- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of J. & K. And Ors. v. Mohd. Iqbal
Factual and Procedural Background
The judgment under appeal is the decree dated 30 November 2004 of the Additional District Judge, Kishtwar, which awarded Rs. 7,00,000 as compensation plus interest at 6% till realization to the respondent (the father) for the death by electrocution of his two minor children. The electrocution occurred on 22 July 2000 at about 7 p.m. near an electric transformer at the Bus Stand, Kishtwar. The respondent, described as a poor paddler from Lal Pattan, Kishtwar, had claimed Rs. 10,00,000 as compensation under various heads. The State appellants challenged the decree, denying negligence and asserting that the transformer was properly fenced and that the children had entered the enclosure unauthorizedly. The trial court framed five issues (set out below), decided Issues Nos. 1–4 in favour of the respondent and awarded Rs. 7 lacs with interest from the date of institution. The State appealed against the trial court's decision; the present opinion addresses that appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether on 22-7-2000 the children of the plaintiff, namely Akhter Hussain and Miss Rozi, while going towards their house at about 7 p.m., died on account of electrocution near Bus Stand, Kishtwar, caused due to the negligent act of the defendants as the electric pole installed near the transformer was short-circuit? (Issue No. 1)
- If Issue No. 1 is proved in the affirmative, whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive damages to the amount of Rs. 10 lacs from the defendants on account of death of the said children? (Issue No. 2)
- Whether the plaintiff has not served the notice under Section 80 CPC and under Section 33 of the Electricity Act on the defendants, and if so, what is its effect on the suit? (Issue No. 3)
- Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action against the defendants, and if so how? (Issue No. 4)
- Reliefs (Issue No. 5).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The State (appellants) denied liability, asserting the electric transformer was properly fenced and located four yards from the main road.
- Even if the equipment was faulty, pedestrians on the main road would not be affected unless they meddled with the enclosure; therefore, the death resulted from the children's own act (unauthorized entry).
- Quantum of compensation awarded by the trial court was excessive.
Respondent's Arguments
- The State was negligent in maintaining the electric transformer and pole; the appellants' own evidence acknowledged electrocution due to a short circuit.
- The State, as the supplier of electric energy, had an obligation to take requisite measures so that transformers and lines do not cause harm to passers-by.
- The appellants failed to lead evidence sufficient to justifiably contest the respondent's claim.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a fact-sensitive analysis primarily grounded on the trial record and the testimony of the appellants' own official witnesses. The reasoning proceeded as follows:
- The court observed that the appellants' defence, as set out under Section 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure, was undermined by evidence produced by the appellants themselves (para 9).
- The court relied significantly on the testimony of DW-Asgar Hussain (Assistant Executive Engineer), who stated: the transformer was fenced on three sides but open on one side; there was no door or signboard restraining entry; on the date of occurrence it was raining; a gunny bag and wooden pieces were found inside the enclosure; one shoe of a deceased child was found within the boundary; and a puncture in the High-Tension link insulator had caused a short circuit affecting the fenced area (para 10).
- The court accepted that the appellants' own witness established both the occurrence of the short circuit and the physical condition of the enclosure (open side, no sign board), and therefore found no reason to depart from the trial court's conclusions (para 11, 15, 21, 25).
- The court noted that learned counsel for the appellants did not effectively contest these factual findings (para 12), and further accepted that the State bore responsibility for supply of electric energy in the area where electrocution occurred (para 13).
- The court referred to the Jammu and Kashmir Electricity Rules, 1978 (Chapter IV) as prescribing measures to be taken by suppliers to avoid danger arising from electricity lines, equipment and premises, and concluded that those statutory safety obligations impose primary liability on the supplier if transmitted electricity causes injury or death (paras 14–16, 18–19).
- The court applied the tort principle that entities undertaking hazardous activities owe a duty to take measures to prevent harm; it described this liability in terms of the doctrine of strict liability as understood in English common law — entities that collect and keep things liable to do mischief must keep them at their peril and are prima facie answerable for the natural consequences of their escape (paras 18–19, 23).
- Concluding that both the strict-liability concept and negligence were established from the respondent's and appellants' evidence (para 20), and given the admission that the enclosure lacked a door and warning signage (para 21, 25), the court found the State negligent in failing to take requisite safety measures to prevent harm to passers-by.
