Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Varun Seacon Ltd. v. Bharat Bijlee Ltd. .

Gujarat High Court
Aug 14, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-defendant supplied equipment including transformers to the appellant-plaintiff in 1995. Disputes arose regarding payments and damages, with the respondent claiming approximately Rs. 19 lacs as balance consideration, and the appellant claiming Rs. 24 lacs damages due to defects. The appellant filed Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995 seeking Rs. 5 lacs. The respondent appeared and filed Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 ("the old Act") seeking a stay of the suit on the ground that disputes should be referred to arbitration. The respondent also filed an interim application (Ex. 5) for stay of suit proceedings pending decision on the main application. The trial court granted the interim stay on March 11, 1996, which is the order under appeal. The parties requested disposal of the main Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 along with the appeal to avoid delay and multiplicity of proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 filed independently under Section 34 of the old Act before the same judicial authority was maintainable or whether such application must be filed within the suit itself.
  2. Whether the application for stay of suit proceedings should be governed by the provisions of the Arbitration Act, 1940 (old Act) or the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (new Act) given the commencement of the new Act on January 25, 1996.
  3. Whether the respondent-defendant was precluded from filing an application under Section 34 of the old Act because it had taken procedural steps in the suit, such as seeking adjournments for filing written statement.
  4. Whether the respondent-defendant could pursue two separate remedies simultaneously: an application under Section 34 of the old Act and an application under Section 11(5) of the new Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The application under Section 34 of the old Act was required to be filed within the suit itself, not as an independent application, rendering Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 not maintainable.
  • The provisions of the old Act alone apply to the application under Section 34, and the new Act should not be considered.
  • Since the respondent-defendant appeared in the suit and filed applications for adjournment to file written statement, it had taken steps in the proceedings and thus was barred from seeking stay under Section 34 of the old Act.
  • The respondent-defendant could not pursue two independent proceedings simultaneously under Section 34 of the old Act and Section 11(5) of the new Act.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Although Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 was not technically filed within the suit, it was filed before the same judicial authority, and there was no bar under Section 34 of the old Act or Section 8 of the new Act to entertain it.
  • Section 85 of the new Act repeals the old Act only for arbitral proceedings, not pending judicial proceedings; hence, the application under Section 34 of the old Act was not automatically dismissed and survived for adjudication under Section 8 of the new Act.
  • Section 8 of the new Act represents a material change from Section 34 of the old Act, allowing stay of suit even if the defendant had taken procedural steps like seeking adjournments.
  • The Arbitration Petition under Section 11(5) of the new Act was filed after the trial court's stay order and after service of notice for appointment of Arbitrator; thus, the respondent was not pursuing mutually exclusive remedies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gajraj Singh v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal (AIR 1997 SC 412) Rule on effect of repeal of an Act and application of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act in case of repeal and re-enactment. The Court relied on the principle that repeal obliterates the Act except for past and closed transactions, and that the new Act governs pending judicial proceedings unless a contrary intention is found.
Qudrat Ullah v. Bareilly Municipality (AIR 1974 SC 396) Effect of repeal on procedural disabilities and rights under repealed enactment. The Court held that procedural disabilities under the repealed Act do not survive repeal if not preserved by the new Act; thus, procedural restrictions under Section 34 of the old Act do not apply to pending applications under Section 8 of the new Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first rejected the appellant's contention that the stay application must be filed within the suit itself, holding that an independent application before the same judicial authority suffices under Section 34 of the old Act and Section 8 of the new Act.

It then analyzed whether the application should be governed by the old or new Act. The new Act commenced on January 25, 1996, repealing the old Act except for arbitral proceedings commenced before that date. Since the appellant's notice for appointment of Arbitrator was dated April 3, 1996, the arbitral proceedings had not commenced before the new Act, and thus the judicial proceedings fall under the new Act.

The Court relied on the Supreme Court's interpretation in Gajraj Singh to conclude that pending judicial proceedings are governed by the new Act, not the old Act, despite the repeal.

Further, the Court observed that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act preserves rights and liabilities but not procedural disabilities, and procedural restrictions under Section 34 of the old Act (such as barring stay if the defendant took any step in the suit) do not survive repeal.

Comparing Section 34 of the old Act and Section 8 of the new Act, the Court noted a legislative intent to depart from the earlier restrictive position. Under the new Act, a party is disentitled from stay only if it has submitted a statement on the substance of the dispute, not merely by taking procedural steps like requesting adjournments.

