Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Cosmas Bhengra v. State Of Jharkhand

Jharkhand High Court
Jun 15, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The two writ petitions were heard together because they raised common questions of law. Both petitioners (Cosmas Bhengra in W.P.(S) No. 474 of 2005 and Reena Kumari in W.P.(S) No. 532 of 2005) challenged memoranda dated 29 December 2004 (Memo No. 4808 and Memo No. 4810 respectively) whereby they were removed from service with retrospective effect from 26 December 2003. In each memo, the orders of removal referred to Rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1935 (the Civil Services Rules).

Both petitioners had applied for appointment as Constables pursuant to an advertisement dated 15 August 2003 (Advertisement No. 01/03) which fixed age criteria as on 1 January 2003. Cosmas Bhengra's date of birth was 4 January 1984, making him three days short of the lower age limit of 19 years as on 1 January 2003, although he was over 19 on the date of application and underwent selection, appointment, training and successfully completed training. Reena Kumari was alleged to have failed the Hindi reading and writing test but to have been shown as 'Pass' in the answer book allegedly by over-writing.

Both petitioners received show-cause notices after training (Memo No. 3831 dated 26 November 2004 for Cosmas; Memo No. 3800 dated 24 November 2004 for Reena). Each filed replies denying the allegations. The respondents did not dispute in their affidavit that no departmental proceedings (no charge-sheet, no appointment of an enquiry officer) were initiated before removal. The respondents, however, asserted a right to remove under Rule 668 and Rule 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the orders of removal issued under Rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services Rules (penal removal) are valid when no departmental enquiry, charge-sheet or appointment of an enquiry officer was made prior to removal.
  2. Whether Rule 668 / Rule 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual (relating to removal during probation without notice for unsatisfactory service) is applicable to the petitioners' removals.
  3. Whether the age irregularity of Cosmas Bhengra (three days short of 19 as on the cut-off date) justified removal when he was over 19 at the time of advertisement/application and had been selected, appointed and trained.
  4. Whether Reena Kumari's alleged alteration/over-writing of her written test result can be determined without initiating departmental proceedings and, if so, what procedure must be followed to resolve the factual dispute about whether she was correctly declared 'Pass'.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents' principal grounds for removal were: (a) Cosmas Bhengra was under-age by three days as per the advertisement's cut-off date; (b) Reena Kumari had failed the reading and writing test but was shown as passed, allegedly by over-writing.
  • The respondents contended they had the right to remove the petitioners under Rule 668 and Rule 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Both petitioners contended they were removed as a measure of punishment under Rules 49 and 55 of the Civil Services Rules without initiation of any departmental proceeding: no charge-sheet, no appointment of any enquiry officer, and no enquiry after notice.
  • Cosmas Bhengra submitted that although three days short of 19 as on 1 January 2003, he was over 19 at the date of application and had been selected, appointed and trained; he expected age relaxation and denied misrepresentation.
  • Reena Kumari denied the allegation of over-writing and asserted that she had been declared successful by the Selection Board and was appointed; she contested removal in the absence of departmental procedure.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from the undisputed factual premise that no departmental proceedings were initiated against either petitioner before issuance of the removal memos, and that the memos themselves referred to Rules 49 and 55 of the Civil Services Rules. The court made the following legal determinations and steps of analysis:

  1. Nature of the impugned orders:

    The orders of removal were treated by the court as penal in nature because they referred to Rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services Rules. Penal removals under those rules require adherence to the procedural safeguards set out in Rule 55 (service of charge-sheet, appointment of an enquiry officer, opportunity of hearing, etc.).

  2. Applicability of Rule 668 / Rule 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual:

    The court examined Rules 668 and 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual and observed that they concern removal of persons who have been appointed and are on probation, specifically permitting removal without notice if service is unsatisfactory during probation. The court held these provisions do not apply where the removal is penal in nature (i.e., based on alleged misconduct or misrepresentation), as in the present cases, because the impugned orders were framed under Rule 49 read with Rule 55 and not as summary probationary removals for unsatisfactory service.

