Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Sughra Bibi And Others

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Nov 30, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (J.P. Singh, J.) — Letters Patent Appeal

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal challenges the judgment dated 29.12.2000 in C.I.M.A No. 117 of 1996, by which the learned single Judge dismissed the appellant's appeal and upheld the award dated 9.3.1996 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jammu.

The factual matrix as stated in the opinion: Noor Hussain was loading milk cans on the rooftop of a bus (registration No. JK 02-A 4817) when the bus driver, allegedly driving rashly and negligently, caused an instantaneous death of Noor Hussain by electrocution with overhead electric wires.

Claimants — Sughra Bibi (widow), Rubla (aged 4 years), Tariq Hussain (stated as aged 272 years in the record), and Sadiq Hussain (aged 1 year) — filed a claim petition registered as file No. 125.Claims. The Claims Tribunal framed issues including (1) whether the accident was caused by the rash/negligent driving of the bus, (2) amount of compensation and by whom payable, (3) whether the offending bus was driven without a valid driving licence and in violation of the insurance policy, and (4) relief.

The Tribunal found in favour of the claimants on issues 1, 2 and 3, holding the driver negligent and awarding Rs. 2,60,000 with interest at 12% and directing New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (the insurer) to satisfy the award. The insurer appealed to the High Court (civil first miscellaneous appeal) on essentially the same ground raised before the Tribunal (challenging the insurer's liability on the basis that the driver did not hold a valid/renewed licence). The learned single Judge rejected the insurer's plea relying on a Division Bench judgment of the Madras High Court (Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indirani), and dismissed the appeal. The present Letters Patent Appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-renewal of the driver's driving licence (i.e., a licence that had not been renewed at the time of the accident) renders the driver "not duly licensed" under section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, thereby enabling the insurance company to escape liability under the policy.
  2. Whether a passenger bus falls within the statutory meaning of a "transport vehicle" for the purposes of section 14(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (relevant to licence currency and renewal periods).
  3. Whether, on the facts of this case, the insurer was exempt from liability because the driver's licence was not renewed (and specifically whether any statutory provision or precedent converts mere non-renewal into lack of being "duly licensed").

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (New India Assurance Co. Ltd.) — Arguments

  • The insurer's counsel contended that the words "duly licensed" in section 149(2)(a)(ii) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, should be read to mean an "effective driving licence"; hence the non-renewal of a driving licence renders the driver not "duly licensed" and relieves the insurer of liability under the policy.
  • The appellant relied on statutory provisions (section 2(10), section 3 and section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988) in support of the contention that a licence not renewed is not "effective" and therefore the driver was not "duly licensed."
  • The appellant cited authorities including Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indirani (Madras), Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Felix Correa ((2003) 10 SCC 289), and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh (2004 ACJ 1 SC) to support its submissions.

Respondents / Claimants — Arguments / Case

  • The claimants produced evidence before the Tribunal establishing negligence of the driver resulting in instantaneous death by electrocution; the Tribunal awarded compensation which the insurer was directed to satisfy.
  • The claimants opposed the insurer's attempt to avoid liability on the ground of non-renewal of the licence; the Tribunal and the learned single Judge rejected the insurer's plea.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indirani, 1995 ACJ 703 (Madras) Relied upon by the learned single Judge below to reject insurer's plea that it could escape liability on licence-related grounds. The learned single Judge had relied on this Division Bench judgment to dismiss the insurer's appeal; the present court noted that the single Judge's reliance on this authority was a basis for upholding the lower court's decision.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Felix Correa, (2003) 10 SCC 289 Cited by learned counsel for the appellant in support of the "effective licence" interpretation (as part of submissions that non-renewal defeats insurer's liability). The court observed that the judgments cited by the appellant (including Felix Correa) do not deal with the specific situation where a licence has not been renewed; accordingly they do not assist the appellant's contention on non-renewal.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, 2004 ACJ 1 (SC) Cited by appellant's counsel; discussed for the meaning of "effective licence" and whether it can be imported into "duly licensed" in section 149(2). The court quoted para 38 of this Supreme Court judgment and relied on it to reject the appellant's attempt to import the concept of "effective licence" from section 3 into the words "duly licensed" in section 149(2). The court held that Swaran Singh actually supports the view that "effective licence" cannot be read into "duly licensed."
Ashok Gangadhar Maratha v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 2000 ACJ 319 (SC) Used to explain the statutory meaning of "transport vehicle" (that for a vehicle to be a transport vehicle it must be a goods carriage) and distinguish passenger vehicles from transport vehicles. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to hold that a passenger bus does not fall within the definition of "transport vehicle" for purposes of section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, thereby undercutting an argument that relied upon classification as a "transport vehicle."