Since the respondent had not filed a written statement on merits but only sought adjournments, the application for stay under Section 8 of the new Act was valid.

Regarding the contention that the respondent was pursuing two mutually exclusive remedies, the Court found that the application under Section 11(5) of the new Act was filed after the stay order and after notice for appointment of Arbitrator, thus not constituting inconsistent remedies.

In view of these analyses, the Court dismissed the appeal and allowed the Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995, staying the suit proceedings during arbitration.

Holding and Implications

The appeal from order dated March 11, 1996 is dismissed. Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 is allowed, and the proceedings of Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995 shall remain stayed during the pendency of arbitration proceedings.

The appellant-plaintiff is granted one month to respond to the respondent's notice for appointment of Arbitrator, with liberty to agree on a common Arbitrator or appoint separate Arbitrators, after which arbitration will proceed under the new Act.

There is no order as to costs. The decision does not set new precedent but clarifies the application of the new Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to pending judicial proceedings and procedural requirements for stay of suits where arbitration agreements exist.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal is directed against the order dated March 11, 1996, passed by the learned Civil Judge (S.D.), Nadiad, below application Ex. 5 in Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995, which was filed by the respondent herein under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 for staying the proceedings of Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995 filed by the appellant herein for recovering an amount of Rs. 5 lacs.

2. The respondent-defendant herein had supplied certain equipments including transformers to the appellant-plaintiff in the year 1995. There were disputes between the parties. The respondent supplier claimed Rs. 19 lacs (Approx.) being the balance amount of consideration whereas the case of appellant plaintiff was that because of the defects in the machines, the appellant had suffered damage of Rs. 24 lacs. The appellant therefore, prayed for a decree of Rs. 5 lacs from the respondent herein by filing Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995 in the Court of the learned Civil Judge (S.D.), Nadiad on Sept. 4, 1995.

3. In the aforesaid suit, the respondent-defendant appeared and on Nov. 22, 1995, filed Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 (hereinafter referred as "the old Act"), praying for stay of the suit on the ground that the disputes between the parties were required to be referred to arbitration. In the said Civil Misc. Application, the respondent-defendant also filed application Ex. 5 for staying the suit proceedings pending the decision of the said Civil Misc. Application. By the order under appeal, delivered on March 11, 1996, the trial Court has stayed the suit proceedings pending the final decision of Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995.

4. Of course, the order under appeal is confined to interim stay application Ex. 5 in Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995, but looking to the nature of the controversy and in order to save delay and multiplicity of proceedings, learned Counsel for the parties have requested the Court to dispose of the said Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 along with the present appeal.

5. Mr. A. C. Gandhi, learned Counsel for the appellant-plaintiff has challenged the aforesaid order on the following grounds :-

(1) The application under section 34 of the old act was required to be filed in Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995. Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 was not filed by the respondent-defendant in the suit, but was an independent application and therefore, was not maintainable under section 34 of the old act.

(2) The application was filed by the respondent defendant under the Old Act and therefore, the provisions of the old act alone are required to be considered while testing the order under appeal.

(3) The respondent-defendant had appeared in the above suit and had filed applications for adjournment for filing written statement and therefore, as per the settled legal position, the respondent-defendant having taken steps in the proceedings, the application under section 34 of the old act ought to have been rejected.

(4) Arbitration Application No. 1 of 1996, purporting to be an application under Section 11(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as "the New Act"), is in the nature of the application under section 20 of the old act and therefore, it was not open to the respondent defendant to pursue two independent separate proceedings by filing such an application under Section 11(5) of the New Act and also pursuing the application under section 34 of the old act.

6. In reply, Ms. Minoo Shah, learned Counsel for the respondent-defendant has made the following submissions :

(i) Although, Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 was technically not an application in Special Civil Suit No. 114 of 1995, the said Civil Misc. Application was filed before the same judicial authority before whom the Special Civil Suit was pending and therefore, there was no bar either under section 34 of the old act or under Section 8 of the New Act for the learned Civil Judge (S.D.), Nadiad, to entertain the application.

(ii) Section 85 of the New Act provides for repeal of arbitral proceedings under the Old Act and does not affect the pending judicial proceedings including application for stay of suit proceedings. Hence, the Civil Misc. Application filed under section 34 of the old act was not required to be dismissed on the ground of repeal of the Old Act, but the application did survive and the same was required to be decided as per the provisions of Section 8 of the New Act.

(iii) Under the provisions of Section 8 of the New Act, there is a material change in the legal position inasmuch as mere filing of application for adjournment in order to file written statement does not debar the respondent-defendant from applying for stay of the suit.

