- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vepar Vikas Co-Operative Bank, Ltd. v. Ghanshyam Lallubhai Patel
Factual and Procedural Background
The matter was listed for hearing before the court but was adjourned at the requester’s instance to enable a possible settlement. No settlement materialized, and the court proceeded to hear the matter on merits. The respondent was an employee of the petitioner-Bank and filed B.I.R. No. 428 of 1977 before the Labour Court challenging the Bank's action in relieving him from service (stated in the record as w.e.f. 30-7-1988) after giving one month's salary. The Labour Court rejected that application. On appeal, the Industrial Court (I.C. No. 61 of 1981) directed the Bank to pay full pay from 30-7-1977 to 12-10-1981 after deducting notice pay. Non-compliance led to a contempt petition in the High Court, after which the Bank and the respondent arrived at a compromise: the Bank agreed to pay 72% of pay for the period and paid Rs. 13,000/-. The respondent thereafter filed Recovery Application No. 613 of 1984 before the Labour Court, claiming Rs. 24,221/- (including pay and additional benefits). The Presiding Officer by order dated 2-5-1987 directed the Bank to pay an additional Rs. 11,000/- and costs of Rs. 100/-. The present petition challenges that Labour Court order dated 2-5-1987.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Labour Court, in disposing of the Recovery Application under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, exceeded its jurisdiction or acted beyond its limits.
- Whether the respondent-employee was entitled to amounts over and above the compromise payment—specifically whether "wages" or back wages include additional benefits such as privilege leave, casual leave, sick leave, national holidays, bonus, house rent allowance and medical allowance.
- Whether the High Court, exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution, can interfere with the Labour Court's order for an alleged error of law or a mere wrong decision.
- Whether interest should be awarded on amounts that were withheld by the petitioner pending challenge to the Labour Court's order.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as reported)
- The Labour Court, while deciding under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, exceeded its jurisdiction.
- The Labour Court accepted a demand which the Bank had objected to.
- The Bank contended that the respondent was not entitled to any difference in salary; whatever salary applied on 30-7-1977 should be taken through to 12-10-1981 and any subsequent rise in pay should not benefit the employee.
- It was pointed out by the petitioner’s counsel that before the Labour Court the Bank had not taken any specific plea nor produced material to support its contentions (the court records the Bank’s counsel conceded this).
Respondent / Respondent's Counsel (as reported)
- The respondent contended in Recovery Application No. 613 of 1984 that, by calculation, Rs. 24,221/- was due, inclusive of pay and benefits (privilege leave, casual leave, sick leave, national holidays, bonus, house rent allowance and medical allowance).
- The respondent’s counsel (Mr. Vasavada) submitted that the petitioner, by filing the petition, had withheld payment to which the respondent was entitled and that the respondent would have earned interest on the withheld amount.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bipinchandra v. Navin Flourine Industries reported in 1981 GLR 1070 | Back wages include all payments to which a permanent employee would be entitled (e.g., dearness allowance, increments, bonus, etc.). | The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that, absent clear qualification in the compromise, "wages" or back wages include other benefits; hence the Bank's contention that the employee was not entitled to differences in salary was rejected. |
| Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaquim reported in AIR 1984 SC 38 | The High Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 is limited to ensuring an inferior court acts within its authority; a mere wrong decision or an error of law does not by itself attract Article 227 jurisdiction. | The court applied this principle to conclude there was no jurisdictional or procedural error apparent on the face of the record and therefore the High Court should not entertain the petition to correct what might be an error of law or a mere wrong decision. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the matter as follows:
- The court noted the adjournment sought for settlement and that no settlement ultimately occurred, requiring disposal on merits.
- The Bank's counsel argued excess of jurisdiction by the Labour Court under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act and contended the employee was not entitled to salary differences arising from subsequent pay rises. The court recorded that the Bank had not taken a specific plea nor produced supporting material before the Labour Court.
- The court examined the nature of the compromise and observed that the Bank agreed to pay "72% of the pay" but did not specify whether that meant pay alone or pay inclusive of statutory/contractual benefits; the court treated ambiguous compromises against the party that failed to clarify terms.