- On the question of quantum, the court accepted the trial court's assessment, rejecting the appellants' contention that the compensation was excessive (para 23).
- Because nothing was pointed out that undermined the trial court's findings, the appellate court affirmed all findings and rejected the appellants' plea that minors should be denied relief because they engaged in wrongful entry (para 24).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The appellate court affirmed the trial court's findings on Issues Nos. 1–4 and the award of compensation.
Direct effect on the parties: The decree of the Additional District Judge, Kishtwar, awarding Rs. 7,00,000 as compensation to the father of the two minor children, together with interest at the rate of 6% from the date of institution of the suit, is affirmed. The appeal was dismissed with costs fixed at Rs. 5,000. The Registry was directed to draw the decree sheet.
Broader implications: The opinion reiterated that suppliers of electric energy have a statutory and tort-based duty to take safety measures to prevent electrical hazards, and that those undertaking hazardous or risky activities may be held strictly liable for resulting injuries or deaths. The court did not announce or rely upon any new case-law precedent in this opinion.
1. Decree dated November 30, 2004, of learned Additional District Judge, Kishtwar, awarding an amount of Rupees seven lacs as compensation along with interest at the rate of 6 per cent till realization in favour of respondent, the father of two minor children who were electrocuted because of short circuit affecting electric pole installed near an electric transformer at Bus Stand, Kishtwar, has been appealed against by the State appellants.
2. The case of the respondent plaintiff is that he is a poor paddler settled in village Lal Pattan, Kishtwar, who started putting up in Kishtwar to make his both ends meet. On July 22, 2000, two children of the respondent plaintiff, namely Akthar Hussain and Baby Rozy, were coming towards their dwelling place, when at about 7 p.m, they were electrocuted near an electric transformer at bus stand, Kishtwar.
3. An amount of rupees ten lacs was claimed as compensation under various heads. The appellants refuted their liability on the premise that the electric transformer installed at bus stand had been properly fenced and was four yards away from the main road. Even if, it was faulty, the pedestrians on the main road, would not be affected unless they fiddle with it. The appellants claimed that there was no fault or negligence on their part and that they were not liable to pay compensation to the respondent, as the death of the children had occurred because of their own act.
4. Out of the pleadings of the parties, the trial Court framed following issues:—
“1. Whether on 22-7-2000 the children of the plaintiff namely Akhter Hussain and Miss Rozi while going towards their house at about 7 p.m died on account of electrocution, near bus stand, Kishtwar caused due to the negligent act of the defendants as the electric pole installed near the transformer was shot-circuit? OP
2. If issue No. 1 is proved in affirmative whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive damages to the amount of rupees ten lacs from the defendants on account of death of the said children? OPP
3. Whether the plaintiff has not served the notice u/S. 80 CPC & u/S. 33 of the Electricity Act on the defendants, if so, what is its effect on the suit? OPD
4. Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action against the defendants if so how? OPD
5. Relief.”
5. After discussing evidence of the parties, Issues Nos. 1 to 4 were decided in favour of the respondent and an amount of rupees seven lacs along with interest at the rate of six per cent from the date of institution of suit was awarded as compensation in favour of the respondent plaintiff.
6. Mrs. S. Hakim, learned Dy. Advocate General for the appellants, submits that the State is not liable for the electrocution of the minors because the minors had unauthorizedly made their entry in the electric transformer enclosure. They, thus, cannot take benefit of their own wrongs. Quantum of compensation too is on higher side, submits the learned Dy. Advocate General.
7. S.M Wajahat and A.A Hamal, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submit that the State was negligent in maintaining its electric transformer and electric pole and that the evidence of the appellants too acknowledges that the electrocution of the children was because of the short circuit. They further submit that the State is under an obligation to take all requisite measures to ensure that the functioning of the electric transformer/s and electric lines does not cause any harm to the passer-by. They further submit that the appellants have not led any evidence on the basis whereof the claim of the respondent could be justifiably contested.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the records.
9. The case set up by the appellants in their reply to the petition of the respondent under Section 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure, gets demolished by the official witnesses who were produced by them during the trial of the case.
