- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kheralu Nagarik Sahakari Bank Ltd. v. State Of Gujarat
Factual and Procedural Background
The common question in these Special Civil Applications concerns the constitutional validity of Section 71 of the Co-operative Societies Act, Gujarat Act 10 of 1962 ("the Act"). The petitioners contend that Section 71 cannot regulate the affairs of a Society engaged in banking business, particularly after the amendment by the Banking Laws (Application to Co-operative Societies) Act, Central Act 23 of 1965, which brought co-operative banks under the purview of the Banking Regulation Act, a Central legislation. The petitioners argue that the provisions of the Gujarat Act are ultra vires the State Legislature's powers under Article 245 of the Constitution. The parties agreed to dispose of all petitions by a common judgment, focusing solely on the legal question of whether Section 71 remains in force after the 1965 amendment to the Banking Regulation Act. They also agreed that factual disputes should be addressed before the authorities issuing show-cause notices under Section 147 of the Act, and thus the Court refrained from examining those factual controversies.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Section 71 of the Co-operative Societies Act, Gujarat Act 10 of 1962, continues to be in force after the amendment of the Banking Regulation Act by Central Act 23 of 1965.
- Whether the State Legislature has the competence to regulate co-operative societies engaged in banking business, or whether such regulation falls exclusively within the legislative domain of the Central Government under Entries 43, 44, and 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule.
- How to harmoniously interpret the overlapping Entries 32 of List II and Entries 43 and 45 of List I in the Seventh Schedule with respect to co-operative societies engaged in banking.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Section 71 of the Gujarat Act cannot control societies engaged in banking business after the 1965 amendment which brought such societies under the Banking Regulation Act.
- The Banking Regulation Act, a Central law enacted under Entries 43, 44, and 45 of List I, exclusively governs banking activities, including those of co-operative banks.
- The State Legislature’s power under Entry 32 of List II to legislate on co-operative societies does not extend to those engaged in banking business.
- Entries 43 and 45 of List I, which cover banking and banking corporations, should be interpreted as excluding State regulation of co-operative banks, even if registered under the Co-operative Societies Act.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Co-operative Societies Act applies to all co-operative societies, including those engaged in banking business, and such societies do not cease to be co-operative societies merely because they do banking business.
- Entry 32 of List II empowers the State Legislature to legislate on co-operative societies, including those engaged in banking, and the exclusion of co-operative societies from Entry 43 of List I supports this interpretation.
- The banking activities of co-operative societies are subject to the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, including Section 71, which regulates their investments and affairs.
- The actions taken under Section 71 of the Act and related provisions are legal and sustainable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Virendra Pal Singh and Ors. v. District Assistant Registrar, 1980 (4) SCC 109 | Co-operative societies engaged in banking business do not cease to be co-operative societies merely because they do banking business; they remain subject to the Co-operative Societies Act. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Co-operative Societies Act continues to control the affairs of co-operative banks and that actions under the Act are legal and sustainable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by recognizing the overlapping legislative entries in the Seventh Schedule and the need to harmoniously interpret them. It noted that Entries 43 and 45 of List I relate to banking and banking corporations, but Entry 43 specifically excludes co-operative societies. Entry 32 of List II empowers the State Legislature to legislate on co-operative societies. The Court concluded that co-operative societies engaged in banking fall exclusively under Entry 32 of List II and thus are subject to State legislation, including the Co-operative Societies Act.
The Court referred to the Apex Court decision in Virendra Pal Singh, which held that co-operative societies do not cease to be such merely because they engage in banking business. The Court observed that the petitioners’ co-operative banks were registered under the Act and that Section 71 governs their investment activities. Although the petitioners invested funds without State Government permission, the Court refrained from commenting on the merits of those actions due to pending proceedings under the Act.
Ultimately, the Court held that the provisions of the Gujarat Act, including Section 71, continue to control the affairs of the co-operative banks and that the actions initiated under the Act are lawful and sustainable.
Holding and Implications
The petitions are dismissed.
The Court held that Section 71 of the Co-operative Societies Act, Gujarat Act 10 of 1962, remains valid and applicable to co-operative banks engaged in banking business, notwithstanding the amendment to the Banking Regulation Act. The State Legislature retains the power to regulate co-operative societies under Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule, even if those societies carry on banking activities. Consequently, actions initiated under the Gujarat Act against the petitioners are legal and sustainable. No relief is granted to the petitioners, and the rule is discharged with ad interim relief vacated. The decision does not establish any new precedent beyond affirming the existing legal position on the legislative competence and applicability of the Co-operative Societies Act to co-operative banks.
1. The common question raised in all these Special Civil Applications is relating to Constitutional validity of Section 71 of the Co-operative Societies Act, Gujarat Act 10 of 1962 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act"). Contention is that Section 71 cannot in any manner control the affairs of a Society, engaged in banking business. Such a Society, after the amendment brought about by the Banking Laws (Application to Co-operative Societies) Act. Central Act 23 of 1965, cannot have any relevance to such activities. On account of the said Central Legislation, the provisions contained in the Act becomes ultra vires the powers of the State Legislature by virtue of provisions contained in Article 245 of the Constitution.
2. Learned Counsels appearing in the case, while arguing the entire issue in detail, agreed to have all these petitions disposed of by a common judgment. They further prayed that This Court need not go into various questions of fact raised in these matters, for, they are to be challenged before the Authorities, who issued notices, requiring the Bank and its officers to show cause why action contemplated by Section 147 of the Act are not to be initiated. On this basis, we refrain from examining the various factual controversies raised by the respective petitioners. We are confining ourselves to the legal question as to whether Section 71 of the Act continues to be in force after the amendment of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as "The Banking Regulation Act") as amended by Central Act 23 of 1965, which came into force with effect from 1-3-1966.
