Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State v. Rajendra

Gujarat High Court
Jun 24, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Per Honourable Mr. Justice M.R. Shah)

Factual and Procedural Background

The incident alleged in the prosecution took place on 13/4/2002 at about 20:30 hours. The prosecution's case was that the accused in abetment of each other verbally abused the complainant with filthy caste-related expressions and, knowing that the complainant belonged to a Scheduled Caste, insulted him in public and threatened to cause his death. The complaint was registered at Gandhidham Police Station as CR No.II-3066 of 2002.

After investigation, a chargesheet was filed and the matter was committed to the Sessions Court under section 209 CrPC. It was registered as Special Case No.3 of 2007 and tried by the Special Judge, Gandhidham-Kutch. Charges were framed for offences under section 3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 of the Indian Penal Code. The accused pleaded not guilty and were tried.

The prosecution examined five witnesses (PWs 1–5) and produced documentary material (including Panchanama, complaint and police records). Two panch witnesses who were examined were declared hostile. The complainant and his wife were examined; there was evidence on record of prior enmity between the parties because the complainant's son had allegedly inflicted a knife injury on the daughter of the accused. On appreciation of the evidence and in the absence of independent corroborative witnesses, the trial court acquitted the accused by its judgment dated 24/8/2007.

The State of Gujarat preferred a Criminal Appeal under section 378 CrPC against the order of acquittal and also applied for leave to appeal under sub‑section (3) of section 378 CrPC (Criminal Misc. Application No.13895 of 2007). The High Court called for trial court records, heard the learned Additional Public Prosecutor and examined the prima facie merits of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether leave to appeal under section 378(3) CrPC should be granted in respect of the trial court's order of acquittal in Special Case No.3 of 2007.
  2. Whether the appellate court should interfere with the trial court's acquittal — i.e., whether the trial court's findings were perverse, contrary to material on record, palpably wrong, manifestly erroneous or demonstrably unsustainable so as to justify reversal into conviction.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Babulal Doshi v. State of Gujarat (1996) 9 SCC 225 The principle that in an acquittal appeal an appellate court should not substitute its own view for that of the trial court and reverse an acquittal into a conviction unless the trial court's findings are perverse, contrary to material on record, palpably wrong, manifestly erroneous or demonstrably unsustainable. The High Court observed that the learned APP failed to show how the trial court's findings met any of these thresholds; therefore the appellate court declined to interfere with the acquittal in conformity with this principle.
Ram Kumar v. State of Haryana, AIR 1995 SC 280 The principle that while the powers of the High Court in appeal from an order of acquittal are as extensive as in appeals against conviction, the High Court should, as a rule of prudence, give proper weight to the trial court's view on credibility, presumption of innocence, benefit of doubt and the advantage the trial judge had in seeing witnesses. The High Court applied this guidance by giving due regard to the trial judge's evaluation of witnesses and credibility, concluding that the trial court's findings were reasonable and should not be disturbed.
Girja Nandini Devi & Others v. Bijendra Narain Chaudhari, AIR 1967 SC 1124 Cited for the proposition that deference should often be shown to the trial court's view where the trial judge had the advantage of seeing witnesses; that general agreement with the trial judge's view can suffice to uphold an acquittal in appropriate facts. The High Court stated it was in general agreement with the trial judge's view and considered that such agreement was sufficient to refuse interference with the acquittal in the facts of the present case.
State of Karnataka v. Hema Reddy & Another, AIR 1981 SC 1417 Another authority on appellate restraint in overturning acquittals where the trial court's reasons are cogent and the evidence has not inspired confidence of the trial judge. The court relied on this decision as part of the line of Supreme Court authorities supporting appellate caution in acquittal appeals, and refused leave to appeal accordingly.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court undertook a review of the trial court record and the prima facie merits of the appeal. The court's reasoning proceeded in the following steps, based on the material set out in the opinion:

  1. Fact appraisal: The court recited the prosecution's case about caste‑related abuses and threats on 13/4/2002, the registration of CR No.II-3066 of 2002, the charges framed and the witnesses and documentary exhibits produced at the trial.
  2. Evaluation of witness situation: The court noted that two panch witnesses were declared hostile and although cross-examined, nothing incriminatory was elicited against the accused. The complainant and his wife were the primary witnesses for the prosecution; both belong to the same community. Importantly, the court recorded that there was enmity between the parties because of an earlier violent incident involving family members (the complainant's son and the accused's daughter).
  3. Assessment of corroboration and independent evidence: The court emphasised the absence of independent witnesses, despite their availability, and the lack of corroboration to the testimony of the complainant and his wife.
  4. Application of standards for interfering with acquittal: Relying on established precedents, the court reiterated that an appellate court should be slow to disturb an acquittal and must not substitute its own view unless the trial court's findings are perverse or meet other stated thresholds. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor was unable to demonstrate that the trial court's findings met any such threshold.
  5. Conclusion from probabilities: Considering the enmity between the parties and the hostile/non‑incriminatory stance of panch witnesses, the court concluded that, on the probabilities, the prosecution failed to establish the charges against the accused.
  6. Resultant disposition: Because the trial judge had given cogent reasons that the High Court found convincing, and because established authorities counselled restraint in disturbing acquittals, the High Court refused leave to appeal and dismissed the appeal at the threshold.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court refused leave to appeal under section 378(3) CrPC and dismissed the appeal at the threshold, thereby upholding the trial court's order of acquittal.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the acquittal recorded by the learned Special Judge in Special Case No.3 of 2007 dated 24/8/2007 stands; the accused are not convicted on the charges under section 3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 IPC.
  • The High Court applied established appellate restraint principles in acquittal appeals; the opinion does not assert that it established any new legal precedent or broader legal rule beyond the application of existing authorities to the facts of this case.

Prepared strictly from the contents of the provided opinion. No information was added beyond what appears in that opinion.

Show all summary ...

(Per : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE M.R. SHAH) The above referred Criminal Appeal is preferred under sec.378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by the State of Gujarat ? applicant herein, against the judgement and order of acquittal delivered by the learned Special Judge, Gandhidham-Kuch in Special Case No.3 of 2007 dtd.24/8/2007, whereby the respondents herein being accused came to be acquitted by the trial court for the offences punishable under sec.3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and for the charges levelled against them under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 of Indian Penal Code.

In the above Criminal Appeal, the State of Gujarat ? applicant herein has also preferred Criminal Misc. Application No.13895 of 2007 under sub-sec.(3) of sec.378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for Leave to Appeal.

Mr.M.R.

Mengdey, learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the State is heard in respect of the matter extensively at this stage also. We have also called for the record and proceedings from the trial court and we have gone through the same throughly whether to grant Leave to Appeal.

Examining the prima facie merits of the appeal, it appears that the alleged incident happened on 13/4/2002 at about 20.30 hours and as per the prosecution, on 13/4/2002 at about 20.30 hours, the accused in abetment of each other gave filthy abuses to the complainant relating to his caste with intention to insult the complainant in public at large, though it was within the knowledge of the respondents that the complainant is belonging to Scheduled Caste community. It was further the case of the prosecution that both the respondents in abetment of each other administered threat to cause death of the complainant and thereby committed offences punishable under section 3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 of Indian Penal Code. The complaint was registered with the Gandhidham Police Station as CR No.II-3066 of 2002.

After investigation was completed, chargesheet came to be filed in the court of learned Judicial Magistrate (First Class), Gandhidham against the accused for the offences punishable under sec.3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 of Indian Penal Code and as the case was triable by the Sessions Court, the case was committed to the Court of learned Special Judge / Sessions Judge, Bhuj under sec.209 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which came to be registered as Special Case No.3 of 2007 and the same was tried by the learned Special Judge, Gandhidham-Kutch. Charge came to be framed against the accused vide Ex.1. The plea of the accused was recorded at Ex. Nos.2 and 3 and both the accused did not plead the guilty and therefore, they were tried for the aforesaid offences. To prove the case, the prosecution examined five witnesses; namely [1] Dinesh Narishbhai Gadhvi PW-1 at Ex.9, [2] Nanduben Karabhai Vankar ? PW-2 at Ex.11, [3] Vijay Haridas ? PW-3 at Ex.13, [4] Kanabhai Bhachubhai Vankar PW-4 at Ex.14 and [5] Maganbhai Dhanabhai Vasava PW-5 at Ex.15. The prosecution produced on record documentary evidences namely Panchnama of place of offence at Ex.10, complaint at Ex.12 and Police Yadi at Ex.Nos.16 and 17. The prosecution submitted Closing Purshis at Ex.18. Thereafter, Further Statement of the accused came to be recorded under sec.313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Panch Witnesses named Dinesh Narishbhai Gadhvi and Vijay Haridas, who were examined at Ex.Nos.9 and 13 repectively, were declared hostile and though they came to be cross examined, nothing was brought out against the accused. The prosecution examined complainant and his wife - PW Nos.4 and 2 respectively at Ex.Nos.11 and 14. Both are husband and wife, belonging to the same community. It has also come on record from the evidence that the son of the complainant had inflicted knife blow upon the daughter of the accused and therefore, there was an enmity between the complainant and the accused. On appreciation of evidence and in absence of independent witnesses being examined, the learned trial court acquitted both the accused for the offences punishable under sec.3(1)(10) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and under sections 504, 506(2) and 114 of Indian Penal Code.

