Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

United Commercial Bank v. Mani Ram

Himachal Pradesh High Court
Oct 23, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — M.R. Verma, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This application was filed under Order 21, Rules 84/85 read with Sections 148 and 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the auction purchaser seeking (a) extension of time to deposit the auction money, (b) a direction not to resell the property already auctioned in his favour, and (c) an order that the amount already deposited by him not be forfeited.

The relevant factual background is: pursuant to a warrant of sale dated 22-6-2002, a landed property (JD No. 1) was put to auction on 3-8-2002. The auction purchaser was the highest bidder at Rs. 1,25,000/-. He paid Rs. 33,000/- immediately after the auction (the 25% deposit required by Rule 84). He failed to deposit the remaining auction money within 15 days of the auction and ultimately deposited the remaining amount on 3-9-2002. The present application followed to seek an extension of time to 3-9-2002 and to prevent resale and forfeiture.

The court heard the decree-holder's counsel and the Law Officer for the State; the auction purchaser's counsel had been partly heard on prior dates (30-9-2002 and 1-10-2002). Records were perused and the matter was finally heard.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court can, in exercise of its powers under Section 148 and/or Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, extend the statutory 15-day period prescribed by Rule 85 of Order 21 for payment of the full purchase money by an auction purchaser.
  2. Whether default in depositing the full purchase money within the statutory period must inevitably result in forfeiture of the deposit made under Rule 84, or whether forfeiture is discretionary under Rule 86 of Order 21, and if discretionary, what relief (if any) is appropriate in the circumstances of this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Auction Purchaser's Arguments

  • The failure to deposit the balance within 15 days was not intentional. It was caused by the auction purchaser's illiteracy and lack of knowledge that the entire sale amount had to be deposited within 15 days.
  • The auction purchaser's mother (about 78 years old) fell ill and required treatment in Chandigarh; this event caused delay in depositing the balance.
  • Accordingly, the time to deposit the amount may be extended till 3-9-2002 and the amount tendered on 3-9-2002 be accepted as valid discharge of his obligation; the property should not be resold and the 25% deposit made on the spot should not be forfeited.

Decree-Holder and State's Arguments

  • Sections 148 and 151 of the Code cannot be invoked to extend the statutory period prescribed under Rule 85 of Order 21 for payment of the purchase money.
  • The consequences prescribed by Rule 86 of Order 21 (including resale and possible forfeiture) must follow when payment is not made within the statutory period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad, AIR 1954 SC 349 - Confirms that Rule 85 (payment within 15 days) is mandatory in its prescription of time.
- Holds that if payment is not made within 15 days, the Court has discretion to forfeit the deposit but is obliged to resell the property; defaulting purchaser forfeits claim to the property.
The court relied on this authority to conclude (a) that the 15-day period under Rule 85 cannot be extended by the Court using Sections 148/151, and (b) that while resale of the property is imperative upon default, forfeiture of the deposit under Rule 86 is discretionary — the Court may forfeit all, part, or none of the deposit after defraying sale expenses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by analyzing the relevant statutory provisions of Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure and the scope of Sections 148 and 151 of the Code:

  1. Rule 84 of Order 21 requires immediate payment by the purchaser of 25% of the purchase money at the auction. The auction purchaser had complied by depositing Rs. 33,000/-. (Finding of compliance with Rule 84.)
  2. Rule 85 prescribes that the full purchase money must be paid into Court before it closes on the fifteenth day from the sale. The court read this provision as a statutory time prescription that is "apparently mandatory in nature." (Interpretation of Rule 85.)
  3. The court analyzed Section 148, observing that Section 148 applies only where the time for doing an act has been fixed by the Court itself; it does not apply where the time is prescribed by statute. Because Rule 85 fixes the 15-day period by statute and not by the Court, Section 148 cannot be invoked to extend the period. (Limit on Section 148.)
  4. Similarly, the court held that the inherent powers under Section 151 cannot be used to grant relief that is beyond the scope of the law. Once the statute prescribes 15 days, the inherent power cannot be used to extend that statutory time. (Limit on Section 151.)
  5. The court relied on the Supreme Court authority (Manilal Mohanlal Shah) to confirm that Rule 85's time requirement is mandatory and that the Court's discretion regarding consequences is limited to forfeiture under Rule 86, while resale is mandatory. (Use of precedent to frame mandatory vs discretionary effects.)
  6. Interpretation of Rule 86: the use of the word "may" shows that forfeiture of the deposit is discretionary (the Court may forfeit all, part, or none of the deposit after defraying sale expenses). However, Rule 87 and the scheme compel resale upon default; cancellation of the auction purchase and obligation to resell is imperative. (Distinction between mandatory resale and discretionary forfeiture.)
  7. Application of facts: the auction purchaser attributed his default to illiteracy, lack of knowledge, and his mother's illness; these averments were supported by affidavit and were not controverted. The court accepted these explanations as credible. (Evaluation of factual excuses.)
  8. Balancing justice and statutory scheme: although the statutory 15-day period could not be extended and resale followed as a consequence, the court concluded that forfeiture of the entire deposit would be too harsh given the accepted reasons for delay. Accordingly, the court exercised the discretionary power under Rule 86 to mitigate the forfeiture by ordering partial forfeiture and partial refund after defraying sale expenses. (Exercise of discretion within statutory constraints.)

