- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chandra Charitable Trust
Factual and Procedural Background
At the instance of the Revenue, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal referred three questions to this Court for its opinion. The referral concerned the tax-exemption status of an assessee-trust under Sections 11 and 12 of the Income-tax Act and the applicability of Section 13(1)(b). Counsel for the Revenue (Mrs. Mona Bhatt) and counsel for the assessee (Mr. R.K. Patel) appeared. The three questions referred asked whether (1) the trust is a religious trust entitled to Section 11 benefit; (2) whether Jainism is a religion and, if not, whether Section 13(1)(b) would apply; and (3) whether a fresh assessment made pursuant to an order under Section 263 was redundant.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, the Appellate Tribunal is right in law and on facts in holding that the assessee-trust is a religious trust entitled to the benefit of Section 11?
- Whether the Tribunal is right in law and on facts in holding that Jainism is not a religion, and if Jainism is not a religion, the bar contained under Section 13(1)(b) would not apply in the present case?
- Whether the Appellate Tribunal is right in law and on facts of the case in holding that the fresh assessment made by the Income-tax Officer pursuant to the order under Section 263 made by the Commissioner of Income-tax is redundant?
Arguments of the Parties
Revenue's Arguments
- Sections 11 and 12 provide exemptions to charitable and religious trusts but Section 13(1)(b) operates as a contra-indication to those exemptions and denies exemption in particular situations.
- Under Section 13(1)(b), exemption is not available where a trust for charitable purposes is created or established for the benefit of any particular religious community or caste.
- Reliance placed on the Division Bench judgment in Shantagauri Ramniklal Trust v. CIT for guidance on requirements to decide whether a trust is religious/charitable.
- Reliance placed on the apex court judgment in Bal Patil v. Union of India to contend that Jainism is a religion.
- Certain covenants in the trust deed indicate the basic purpose is to promote Jainism or to help the caste/community which follows Jainism; if so, exemption should not be available under Sections 11/12 because Section 13(1)(b) would apply.
Assessee's Arguments
- Reliance on this Court's judgment in CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society, submitted that exclusion under Section 13(1)(b) applies only to charitable trusts and charitable institutions.
- Submitted that where a trust is both charitable and religious in nature, the assessee would remain entitled to exemption under Section 11 of the Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shantagauri Ramniklal Trust v. CIT | Guidance on requirements to be taken note of while deciding whether a trust is a religious charitable trust. | Referred to by the Revenue as authority on the requirements to determine religious/charitable character; used as part of the materials considered. |
| Bal Patil v. Union of India | To contend that Jainism is a religion and not merely a philosophy or lifestyle. | Invoked by the Revenue to support the proposition that Jainism is a religion; the Court observed that this question loses much of its importance in view of the principle applied from CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society. |
| CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society | Principle that exclusion under Section 13(1)(b) applies only to charitable trusts/institutions and that a trust which is both charitable and religious may still be entitled to exemption under Section 11. | Accepted by the Court as determinative: if a trust's deed shows goals beyond mere propagation/maintenance (i.e., charitable objectives in addition to religious ones), the trust becomes charitable as well as religious and Section 13(1)(b) would not apply. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the questions in the light of the authority in CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society. It observed that whether Jainism is characterized as a religion or a life-style is of reduced importance where the trust-deed, by its covenants, demonstrates objectives beyond mere propagation or maintenance of religious functionaries and places (for example, other charitable goals).
Applying the Barkate principle, the Court reasoned that if from the trust-deed it can be spelt out that, in addition to propagating Jainism or maintaining temples and ascetics, there are other goals set out in the deed, the trust would be both charitable and religious (a "charitable religious trust"). In that situation, Section 13(1)(b) — which denies exemption where a trust is created for the benefit of a particular religious community or caste — would not be applicable to exclude exemption under Section 11.
On that basis the Court concluded that once the central question is resolved against the Revenue (i.e., applying Barkate to treat the trust as charitable as well as religious where the deed shows additional goals), the remaining referred questions could also be decided against the Revenue.
Holding and Implications
Reference disposed of; questions answered against the Revenue.
Direct consequence for the parties: the Court accepted the principle in CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society and held that where the trust-deed shows charitable objectives in addition to religious ones, the trust is to be treated as charitable as well as religious and Section 13(1)(b) would not operate to deny exemption under Section 11. On that basis the reference was disposed of against the Revenue and no costs were awarded.
Broader implications: the opinion does not set out any new precedent beyond applying the cited authorities; it resolves the referred questions in the particular facts by following the Barkate principle.
1. Mrs. Mona Bhatt, learned Counsel for the Revenue and Mr. R.K. Patel, learned Counsel for the assessee.
At the instance of the Revenue, the Tribunal has referred the following questions for our opinion:
(1) Whether, the Appellate Tribunal is right in law and on facts in holding that the assessee-trust is a religious trust entitled to the benefit of Section 11?
(2) Whether the Tribunal is right in law and on facts in holding that Jainism is not a religion, and if Jainism is not a religion, the bar contained under Section 13(1)(b) would not apply in the present case?
(3) Whether the Appellate Tribunal is right in law and on facts of the case in holding that the fresh assessment made by the Income-tax Officer pursuant to the order under Section 263 made by the Commissioner of Income-tax is redundant?
2. Learned Counsel for the Revenue submits that Section 11 and Section 12 of the Income-tax Act while providing certain exemption to charitable religious trusts, Section 13(1)(b), contraindication to Sections 11 and 12, denies exemption in particular situations. She submits that, according to Section 13(1)(b), exemption would not be available in the case of a trust for charitable purposes or a charitable institution created or established after the commencement of the Act, any income thereof if the trust or institution is created or established for the benefit of any particular religious community or caste. Referring to a Division Bench judgment of this Court in the matter of Shantagauri Ramniklal Trust v. CIT , it is submitted that what are the requirements to be taken note of while deciding the question whether the trust is a religious charitable trust or not. Reliance is also placed on a judgment of the apex court in the matter of Bal Patil v. Union of India , to contend that Jainism is not a simple philosophy or a life-style but in fact it is a religion itself. Referring to certain covenants of the trust deed, it was submitted that as the basic purpose of creation of the trust was to promote Jainism which is a religion or to help the caste/community which follows Jainism, and, if that be so, exemption would not be available, but the case of the respondent-trust would be counted out of the exemption Clause and would be included in exceptions.
3. Shri Patel, learned Counsel for the respondent-assessee, on the other hand, placed reliance upon yet another judgment of this Court in the matter of CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society and submitted that exclusion from exemption under Section 13(1)(b) applies only to charitable trusts and charitable institutions and if the trust is charitable as well as religious in nature, the assessee would be entitled to exemption under Section 11 of the Act.
4. A The question, that what should be the principle adopted and whether Jainism is a life-style or a religion, would lose much of its importance in view of the judgment of this Court in the matter of CIT v. Barkate Saifiyah Society . If Jainism is accepted to be a religion and from the covenants of the trust-deed it can be spelt out that not only to propagate Jainism or help and assist maintenance of the temple, sadhus, sadhvis, shraviks and shravaks, yet other goals are set in the trust deed, then the trust would become a charitable trust, so also a religious trust or it can be addressed as a charitable religious trust, and, if that be so, Section 13(1)(b) would not be applicable. Once the basic question is answered against the interests of the Revenue, then the other questions can conveniently be decided against the interests of the Revenue. The reference stands disposed of accordingly. No costs.
Alert