- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Gujarat v. Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna
Judicial Opinion Summary — Shethna, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The State of Gujarat filed a Miscellaneous Criminal Application challenging a common judgment and order dated 28-9-2001 (also referred to in the opinion as dated 20-9-2001) passed by Shri V. B. Mayani, Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar. That impugned judgment related to Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 and Misc. Criminal Application No. 479 of 2001. In that order the learned Additional Sessions Judge rejected Misc. Criminal Application No. 479 of 2001 (filed by accused Kamlesh Prabhudas Tanna) but allowed the application filed by accused Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna (aged 57 years) and ordered her release on bail in respect of offences registered as Crime Register No. I-430 of 2001 with Jamnagar City B Division Police Station under Sections 304-B, 498-A, 306/34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act.
The State, through its Additional Public Prosecutor Shri K. C. Shah, sought cancellation of that bail order. The High Court issued notice to the respondent-accused, who was duly served but did not appear; the Court decided the application in her absence after hearing the A.P.P. The High Court considered an earlier order of the same Additional Sessions Judge dated 19-9-2001 (Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 2001) rejecting an anticipatory bail application by Sushilaben, produced on record by the A.P.P.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the regular bail granted to the respondent-accused Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna by Shri V. B. Mayani (in Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001) should be quashed and set aside on the ground that it is inconsistent with and contrary to the earlier order (19-9-2001) of the same Judge rejecting her anticipatory bail application.
- Whether the learned Additional Sessions Judge committed such an abuse of discretion or illegality in granting bail that the High Court should exercise its power to cancel the bail order.
- Whether the circumstances warrant administrative action (departmental inquiry) against the learned Additional Sessions Judge for the manner in which the bail order was passed.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant / State (represented by Shri K. C. Shah, A.P.P.)
- Argued that the same learned Additional Sessions Judge had rejected the respondent-accused's anticipatory bail application (Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 2001 on 19-9-2001) after a detailed speaking order running into nine typed pages, observing a very strong prima facie case against the accused and holding that she could not be released on bail merely because there were minor children.
- Pointed out that in Para 8 of the earlier order the Judge explicitly observed that "merely because 2 minor children of deceased Sandhya who are aged 3 years and 7 months only and. that there is no one to look after them would not be a ground to release the accused Sushilaben on bail".
- Contended that, despite that earlier finding, within nine days the same Judge granted regular bail (in the impugned judgment) on the ground that the earlier situation changed because the small children were then in jail and would otherwise remain in jail with their grandmother — a reason running contrary to his earlier conclusion.
- Submitted that the Judge overlooked the claim of the grandfather (father of the deceased Sandhya) seeking custody of the minor children and his objection to the children being kept in jail with the accused; that custody claim and objection were not considered in the bail order.
- Consequently, urged that the impugned bail order should be quashed and set aside.
Respondent / Accused (Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna)
- The respondent was duly served with notice of the High Court's proceeding but did not appear and did not present arguments; the opinion records that the bail application was decided in her absence after hearing the A.P.P.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ilaben Wd/o. Dipakkumar Dhanraj Shah v. State of Gujarat, 1993 (2) GLR 1148 | Illustration where bail was granted on the ground that the accused had minor children. | The learned Additional Sessions Judge considered this judgment while deciding the earlier anticipatory bail application and distinguished it on facts, observing that the factual matrix in Ilaben (accused having minor children) was not present in the present case; thus Ilaben did not support grant of anticipatory bail to Sushilaben. |
| Reported judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court (2001 Criminal Law Journal — specific citation without party name) | Instances where the Supreme Court granted bail to an older lady convicted and sentenced for murder of a daughter-in-law so she could look after her grandchildren, particularly where she had been in jail long and appeal would take time. | The learned Additional Sessions Judge examined this Supreme Court decision and concluded it had no relevance to the facts of the present case; therefore it did not justify anticipatory bail for Sushilaben. |
| Solanki Ravibhai Dipubhai v. State of Gujarat, 1992 (1) GLR 631 : 1992 (2) CCR 1820 | Principle: "Ordinarily when the accused who can be granted regular bail in such type of cases, the accused should be granted anticipatory bail." | The learned Judge considered this proposition but found that the present facts did not amount to a case where anticipatory bail should be granted, i.e., it was not a case appropriate for anticipatory bail under the cited principle. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The High Court proceeded stepwise:
- The Court noted that the earlier order of the same Additional Sessions Judge (dated 19-9-2001) rejecting the respondent's anticipatory bail application was a detailed, nine-page speaking order in which the Judge had considered relevant precedents (including Ilaben and the Supreme Court decision reported in 2001 CLJ) and had concluded there was a strong prima facie case against the accused; the Judge specifically held that the existence of minor children who needed care would not be a ground to release the accused on bail in that earlier order.
- The Court observed that, notwithstanding that earlier conclusion, within nine days the same Judge granted regular bail to the same accused in Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 (impugned order), relying on the change in circumstance that the small children were then in jail and would otherwise remain in jail with their grandmother. The High Court characterized that later reasoning as directly contrary to the earlier explicit finding that the presence of minor children was not a ground for bail.