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise statutory and precedent-based analysis limited to the matters raised in the appeal:

  1. Statutory definitions and scope:
    • The court examined section 2(10) (definition of "driving licence") and concluded that it merely defines a driving licence as a licence issued by a competent authority (excluding only a learner's licence). It does not exclude from the definition a person who possesses a valid licence that has not been renewed after its renewal became due.
    • Sections 3 and 14 were considered and the court observed they do not assist the appellant's contention that non-renewal converts a licensed person into an unlicensed one for the purpose of section 149.
  2. Precedential guidance regarding "effective licence" and "duly licensed":
    • The court noted that the authorities cited by the appellant do not deal with cases where a licence has not been renewed, and therefore are not directly applicable to the question before the court.
    • Crucially, the court relied on para 38 of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh (SC), which holds that the words "effective licence" in section 3 cannot be imported into sub-section (2) of section 149 and that the words "duly licensed" used in section 149(2) are used in the past tense. On this basis the court rejected the appellant's submission that "effective licence" should be read into "duly licensed."
  3. Analysis of section 14 (currency of licences) and classification of vehicles:
    • The court examined section 14, which prescribes currency periods for licences (including different regimes for "transport vehicles" and other licences). The court concluded a passenger bus is not a "transport vehicle" as defined for these purposes, relying on the Supreme Court in Ashok Gangadhar Maratha to interpret "transport vehicle" as meaning goods carriage.
    • Consequently, the appellant's attempt to rely on the transport-vehicle renewal regime in section 14(2)(a) failed because a passenger bus does not fall under that classification.
  4. Effect of non-renewal and section 15 (renewal of licences):
    • The court reviewed section 15 governing renewal. It highlighted the fourth proviso: if an application for renewal is made more than five years after the licence ceased to be effective, the licensing authority may refuse renewal unless the applicant passes a test of competence. The court observed there is no other statutory provision that automatically disables a person from being able to drive simply because the licence has not been renewed.
    • On this basis the court concluded that a person once licensed remains a person able to drive unless there is proof of physical disability or a lapse greater than five years that engages the proviso in section 15; mere non-renewal within five years does not convert the person into "not duly licensed."
  5. Application to facts:
    • The court noted that the present case did not allege or establish that more than five years had elapsed since expiry of the licence or that the driver had some physical disability. Therefore the insurer's plea that non-renewal rendered the driver "not duly licensed" was misconceived and unsustainable.
  6. Conduct of litigation and costs:
    • The court criticized the insurer for repeatedly raising the same plea over many years, thereby prolonging litigation and causing hardship to the widow and minor dependents. The court found this a fit case to award substantial litigation expenses to the claimants and ordered Rs. 50,000 as such costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Direct consequences and implications:

  • The judgment of the learned single Judge and the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal were upheld; New India Assurance Co. Ltd. remains liable to satisfy the award (previously quantified by the Tribunal at Rs. 2,60,000 with interest at 12%).
  • The insurer was ordered to pay litigation expenses/costs of Rs. 50,000 to the claimants-respondents for having prolonged litigation and causing hardship to the victims' family.
  • The court's reasoning resolves the specific question addressed: non-renewal of a driving licence (within five years of expiry and absent proof of physical disability or other statutory disqualification) does not convert a licensed person into one who is "not duly licensed" under section 149(2) so as to absolve the insurer of liability. The opinion rests on statutory construction (sections 2(10), 14, 15) and relevant Supreme Court authority (para 38 of Swaran Singh and Ashok Gangadhar Maratha) as applied in the case.
  • The opinion confines itself to the direct effect on the parties in this litigation; no separate new broader legal principle or precedent beyond the statutory and precedent application in this case is set out by the court in this opinion.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add facts, inferences, or outside information not contained therein.