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application to extend the statutory 15-day period and to prevent resale was dismissed; the Court held that the 15 days prescribed by Rule 85 cannot be extended by invoking Sections 148 or 151 of the Code. Resale of the property upon default is mandatory, but forfeiture of the deposit under Rule 86 is discretionary. The Court ordered that, after defraying the expenses of the sale, fifty percent of the remaining portion of the Rs. 33,000/- deposit be forfeited to the Government and the other fifty percent be refunded to the auction purchaser. The additional sum of Rs. 92,000/- that the auction purchaser deposited on 3-9-2002 was ordered to be refunded to him. The application was disposed of in these terms.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the auction purchaser's prayer for extension of time and for preventing resale was denied; resale is to proceed pursuant to the statutory scheme. The auction purchaser does not lose all of his initial deposit: after deducting sale expenses, half of the remaining deposit is forfeited and half is refunded, and the late-deposited Rs. 92,000/- is refunded.
  • Legal principle reaffirmed: the court reaffirmed that the 15-day time-limit in Rule 85 is a statutory prescription that the Court cannot extend under Section 148 or its inherent powers under Section 151. The decision follows and applies the precedent in Manilal Mohanlal Shah (AIR 1954 SC 349) concerning the mandatory nature of the payment period and the mandatory resale obligation on default, while recognizing judicial discretion in forfeiture under Rule 86.
  • No new precedent was stated to be laid down; the judgment applies and reconciles existing statutory provisions and precedent to the facts before the court.
Order accordingly.
Show all summary ...

M.R Verma, J.:— This application under O. 21, Rr. 84/85 read with Sections 148/151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereafter referred to as ‘the Code’) has been filed by the applicant-auction purchaser (hereafter referred to as ‘the auction purchaser’) for extension of time to deposit the auction money and not to direct resale of the property already auctioned in his favour and not to forfeit the amount already deposited by him.

2. Brief facts leading to the presentation of this application are that in execution of a decree pursuant to the warrant of sale dated 22-6-2002, the landed property of JD No. 1 was put to auction in which the auction purchaser was the highest bidder in the sum of Rs. 1,25,000/-. Immediately after the auction, he deposited a sum of Rs. 33,000/- of the auction money on the spot. However, he failed to deposit the remaining auction money within 15 days of the date of auction. Hence this application.

3. It has been averred in the application that the auction purchaser is an illiterate rustic villager and was not aware that the “total sale amount” was required to be deposited within 15 days of the auction nor he was so informed by anyone. Further, mother of the auction purchaser, who is about 78 years of age, fell ill and had to be removed to Chandigarh for treatment and this fact also resulted in delay in depositing the remaining auction amount within the prescribed time. In the aforesaid circumstances, the remaining auction amount has been deposited by the auction purchaser on 3-9-2002, therefore, the time to deposit such amount may be extended till 3-9-2002 and the property may not be ordered to be resold and deposited amount may not be forfeited.

4. I have finally heard the learned counsel for the decree holder. However, learned counsel for the auction purchaser was not present today but he has been heard in part on 30-9-02 and 1-10-2002. Records also perused.

5. When the matter was partly heard on 30-9-02 and 1-10-2002, the learned counsel for the auction purchaser had contended that the lapse in not depositing the amount within the stipulated period was not intentional but because of the illness of the mother of the auction purchaser and want of knowledge on his part that such amount had to be deposited within 15 days of the auction. It was, therefore, urged that the time for depositing the amount may be extended till 3-9-2002 in exercise of the powers of this Court under Sections 148/151 of the Code and the amount tendered on 3-9-2002 may be accepted as valid discharge of the obligation of the auction purchaser and the property may not be resold and the 1/4th of the amount deposited by him on the spot may not be forfeited.

6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the DH and the learned Law Officer for the State, submitted that the provisions of S. 148 and/or 151 of the Code cannot be invoked to extend the time and the necessary consequences as per Rule 86 of Order 21 of the Code must follow.

7. There is no dispute that the auction took place on 3-8-2002. Rule 84 of Order 21 of the Code requires the auction purchaser to pay immediately after he is so declared, a deposit of 25% of the amount of his purchase money to the officer or other person conducting the sale. Having deposited a sum of Rs. 33,000/-, the auction purchaser had complied with this requirement.

8. Rule 85 of Order 21 of the Code provides for depositing of the remaining purchaser money and reads as follows:

“Time for payment in full of purchase money

The full amount of purchase money payable shall be paid by the purchaser into Court before the Court closes on the fifteenth day from the sale of the property.

Provided that, in calculating the amount to be so paid into Court, the purchaser shall have the advantage of any set off to which he may be entitled under R. 72.”