- The High Court emphasized that, although interference with an exercise of judicial discretion in bail matters is normally exceptional, this case presented exceptional circumstances. The learned Judge had effectively re-opened the merits and demerits and adopted a rationale inconsistent with his prior ruling. The High Court regarded this inconsistency as amounting to an improper and illegal exercise of discretion such that no reasonable person would have come to the differing conclusion on the same facts within such a short interval.
- The Court further found that the Additional Sessions Judge had overlooked material objections and facts placed on record — specifically the grandfather's claim for custody of the minor children and his objection to the children remaining in jail with the accused — and that these matters were not even mentioned in the bail order.
- On this basis the High Court concluded that the manner in which the regular bail was granted gave rise to a strong suspicion of oblique motive and bad faith sufficient to warrant more than mere appellate correction; it recommended departmental inquiry against the learned Judge for the manner in which he passed the impugned order.
- Accordingly, the Court allowed the State's application, quashed and set aside the impugned bail order, and directed immediate custody of the accused; it also directed the Registrar to place records before the Chief Justice for departmental action against the Additional Sessions Judge.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Court's principal ruling was to quash and set aside the bail order. The core ruling is summarized as: The impugned judgment and order granting regular bail to Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna is quashed and set aside, and she is ordered to be taken into custody forthwith.
Consequential directions (direct effects on the parties):
- The Investigating Officer was directed to arrest and take the accused Sushilaben into custody forthwith.
- The Registrar was directed to place copies of the present order along with the earlier anticipatory bail order (Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 2001 decided on 19-9-2001) and the regular bail application (Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 decided on 28-9-2001) before the Chief Justice for consideration and appropriate action by way of departmental inquiry against Shri V. B. Mayani, Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; rather, it applies established supervisory powers to set aside what it found to be an improper and inconsistent judicial exercise of discretion in granting bail and it directs administrative inquiry into the judge's conduct. The Court expressly treated this as an exceptional case warranting interference with a discretionary bail order.
Shethna, J.
1. The State of Gujarat has filed this Misc. Criminal Application against the impugned common judgment and order dated 28-9-2001 passed by Shri V. B. Mayani, learned Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar in Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 and Misc. Criminal Application No. 479 of 2001, whereby the learned Judge rejected the Misc. Criminal Application No. 479 of 2001 filed by accused Kamlesh Prabhudas Tanna but allowed the application filed by accused Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna, who is aged 57 years and ordered to release her on bail for the offences punishable under Sections 304-B, 498-A, 306/34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, registered as Crime Register No. I-430 of 2001 with Jamnagar City B Division Police Station.
2. Shri K. C. Shah, learned A.P.P., for the applicant vehemently submitted that in the instant case, the same learned Additional Sessions Judge, Shri V. B. Mayani dismissed the anticipatory bail application being Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 2001 filed by the respondent-accused Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna just before 9 days of grant of her regular bail application being Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001. While rejecting the anticipatory bail application filed by the respondent-accused, the learned Additional Sessions Judge by his speaking order running into 9 typed pages observed that there was a very strong prima facie case against the accused, therefore, though she is a lady accused she could not have been released on bail. Mr. Shah further submitted that in Para 8 of his earlier order dated 19-9-2001, the learned Additional Sessions Judge in no uncertain terms observed that, "merely because 2 minor children of deceased Sandhya who are aged 3 years and 7 months only and. that there is no one to look after them would not be a ground to release the accused Sushilaben on bail". In spite of this clear observations by the learned Judge, for the reasons best known to him, within 9 days, granted regular bail application of the respondent-accused Sushilaben by observing in Para 13 of his impugned judgment that, "When the earlier bail application of Sushilaben was rejected, small children of deceased Sandhya were not in jail but now they are in jail, therefore, there is a change in circumstance, and therefore, she should be enlarged on bail". Mr. Shah submitted that this reasoning assigned by the learned Judge for releasing the respondent-accused on bail runs contrary to what he observed in his earlier order dated 19-9-2001 while dismissing the anticipatory bail application filed by the respondent-accused wherein he had clearly observed in Para 8 of his judgment that there is no one to look after the minor children of deceased Sandhya would not be a ground to release her on bail. He also submitted that the grandfather of minor children and father of deceased Sandhya has already claimed the custody of his grand children i.e. children of his daughter Sandhya in the bail application submitted by the respondent-accused Sushilaben but without considering the same, the learned Judge has released her on bail only on the ground that minor children had to stay in jail along with accused Sushilaben. He, therefore, submitted that the impugned order of releasing the respondent-accused on bail should be quashed- and set aside.
3. In the instant case, the respondent is duly served with the notice issued by this Court, but no one appears for her, therefore, this bail application is decided in her absence after hearing learned A.P.P. Shri Shah.