10. DW-Asgar Hussain states that he was posted as Assistant Executive Engineer, Kishtwar and Bashir Ahmed was his Junior Engineer, who was Incharge of bus stand area with Raiz Ahmed as incharge Line Man. He states that the electric transformer near the bus stand stood fenced from three sides but was open from one side. When reached on spot on the date of occurrence, he found that the weather was bad and it was raining; he found gunny bag containing some wooden pieces on spot. One shoe of the deceased was also found within the boundary of the electric transformer. According to this witness, the incident had taken place because of puncture in the High-Tension link insulator, which resulted in short circuit of whole of the fenced area where electric transformer had been set up. He is emphatic in saying that there was no door installed near the electric transformer enclosure and the children could go inside from the opening. He further said that there was no sign board near the electric transformer which would indicate that the entry to the area was restricted.
11. In view of this version of the concerned Electric Engineer, I do not find any reason to come to a conclusion different from one reached at by learned Additional District Judge, Kishtwar, on the basis of evidence produced by the parties.
12. When confronted with this statement of appellant's own witness, learned counsel for the appellants, had nothing much to say on the factual aspect of the case, that the children had died because of the short circuit of the electric pole, electric transformer and the enclosure.
13. Learned counsel for the appellants admits that the responsibility to supply the electric energy in the area where electrocution had taken place was that of the State.
14. The Jammu and Kashmir Electricity Rules, 1978, in Chapter IV prescribe various measures, which are required to be taken by a supplier of electric energy, to avoid danger arising from the electricity lines, equipments and the premises, where such supply lines, wires, fittings and apparatus are installed.
15. Various safety measures are required to be taken by the supplier of electric energy in terms of the Rules to ensure that no danger is caused to anyone because of the use of electric energy, wires, apparatus or premises. If the electric energy so transmitted causes injury or death of anyone, who gets trapped into it, the primary liability to compensate the sufferer is that of the supplier of the electric energy.
16. So long as the electricity transmitted, through the wires is potential of dangerous dimensions, the Manager of its supply, i.e, State Government, have the added duty to take safety measures to prevent escape of such energy and to see that there is no short circuit of such equipments, wires, etc. and none is put to any peril.
17. The State cannot be conceded any defence of attributing mischief to users of the road for electrocution because of short circuit. This is particularly so in case of minors, who under law, are presumed to be disabled of taking care of themselves. The transmission of electric energy by the State, carries with it the added responsibility of ensuring that the carriage of such electric energy does not cause any damage to anyone and that all the electric lines and areas through which the energy is to pass, are not prone to damage to the users of public road or areas in and around such areas.
18. The persons or authorities undertaking an activity involving hazardous or risky exposure to human life are liable under Law of Torts to compensate for the injury suffered by any other person in respect of any negligence or carelessness on the part of the persons/authorities, who undertake such hazardous or risky activity. The liability cast on this count is in law known as “Strict Liability”. It differs from the liability, which arises on account of the negligence or fault.
19. The Doctrine of Strict Liability as it is understood in English Common Law is that the person who for his own purposes collects and keeps there anything liable to do mischief, if it escapes, must keep it at his peril and if he does not do so, he is prima-facie, answerable for all the damages which is natural consequence of its escape.
20. The respondent plaintiff has proved both these concepts from his evidence as also from appellants evidence, who have acknowledged electrocution because of short circuit.
21. The admission of the appellant's witness that one side of the electric transformer enclosure was open and there was no sign board of danger or of any prohibition regarding entry in the enclosure, goes a long way in proving that the State and its functionaries have been negligent in taking requisite measures to ensure that the electricity being supplied by it does not cause harm to the passers by.
22. In the Indian society, parents expect a lot from their off-springs and carry great expectations from them, who according to the culture, values and ethos are supposed to take care of parents in their old age. The parents are, thus, required to be compensated for all that they had expected from their children.
23. The compensation awarded, by the learned Additional District Judge, Kishtwar, to the father of the two minor children does not, therefore, appear to be on the higher side as urged by Mrs. Hakim.
24. Finding of the learned trial Court on all the issues is, thus, affirmed, because nothing has been pointed out by the appellants regarding the unsustainability of the findings of the trial Court. The plea raised by the learned counsel for the appellants that the minors cannot take benefit of their own wrongs is untenable, in view of the clear proposition of law that those carrying out activity involving hazardous or risky exposure to human life, are required to carry out their activity only after taking such measures that their activity does not cause any loss or damage to anyone.
25. No other point has been urged by the learned counsel for the appellants in support of the appeal.
26. This appeal is, therefore, without merit, which is, accordingly, dismissed with costs quantified at rupees five thousand. Registry to draw decree sheet.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert