Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lalita Shuri Tikku And Others v. State Of Jammu And Kashmir And Others

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Mar 16, 1966
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

By notification the Principal of Government Medical College, Srinagar invited applications for admission to the 1st year MBBS course. The minimum qualification was passing F.Sc. Medical group or Pre-Medical examination of any recognized university. Many candidates, including the seven petitioners in these connected petitions, applied and were interviewed by a selection board. The Principal prepared an original merit list and forwarded it to the Government through the Secretary of the relevant department.

The petitioners alleged that, although they were ranked high in the original merit list, the Government asked for a revised list in which the petitioners were placed much lower. Ultimately 75 candidates from the State were selected for admission. The petitioners claimed that the Government ignored their higher marks and made selections based on caste, creed and residence rather than on merit, thereby discriminating against them in contravention of Articles 14, 15 and 29 of the Constitution of India. One petitioner (Kumari Billori) specifically alleged discriminatory treatment inter se among members of the scheduled castes.

The respondents (represented by the Chief Secretary and the Advocate General) defended the selections on the basis that some candidates selected had been drawn from socially and educationally backward classes, some from Jammu residents, and some from scheduled castes. The Chief Secretary filed affidavits asserting such classifications but did not disclose supporting data or identify the classes relied upon.

The petitions were taken up while a major portion of the academic session was over. The court considered the petitions with evidence and the parties' affidavits and rendered the present judgment ordering relief to the petitioners.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the selection of candidates for admission to the 1st year MBBS course was arbitrary or discriminatory and thereby contravened Articles 14, 15 and 29 of the Constitution of India.
  2. Whether the State lawfully made a special provision under Article 15(4) for socially and educationally backward classes, scheduled castes or residents of Jammu, and if so whether such classification met constitutional limits.
  3. If the selection was impermissibly discriminatory, what relief should be granted given that many selected candidates had already been admitted and a major portion of the session had elapsed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted they stood much higher on the original merit list prepared by the Principal than those ultimately selected by the Government.
  • They alleged the Government made selections on the basis of caste and creed rather than merit, and thereby discriminated against them in violation of Articles 14, 15 and 29 of the Constitution.
  • Kumari Billori alleged inter se discrimination within the scheduled caste group: despite higher marks and proof of scheduled-caste status (including a magistrate's certificate), she was overlooked in favour of lower-scoring scheduled-caste candidates.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents (through the Chief Secretary and the Advocate General) contended the selections were made on merit overall but that certain preferences were given to candidates drawn from (a) socially and educationally backward classes, (b) permanent residents of Jammu, and (c) scheduled castes.
  • The Advocate General argued that the affidavits of the Chief Secretary should be treated as evidence of a special provision under Article 15(4), with selection being made accordingly (including reservation of seats for Jammu residents and other categories).
  • In support of residence-based classification, reliance was placed on precedents and propositions that residence is distinct from place of birth and that Article 15 permits discrimination based on place of residence.
  • The Chief Secretary's affidavits, however, did not furnish data, statistics or identify the classes said to be socially and educationally backward; they were the first occasion the point was taken in answer to these petitions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1963 SC 649 Established that provisions of Article 29(2) must be read subject to Article 15(4); special provision under Article 15(4) must be for classes (not individuals); classification cannot be based solely on caste; courts can examine whether a special provision is within permissible limits; a 68% reservation was held beyond permissible limits in that authority. The court relied on this authority to derive the tests and conditions for permissible classification under Article 15(4) and to hold that the impugned classification and reservation in the present case were inconsistent with Article 15(4).
AIR 1965 Pat 372 (Division Bench, Patna High Court) Addressed a similar situation and held that fixation of a backward class made purely on the basis of caste without considering Supreme Court principles was improper. The court cited this decision to fortify its conclusion that the State in the present case had fixed or preferred candidates on the basis of caste without applying the principles required by the Supreme Court.
AIR 1958 Kerala 33 Held that residence is distinct from place of birth and selection based on residence cannot be hit by Article 15 or 29; supports discrimination permitted on the ground of place of residence. The court relied on this authority (and related Supreme Court observations) to accept that a classification based on residence (here: seats reserved for Jammu residents) is permissible under Article 15.
AIR 1955 SC 334 Observed that place of birth and residence are different matters and that Article 15(4) permits discrimination based on place of residence. The court applied this principle to uphold the legality of reserving seats for candidates from Jammu as a permissible residence-based classification.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by reference to constitutional provisions and the Supreme Court authority (AIR 1963 SC 649) to determine the validity of any special provision or classification claimed by the State under Article 15(4). The reasoning unfolded in the following steps, drawn from the opinion:

  1. The court reiterated that Article 29 prohibits denial of admission to any candidate on grounds of religion, race, caste, language, etc., but Article 15(4) (inserted by the First Amendment) permits the State to make special provisions for socially and educationally backward classes, scheduled castes and scheduled tribes. To claim protection under Article 15(4) the State must show that a special provision has been made either by legislation or by executive action.
  2. The court extracted and summarized from authority the conditions that a permissible classification for backward classes must satisfy. These conditions (as set out in the opinion) are:
    • The backward class must be a class of citizens and not individual citizens;
    • The class must be grouped after considering multiple factors (social, economic, caste, education) and not based on caste or religion alone;
    • The class must be both socially and educationally backward; when assessing educational backwardness, student population percentages (e.g., five per thousand benchmark mentioned) are relevant, and poverty/economic conditions bear on social backwardness;
    • Reservations should not be disproportionate so as to exclude other citizens (the opinion notes that a 68% reservation was held invalid in the cited Supreme Court authority);
    • A special provision must be made by the State, either by legislation or by executive order/notification, showing that the State applied its mind and relied on data/statistics in declaring the class backward.
  3. Applying these tests to the facts, the court found that the State failed to satisfy the required conditions:
    • The Chief Secretary's affidavits, which for the first time asserted classification, did not disclose the data, statistics or identify the classes treated as socially and educationally backward;
    • There was no evidence of any legislative enactment or executive notification having been issued before or at the time of selection to constitute the required "special provision" under Article 15(4); the classification was only asserted in answer to the petitions;
    • The selection appears to have given preference to certain candidates "merely because they happened to belong to a particular caste or religion," and in the case of scheduled castes a preference was shown inter se among members of the caste that disadvantaged the petitioner Kumari Billori;
    • In the absence of material showing social and educational backwardness (for example, evidence of extremely low education levels or poverty), the court concluded it could not accept that the so-called class legitimately qualified as both socially and educationally backward under the constitutional test.
  4. The court considered the claim that seats were reserved for residents of Jammu. Applying the precedents about domicile and residence, the court accepted that discrimination based on place of residence is permissible under Article 15 and that the Chief Secretary had indicated that 23 out of 75 seats were reserved for Jammu residents. The court therefore upheld the validity of the residence-based classification.
  5. Regarding individual marks and treatment, the court analyzed the petitioners' marks as supplied by the Advocate General. The court observed an instance where the Selection Board had deducted 10 marks from one petitioner (Romesh Kumar Tikku) because he passed at the second attempt; the court saw no warrant for that deduction from the University aggregate, and therefore counted the university aggregate for fairness. The court identified specific selected candidates who had lower marks than several petitioners and concluded those preferences were given because of caste/reservation considerations that did not meet constitutional requirements.
  6. As to remedy, the court balanced the competing considerations: (a) a major portion of the academic session had passed, (b) the other selected candidates had not been made parties and their admissions could not be vacated without injustice, and (c) the Chief Secretary had not asserted that all seats were filled leaving no room. The Advocate General indicated that the petitioners could be admitted without much inconvenience.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions were allowed and a writ of mandamus was issued commanding the respondents to admit the petitioners to the 1st year MBBS course of the Government Medical College, Srinagar.

Implications and direct effects as stated in the opinion:

  • The court directed admission of the petitioners to the 1st year MBBS course to which they were entitled by virtue of their merit, without disturbing the existing admissions of other candidates.
  • The court expressly noted the particular case of Kumari Billori as one of hostile discrimination within scheduled-caste selections and found that her treatment was contrary to Articles 15(4) and 29.
  • The court upheld as permissible the State's reservation of seats for residents of Jammu (23 out of 75 seats) as a residence-based classification under Article 15.
  • The court emphasized that, in future, if the State intends to make a special provision under Article 15(4), it should do so either by legislative enactment or by executive order/notification and should record the statistics and factors relied upon (referring to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court and "Balaji's case").
  • There was no order as to costs in the special circumstances of the case.

Judicial concurrence: Ali, J. delivered the leading judgment; J.N. Bhat, J. concurred and expressly agreed with the order, noting discrimination on the basis of religion.

Relief Ordered

The court allowed the petitions and issued a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to admit the petitioners to the 1st year MBBS course at Government Medical College, Srinagar. The court did not disturb the admissions of other selected candidates and made no order as to costs.

This summary is confined to the information and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce facts or conclusions beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Ali, J.:— These seven applications for an appropriate writ directing the respondents to admit the petitioners to the Medical College, Srinagar raise common questions of law and fact and would, therefore, be disposed of by one common judgment.

2. The facts leading to the presentation of these petitions may be briefly summarised as follows:— By a notification issued by the Principal Medical College Srinagar applications were invited for admission to the 1st year of MBBS course of lire said college. The minimum qualification under the Notification was that the candidate must have passed either F.Sc Medical group or Pre Medical examination of any recognized university. A large number of candidates including the petitioners applied for admission to the Government Medical College. Srinagar and after the candidates were interviewed by a selection board, a merit list was prepared by the Principal and forwarded to the Government through the Secretary General department.

3. The allegation of the petitions is that although the petitioner's names were pretty high in the original merit list submitted by the Principal yet the Government with an intention of making an arbitrary selection, asked for a revised list in which the petitioners were placed very much below and ultimately 75 candidates from the State were selected for admission to the Government Medical College. Sri nagar the petitioner's case is that while selecting the candidates the Government ignored the cases of the petitioners who had secured much higher marks than the candidates who have actually been selected. It is also stated by the petitioners that the selection was made purely on the basis of caste, creed rather than on merit. The petitioners further complained of hostile discrimination at the hands of the State which is in direct contravention of the provisions of Articles 14, 15 and 29 of the Constitution of India. The petitioners have further submitted that although some sort of reservations are alleged to have been made for scheduled caste and the residents of Jammu but there also the selection was made by discriminating between the candidates inter se rather than selecting candidates from a class as a whole. In writ petition No. 69 of 1965 Kumari Bilori alleges that she belongs to scheduled caste and although she secured much higher marks than other candidates who have been selected from the scheduled caste, her claim was completely ignored and a discrimination was thus made as between the class itself.

4. The petitions have been contested by the respondents firstly on the ground that the selection was made purely on merit and those candidates who were selected with lesser marks than the petitioners, were drawn from socially and educationally backward classes or the scheduled caste as classified by the Govt. In the affidavits which have been filed by the Chief Secretary on behalf of the respondents, no data or statistics have been given in support of their plea that certain reservations were made for socially and educationally backward classes. It is also not indicated in the affidavits as to who the socially and educationally backward classes are.

5. It appears that no special provision had been made by the Government in respect of seats for socially and educationally back ward classes, or members of the scheduled caste at the time of selecting the candidates or even till the time when the writ petitions were presented to this court.

6. The point, however, has been taken for the first time in the affidavits filed by the Chief Secretary and that too without giving any data for the basis of the classification made by the Government. It is true that Article 29 clearly prohibits the State from denying admission to any candidate into an educational institution maintained by it on the ground of religion, race, caste, language or any of them. Article 29 thus enshrines a fundamental right to the citizens of India with respect to admission into educational institutions maintained by the State or those receiving aid out of the State funds Article 15 sub-clause 4 which was inserted by the Constitution 1st Amendment Act of 1961 is a proviso to Article 29 and permits the State to make any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward class of citizens or for the scheduled castes and the scheduled tribes in order therefore, to claim the benefit of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India the State must show that a special provision has been made either by a Legislative enactment or even by an executive order. Where, however, no such provision is made by the State. Article 29 will apply without any fetters and the State is not permitted to make any discrimination on the grounds mentioned in Article 29 of the Constitution of India. Even when the State makes a special provision under Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India, the matter is clearly justiciable and the courts can examine whether the provision falls within permissible limits of Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India. The matter appears to have been considered at length by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in AIR 1963 SC 649. In this authority, their Lordships clearly indicated that the provision of Article 29(2) have to be read subject to the provisions of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India. It was further pointed out that the provision contemplated by Article 16(4) must be made for socially and educationally backward class of citizens and not for individual citizens as such. In other words, what their Lordships meant was that although the Government could make a classification of a particular section of backward classes, it could not be allowed to ignore the other members of the society completely in the garb of making a provision for a particular class and where the provision is made for a backward class purely on the basis of caste, such a classification is not permitted even by Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India While the Government could take caste of the class concerned as one of the factors to be considered a classification on the basis of caste alone be beyond the purview of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India. Their Lordships further pointed out that in making such a provision, the State has to consider the social conditions of the class namely the extent of its poverty or progress as also the question as to how far the class concerned is educated. In other words, whenever a provision is made the courts could consider the validity of the provision by examining the factors and the data on the basis of which the provision has been made in order to determine whether the provision is justified by the plain language of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India. In the case before their Lordships of the Supreme Court a reservation of 68 per cent was held to be beyond the permissible limits of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India. In this connection, their Lordships observed as follows:

“Therefore, in dealing with the question is to whether any class of citizens is socially backward or not, it may not be relevant to consider the caste of the said group of citizens in this connection it is, however, necessary to bear in mind that the special provision is contemplated for classes of citizens and not for individual citizens as such, and so though the caste of the group of citizens may be relevant, its importance should not be exaggerated. If the classification of backward classes of citizens was based solely on the caste of the citizens, it may not always be logical and may perhaps contain the vice of perpetuating the caste themselves.

......

All that this court is called upon to do in dealing with the present petitions is to decide whether the tests applied by the impugned order are valid under Article 15(4). If it appears that the test applied by the order in that behalf is improper and invalid, then the classification of socially backward classes based on that test will have to be held to be inconsistent with the requirements of Article 15(4).”

7. In our opinion, when the State makes a special provision for the advancement of the weaker sections of society specified in Article 15(4) it has to approach its task objectively and in a rational manner Undoubtedly, it has to take reasonable and even generous steps to help the advancement of weaker elements: the extent of the problem must be weighed, the requirements of the community at large must be borne in mind and a formula must be evolved which would strike a reasonable balance between the several considerations. Therefore, we are satisfied that the reservation of 68 per cent directed by the impugned order is plainly inconsistent with Article 15(4)…. We have already noticed that the impugned order in the present case has categorised the Back-ward classes on the sole basis of caste, which, in our opinion, is not permitted by Article 15(4); and we have also held that the reservation of 68 per cent made by the impugned order is plainly inconsistent with the concept of special provision authorised by Article 15(4). Therefore, it follows that the impugned order is a fraud on the Constitutional powers conferred on the State by Article 15(4)”

8. Thus analysing the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in the case cited above, the permissible classification of a backward class must satisfy the following conditions:

1 That the said backward class must be drawn from a class of citizens and not from individual citizens as such

2 That the said class must be grouped after considering several factors social, economic, caste and the like and should not be based on caste or religion alone

3 That the said class must not only be socially but also educationally backward. In considering social backwardness of a class of citizens the poverty or the economic conditions of a particular class may be vital factors. Similarly in considering the educational backwardness, the Government has got to keep in mind the percentage of student population of the class of citizens. Where the student population of such a class is to the extent of five per thousand or more it cannot be considered to be educationally backward

4 The reservation of seats in the class concerned should not be disproportionate so as to exclude completely the other members of the society or the citizens A reservation of 68 per cent for a particular class of citizens or community has been held by the Supreme Court to be invalid and beyond the permissible limits of Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India.

5 In order to make a classification a special provision must be made by the State either by a Legislative enactment or by an executive order.

9. In the instant case, we are satisfied that none of these conditions have been fulfilled while preferring some of the candidates from the so-called backward class to the petitioners. We are further fortified in our view by a division bench of the Patna High Court reported in AIR 1965 Pat 372, where under similar circumstances a Division Bench of the Patna High Court held that the fixation of a backward class was made purely on the basis of caste without taking the principles laid down by the Supreme Court into consideration.

10. it is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the present case falls clearly within the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the aforementioned case. On the other hand, the Advocate General submitted that in the instant case, the selection was made on the basis of classification contemplated by Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India. He drew our attention to the affidavits of the Chief Secretary in various petitions which show that the selection was made, firstly on the basis of candidates who were drawn from socially and educationally backward classes, secondly of candidates who were residents of Jammu and thirdly, of candidates who were drawn from scheduled caste. It was, therefore, contended by the Advocate General that the affidavits of the Chief Secretary should be construed as a special provision falling within the permissible limits of Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India. We are however, unable to agree with tins argument Article 15(4) as already indicated, clearly contemplates that there must be a special provision for the classes mentioned in that Article, such a provision need not be made by a Legislative enactment and it can be made also by an executive order, but there must be some order of notification to show that the State having applied its mind to the various factors and the statistics of a particular class of citizens considers it to be a socially and educationally backward class for whose benefit provision has to be made. In the instant case, no such provision at all appears to have been made by the State. For the first time, in answer to the petitions, the stand taken by the Chief Secretary is that the selection has been made after taking into consideration the nature of the socially and educationally backward classes of citizens and of scheduled castes. Even in the affidavits, the Chief Secretary has not disclosed the data, statistics of the factors which go to make a particular class as a socially and educationally backward one. It has not even been indicated as to which is the class of citizens which has been declared to be socially and educationally backward. In these circumstances, therefore we are constrained to hold that since no provision under Article 15(4) has been made the selection has been made on a purely discriminatory basis. At any rate, it is manifest that the selection of the candidates who have secured lessen marks than the petitioners has been made purely on the basis of caste in the case of candidates drawn from the so-called socially and educationally backward community. They have been given preference merely because they happened to be long to a particular caste or religion and in the case of scheduled castes preference has been given to them merely because they belonged to scheduled caste. Such a discrimination however, as pointed out by the Supreme Court in the case mentioned above is not at all permissible by Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India. Indeed, if the Chief Secretary had disclosed the various statistics and the factors which led the Government to make the classification, this court would have been able to determine whether the classification made was within the permissible limits of Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India take for instance the case of those candidates who are drawn from the so-called socially and educationally backward community and who have been preferred to the petitioners. There is no evidence or material in this case to show in what way the so-called class of citizens can be termed as both socially and educationally backward class. It has not been alleged that the percentage of education of the so-called class of citizens is so low that they may be treated as educationally backward. We might mention here that in the case before the Supreme Court the average of a student population at 5 per thousand was not considered to be sufficient to enable the so-called class of citizens to be treated as educationally backward in the State. Similarly, it has not been shown before us that social backwardness of the so-called class of citizens arise from extreme poverty. In absence, therefore, of any such materials before the court, it will be difficult for us to hold that the so-called class of citizens could be grouped as socially and educationally backward class. At any rale, the fact remains that in absence of any special provision having been made by the State under Article 15(4) of the Constitution of India, Article 29 applies without any fetters and the State is not permitted to make any discrimination on the ground of caste, race, language or the like.

11. We might indicate that according to the list submitted by the Advocate General, the petitioners Romesh Kumar Tikku, Khema Kaul. Lalita Shuri. Bansi Lal Kaul. Nancv Tikku, Bimla Tikku and Kumari Billori have secured 346, 340½, 323½, 308, 319, 314½ and 280½ marks respectively including the marks granted to these candidates at the interview. We might mention here that in the case of Romesh Kumar Tikku the aggregate which he had secured at the University Examination was actually 343 but the Selection Board deducted 10 marks because he had passed at the University examination at the second attempt. We see no warrant at all on the part of the Selection Board to have deducted 10 marks from the aggregate which the candidate had secured at the University by virtue of his sheer merit. At the most the Selection Board could have deducted marks reserved for the interview, if this principle was to be kept into consideration. In these circumstances we have therefore, taken the aggregate of the petitioner is secured by him in the University ignoring the deduction of 10 marks by the Selection Board. Even otherwise the aggregate of this petitioner including the marks awarded at the interview would come to 336, which is higher than the aggregate of some of the candidates selected by the Government. On the other hand some of the candidates who have been selected for admission to the Government Medical College have secured lesser marks than these candidates and these are Nos. 27, 30, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 to 42, 48 to 55, 58, 69, 70, 71 and 72, in the list of the candidates who have been selected for admission to the Government Medical College the candidates with lesser marks were obviously selected merely because they happened to belong to the so-called backward class of citizens of Kashmir province. As regards the candidates drawn from Jammu it was submitted by the Advocate General that such a classification could be made on the basis of residence. In this connection reliance was placed on an observation of Kerala High Court reported in AIR 1958 Kerala 33 and the provisions of Article 15 of the Constitution of India. It is true that what Article 15 prohibits is discrimination on the ground of birth alone. Their Lordships of the Kerala High Court held that since residence is a matter separate from the place of birth, selection based on the ground of residence cannot be hit by Article 15 or 29 of the Constitution of India. In (S) AIR 1955 SC 334 it was clearly pointed out that the place of birth and residence were different matters and Article 15(4) permits discrimination based on place of residence. It is not disputed before us that some of the candidates who were preferred to the petitioners were drawn from Jammu and were permanent residents of Jammu a part of the State of Jammu and Kashmir. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court have held that even different areas in the State could be regarded as a country for the purpose of domicile. In this connection their Lordships of the Supreme Court observed as follows:—

“Domicile has reference to the system of law by which a person is governed and when we speak of the domicile of a country, we assume that the same system of law prevails all over that country. But it might well happen that laws relating to succession and marriage might not be the same all over the country, and that different areas in the State might have different laws in respect of those matters. In that case, each area having a distinct set of laws would itself be regarded as a country for the purpose of domicile.”

12. In view, therefore, of the decision of the Supreme Court, there can be no doubt that the State could be permitted to make a discrimination on the ground of place of residence. The Chief Secretary in his affidavit has clearly indicated that 23 out of 75 seats were reserved for candidates coming from Jammu such a classification, however, being permissible by Article 15(1) cannot be held to be invalid. In these circumstances, therefore the argument of learned Advocate General on this score must prevail.

13. Lastly the case of Kumari Billori appears to us to be one of wanton and hostile discrimination. According to the list submitted by the Advocate General. Kumari Billori who appears at Serial No. 281 secured 280½ marks and is described in the list as a member of scheduled caste she has also stated this fact in her affidavit and has also filed a certificate from a Magistrate to the effect that she belongs to the scheduled caste. The Chief Secretary in his affidavit has merely stated that sufficient materials have not been produced to show that Kumari Billori belongs to scheduled caste, but has not categorically denied the fact that she belongs to the scheduled caste. On the materials in this case we are satisfied that Kumari Billori was doubtless a member of the scheduled caste. Despite this fact two of the candidates belonging to the scheduled caste in the list of the selected candidates namely Gur Dass and B.R Panhotay have been given preference to Kumari Billori although the marks seemed by them were 275 and 269 respectively which were obviously less than Kumari Billori. It is therefore, manifest that a discrimination inter se between members of the scheduled caste has also been made by the State and Kumari Billori appears to have been subjected to hostile discrimination instead of her case being considered on merits.

14. Thus it is apparent that the discrimination by the State in respect of the petitioner Kumari Billori is clearly hit by Article 29 of the Constitution of India and is beyond the permissible limits of Article 15 sub-clause 4. For the reasons mentioned above, we are satisfied that the contentions raised by the petitioners are sound and must prevail.

15. The next question that falls for consideration is as to the rebel which should be granted to the petitioners. The petitions have been taken up at a time when a major portion of the session is already over. Furthermore, as the candidates who have been preferred to the petitioners have not been made parties to these petitions it will be wholly unjust to quash their admissions at this stage. Thirdly, the Chief Secretary has not alleged that all the seals in the Government Medical College have been filled up leaving no room for any further admission. On the other hand the Advocate General informs us that it the petitioners are ordered to be admitted at the Government Medical College Srinagar by this court, this can be done without much inconvenience. In these circumstances we feel that the admission of the other candidates need not be disturbed and the interests of justice will be served by issuing a writ of Mandamus commanding the respondents to admit the petitioners to the 1st year MBBS course of the Government Medical Collage Srinagar to which they are entitled by virtue of their merit. We however hope that in future, at the time of making selection of the candidates for admission to the Government Medical College Srinagar the Government may consider the desirability of making a special provision as contemplated by Article 15 sub-clause 4 of the Constitution of India either by Legislative enactment or by an executive order enshrining the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Balaji's case, as indicated above.

16. For these reasons, therefore, we would allow the petitions and a writ of mandamus is hereby issued commanding the respondents to admit the petitioners to the 1st year MBBS course of the Government Medical College, Srinagar.

17. In the special circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.

18. J.N Bhat, J.:— As the petitioners have been discriminated against on the basis of their religion I agree to the order proposed by my learned brother.

EJ/AGT/D.V.C

19. Petitions allowed.