 (exhibit G) introduced exclusions, including an exclusion for units with fixed asset investment of Rs. 10 lakhs and above.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the demand notices (annexures R, S and T) and related assessments are illegal, opposed to law or ultra vires the powers of the assessing authority.
  2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the benefits/concessions under the Government notification of 30 June 1969 (exhibit A) and the procedure in the 11 August 1975 notification (exhibit B), including the right to withhold payment of sales tax on raw materials.
  3. Whether the petitioner is disqualified from claiming the benefits on the ground that it is a successor-in-interest to an earlier company (Malbar Chemical Fertilizers) incorporated in 1964.
  4. Whether the 12 January 1977 notification (exhibit G), specifically clauses (iv) and (v) excluding units with fixed assets of Rs. 10 lakhs and above, applies to the petitioner and precludes the claimed benefit.
  5. Whether non-compliance with the procedural requirement of prior permission under the 1975 notification precludes the petitioner from withholding tax and therefore validates the tax demand.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on the Government notification dated 30 June 1969 (exhibit A) and the 1975 notification (exhibit B) to claim entitlement to refund/adjustment and to withhold sales tax payable on raw materials.
  • The petitioner asserted it went into production on 15 March 1976 (after the 1969 notification) and therefore qualified as a new unit for the purposes of the incentive, despite its incorporation in 1971 and notwithstanding any connection to an earlier company; the fact of succession to name/objects of an earlier company did not, according to the petitioner, disentitle it to benefits.
  • The petitioner represented that applications for permission to withhold tax were filed (e.g., annexure H for May 1976 to March 1977) and a renewal request was made for 1977–78.
  • Counsel (Sri Kumar, for M/s King and Partridge) argued that whatever relief was extended to other eligible units (in related litigation) should also be extended to the petitioner—relying on the operative passages of the decision in Dharmendra's case that earlier orders remain valid for eligible units.

Respondent-State's Arguments

  • The State contended that the petitioner was not entitled to the benefit of the 1969 notification because it was effectively a successor-in-interest to an earlier company, Malbar Chemical Fertilizers (incorporated 1964), and therefore could not be treated as a "new" industrial unit for eligibility.
  • The State relied on the 1977 notification (exhibit G) and its exclusions (clauses (iv) and (v)) to deny benefits to units with fixed assets of Rs. 10 lakhs and above, and maintained that the authority must give effect to the Government Order unless its legality were challenged.

Other Pleadings / Responses

  • In reply to the State's objections, the company explained the formation of a new company in 1971, raising new capital and erection of factory (circa 1973) aided by incentives, and asserted entitlement to incentives for a five-year period (claimed to end 1980–81).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dharmendra Trading Co. v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, ILR (1979) 2 KAR 1909 The learned single Judge declared and directed that: (i) the Government Orders of 30 June 1969 and 11 August 1975 remain valid and are not abrogated by the 12 January 1977 Order for industries started after 30 June 1969 and before 12 January 1977; (ii) claims of new industrial units started between those dates shall be considered under the 1969 and 1975 orders; (iii) respondents shall not enforce demands without re-examining the claims as directed. The Court acknowledged the decision and its ratio that benefit could not be denied merely because some units had abused it. However, the Court held that Dharmendra's case did not automatically entitle the petitioner to relief where statutory procedural prerequisites (prior permission under exhibit B) were not complied with, and where other exclusions (exhibit G) applied.
Supreme Court decision reported as [1988] 70 STC 59 (appeal from the decisions in the Dharmendra batch) Affirmation of the High Court's decision in the Dharmendra batch (i.e., the High Court's view was affirmed by the Supreme Court). The Court noted that the High Court's decision had been affirmed by the Supreme Court and relied on that affirmation when considering whether the 1969/1975 orders remained available to eligible units; nevertheless the Court distinguished the present petitioner on the basis of non-compliance with the 1975 procedure and applicability of the 1977 exclusion.
Writ Petition Nos. 373 of 1977 and 939 of 1980 (High Court decisions referenced) These earlier writ petitions were referenced as antecedent litigation that led to directions affecting related cases; the opinion does not set out a separate legal principle from these writ petitions within the text. The Bench recorded that the matter came before the Division Bench following a direction in 1987 in view of decisions in these writ petitions; the Court also observed that no explicit section 9 reference was found referring the matter to a Division Bench.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner, applying statutory scheme, facts, and precedent as follows:

  1. Eligibility principle: The Court accepted the general principle (from Dharmendra's case) that the benefit of the 1969 notification was to encourage setting up of industries and that the essential condition for entitlement was that an industrial unit go into production after the commencement of the 1969 notification. The Court held that succession to the name or objects of an earlier company did not, by itself, disentitle a unit which went into production after the notification date.
  2. Procedural compliance under the 1975 notification (exhibit B): The 1975 notification prescribed a procedure requiring an industrial unit to secure prior permission from the assessing authority to withhold tax (subject to Government permission). The Court emphasized that this prior permission was a condition precedent to withholding tax.
  3. Application of facts to procedure: Although the petitioner had applied for permission (and had permission for a six-month period preceding 1 April 1977 to withhold tax for 1976–77), the petitioner conceded (through its counsel) that for the relevant year (1977–78) no permission had actually been granted. The Court concluded that absence of the mandatory prior permission meant the petitioner was not entitled to withhold tax for the disputed period.
  4. Effect of the 1977 notification (exhibit G): Clauses (iv) and (v) of exhibit G expressly excluded units with fixed asset investment of Rs. 10 lakhs and above from the sales tax refund concession. The Court found that the petitioner’s assets ran to crores of rupees and therefore fell within the exclusion. The Court noted that the exclusion was not considered in Dharmendra's case because it had not been pleaded there.
  5. Challenge to the 1977 exclusion and amendment request: The petitioner sought permission to amend the petition to challenge the validity of clauses (iv) and (v) of exhibit G. The Court declined permission to amend due to the significant lapse of time and the fact that the period of benefit had long expired (nearly eight years at the time of the order).
  6. Conclusion of legality of demand: Considering the petitioner’s failure to comply with the procedural requirement (no prior permission to withhold) and the express exclusion in the 1977 notification applicable to the petitioner on the basis of its asset value, the Court found the demands (annexures R, S and T) to be justifiable and made in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ petition dismissed; the demand notices (annexures R, S and T) and consequential proceedings were sustained as lawful.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The petitioner's application to quash the demand notices and assessments was refused; the tax demand of Rs. 19,08,364.90 (as per annexure R) and related notices stand sustained.
  • The petitioner's request to be permitted to amend its petition to challenge the 1977 notification's exclusions was denied because of the long delay and expiry of the benefit period.
  • The Court made no order as to costs.

Broader implications:

The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle beyond application of existing notifications and the requirement of procedural compliance. The Court distinguished the petitioner from units covered by Dharmendra's case on factual and procedural grounds (lack of prior permission and applicability of the 1977 exclusion). The opinion does not state that it creates a new precedent beyond these determinations.

Show all summary ...

M.P Chandrakantaraj Urs, J.:— Petitioner is Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd., Bangalore. It is aggrieved by the letter of demand as at annexure R which is dated 3rd November, 1978. Pursuant to annexure R, demand in form 5, under the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957 has been issued as at annexure S. Thereafter it has been followed by a further notice proposing to take action against the writ petitioner under sub-section (3) of section 13 of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957, if the demand is not met within the specified time therein. Therefore, the writ petition seeking the following reliefs:

(a) a writ in the nature of certiorari or such other writ order or direction as this Honourable Court deems fit quashing the demand notices, exhibits R, S and T bearing Nos. 3010206/78-79 issued by the second respondent dated 3rd November, 1978, 31504838/78-79 and assessment No. 31504838/79 issued by the third respondent dated 20th August, 1979 and 20th January, 1980, respectively declaring that the demands made therein are illegal, opposed to law and ultra vires of the powers of third respondent;

(b) a writ in the nature of mandamus or such other writ order or direction as this Honourable Court deems fit directing respondents 1 to 3 to grant to the petitioner the concession for adjustment of the sales tax payable on the raw materials purchased by it as applied for by the petitioner under exhibits F, H and J and to continue to grant the same for the period to which it is entitled to on the basis of the Government Orders, exhibits A and B.

2. Before we proceed further to dispose of the petition, we must notice that the matter has come before the Division Bench on account of the direction issued some time in 1987 by a learned single Judge in view of the decision rendered in Writ Petition No. 939 of 1980 which followed the decision in Writ Petition No. 373 of 1977. We have not been able to find any specific reference order in terms of section 9 of the Karnataka High Court Act referring the matter to a Division Bench. The facts relating to the petition may be stated and they are as follows:

“Petitioner has asserted that it is a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 and carries on the business of manufacturing chemical fertilisers. It appears it went into production on 15th March, 1976 though the company was incorporated in the year 1971. By a notification issued by the Government as at annexure A in the purported exercise of power under section 8-A of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), the company was entitled to certain benefits concerning sales tax. Therefore pursuant to the Notification dated 30th June, 1969, it was followed by Notification dated 11th August, 1975, providing for procedure to derive the benefit in regard to refund of sales tax on raw material purchased by certain new industries set up after the date of notification in 1969 the company was withholding payment of the sales tax due to the Government to be adjusted against the refund available to it under the 1969 notification as at exhibit A. By the 1975 notification as at exhibit B, a procedure was provided by which industrial units which were entitled to get the benefit under 1969 order were required to make an application each year seeking permission to withhold the payment of sales tax and could so withhold if the permission was granted by the concerned assessing authority. As such, as evidenced by annexure H an application was filed seeking permission to withhold sales tax payable against tax paid on purchase of raw materials used in the manufacture as per the monthly returns filed by the company for the period May 1976 to March 1977 and similarly by letter dated 27th March, 1977, the permission sought for and obtained earlier was requested to be renewed for the year 1977-78. When permission was awaited by the company, exhibit R, demanding the sum of Rs. 19,08,364.90 was received which in turn gives rise to the issuance of exhibits S and T the formal demand notice as well as the threat to impose penalty under sub-section (2) of section 13 of the Act.”

3. We do not propose to advert to other averments in the petition in the light of the undisputed facts which we have stated.

4. The respondent-State of Karnataka in its statement of objections has taken the extreme stand that the petitioner was not entitled to the benefits of the 1969 notification as at exhibit A because the petitioner-company was only a successor-in-interest to an earlier company called “Malbar Chemical Fertilizers” incorporated as early as 1964 having its registered office at New Delhi and therefore merely because it commenced its activity in 1976, it would not be eligible to the benefits or incentives under order as at exhibit A.

5. In the reply filed to the statement of objections, the company has clarified as to how a new company was formed in 1971 pursuing the object for which the earlier company had been incorporated and new capital structure was provided for and raised and it was only in or about 1973 after obtaining the loan, the factory was erected partly on account of the incentives offered by the 1969 notification of the State Government as at exhibit A and therefore, the company was and is entitled to the benefits or incentives offered for a period of 5 years which according to the company would have ended in the year 1980-81. We must not at this stage fail to notice that a further notification came to be issued by the respondent-State of Karnataka in the year 1977 as at exhibit G bearing the date 12th January, 1977. Pursuant to that notification of 1977 several industrial units came to be denied the incentives and refund of sales tax paid by the industries so eligible on the ground that industries had abused or misused the incentive offered and those industrial units challenged the legality and correctness of the denial in several batch of writ petitions, first of which were decided by this Court in the case of Dharmendra Trading Co. v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, ILR (1979) 2 KAR 1909. That decision rendered by a learned single Judge of this Court was affirmed by a Division Bench and on appeal to the Supreme Court, the said appeal came to be dismissed affirming the views of the learned single Judge and the Division Bench of this Court. The decision of the Supreme Court is reported in [1988] 70 STC 59. In that view of the matter having regard to the decision of this Court earlier, affirmed by the Supreme Court as noticed by us, the petitioner contended that annexure R was clearly without the authority of law and therefore liable to be quashed as it had denied the benefit of the incentive offered to the new industry set up by it after 30th June, 1969. We must hold that the stand taken by the Government that the petitioner was not entitled to the benefit on account of not being a new industry is not well-founded. It is not a company or individual who is given the benefit of the incentive offered by the 1969 notification as at exhibit A. The condition precedent for deriving the benefit of incentive offered is that it should go into production after commencement of the operation of the notification extending the incentive. The very purpose of offering incentive was for encouraging the setting up of industries in the State. Therefore that petitioner had succeeded in some manner to the name and objects of the earlier company will not disentitle it to the benefits of the incentive offered by the 1969 notification. The State cannot deny that it went into production only in 1976 which is very much after the notification as at exhibits A and B. In fact it cannot be disputed for the simple reason, permission was indeed granted for the six months preceding 1st April, 1977 to withhold the sales tax payable for the previous year, namely, 1976-77. We have already noticed, it was only for the year 1977-78 though permission was applied for, the same was not granted and exhibit R, the letter demanding the payment of tax was issued. Therefore, we have no doubt in our mind, ordinarily the petitioner would have the benefit of the judgment which clearly stated that benefit could not be denied merely on the ground that some units were abusing it. That is the ratio of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Dharmendra's case, [1988] 70 STC 59.