- The court relied on authority (Bipinchandra v. Navin Flourine Industries) and the statutory definition of "wages" in the Bombay Industrial Relations Act, 1946 (section 3(39) as quoted in the record), which defines wages expansively to include bonuses, allowances, value of amenities, employer contributions, travelling allowance, sums to defray special expenses, and gratuity.
- On jurisdiction, the court found no jurisdictional or procedural error apparent on the face of the record in the Labour Court's disposal under Section 33(C)(2). Citing Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaquim, the court emphasized that Article 227 is not a forum to correct mere errors of law or reweigh evidence, but to ensure inferior tribunals act within their authority.
- Despite refusing to interfere with the substantive decision on those grounds, the court accepted the respondent's submission that the Bank had withheld amounts due and that the respondent had been deprived of the benefit of timely payment; accordingly, the court considered an award of interest appropriate.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Petition dismissed.
Direct consequences ordered by the court:
- The petitioner-Bank is directed to pay Rs. 11,000/- plus Rs. 100/- (costs) to the respondent with 9% interest from 2-5-1987 until the date of payment.
- The directed amount is to be paid within four weeks from the date of the opinion.
- The Rule is discharged, interim relief stands vacated, and there is no order as to costs.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; it applies established principles (including the expansive statutory definition of "wages" under the Bombay Industrial Relations Act and the limits of Article 227 supervisory jurisdiction as explained in Mohd. Yunus). The decision's practical effect is to uphold the Labour Court's award (subject to the interest direction) and to reiterate that ambiguous compromise terms will be construed so as not to defeat statutory inclusions in "wages."
1. This matter was placed for hearing before me prior to vacation. However, learned Advocate for the petitioner requested the Court to adjourn the matter on the ground that the matter is likely to be settled. With a view to see that if there is amicable settlement, though the matter was old one, the Court granted time, but today, when the matter is called out, the Court is informed that till today, there is no settlement, and therefore, the Court has to dispose of the matter on merits.
2. Mr. Nirav Majmudar, learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner argued this matter at length. He submitted that the Labour Court, while examining the matter under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') has exceeded its limit. He further submitted that the Labour Court accepted the demand which was objected by the petitioner-Bank. However, on a specific question being put by the Court, Mr. Majmudar had to say very frankly that before the Labour Court, the Bank has neither taken any specific plea nor produced any material in support of the contentions.
3. The respondent was an employee of the petitioner-Bank. The respondent filed an application before the Labour Court being B.I.R. No. 428 of 1977 challenging the action of the petitioner-Bank in relieving him from service w.e.f. 30-7-1988 after giving one month's salary. The Labour Court rejected the application. Aggrieved, respondent filed an appeal before the Industrial Court being No. I. C. No. 61 of 1981. The Industrial Court directed the petitioner-Bank to pay full pay from 30-7-1977 to 12-10-1981 after deducting the notice pay given to the respondent herein. As the said order was not complied with, the respondent moved a contempt petition before this High Court, and it appears that the petitioner herein arrived at a settlement with the respondent. The petitioner agreed to pay 72% of the pay for the period from 30-7-1977 to 12-10-1981 and the respondent agreed to accept the same. Accordingly, the petitioner paid a sum of Rs. 13,000/- to the respondent. However, the respondent filed Recovery Application No. 613 of 1984 before the Labour Court, Vadodara contending that as per his calculation an amount of Rs. 24,221/- is due to him as he was entitled to get not only pay, but also benefits such as privilege leave, casual leave, sick leave, national holidays, bonus, house rent allowance and medical allowance. The Presiding Officer, after hearing the parties, by order dated 2-5-1987 directed the petitioner to pay an additional amount of Rs. 11,000/- and also cost of Rs. 100/-. The present proceedings are initiated by the Bank against the aforesaid order dated 2-5-1987 passed by the Presiding Officer of the Labour Court, Vadodara.
