- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kanhu Ram And Others Accused- v. Durga Ram Complainant-.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners challenge an order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur, which overruled their objections and issued process in a private criminal complaint filed under provisions of the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 (renamed Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1976).
The factual matrix in the opinion is as follows:
- On 14 March 1978 there was a quarrel between one Ramka and petitioner No. 14, Babu Ram. In subsequent criminal proceedings Ramka was prosecuted and the respondent stood surety for Ramka.
- Ramka is alleged to be a Harijan (a scheduled caste member) and the respondent-complainant is a Rajput.
- On 26 March 1978 the petitioners (Rajputs) are said to have met at the house of petitioner No. 3 Vijay Ram and resolved to ex-communicate him for becoming surety for an untouchable; they are also alleged to have resolved to call the respondent a Harijan.
- The respondent filed a private complaint on 24 April 1978 in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur. The Magistrate initially directed police investigation (27 April 1978). The S.H.O. reported a police challan had already been produced in respect of the same incident (11 May 1978).
- The Magistrate reviewed the file and the police challan and eventually issued process in the private complaint on 14 June 1978.
- On 6 December 1978 the petitioners applied to the Magistrate arguing (i) that the respondent, being a Rajput, had no locus standi to initiate proceedings under the Untouchability Act (their case being that only a scheduled caste person could file such a complaint), and (ii) that process was illegal because the requirements of Section 204(2) CrPC (filing list of prosecution witnesses before issue of process) were not complied with.
- The Magistrate rejected the locus standi objection on 11 January 1979, holding the offence cognizable and there being no provision restricting who may file the complaint. Aggrieved, the petitioners filed the present petition challenging that decision and the issuance of process.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent-complainant (a person of a non-scheduled-caste community) had locus standi to file the private complaint for an offence under the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 (Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1976).
- Whether the issuance of process by the Magistrate was vitiated by non-compliance with the requirement of Section 204(2) (referred to as clause (1-A) in older decisions) of the Criminal Procedure Code, namely the filing of a list of prosecution witnesses before issuing summons or warrant.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The respondent-complainant had no locus standi to file a complaint under the Untouchability (Offences) Act because, they contended, only a scheduled caste person could properly initiate such proceedings.
- The process issued by the Magistrate was illegal because it was issued without compliance with Section 204(2) CrPC — i.e., no list of prosecution witnesses was filed before issuing process, rendering the order invalid.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent's counsel contended that a list of witnesses had been filed along with the complaint and that a further list had been supplied subsequently. The court found no such list in the record and could not take notice of any unrecorded filing.
- The complaint, as advanced by the respondent, proceeded on the factual allegations described in the background (assembly, resolution to ex-communicate/call the complainant a Harijan, etc.).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ram Narain v. Bishamber Nath, AIR 1961 Punj 171 | Held that clause (1-A) (equivalent to clause (2) of Section 204 CrPC) is mandatory; process issued before filing list of witnesses would be invalid; courts must satisfy themselves about the prima facie nature of a charge before issuing process. | Cited by the court as an authority supporting the mandatory construction of Section 204(1-A); the decision was taken into account in weighing the competing authorities on whether non-compliance is fatal. |
| Chaturbhuj v. Naharkhan, AIR 1958 Madh Pra 28 | A single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High Court took the view that clause (1-A) of Section 204 (old Code) was mandatory. | Referred to as supporting the view that filing a list before issuing process is mandatory. |
| Patel Dhanji Mavji v. Gadhvi Govind Jiva, 1974 Cri LJ 241 (Gujarat High Court) | Held Section 204(1-A) mandatory; where nothing indicates the complainant is the solitary witness and the court has not enquired, issuing process without the required list is unsustainable. | Relied on by the court as an additional authority favouring the mandatory construction and protective purpose of Section 204(1-A). |
| Abdullah Bhat v. Ghulam Mohd. Wani, 1972 Cri LJ 277 (Full Bench, Jammu & Kashmir) | Full Bench held non-compliance with Section 204(1-A) is not an illegality making proceedings void; it is a curable irregularity. The provision protects the accused but is not mandatory in the sense that absence of prejudice will not vitiate the trial. | The court expressly endorsed this Full Bench view and treated non-compliance as potentially curable rather than automatically fatal, applying that reasoning to the present facts. |