4. At the outset, it may be stated that along with this application for cancellation of bail, certified copy of the previous judgment and order dated 19-5-2001 passed by Shri V. B. Mayani, Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar in Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 2001 for anticipatory bail filed by Sushilaben was not annexed which is now produced on record by learned A.P.P. Shri K. C. Shah. The earlier order of rejection of anticipatory bail application was passed on 19-9-2001 which runs into 9 typed pages wherein the learned Judge considered the judgment of this Court in the case of Ilaben Wd/o. Dipakkumar Dhanraj Shah v. State of Gujarat, reported in 1993 (2) GLR 1148. In that case, the accused was granted bail on the ground that she had minor children. That was not the case in the instant case, therefore, the learned Judge refused to grant anticipatory bail. The learned Judge also considered the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court reported in 2001 Criminal Law Journal, wherein the Honourable Supreme Court has granted bail on the ground that the lady-accused was an old one who was convicted and sentenced for committing murder of her own daughter-in-law whose bail application for looking after her grand children was rejected wherein the Honourable Supreme Court granted bail on the ground that the accused was in jail for a long time and it would take time for final disposal of her appeal filed against the order of conviction and sentence passed by the learned Judge, However, the learned Judge found that the aforesaid judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court has no relevance on the facts of this case, therefore, he rejected the anticipatory bail application as in the instant case, the accused Sushilaben was not making any demand of the custody of her own grand children but she wanted to look after small children of deceased Sandhya her daughter-in-law and on such ground, the accused cannot be granted anticipatory bail.
5. The learned Judge also considered the judgment of this Court reported in Solanki Ravibhai Dipubhai v. State of Gujarat, 1992 (1) GLR 631 : 1992 (2) CCR 1820 wherein it has been held that,
"Ordinarily when the accused who can be granted regular bail in such type of cases, the accused should be granted anticipatory bail". Having considered that judgment, the learned Judge found that this was not the case of granting regular bail, and therefore, there was no question of granting anticipatory bail.
6. Surprisingly, within 9 days of passing of the earlier order of rejecting anticipatory bail application of respondent-accused, the same learned Additional Sessions Judge Shri V. B. Mayani of Jamnagar has granted regular bail only on the ground that the small children of deceased Sandhya had to remain in jail along with their grand mother - accused Sushilaben. This finding runs absolutely contrary to a clear cut finding recorded by him while deciding anticipatory bail application.
7. In the instant case, the respondent-accused is not appearing either in person or through her Advocate though she is duly served with the notice for cancellation of bail issued of this Court in this petition. 1 am conscious that when the learned Judge exercises his discretionary power of grant of bail, then ordinarily, this Court would not interfere in an application filed for cancellation of bail unless and until a special case is made out to interfere with such orders. As stated earlier, the facts of this case are not only glaring, but also shocking. The learned Judge, who himself rejected the anticipatory bail application just 9 days before the grant of regular bail application, has entered into an arena which was forbidden under law by going into the merits and demerits of the case. Having gone through the same, he has come to a conclusion that there was a strong prima fade case against the accused and that the circumstances narrated in her anticipatory bail application do not warrant any grant of anticipatory bail and according to him it was not a case of even regular bail which could be granted in a regular bail application. But, surprisingly, within 9 days, on the same facts, the learned Judge took a somersault and granted regular bail only on the ground that the minor children of deceased Sandhya had to remain in jail along with their grand mother - accused Sushilaben. The learned Judge who earlier rejected the anticipatory bail application of the respondent-accused was very much conscious and aware of this fact when he rejected her anticipatory bail application. In spite of it, he granted regular bail, which was not only highly improper but illegal. In my considered opinion, no reasonable man on earth would take different view of the matter tike this Judge.
It must be stated that the learned Judge has conveniently overlooked the objections raised by the grand father of minor children and father of deceased Sandhya regarding grant of bail to the accused and his claim regarding custody of minor children to be handed over to him during the pendency of the case and they should not be kept in jail along with accused Sushilaben. There is not even a whispher in his order of granting bail.
The way in which the learned Judge has granted regular bail to the accused has left us much to desire. It prima fade shows that there is an oblique motive in passing such order for which departmental inquiry should be initiated against him. Suffice it to say, that this is a case which squarely falls within the criteria laid down by the Honourable Supreme Court for setting aside the discretionary order of bail granted by the learned Judge in favour of the respondent-accused.
8. In view of the above discussion, this application is allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 20-9-2001 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar in Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 filed by the respondent-accused Sushilaben Prabhudas Tanna is hereby quashed and set aside. Accordingly, she is ordered to be taken into custody forthwith. The Investigating Officer shall arrest and take her into custody forthwith.
9. The Registrar of this Court is directed to place copy of mis order along with the copy of the earlier anticipatory bail application i.e. Misc. Criminal Application No. 468 of 200i decided on 19-9-2001 and copy of regular bail application i.e. Misc. Criminal Application No. 478 of 2001 decided on 28-9-2001 before the learned Chief Justice for taking appropriate action by way of departmental inquiry in the matter against Shri V. B. Mayani, Additional Sessions Judge, Jamnagar at the earliest.
Alert