We have heard the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State at length and also considered the record and proceedings as well as the impugned judgement and order of acquittal. It is borne out from the record that there was an enmity between the complainant and the accused and the son of the complainant inflicted knife blow upon the daughter of the accused and in light of the above, the evidence and deposition of the complainant and his wife are required to be appreciated. Both the panch witnesses examined at Ex.Nos.9 and 13 have turned hostile. No independent witnesses have been examined though available. Even considering the deposition of the complainant and his wife, who are examined at Ex.Nos.14 and 11, the charge for the alleged offences is not proved against the accused. The prosecution has failed to prove the case against the accused.

If the aforesaid circumstances at this juncture are taken into consideration with the fact that there is an enmity between the complainant and the accused, the possible conclusion from the probabilities of the case would be that the prosecution has failed to establish the charges levelled against the respondent accused.

The learned trial court has properly appreciated the evidence and has reached to the possible conclusion from the evidence that in the above said circumstances and when there is no corroboration to the say of the witnesses, the respondent ? accused were entitled to acquittal. This conclusion cannot be interfered with for the reasons stated above.

In view of the unsatisfactory evidence led by the prosecution, we are of the considered opinion that no illegality is committed by the learned trial judge in acquitting the accused of the offences with which they were charged and we are in complete agreement with the findings, ultimate conclusion and resultant order of acquittal recorded by the learned trial Judge, as, in our view, no other conclusion is possible except the one reached by the learned trial Judge.

It is a cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence that in an acquittal appeal if other view is possible then also appellate Court cannot substitute its own view by reversing the acquittal into conviction, unless the findings of the trial Court are perverse, contrary to the material on record, palpably wrong, manifestly erroneous or demonstrably unsustainable. (See Ramesh Babulal Doshi V. State of Gujarat (1996) 9 SCC 225). In the instant case, the learned APP has not been able to point out to us as to how the findings recorded by the learned trial Court are perverse, contrary to material on record, palpably wrong, manifestly erroneous or demonstrably unsustainable.

In the case of RAM KUMAR V. STATE OF HARYANA, reported in AIR 1995 SC 280, Supreme Court has held as under:

?SThe powers of the High Court in an appeal from order of acquittal to reassess the evidence and reach its own conclusions under Sections 378 and 379, Cr.P.C. are as extensive as in any appeal against the order of conviction. But as a rule of prudence, it is desirable that the High Court should give proper weight and consideration to the view of the Trial Court with regard to the credibility of the witness, the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused, the right of the accused to the benefit of any doubt and the slowness of appellate Court in justifying a finding of fact arrived at by a Judge who had the advantage of seeing the witness. It is settled law that if the main grounds on which the lower Court has based its order acquitting the accused are reasonable and plausible, and the same cannot entirely and effectively be dislodged or demolished, the High Court should not disturb the order of acquittal."

It may be noted that this is an acquittal appeal in which Court would be slow to interfere with the order of acquittal. Infirmities in the prosecution case go to the root of the matter and strike a vital blow on the prosecution case. In such a case, it would not be safe to set aside the order of acquittal, more particularly, when the evidence has not inspired confidence of the learned trial Judge. As this Court is in general agreement with the view expressed by the learned trial Judge, it is not necessary for this Court either to reiterate the evidence of the prosecution witnesses or to restate reasons given by the learned trial Judge for acquittal and in our view, expression of general agreement with the view taken by the learned trial Judge would be sufficient in the facts of the present case for not interfering with the judgment of the learned trial Judge and this is so, in view of the decisions rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of GIRJA NANDINI DEVI AND OTHERS V. BIJENDRA NARAIN CHAUDHARI, AIR 1967 SC 1124 and STATE OF KARNATAKA V. HEMA REDDY AND ANOTHER, AIR 1981 SC 1417.

On overall appreciation of evidence, this Court is satisfied that there is no infirmity in the reasons assigned by the learned trial Judge for acquitting the accused. Suffice it to say that the learned trial Judge has given cogent and convincing reasons for acquitting the accused and the learned A.P.P. has failed to dislodge the reasons given by the learned trial Judge and convince this Court to take a view contrary to the one taken by the learned Judge.

Seen in the above context, we do not find any valid reason or justifiable ground to interfere with the impugned judgment and order acquitting the accused of the offences with which they were charged. Hence, leave to appeal deserves to be refused by dismissing the appeal in limine.

For the foregoing reasons, leave to appeal is refused. The appeal is dismissed at the threshold.

[J.R.

VORA, J.] [M.R.

SHAH, J.] rafik Top