| Banarsi Das v. Berar Oil Industries, (1966) 2 Delhi LT 357 (Punjab High Court) | Held that failure to comply with mandatory provisions of Section 204(1-A) will not vitiate proceedings unless such failure has caused prejudice to the accused. | Cited to support the proposition that non-compliance does not automatically invalidate proceedings absent prejudice. |
| Sunilakhya Chowdhury v. H.M. Jadwet, AIR 1968 Cal 266 | Observed that the legislative intention in enacting Section 204(1-A) is that a list of witnesses should be filed before issuing summons/warrant, though the point in time need not necessarily be when the petition/complaint is filed. | Referred to by the court as interpretative support for the requirement that lists be filed before issuance of process, while noting timing nuances. |
| Mowu v. The Supdt. Special Jail, Nowgong, (1971) 3 SCC 936 | The Supreme Court casually touched the point (paragraph 16) but did not decide the issue because the local procedure differed. | Noted by the court as a Supreme Court reference which did not decide the question; used to show the point has been considered at higher levels but not authoritatively resolved there. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court addressed the two principal contentions in sequence and applied statutory interpretation, comparative authority, and the safeguard against reversal embodied in Section 465 CrPC.
On locus standi:
- The court referred to Section 15 of the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 and concluded that offences under the Act are cognizable.
- There is nothing in the statute to indicate that only a scheduled caste person may file a complaint under the Act. Consequently, the petitioners' argument that the Rajput respondent lacked locus standi was without substance and was rejected.
On compliance with Section 204(2) CrPC (clause (1-A) of the old Code):
- The court acknowledged a competing line of authorities. Several High Court decisions were cited that treat the filing of the list of prosecution witnesses before issuance of process as mandatory (e.g., Punjab, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat decisions). Conversely, a Full Bench of the Jammu & Kashmir High Court viewed non-compliance as a curable irregularity rather than an automatically vitiating illegality.
- The court observed the respondent's counsel claimed a list of witnesses had been filed, but found no such list on the record and therefore could not accept that claim.
- Turning to Section 465 of the Code (equivalent to old Section 537), the court emphasized that an appellate or revisional court should not reverse or alter an order for an error, omission or irregularity in procedure unless a failure of justice has actually been occasioned.
- The court posed the decisive question: even if issuance of process without the required list were illegal, did that illegality result in a failure of justice?
- The court concluded there was no failure of justice for several reasons explicitly stated in the opinion:
- The proceedings had not yet proceeded to evidence, so the complainant could still be required to file the list of witnesses before recording evidence.
- The police had instituted a case and produced a challan in respect of the same incident; that challan had been perused by the Magistrate and would be available to the accused.
- Because the accused could be provided the necessary information (names of witnesses) before evidence, there was no prejudice or failure of justice within the meaning of Section 465.
- On this basis the court respectfully endorsed the reasoning of the Jammu & Kashmir Full Bench that non-compliance is curable and not automatically fatal, and dismissed the application attacking issuance of process.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPLICATION DISMISSED.
Implications and immediate effects:
- The court upheld the Magistrate's rejection of the locus standi objection: a private complainant who is not a member of the scheduled caste may file a complaint under the Untouchability (Offences) Act; the offences are cognizable and the statute contains no restriction as to who may complain.
- The court held that even assuming (for argument) that filing the list of prosecution witnesses under Section 204(2) CrPC is mandatory, the procedural omission did not result in a failure of justice under Section 465 CrPC in the present circumstances. Therefore, the issuance of process was not set aside.
- The court ordered that, before recording evidence, the learned Magistrate must compel the complainant to file a list of witnesses whom he proposes to examine, and only thereafter proceed to record evidence.
- No new broad precedent was announced: the court expressly weighed existing conflicting authorities and endorsed the Full Bench view that non-compliance may be curable; the decision's direct effect is to dismiss the petition and to require remediation (filing of witness list) before evidence is taken.
Disposition: Application dismissed; order directing the Magistrate to compel the complainant to file a list of witnesses before recording evidence.