6. It was however argued by Sri Kumar, appearing for M/s. King and Partridge that whatever was extended to the other units should also be extended to petitioner's unit. It had been clarified, the incentives, particularly in view of the observations of the learned single Judge in para 15 of Dharmendra's case as reported in ILR (1979) 2 KAR 1909 at page 1928, would continue in favour of all eligible units. The passage relied upon reads as follows:

“In the result, I declare and direct by issue of a writ in the nature of mandamus to the respondents in each of the writ petition, as under:

(i) that Order Nos. CI 58 FMI 69 and FD 396 CSL 74 dated 30th June, 1969 and 11th August, 1975, respectively, and any other order made thereto by the Government of Karnataka dealing with mode and form of exemption from payment of sales tax on the new industrial units started on and after 30th June, 1969, continue to be valid and binding on the respondents and they are not abrogated by the Order No. CI 141 FMI 76 dated 12th January, 1977, which order will apply only to the new industries that have been started by the petitioner on or after that date;

(ii) that the claim of each of the petitioner in respect of a new industrial unit started on or after 30th June, 1969, but on or before 12th January, 1977, for refund, adjustment and exemption from payment of sales tax under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 (Karnataka Act No. 25 of 1957), shall be considered and disposed of by the competent authority/authorities in accordance with Order Nos. CI 58 FMI 69 and FD 396 CSL 74 dated 30th June, 1969 and 11th August, 1975, respectively, and any other order made thereto by the Government of Karnataka from time to time dealing with the mode and form of exemption from payment of sales tax and not in accordance with the Order No. CI 141 FMI 76 dated 12th January, 1977;

(iii) that the respondents shall not enforce any of the demands made against any of the petitioners without re-examining their claims as directed by this order.”

7. But we cannot accede to the contentions that the decision rendered by this Court, affirmed by the Supreme Court covers the petitioner. But under exhibit B, the 1975 notification, a clear procedure was provided in order to claim the benefit of refund on the sales tax paid on raw materials purchased by the industrialists. The industrialists claiming the benefit had to secure the prior permission of the assessing authority to withhold the tax subject to the Government's permission. In other words prior permission was a condition precedent. In the instant case Mr. Kumar was not able to satisfy us, permission had indeed been granted. On the other hand, he fairly conceded that though an application was made, no permission was actually granted to withhold the payment. Therefore, in view of the 1975 notification prescribing the procedure for claiming the benefit under the 1969 notification as at exhibit A, there has been no compliance and as such, the petitioner will not be entitled to withhold the tax, with the result the demand at annexures R, S and T would be justifiable and legal.

8. There is yet another fact which persuades us to deny the relief prayed for by the petitioner and that is the notification as at annexure G dated 12th January, 1977, in clauses (iv) and (v) specifically excluded the incentive offered to new industrial units if the units had an investment of fixed asset in excess of Rs. 10 lakhs. That was not a question considered in Dharmendra's case, [1988] 70 STC 59 (SC) and ILR (1979) 2 KAR 1909, either by this Court or the Supreme Court as it was never pleaded nor argued. Clauses 4 and 5 read as follows:

“(iv) Industrial units with an investment on fixed assets of Rs. 10 lakhs and above and who are entitled to a development loan under the Government order dated 4th April, 1975, will not be entitled to the concession of refund of sales tax on raw materials.

(v) This scheme will continue to be implemented by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes based on a certificate issued by the Directorate of Industries and Commerce as regards the value of fixed assets.”

9. Mr. Kumar did not dispute that the assets of the petitioner-company run to crores of rupees and therefore is far in excess of the amount specified in clause (iv) of the order as at exhibit G. Unless the petitioner challenged the legality or otherwise the exclusion of the benefit to it the authority was bound to give effect to the Government Order. It would not be open to the authority to sit in judgment over the Government Order and it is not possible to make out in this writ petition that there was any plea made questioning the legality or validity of the order as at annexure G with reference to units with over Rs. 10 lakhs invested in machinery. In that view of the matter, the letter of demanding payment followed by exhibits S and T which are consequential cannot be said to be without the authority of law. No doubt, Mr. Kumar, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submitted that he may be permitted to amend the petition and challenge the validity of the order with reference to clauses (iv) and (v). We have declined to grant that permission having regard to the enormous lapse of time. The period of benefit has expired long ago, which is nearly 8 years. It was however contended that the passage extracted from the order of the learned single Judge in Dharmendra's case, ILR (1979) 2 KAR 1909 clearly held that the 1977 notification had not in any way abrogated the notification issued earlier as at annexure A in 1969. But then a careful reading of the passage which we have extracted earlier in the course of this order clearly goes to show that observation was made with reference to the petitioners before the court in that batch of writ petitions and it was not a general observation in regard to the other contents of the order made in 1977 as at exhibit G.

10. In the result, we have no choice but to sustain the demand made for the reasons we have given and dismiss this writ petition. There will be no order as to costs.

11. Writ petition dismissed.