  3. Procedural infirmity:

    Because the respondents accepted that no charge-sheet or departmental enquiry was conducted as required by Rule 55, the court concluded that the penal removal orders could not stand. The court emphasized that such orders could not be passed retrospectively without the procedural steps mandated by Rule 55 (no charge framed, no enquiry officer appointed, no enquiry after notice to petitioners).

  4. Application to Cosmas Bhengra:

    The court noted Cosmas was three days short of the minimum age on the retrospective cut-off date but was over 19 on the date of advertisement/application, had cleared physical and written tests, was recommended, appointed, trained and had not been found to have misrepresented his age (the impugned order itself accepted no misrepresentation). The court referred to a relaxation rule (framed under the proviso to Article 309, via notification dated 28 November 1956) allowing competent authority to relax service conditions and found that Cosmas's case was fit for relaxation because he was only three days under the cut-off and was compliant at the time of application/selection. The court also reasoned that any irregularity was regularized by the time of application because he had attained 19 years by then.

  5. Application to Reena Kumari:

    The court reinstated Reena with full back wages but remitted her case to the respondents with a specific limited liberty: the respondents may determine whether she was declared 'Pass' in the Hindi reading and writing test. The court directed that the examiner who signed the answer book and gave an opinion of 'Fail' or 'Pass' should be examined and that if a mistake by the examiner led to an improper entry, Reena would get the benefit. Crucially, the court required that any decision in this respect be taken only after initiation of departmental proceedings, with notice and opportunity to the petitioner (i.e., procedural fairness under Rule 55 must be followed).

  6. Relief ordered:

    Given the procedural defects in the removals and the considerations above, the court set aside the removal memos for both petitioners, ordered reinstatement and full back wages, but remitted Reena's case for a departmental determination as outlined. The court declined to remit Cosmas's case to respondents for re-evaluation of the legality of his appointment, instead directing reinstatement without reopening the appointment's legality.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were allowed. The court set aside Memo No. 4808 dated 29 December 2004 (as to Cosmas Bhengra) and Memo No. 4810 dated 29 December 2004 (as to Reena Kumari). Both petitioners were reinstated with full back wages. Cosmas Bhengra's reinstatement was final and the court declined to remit his appointment for reopening; Reena Kumari's reinstatement was accompanied by a remittal to the respondents to determine, by departmental proceedings (with notice and hearing), whether she had in fact been declared 'Pass' in the Hindi reading and writing test and to examine the examiner's evidence regarding any overwriting.

Implications: The direct consequences are (a) both petitioners are reinstated with full back wages, and (b) Reena Kumari's case may be subjected to departmental proceedings limited to resolving the factual dispute about her test result, following procedural safeguards. The opinion does not set out broader precedent-making analysis beyond its application of Rules 49, 55 of the Civil Services Rules and the non-applicability of Rule 668/668(KA) to penal removals; it therefore does not announce a novel legal principle beyond the application of those rules to the facts of these cases.

Order as to costs: The court ordered no costs in the facts and circumstances.

Show all summary ...

S.J Mukhopadhaya, J.:— In both the writ petitions, as common questions of law involved, they were heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.

2. The petitioner Cosmas Bhengra of W.P(S) No. 474 of 2005 has challenged the order contained in Memo No. 4808 dated 29th December, 2004, whereby and where under, he has been removed from service as a measure of punishment as envisaged under rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1935 (hereinafter referred to as the Civil Services Rules). The order of removal has been given effect from retrospective date i.e 26th December, 2003 and issued under the signature of S.P East Singhbhum, Jamshedpur.

3. The main plea taken by the respondents to remove the petitioner from service is that the petitioner was under-age by three days as per terms of advertisement.