1. This petition is filed by the above referred petitioners against the order passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur, overruling the petitioner's objections to the issue of process on the ground that the respondent, who is a private complainant, had no locus standi to initiate criminal proceedings for the offence contemplated by Section 7 of the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 which is re-named as Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1976. The facts of the case are that on 14th March, 1978, there was quarrel between one Ramka and the present petitioner No. 14 Babu Ram. As a result of this quarrel, Ramka was sought to be prosecuted, and in those proceedings, the present respondent stood surety for Ramka. Ramka is admittedly a Harijan, a member of the scheduled caste, and hence, is considered to be an untouchable by some high caste persons.
2. The allegation of the respondent-complainant, who is himself a Rajput by caste, says that on 26-3-1978 the present petitioners who are also Rajputs assembled in the house of petitioner No. 3 Vijay ram and resolved to ex-communicate him as he became the surety of an untouchable person. They are also said to have resolved to call the respondent-complainant a Harijan.
3. On these allegations the respondent filed a private complaint in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur on 24-4-1978. Proceedings of the court of the learned Magistrate show that on 27-4-1978 the learned Magistrate postponed the issue of process and directed an investigation to be made by the concerned Station House Officer. The S.H.O reported on 11-5-1978 that a police challan was already produced before the court with regard to the same incident against six accused persons, and therefore, no further enquiry was required to be made in this case. After the receipt of such a report of S.H.O, the court took up the matter on 31-5-1978 and ordered that the file of the present case along with the challan produced by the police in the other case should be put before the court on 8-6-1978. On 8-6-1978, the matter again came up before the court but no progress was made and the case was adjourned to 14-6-1978, on which date the court issued process in this case.
4. It is found that thereafter on 6-12-1978 the present petitioners moved an application before the learned Magistrate that the respondent-complainant being a Rajput had no locus standi to file this complaint. The contention appears to be that it is only a scheduled caste person who can file such a complaint. The learns ed Magistrate rejected this application on 11-1-1979 holding that the offence in question was cognizable and since there was no provision that only a scheduled caste person could file a complaint of this type the objection had no substance.
5. Being aggrieved by the above referred decision of the learned Magistrate, the petitioners have preferred this application. In this application, apart from the original contention that the respondent-complainant had no locus standi to file this complant, one more contention is raised to show that the process issued by the learned Magistrate is illegal inasmuch as provisions of Section 204(2) which require that a list of prosecution witnesses should be filed before the process is issued, have not been complied with.
6. So far as the first contention is concerned, it is evident by reference to Section 15 of the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 that the offences under the Act are cognizable and there is nothing in the Act to show that only a particular person can file a complaint for the offences committed under the Act. Under the circumstances, there is no substance in the contention that the respondent-complainant has no locus standi to file this complaint.
7. So far as the next contention is concerned, it is apparent from the provisions of Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 that it provides that no summons for warrant shall be issued against the accused under sub-section (1) until a list of the prosecution witnesses has been filed. The argument was that since it is apparent from the complaint as well as the statement of the complainant which was subsequently recorded that neither of them disclose any list of witnesses, the order issuing the process is vitiated. My attention was drawn to the decision given by the Punjab High Court on this point in Ram Narain v. Bishamber Nath reported in AIR 1961 Punj 171 wherein it is held that the provisions of clause (1-A) (which was equivalent to clause (2) of Section 204 of the Cr. P.C 1973) are mandatory in the sense that a process issued before the filing of the list of witnesses would be invalid. It is further observed in that decision by Dua, J. that provisions which enjoin the courts to satisfy themselves about the prima facie nature of a criminal charge, before issuing a process, must be intended, in the absense of a clear suggestion to the contrary, to be mandatory.
8. I find that before the Punjab High Court pronounced the above referred decision, a single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High Court also took a similar view with regard to clause (1-A) of Sec. 204 of the old Code as reported in Chaturbhuj v. Naharkhan, AIR 1958 Madh Pra 28. In another decision of Gujarat High Court, a learned single Judge of that Court held in Patel Dhanji Mavji v. Gadhvi Govind Jiva, 1974 Cri LJ 241 that provisions of Section 204(1-A) are mandatory, and that they were enacted for protecting the interest of the accused. It is further observed in that case that where nothing was brought on record by the complaint to indicate that he does not want to examine any other witness and that he was the solitary witness, and if the court has not made any enquiry from the complaint on this point, the order passed regarding the issuing of process without filing any such list as required by the section could not be sustained in law.