Show all summary ...

J.P Singh, J.:— This Letters Patent Appeal is directed against judgment dated 29.12.2000 in C.I.M.A No. 117 of 1996, whereby while dismissing the appeal of appellant, learned single Judge has upheld the award dated 9.3.1996 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jammu.

2. Facts leading to the filing of this Letters Patent Appeal may be summarised thus:

One Noor Hussain was loading milk in cans on the rooftop of a bus bearing registration No. JK 02-A 4817 when driver of the bus, without taking requisite care and caution, drove it rashly and negligently, which resulted in the instantaneous death of said Noor Hussain because of electrocution with overhead electric wires.

3. Sughra Bibi, widow of the deceased; Rubla aged 4 years; Tariq Hussain aged 272 years and Sadiq Hussain aged 1 year, filed a claim petition which came to be registered as file No. 125.Claims.

4. The Claims Tribunal raised following issues for deciding the claim petition. These issues read thus:

“(1) Whether accident involving death of the deceased has occurred by the use of the offending bus driven rashly and negligently by its driver respondent No. 3? OPP

(2) What is amount of compensation payable to the petitioners and by whom in the event of proof of issue No. 1 in the affirmative?” OPP

(3) Whether offending bus was driven without a valid driving licence and in violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy? OPR-1

(4) Relief.”

5. The claimants led their evidence on the basis whereof issue Nos. 1, 2 and 3 were decided in favour of the claimants in holding that the driver of the vehicle was negligent in driving the vehicle, which resulted in instantaneous death of Noor Hussain, the deceased. The claimants were held entitled to an amount of Rs. 2,60,000 along with interest at the rate of 12 per cent.

6. After discussing the issue No. 3, in detail, the Tribunal held that the insurance company cannot escape its liability on the plea that the driver of the offending vehicle did not hold a valid driving licence in his favour. The plea raised by the insurance company that the licence though issued in the name of the driver had not been renewed on the date of accident and as such the insurance company was absolved of its liability, was found to be without merit.

7. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. was, thus, directed to satisfy the award.

8. The appellant insurance company, filed a civil first miscellaneous appeal in this court putting up the same plea, which it had raised before the Tribunal.

9. Relying on a Division Bench judgment of Madras High Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indirani, 1995 ACJ 703 (Madras), the learned single Judge rejected the plea and dismissed the appeal of the insurance company with costs quantified at Rs. 1,000.

10. Undaunted by the repeated failure of its plea, which appears to have been projected only with a view to protract the litigation and facilitate the filing of the appeals one after another, one of the premier insurance companies of the country, ventured again to protract the litigation and aggravated the misery and suffering of those who had been left without a breadwinner.

11. Mr. R.K Gupta, learned counsel appearing for New India Assurance Co. Ltd., canvassed the same old story which the company had been projecting since 1994, when the claim petition was filed. Mr. Gupta referred to section 2(10), section 3 and section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, to canvass that expression ‘duly licensed’ appearing in section 149(2)(a)(ii) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, would mean ‘effective driving licence’. According to Mr. Gupta, non-renewal of a licence of a driver would mean that he is not duly licensed to drive the vehicle, which in turn would be sufficient for an insurance company to avoid its liability with the aid of section 149 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

12. Mr. R.K Gupta refers to Oriental Insurance Co, Ltd. v. Felix Correa, (2003) 10 SCC 289 and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, 2004 ACJ 1 (SC), to support his submission.

13. We have considered the submission of Mr. R.K Gupta, as also the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.

14. Section 2(10) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, does not advance the plea raised by Mr. Gupta, in that, it only defines ‘driving licence’, which means the licence issued by a competent authority under Chapter II authorising the person specified therein to drive, otherwise than as learner's licence, a motor vehicle or a motor vehicle of any specified class or description. This definition excludes only a learner's licence from the definition of the driving licence. It does not exclude a person who though possessing a valid driving licence under Chapter II, has not got it renewed or had got it renewed after the date when its renewal became due.

15. Likewise, sections 3 and 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, also do not provide any assistance to learned counsel for the appellant.

16. The judgments cited by the learned counsel for the appellant do not deal with a case where the licence of a driver has not been renewed.

17. Learned counsel for the appellant was repeatedly asked to cite any judgment which may support his submission that non-renewal of licence for a short or long period would bring the case of such licensee as an unlicensed person, disabled, as such, to drive a motor vehicle.

18. Judgment cited by Mr. Gupta in support of his submission reported as National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, 2004 ACJ 1 (SC), does not support his submission. It, on the other hand, holds in para 38 that words ‘effective licence’ used in section 3 cannot be imported in words ‘duly licensed’ occurring in section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. It would be profitable to refer this para. Para 38 reads, thus:

“(38) The words ‘effective licence’ used in section 3, therefore, in our opinion cannot be imported for sub-section (2) of section 149 of Motor Vehicles Act. We must also notice that the words ‘duly licensed’ used in sub-section (2) of section 149 are used in past tense.”

19. In view of what has been held by Hon'ble Apex Court of India in the above quoted para, we are not inclined to accept the plea of Mr. Gupta that expression ‘effective licence’ is to be kept in view while interpreting the expression ‘duly licensed’, occurring in section 149.

20. The plea of learned counsel for the appellant, even otherwise, is untenable because the counsel had additionally sought to bring the case of non-renewal of licence of the driver of a passenger vehicle, in section 14(2)(a). This the learned counsel appears to have done being conscious of the fact that the case of the appellant in respect of non-renewal of licence of the driver of a passenger vehicle, may not fall in clause 14(2)(b), because the age of the driver and date of issue of licence had not been proved by the insurance company.

21. In order to appreciate the plea raised by learned counsel for appellant, we may refer to section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which reads thus:

“14. Currency of licences to drive motor vehicles.— (1) A learner's licence issued under this Act shall, subject to the other provisions of this Act, be effective for a period of six months from the date of issue of the licence.

(2) A driving licence issued or renewed under this Act shall,—

(a) in the case of a licence to drive a transport vehicle, be effective for a period of three years:

Provided that in the case of licence to drive a transport vehicle carrying goods of dangerous or hazardous nature be effective for a period of one year and renewal thereof shall be subject to the condition that the driver undergoes one day refresher course of the prescribed syllabus; and

(b) in the case of any other licence,—

(i) if the person obtaining the licence, either originally or on renewal thereof, has not attained the age of fifty years on the date of issue or, as the case may be, renewal thereof,—

(A) be effective for a period of twenty years from the date of such issue or renewal; or

(B) until the date on which such person attains the age of fifty years, whichever is earlier;

(ii) if the person referred to in subclause (i), has attained the age of fifty years on the date of issue or as the case may be, renewal thereof, be effective, on payment of such fee as may be prescribed, for a period of five years from the date of such issue or renewal:

Provided that every driving licence shall, notwithstanding its expiry under this sub-section, continue, to be effective for a period of thirty days from such expiry.”

22. There is no reason for us to accept the argument of Mr. Gupta that a passenger bus would fall within the definition of a ‘transport vehicle’ as contemplated by section 14(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. A plain reading of various clauses of section 2, would demonstrate that passenger motor vehicles have been specifically defined in section 2 of the Motor Vehicles Act, whereas ‘transport vehicle’ has been specifically defined in sub-section (47) of section 2. A passenger bus cannot, thus, be said to fall in the definition of ‘transport vehicle’ in terms of section 14 of Motor Vehicles Act.

23. The plea projected by Mr. Gupta cannot, thus, come to his rescue to support the view that licence of the driver had ceased to be effective in the absence of any proof on records that the driver had attained the age of fifty years on the date of issue or renewal of the licence.

24. We are supported in taking this view by a judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Ashok Gangadhar Maratha v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.., 2000 ACJ 319 (SC), wherein it has been observed that:

“(6) … For a vehicle to be a transport vehicle, it must be a goods carriage which in turn means any motor vehicle constructed or adapted for use solely for the carriage of goods or when not so constructed or adapted used for the carriage of goods. We have the definitions of ‘heavy goods vehicle’ and ‘medium goods vehicle’…”

25. Reasons given by the Tribunal as also learned single Judge, do not warrant acceptance of any view other than the one taken by two courts. A driver once licensed continues to possess the ability to drive the vehicle unless it is proved on facts that he has incurred any physical disability to drive the motor vehicle. Non-renewal of his licence would not disable him, as such, to drive the vehicle. Such omission of the driver would, however, entail infraction of the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act, for which he may be appropriately punished under the Act, if his licence is otherwise proved to need renewal under law. Non-effectiveness of his licence would not, however, permit him to be treated as ‘not duly licensed’ under section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act.

26. Section 15 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, deals with ‘Renewal of driving licences’. We may refer to this section to appreciate the effect of this section on the plea raised by the learned counsel for the appellant. Section 15 reads thus:

“15. Renewal of driving licences.— (1) Any licensing authority may, on application made to it, renew a driving licence issued under the provisions of this Act with effect from the date of its expiry:

Provided that in any case where the application for the renewal of a licence is made more than thirty days after the date of its expiry, the driving licence shall be renewed with effect from the date of its renewal:

Provided further that where the application is for the renewal of a licence to drive a transport vehicle or where in any other case the applicant has attained the age of forty years, the same shall be accompanied by a medical certificate in the same form and in the same manner as is referred to in sub-section (3) of section 8, and the provisions of subsection (4) of section 8 shall, so far as may be, apply in relation to every such case as they apply in relation to a learner's licence.

(2) An application for the renewal of a driving licence shall be made in such form and accompanied by such documents as may be prescribed by the Central Government.

(3) Where an application for renewal of a driving licence is made previous to, or not more than thirty days after the date of its expiry, the fee payable for such renewal shall be such as may be prescribed by the Central Government in this behalf.

(4) Where an application for the renewal of a driving licence is made more than thirty days after the date of its expiry, the fee payable for such renewal shall be such amount as may be prescribed by the Central Government:

Provided that the fee referred to in subsection (3) may be accepted by the licensing authority in respect of an application for the renewal of a driving licence made under this sub-section if it is satisfied that the applicant was prevented by good and sufficient cause from applying within the time specified in sub-section (3):

Provided further that if the application is made more than five years after the driving licence has ceased to be effective, the licensing authority may refuse to renew the driving licence, unless the applicant undergoes and passes to its satisfaction the test of competence to drive referred to in sub-section (3) of section 9.

(5) Where the application for renewal has been rejected, the fee paid shall be refunded to such extent and in such manner as may be prescribed by the Central Government.

(6) Where the authority renewing the driving licence is not the authority which issued the driving licence it shall intimate the fact of renewal to the authority which issued the driving licence.”

27. It is only the fourth proviso appended to the section which prescribes that if the application for the renewal of driving licence is made more than 5 years after the driving licence has ceased to be effective, the licensing authority may refuse to renew the driving licence, unless the applicant undergoes and passes to its satisfaction the test of competence to drive referred to in sub-section (3) of section 9.

28. There is no other disabling provision which debars a licensing authority to renew the expired driving licence on any prescribed condition of testing the capability of the person to drive a motor vehicle.

29. A person once found entitled to the issuance of a driving licence would, thus, continue to be a person able to drive a motor vehicle regardless of the renewal of his driving licence unless five years have elapsed from the date when his existing driving licence has ceased to be effective. In this view of the matter, we find that the non-renewal of licence within a period of five years from the date of issue or renewal thereof, would not bring such licensee in the definition of ‘not a duly licensed person’.

30. The present case is not based on any such plea that the licence of the driver had not been renewed within a period of five years from the date of its alleged expiry.

31. The plea raised by Mr. Gupta is, therefore, misconceived which is accordingly rejected.

32. No other plea has been raised by Mr. R.K Gupta.

33. This appeal is, accordingly, found to be without any merit. It is, accordingly, dismissed.

34. Facts of the present case, amply demonstrate as to how a premier insurance company of the country has misused the judicial channel to drag a widow and her minor sons and daughter to the highest court of the State, thereby causing agony, inconvenience besides unnecessary pecuniary loss in arranging money to defend this litigation launched by the insurance company. The widow and minors have been deprived of their due for over a period of 11 long years. This is a fit case where the claimants need to be substantially compensated by awarding litigation expenses in their favour.

35. We, accordingly, while dismissing the appeal, burden the insurance company to pay an amount of Rs. 50,000 (rupees fifty thousand) as litigation expenses/costs to the claimants-respondents.

36. Appeal dismissed.