4. So far as petitioner Reena Kumari of W.P(S) No. 532 of 2005 is concerned, she has challenged the order, contained in Memo No. 4810 dated 29th December, 2004, whereby and where under she has been removed from service as a measure of punishment as envisaged under Rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services Rules. The order of removal has been given effect from retrospective date i.e 26th December, 2003 and issued under the signature of S.P East Singhbhum, Jamshedpur.

5. The main ground taken by the respondents is that though she was shown to have failed in the written test, but most probably due to oyer-writing and showing her to have passed, she was recommended by the Selection Committee and appointed to the post of Constable.

6. In both the cases, the main plea taken by the petitioners is that they have been removed from service as a measure of punishment without initiation of a departmental proceeding though in the order of removal the respondent S.P East Singhbhum, Jamshedpur has referred Rules 49 and 55 of the Civil Services Rules.

7. The case of the petitioners is that they applied for appointment to the post of constable in pursuance of advertisement published by respondents in Newspapers on 15th August, 2003 (Advertisement No. 01/03). 15th September, 2003 was the last date for submission of applications. It was mentioned that the candidates should be in the age-group of 19 to 35 years (for general Category), 19 to 40 (for S.T/S.C categories) and 19 to 37 (for Backward/Extreme Backward Categories), as on 1 st of January 2003.

8. Both the petitioners applied in pursuance of said advertisement. The petitioner Cosmas Bhengra of W.P (S) No. 474/05 was more than 19 years of age at the time of application (applied in August, 2003), but was three days less than 19 years as on 1st January, 2003, his date of birth being 4th January, 1984. The petitioners were provided with Admit Cards, appeared in the physical and written test along with others and completed all the formalities. They having been selected by the Selection Board, were recommended for appointment and were appointed. Cosmas Behngra was appointed vide letter dated 6th February, 2004 issued by the S.P Jamshedpur. By another letter dated 6th February, 2004,- the petitioner Reena Kumari was appointed by S.P Jamshedpur. Both of them were sent for police training and came out successful. After return from the training, petitioner Cosmas Bhengra received a Memo No. 3831 dated 26th November, 2004 whereby he was asked as to why he be not dismissed from service. It was informed that as per advertisement, a candidate should have been in between 19-40 years of age as on 1st January, 2003 and when he applied he was found to be less than 19 years of age. It was alleged that the petitioner Cosmas Bhengra had given wrong information which shows his doubtful conduct and for that why he be not dismissed being ineligible for appointment. Petitioner Cosmas Bhengra thereafter filed show cause reply and submitted that he was about 19 years of age i.e three days less than 19 years as on 1st January, 2003 and thought that his age will be relaxed having attained 19 years of age at the time of application. Thereafter, without any departmental enquiry or charge-sheet, without appointment of any Enquiry Officer and without any enquiry, petitioner (Cosmas Bhengra) was removed from service as a measure of punishment in terms of Rules 49 and 55 of the Civil Services Rules by impugned Memo No. 4808 dated 29th December, 2004 from a retrospective effect i.e w.e.f 26th December, 2004, itself.

9. So far as petitioner Reena Kumari is concerned, she also received a show cause notice after return from training. She was noticed vide Memo No. 3800 dated 24th November, 2004 and was asked to show cause as to why she be not dismissed from service. It was alleged that though she was found successful in the physical test, but she failed in the reading and writing test. It was alleged that she through somebody else, got it over-written in the answer book and the word ‘Fail’ was changed into ‘Pass’, which was completely illegal and thereby as to why she be not dismissed from service. This petitioner Reena Kumari by her show cause reply dated 12th December, 2004 denied the allegation and submitted that she having been declared successful in the written test by the Selection Board, she was appointed. Thereafter without issuance of any charge-sheet, without appointment of any Enquiry Officer, without any departmental enquiry, she was removed from service as a measure of punishment vide Memo No. 4810 dated 29th December, 2004 from a retrospective date i.e w.e.f 26th December, 2004.

10. The respondents in their counter affidavit have not disputed the fact that no departmental proceeding was initiated against the petitioners and without any such proceeding they were removed from service. It was accepted that no charge-sheet was served as per Rule 55 of the Civil Services Rules.

