Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Patel v. Gujarat

Gujarat High Court
Sep 2, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner-original appellant filed a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging an order dated 31.7.2008 passed by the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch. The impugned order rejected the petitioner's application for condonation of a 219-day delay in preferring an appeal against an order/permission granted by the Wakf Board. The petitioner had submitted a delay condonation application (No. 95 of 2007) before the learned Civil Judge, which was dismissed on the ground that the appeal was not maintainable under Section 51 of the Wakf Act. There was a dispute regarding whether an appeal against the Wakf Board’s order is maintainable before the Tribunal or the Civil Judge. The petitioner contended that the trial court should have first condoned the delay and then decided on the maintainability of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of 219 days in preferring the appeal against the Wakf Board’s order should be condoned.
  2. Whether an appeal against the permission/order of the Wakf Board is maintainable before the Tribunal or the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge under Section 51 of the Wakf Act.
  3. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the delay condonation application on the ground of non-maintainability without first condoning the delay.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • There was a delay of 219 days in preferring the appeal, for which condonation was sought.
  • The trial court should have first condoned the delay before considering the maintainability of the appeal under Section 51 of the Wakf Act.
  • The impugned order dismissing the delay condonation application solely on the ground of non-maintainability was erroneous.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The appeal against the permission granted by the Wakf Board is not maintainable as per Section 51 of the Wakf Act.
  • The trial court correctly dismissed the delay condonation application on this basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted a serious dispute regarding the maintainability of the appeal against the Wakf Board’s order under Section 51 of the Wakf Act. It held that the learned trial court erred in dismissing the delay condonation application without first condoning the delay. The court reasoned that the delay should have been condoned initially, and only thereafter should the maintainability of the appeal be considered. The court therefore quashed and set aside the impugned order and directed the trial court to condone the delay and then decide the maintainability issue, allowing the respondents to submit appropriate applications on maintainability before the trial court or Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 31.7.2008 is quashed and set aside. The delay of 219 days in preferring the appeal against the Wakf Board’s order is condoned. The appeal will be placed before the learned trial court or Tribunal for consideration. The question of maintainability of the appeal under Section 51 of the Wakf Act is kept open for determination by the trial court or Tribunal after hearing submissions from the respondents. No order as to costs is made. This decision does not set a new precedent on maintainability but ensures procedural correctness by requiring delay to be condoned before maintainability is adjudicated.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard Shri Y.N. Ravani, learned advocate for the petitioner and Shri L.R. Pathan, learned advocate for the respondent No.1 and Ms. Nasarin N. Shaikh, learned advocate for the respondent Nos. 2 to 11.

2. By way of this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner-original appellant has prayed for an appropriate writ, direction and / or order quashing and setting aside the order passed by the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch dated 31.7.2008 passed below Exh. 1 in Condonation Application No. 95 of 2007 in rejecting the said application and not condoning the delay of 219 days in preferring the appeal challenging the order passed by the Wakf Board.

3. It appears that there was delay in preferring the appeal against the permission granted by the Wakf Board, petitioner preferred appeal before the Tribunal constituted under the Wakf Act or the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch that there was a delay in preferring the appeal the petitioner-appellant submitted the delay condonation application No. 95 of 2007 and requested to condone the delay in preferring the appeal. However, the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch by impugned order dated 31.7.2008 dismissed the said application by observing that considering Section 51 of the Wakf Act appeal is not maintainable.

4. It appears that there is a serious dispute whether the appeal against the permission / order of the Wakf Board is maintainable before the Tribunal or not as provided under Section 51 of the Wakf Act. Under the circumstances, the learned trial Court ought to have condoned the delay first and ought to have considered thereafter the controversy with respect to maintainability of the appeal against the order passed by the Wakf Board and / or permission granted by the Wakf Board. Under the circumstances, the impugned order passed by the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch requires to be quashed and set aside and delay is to be condoned in preferring the appeal by further directing the learned trial Court to consider the question with respect to maintainability of the appeal has submitted on behalf of the respondents.

5. For the reasons stated above, petition succeeds. The impugned order passed by the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bharuch dated 31.7.2008 passed below Exh. 1 in Condonation Application No. 95 of 2007 is hereby quashed and set aside and delay in preferring the appeal against the permission / order of the Wakf Board is hereby condoned. As the delay is condoned the appeal will be placed before the learned trial Court / Tribunal and the question with respect to maintainability of the appeal is kept open and it will be open for the respondents to submit an appropriate application before the learned trial Court / Tribunal that such an appeal against the permission granted by the Wakf Act is not maintainable and the same be dealt with and considered by the learned trial Court / Tribunal before passing any further order in the appeal. Rule is made absolute. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to cost.

(M.R.

Shah, J.) Kaushik Top