(iv) The respondent has filed Arbitration Petition No. 1 of 1996 under the provisions of sub-section (5) of Section 11 of the New Act since the appellant plaintiff was served with the notice dated April 3, 1996 by the respondent defendant, for appointment of an Arbitrator. An amount of Rs. 5,000/- has also been deposited by the respondent defendant pursuant to the order passed by the learned Acting Chief Justice requiring the parties to deposit Rs. 5,000/- each. The application under Section 11(5) of the New Act was filed after and pursuant to the order of the trial Court under Section 8 of the New Act. Hence, there is no question of the respondent-defendant pursuing two mutually exclusive remedies.

CONTENTION NO. (1)

7. The first ground urged by Mr. Gandhi that Civil Misc. Application under section 34 of the old act or even under Section 8 of the New Act is not maintainable and that an application for stay must be made in the suit itself, cannot be accepted. All that the provisions of Section 34 of the Old Act and Section 8 of the New Act require is that the defendant should invite the attention of the judicial authority hearing the suit to the arbitration agreement and pray for the suit proceedings to be stayed so as to enable the arbitration agreement to be carried out. Whether this is done by filing an application in the same suit or through a so called independent application before the same Court is a matter of no consequence.

CONTENTIONS NOS. 2 AND 3 :

8. However, the moot question is whether the application was required to be decided under the provisions of Section 34 of the Old Act or under the provisions of Section 8 of the New Act.

The provisions of the new act came into force on Jan. 25, 1996, Section 85 of the New Act, provides for repeal, inter alia, of the Arbitration Act, 1940 (i.e. the Old Act.) Saving clause containing sub-section (2) thereof reads as under :-

"(2) Notwithstanding such repeal :

(a) the provisions of the said enactments shall apply in relation to arbitral proceedings which commenced before this Act came into force unless otherwise agreed by the parties, but this Act shall apply in relation to arbitral proceedings which commenced on or after this Act comes into force;

(b) all rules made and notifications published, under the said enactment shall, to the extent to which they are not repugnant to this Act be deemed respectively to have been made or issued under this Act.

In the instant case, the appellant-plaintiff had given a notice for appointment of an Arbitrator to the respondent-defendant on April 3, 1996 and therefore, the arbitral proceedings had not commenced before the commencement of the New Act.

The learned Counsel for the respondent defendant is right in contending that sub-section (2) of Section 85 of the Act saves the applications of the provisions of the old act to arbitral proceedings which had commenced before the commencement of the New Act, but as far as the judicial proceedings are concerned, though the same would continue, the law applicable to such judicial proceedings would be the provisions of the new act w.e.f. January 25, 1996.

9. In this connection, it is necessary to take note of the following well settled rule of interpretation, which is also reiterated by the Supreme Court in the case of Gajraj Singh v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal (AIR 1997 SC 412), (Para 23) :-

"Whether an Act is repealed it must be considered, except as to transactions past and closed, as if it had never existed. The effect thereof is to obliterate the Act completely from the record of the Parliament as if it had never been passed, it never existed except for the purpose of those actions which were commenced, prosecuted and concluded while it was existing law ........"

However Section 6 of the General Clauses Act 1897, provides, inter alia, that where the Act repeals any enactment, unless a different intention appears, the repeal shall not.

(a) revive anything not in force or existing at the time at which the repeal takes effect; or

(b) affect the previous operation of any enactment so repealed of anything duly done or suffered thereunder; or

(c) effect any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under any enactment so repealed, and any such investigation, legal proceedings or remedy may be instituted, continued or enforced.

In the case of Gajraj Singh, (supra), therefore, the Supreme Court has held that (Para 25) :-

"When there is a repeal and simultaneous re-enactment, Section 6 of the General Clauses Act would apply to such a case unless contrary intention can be gathered from the repealing Act. Section 6 would be applicable in such cases unless the new legislation manifests intention inconsistent with or contrary to the application of the Section. Such incompatibility would have to be ascertained from all relevant provisions of the new act. Therefore, when the repeal is followed by a fresh legislation on the same subject, the Court would undoubtedly have to look to the provisions of the new act only for the purpose of determining whether the new Act indicates different intention. The object of repeal and reenactment is to obliterate the Repealed Act and to get rid of certain absolute matters."