3. It is common case of all the parties to these proceedings that concerned District Co-operative Banks are "Co-operative Societies", coming within the definition of that expression under the Act. All these banks are Societies, registered under the Act and are doing business of 'banking', as defined in Section 5 of the Banking Regulation Act. These banks carry out the business of banking by accepting deposits of money from the public for the purpose of lending or for investment. The money so accepted are repayable on demand or otherwise, withdrawable by cheque, draft, order or otherwise. Consequently, it is contended that these Societies are Banking Companies. As such, they come under the purview of Banking Regulation Act, which is a Central Enactment. Provisions contained in the Gujarat Act can, under no circumstance, control the banking activities of these Co-operative Banks. Any provision for controlling the affairs of these banks in the Act will be beyond the Legislative competence of the Gujarat Legislative Assembly. Entries 43, 44 and 45 in List 1 of Seventh Schedule authorises the Central Government and the Central Government alone to legislate on Banking and Banking Corporations. Invoking the power under those Entries, Central Government enacted Banking Regulation Act, as amended by Act 23 of 1965. By that Amending Act, Co-operative Banks have been brought under the Banking Regulation Act. Co-operative Societies Act of Gujarat has been enacted, invoking the powers under Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. The said enactment can, under no circumstances, enable the State Government or its officers to impose any restriction in the activities of the Bank.
4. Argument advanced by learned Counsel representing the petitioners is that matters regarding incorporation, regulation and winding up of Banking Societies, even if registered under the Co-operative Societies Act would fall within Entry 43 of List 1 of the Seventh Schedule. Entry 45, being one taking, within its ambit anything and everything connected with Banking, should cover the banking activities of Co-operative Societies as well. Therefore, any society, even if it is registered under the Act, can be controlled by Central Legislation, coming under Entry 43 or Entry 45 of List 1. Entry 32 in List II, though empowers the State Legislature to make laws with respect to the Co-operative Societies, cannot be taken as an authorisation to legislate on Co-operative Societies dealing in banking business. Contention is that if a particular subject falls under List 1 in the Seventh Schedule, then the Parliament has the exclusive power to legislate on that subject and consequently, the State is deprived of any power to make law in respect of that matter.
4.1 It is settled law that various Entries in the various Lists in the Seventh Schedule must be given widest possible interpretation. It is also settled position that if some of the Entries in the different Lists overlap or appear to be in direct conflict, it is the duty of the Court to reconcile the Entries and bring about a harmonious construction. A Co-operative Society, carrying on banking business, may appear to be a Corporation concerned with the business of banking. Thus, it may appear to be falling within the ambit of Entry 43 of List 1. So also, since it is carrying on the business of banking, it may appear to be coming within the scope of Entry 45 of List 1. To have a harmonious construction of Entry Nos. 43 and 45, it is to be understood that only business of banking, pure and simple, falls within the purview of Entry 45, while incorporation of a Trading Corporation, engaged in banking, must fall within the ambit of Entry 43. In this view, to have a harmonious understanding, Co-operative Banks may fall within Entry 43 and not under Entry 45 of List 1. But Entry 43 specifically excludes Co-operative Societies from its purview. When such a specific exclusion of the Co-operative Societies is provided in Entry 43, Cooperative Societies, engaged in banking, should be taken out of the purview of Entry 43 as well. Co-operative Societies have been brought under Entry 32 of List II. The Stale Legislature has thereby power to legislate on all matters concerning Cooperative Societies. Such Co-operative Societies falling under Entry 32 of List II may even be engaged in the business of banking. This and this alone can be the harmonious interpretation of the various Entries in List 1 and II mentioned above.
5. In Virendra Pal Singh and Ors. v. District Assistant Registrar 1980 (4) SCC 109 the Apex Court dealing with an identical issue, observed:
... Merely because they do banking business such Co-operative Societies do not cease to be Co-operative Societies, when otherwise they are registered under the Co-operative Societies Act and are subject to the duties, liabilities and control of the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act....
In the instant cases, all these Societies were registered under the Co-operative Societies Act. They are falling under the category of Central Co-operative Banks. Such a bank, as per the Act, is registered with the primary object of creating funds to be loaned to other Societies. The District Co-operative Bank has, thus, the primary object of financing other Societies in that District. Section 71 of the Act enumerates the various institutions in which a Co-operative Bank is to make investments. Clause (g) of Section 71(1) enables the State Government to permit any society to invest the funds in any institution other than those mentioned in Clauses (a) to (f) of this sub-section. Petitioners sought the permission of the State Government to invest funds in the institution outside those falling under Clauses (a) to (f). Government did not accord permission to make such investment. In spite of this, they invested the funds in another Mutual Fund. That investment, according to the Bank, was for getting more returns. On account of the liquidation of the Mutual Fund, in which the investment has been made, notices have been issued to the Bank, calling for explanation as to why action should not be initiated, as contemplated by Section 148 of the Act. Petitioners have not filed their replies to those notices. In such a situation, any observation made by us on this issue may prejudice one side or the other in the proceedings that follow the show-cause notice. So, Counsel appearing on either side rightly requested us not to dwell into that aspect of the matter in the judgment. Accordingly, we refrain from expressing our views on the justifiability or otherwise of the action taken by the Bank and its office-bearers in depositing funds in the Mutual Fund.
6. In view of what has been stated above and in the light of the decision of the Apex Court, referred to earlier, we hold that the provisions, of the Act controls the affairs of the petitioners herein and actions initiated under that Act are legal and sustainable. We do not find any reason to interfere with the action taken under the Act. Petitioners, if they are so advised, have to face the proceedings in accordance with law. The petitioners are not entitled to any of the reliefs asked for in these petitions. They are accordingly dismissed. Rule is discharged. Ad interim relief is vacated.
Alert