9. It is clear on a bare reading of the aforesaid provisions that the full amount of purchase money shall be paid by the auction purchaser to the Court on or before the 15th day from the sale of the property and this provision is apparently mandatory in nature.

10. The contention of the learned counsel that this period of 15 days as prescribed under Rule 85 supra, can be extended by the Court in exercise of its powers under Sections 148 and 151 of the Code, is not tenable. Section 148 of the Code will apply only to a case where the time has been fixed by the Court for doing any act under any provision of the Code. This section will, however, have no application where the time for doing certain act has not been fixed by the Court but is prescribed by law. The 15 days time for depositing the entire purchase money by the auction purchaser is prescribed by the Statute and is not fixed by the Court, therefore, the Court has no power to extend the time prescribed under Rule 85 supra in exercise of its powers under Section 148 of the Code. The inherent powers of the Court under Section 151 of the Code also cannot be invoked to grant a relief beyond the scope of law. Once the law has fixed time of 15 days for depositing the full amount of purchase money in the Court, such period cannot be extended by the Court in exercise of its inherent powers.

11. In Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad, AIR 1954 SC 349, the Hon'ble Apex Court, while dealing with the provisions of O. 21, R. 85 of the Code, held as under:

“The provision regarding the deposit of 25 per cent by the purchaser other than the decree holder is mandatory as the language of the rule suggests. The full amount of the purchase money must be paid within fifteen days from the date of the sale but the decree holder is entitled to the advantage of a set off. The provision for payment is, however, mandatory…… (Rule 85). If the payment is not made within the period of fifteen days, the Court has the discretion to forfeit the deposit and there the discretion ends but the obligation of the Court to resell the property is imperative. A further consequence of non payment is that the defaulting purchaser forfeits all claim to the property….. (Rule 86).”

12. In view of the above position in law, the time limit of 15 days to deposit the full amount of purchase money payable by the auction purchaser, as provided under Rule 85 supra, cannot be extended.

13. The next question which arises for consideration is whether the default of the auction purchaser in depositing the full purchase money within the stipulated, must invariably result in forfeiture of 25% of purchase money deposited by him immediately after the finalisation of the auction or the Court has the discretion in the matter of such forfeiture?

14. Rule 86 of Order 21 of the Code which deals with the procedure in default of payment of the purchase money as provided under Rule 85 reads as follows:

“In default of payment within the period mentioned in the last preceding rule, the deposit may, if the Court thinks fit, after defraying the expenses of the sale, be forfeited to the Government, and the property shall be re-sold, and the defaulting purchaser shall forfeit all claim to the property or to any part of the sum for which it may subsequently be sold.”

15. A bare reading of the above provisions makes it abundantly clear that it is not obligatory upon the Court to forfeit the deposit made under Rule 84 of Order 21 of the Code in case of default to deposit the full purchase money. The use of expression “may” regarding such forfeiture clearly makes out that it is discretionary with the Court to forfeit such deposit as a whole or in part or not to forfeit it at all and permit the auction purchaser to withdraw the same after defraying the expenses of the sale.

16. In Manilal Mohanlal Shah's case (AIR 1954 SC 349) (supra), (the extract whereof has already been quoted hereinabove) the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while dealing with the scope of Rule 86 (supra), also held that the Court has the discretion in the matter of forfeiture of deposit. However, in view of the provisions of Rule 86 supra read with Rule 87 providing for resale of the property, it is clear that default of the auction purchaser in making the payment of full purchase money in accordance with Rule 85, will result in automatic cancellation of the auction purchase and the obligation of the Court to resell the property is imperative and indispensable as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Manilal Mohanlal Shah's case (supra), the relevant part whereof has already been quoted hereinabove.

17. As already stated hereinabove, the default committed by the auction purchaser in not depositing the full amount within the prescribed period has been attributed to his being illiterate and unaware of the relevant provisions of the law and also to the illness of his mother and the time consumed in her treatment. The averments in this regard as made in the application are duly supported by affidavit of the auction purchaser and there is no counter. Thus, there is no reason to disbelieve the reasons assigned by him for committing the default. I am, therefore, inclined to hold that the forfeiture of the entire amount deposited by the auction purchaser under Rule 84 of Order 21 of the Code will be too harsh an action. The interest of justice will be met if after deducting the expenses of the sale, one half of the remainder of the amount is forfeited and the remaining half is ordered to be refunded to the auction purchaser.

18. As a result, the prayer of the auction purchaser to extend the time for depositing of full purchase money and not to resell the property is dismissed. Out of the amount of Rs. 33,000/- deposited by the auction purchaser immediately after the auction, the expenses incurred in the sale will be retained and 50% of the remaining amount, after defraying expenses of sale is forfeited to the government and the remaining half thereof is ordered to be refunded to the auction purchaser. Needless to say, that the amount of Rs. 92,000/- deposited by the auction purchaser on 3-9-2002 will be refunded to him. Application is accordingly disposed of in terms of the above order.

Order accordingly.