9. As against this, a Full Bench of Jammu and Kashmir High Court has held in Abdullah Bhat… v. Ghulam Mohd. Wani…. reported in 1972 Cri LJ 277 that non-compliance of Section 204(1-A) is not an illegality which renders subsequent proceedings null and void but a curable irregularity. It is further observed in that decision that Section 204(1-A) which is a salutary provision is made not in public interest but only for the protection and benefit of the accused and has to be complied with normally; however. It is not mandatory in the sense that even if no prejudice is caused to the accused it will vitiate the trial.
10. In Banarsi Das v. Berar Oil Industries reported in (1966) 2 Delhi LT 357 the Punjab High Court held that unless the failure to comply with mandatory provisions of Section 204(1-A) of the Cr. P.C have caused some prejudice, the proceedings are not vitiated.
11. In Sunilakhya Chowdhury v. H.M Jadwet reported in AIR 1968 Cal 266, a single Judge of the Calcutta High Court has observed that the intention of the Legislature in enacting Section 204(1-A) is quite clear, and it is, that before issuing of the summons or warrant against the accused persons, the list of witnesses should be filed because the point of time need not be when the petition or complaint is filed.
12. The Supreme Court has casually touched this point in Mowu v. The Supdt. Special Jail, Nowgong in paragraph 16 of the reported judgment (1971) 3 SCC 936, but did not decide the point in view of the fact that the procedure prevailing in Nagaland was different.
13. It should be noted before proceeding further that Miss Kamlesh Sharma, the learned Advocate of the respondent contended that she was instructed to say that along with the complaint her client had filed a list of witnesses and had also supplied a further list of witnesses subsequently. However, no such list is found in the record of the case and, therefore, no notice of any such filing can be taken.
14. I am of the opinion that even if filing of a list contemplated by sub-section (2) of Section 204 is considered to be mandatory, the provisions contained in Section 465 of the Code have to be taken into consideration before declaring the issue of process as illegal. This Sec. 465 of the new Code is equivalent to Sec. 537 of the old Code and it provides that no finding, sentence or order passed by a court of competent jurisdiction shall be reversed or altered by a court of appeal, or revision on account of any error, omission or irregularity in the complaint, summons, warrant, proclamation, order, judgment or other proceedings before or during the trial unless in the opinion of the appellate or the revisional court a failure of justice has, in fact, been occasioned thereby. The difficulty which is relied upon by the learned Advocate of the petitioners is the difficulty amounting to an error in issuing the process. Therefore, the impugned order issuing the process cannot be set aside unless this court finds that it has resulted in failure of justice.
15. The crucial question, therefore, is whether, even if it is believed that the order issuing process was illegal, that order has resulted in failure of justice. I find that the obvious answer to this question is in the negative, because the matter has not yet proceeded further and the complainant can be asked to furnish a list of witnesses before evidence is recorded in the case, so that the accused, for whose protection sub-section (2) of Section 204 is enacted, can know the nature of the evidence which the complainant is likely to produce. Moreover, the above referred proceedings which were undertaken in the case before the process was actually issued show that as regards the same incident the police has instituted a case and has filed a challan. That challan was perused by the court and it would be also open to the accused to have a reference to that challan. Under these circumstances, I find that even believing that the provisions contained in sub-section (2) of Sec. 204 Cr. P.C are mandatory, since the matter has not proceeded further and since it is yet open to supply the necessary information to the accused as regards the names of the witnesses against him, this is not a case in which it can be said that there has been any failure of justice within the meaning of Section 465 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In this connection I very respectfully endorse the view taken by the Full Bench of the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir in the above referred case of Abdullah Bhat v. Ghulam Mohd. In the result this application fails and the same is dismissed. I, however, order that before recording evidence, the learned Magistrate shall compel the complainant to file a list of witnesses whom he proposes to examine and shall thereafter proceed to record evidence in the case. Orders accordingly.
16. Application dismissed.
Alert