11. While the facts, as narrated above, have been reiterated, it is pleaded that the respondents have right to remove the petitioners from service as per Rule 668 (KA) of the Bihar Police Manual.

12. From the plain reading of Rules 668 and 668(KA) of the Bihar Police Manual, it will be evident that the same relates to removal of those who have been appointed and are on probation. Under Rule 668 (KA), the competent authority has right to remove a person without any notice if service is found unsatisfactory during the period of probation.

13. The aforesaid rule is not applicable in the case of the petitioners herein, as they have not been removed from service on the ground of unsatisfactory service, while on probation. The orders of removal both dated 29th December, 2004 suggest that the orders have been passed under Rule 49 read with Rule 55 of the Civil Services Rules and thereby they are penal, in nature. Such orders of removal of service having been passed without initiation of a departmental proceeding as per Rule 55 of Civil Services Rules, no charge having framed against the petitioner, no Enquiry Officer having been appointed, no enquiry having been conducted after notice to the petitioners and the orders of removal having issued from retrospective date, such orders cannot be upheld.

14. Accordingly, the orders, as contained in Memo No. 4808 dated 29th December, 2004, so far as it relates to Cosmas Bhengra, and Memo No. 4810 dated 29th December, 2004, so far as it relates to Reena Kumari, are set aside.

15. So far as Cosmas Bhengra is concerned, admittedly, he was more than 19 years of age of the time of advertisement (15th August, 2003). He was merely three days less than 19 years as on the cut-off date i.e 1st of January, 2003, a cut-off date which was fixed from a retrospective date.

16. Admittedly, he applied along with others, came out successful both in physical and written tests and after recommendation of the Selection Board and having competed along with others, was appointed to the post of Constable. He also came out successful in the Police Training to which he had gone after his appointment.

17. The respondent State have framed a statutory rule under proviso to Article 309 vide No. 111.R-1-2010/55-A-1150 dated 28th November, 1956 commonly known as Relaxation Rule. Under such Rule, it is always open to the competent authority to relax any condition of service in regard to any individual and a class of person. As the petitioner Cosmas Bhengra was more than 19 years of age as on the date of advertisement, he was more than 19 years on the date he applied for appointment, as admittedly, he came out successful in both physical and written tests and competed and so recommended for appointment and as admittedly, he had not made any misrepresentation, as accepted in the impugned order dated 29th December, 2004, his case was a fit case for relaxation of age by the competent authority, as he was merely three days less than 19 years of age as on 1st January, 2003. Further, even if it is accepted that this petitioner was under age as on 1st January, 2003, he having attained the age of 19 years after three days, irregularity if any stood regularized by the time of application.

18. For the said reason, this Court is not remitting his (Cosmos Bhengra) case to the respondents nor giving any liberty to reopen the issue relating to legality of appointment of Cosmas Bhengra. He, accordingly, stands reinstated to the post with full back wages, his order of removal having been set aside by this Court, as ordered above.

19. So far as petitioner Reena Kumari is concerned, she also stands reinstated with full back wages, her order of removal having been set aside, but her case is remitted with liberty to the respondents to determine whether she was declared ‘Pass’ in the Hindi reading and writing test'. It will be appropriate if the evidence of the examiner is taken who put his signature on the answer book and gave his opinion as ‘Fail’/on ‘Pass’. If by mistake, she was declared ‘Fail’, but having found ‘Pass’, the examiner created mistake by overwriting ‘Fail’ as ‘Pass’, in such case, the petitioner Reena Kumari will get the benefit and will be treated to have been passed in the ‘Hindi reading and writing test’.

20. A decision in this respect be taken only after initiation of a departmental proceeding, after notice and hearing the petitioner Reena Kumari.

21. Both the writ petitions are allowed with aforesaid observations and directions. However in the facts and circumstances, there shall be no order, as to costs.