4. It is contended before this Court that the respondent-employee is not entitled to any difference in salary. According to the petitioner-Bank, whatever the salary was required to be paid on 30-7-1977 was required to be taken into consideration till 12-10-1981. According to the employer, even if there was rise in pay, the employee would not get the said benefit. This contention raised by the petitioner is required to be rejected. If the petitioner was of the view that a particular amount is required to be paid, then at that time, instead of stating 72% of the wages, it ought to have stated a particular sum. If that would have been made clear before the Court hearing the contempt application, then possibly there would have been no occasion for the respondent-employee to make a grievance before the Labour Court. It is known in the labour field that unless and until it is specified, wages would include other benefits also.
5. A Division Bench of this Court, in the case of Bipinchandra v. Navin Flourine Industries reported in 1981 GLR 1070 considered this aspect and clarified as under in paragraph 5 :
"We may make it clear that back wages will include all the payments to which a permanent employee would be entitled to, such as dearness allowance, increments, bonus etc."
6. In the circumstances, it was for the petitioner-Bank, to specifically state at the relevant time in the compromise purshis as to what it intends to pay. If the Bank would have specifically stated pay only and nothing else, the respondent may not have agreed to the compromise. In the absence of any clear terms, wages would include other benefits also.
7. It is also required to be noted at this juncture that me matter is covered under the Bombay Industrial Relations Act, 1946. The provisions contained in sub-section (39) of Section 3 defines wages as under :-
"Wages" means remuneration of all kinds capable of being expressed in terms of money and payable to an employee in respect of his employment or work done in such employment and includes -
(i) any bonus, allowances (including dearness allowance), reward or additional remuneration; (ii) the value of any house accommodation, light, water, medical attendance or other amenity or service; (iii) any contribution by the employer to any pension or provident fund; (iv) any travelling allowance or the value of any travelling concession; (v) any sum paid or payable to or on behalf of an employee to defray special expenses entailed on him by the nature of his employment; (vi) gratuity payable, if any."
Thus, the contention raised by Mr. Majmudar, in view of the specific provision, cannot be accepted.
8. In the instant case, the Labour Court disposed of the application made under Section 33(C)(2) of the Act. There is no jurisdictional error or procedural error apparent on the face of the record. Therefore, the supervisory jurisdiction conferred on the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution being limited to seeing that an inferior Court or tribunal acts within the limit and not to correct an error apparent on the face of the record much less an error of law, the Court would not be entitled to entertain the petition as canvassed by learned Advocate Mr. Majmudar. The Apex Court in the case of Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaquim reported in AIR 1984 SC 38 held as under :
"A mere wrong decision without anything more is not enough to attract the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227.
The supervisory jurisdiction conferred on the High Courts under Article 227 of the Constitution is limited "to seeing that an inferior Court or Tribunal functions within the limits of its authority", and not to correct an error apparent on the face of the record, much less an error of law. In this case there was, in our opinion, no error of law much less an error apparent on the face of the record. There was no failure on the part of the learned Subordinate Judge to exercise jurisdiction nor did he act in disregard of principles of natural justice. Nor was the procedure adopted by him not in consonance with the procedure established by law. In exercising the supervisory power under Article 227, the High Court does not act as an Appellate Court or Tribunal. It will not review or re weigh the evidence upon which the determination of the inferior Court or tribunal purports to be based or to correct errors of law in the decision."
9. Mr. Vasavada, learned Advocate submitted that the petitioner, by filing this petition withheld payment of the amount which otherwise the respondent was entitled to receive. He further submitted that the respondent employee would have earned interest on the amount which was withheld by the Bank. If the amount would have been paid to the respondent at the relevant time, the question would have been different, but as the respondent has been denied the benefit of the order, I see much force in the request made by Mr. Vasavada claiming interest on the amount retained by the Bank.
10. Under the circumstances, the petition is dismissed. The petitioner is directed to pay amount of Rs. 11,000/- plus Rs. 100/- to the respondent with 9% interest from 2-5-1987 till date of payment. The said amount shall be paid within a period of four weeks from today.
11. Rule is discharged. Interim relief stands vacated. No order as to costs.
12. Petition dismissed.
Alert