10. Looking to the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 85 of the New Act, it is clear that the New Act, while repealing the Old Act, intended to save the repealed Act only for the pending arbitral proceedings. Thus, an intention inconsistent with the provisions of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act is clearly manifested insofar as the question of applicability of section 34 of the old act to pending judicial proceedings is concerned and, therefore, applications under section 34 of the old act which are pending in a Civil Court on the date of commencement of the New Act are governed by the New Act and not by the Old Act.

11. Even other wise, even if one were to apply the provisions of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, what the said provisions save are rights, privileges, obligations and liabilities but not any procedural disabilities. In the case of Qudrat Ullah v. Bareilly Municipality (AIR 1974 SC 396), (Paras 20 and 21) the Supreme Court has laid down that where a party to the proceedings had no right or privilege under the repealed Act, which imposed a procedural restriction or a procedural disability on the other side, repeal of the Old Act and simultaneous re-enactment without that disability does not continue the procedural disability, even on application of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act. It is clear that the restriction contained in section 34 of the old act that the party should not have taken any other step in the proceedings was a procedural disability on the defendant rather than a right on the plaintiff. This Court is, therefore, justified in taking the view that pending applications under section 34 of the old act such as Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 in the present case are covered by the provisions of Section 8 of the New Act and not by section 34 of the old act.

12. Looking to the provisions of Section 8 of the New Act and comparing the same with the provisions of Section 34 of the Old Act, it is clear that the legislature intended to make a clear departure from the provisions contained in Section 34 of the Old Act as would be clear from a bare reading of section 34 of the old act and Section 8 of the New Act.

section 34 of the old act :

"Power to stay legal proceedings where there is an arbitration agreement. - Where any party to an arbitration agreement of any person claiming under him commences any legal proceedings against any other party to the agreement or any person claiming under him, in respect of any matter agreed to be referred, any party to such legal proceedings may, at any time before filing a written statement or taking any other steps in the proceedings, apply to the judicial authority before which the proceedings are pending to stay the proceedings; and .......... such authority may make an order staying the proceedings."

Section 8 of the New Act :

Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is an arbitration agreement. -

(1) A judicial authority before which an action is brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party so applies not later than when submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute, refer the parties to arbitration.

Now, the underlined words in sub-section (1) of Section 8 make a clear departure from the legal position as contained in section 34 of the old act, under which if the defendant had filed an application for adjournment for filing written statement, it was treated as taking a step in the suit proceedings and therefore, it was held that in such a case the suit was not required to be stayed at the instance of a defendant who had displayed an intention to proceed with the suit and acquiesce in the method of resolution of dispute adopted by the plaintiff, namely filing of the suit and thereby indicated that it had abandoned its right under the arbitration agreement to get the dispute resolved by arbitration. Realizing that such an interpretation was bringing about anomalous results and frustrating the laudable object of the arbitration law, the legislature has advisedly made a clear departure from the earlier position and, therefore, now a party is disentitled from getting stay of the suit only if the party has earlier submitted its statement on the substance of the dispute, that is, if earlier the defendant has filed its reply on merits.

13. In the instant case, admittedly the respondent defendant had not filed any written statement on merits and had submitted Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 with a prayer to stay the proceedings of the suit on the ground that the disputes between the parties were required to be referred to arbitration. Hence mere filing of applications for adjournment to file Written Statement did not debar the defendant from prosecuting application under Section 8 of the New Act.

CONTENTION NO. 4 :

14. The submission urged on behalf of the appellant that the respondent-defendant was prosecuting two mutually exclusive remedies also cannot, be accepted in view of the fact that the application under Section 11(5) of the New Act was filed after the trial Court stayed the suit and after service of notice given by the respondent-defendant to appellant-plaintiff for appointment of Arbitrator, which was not responded to.

15. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the Appeal From Order deserves to be dismissed. In view of the joint request of learned Counsel for the parties, since the same arguments would be required to be considered while deciding the Civil Misc. Application, this order in appeal arising from the order below application Ex. 5 in Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 shall also be treated as final order on Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 which hereby deserves to be allowed.

16. Mr. Gandhi submits that since the appellant plaintiff was pursuing the present remedy of appeal, appellant plaintiff had not responded to the notice given by the other side in April, 1996 and that since that controversy has been resolved only today, the appellant plaintiff be given one month's time to appoint their Arbitrator.

17. The request made by Mr. Gandhi seems to be reasonable in view of the fact that till now, the controversy whether the suit proceedings were required to be stayed or not was pending before this Court. The appellant-plaintiff shall therefore reply to the respondent-plaintiffs notice for appointment of an Arbitrator within one month from today. It will be open to the parties to arrive at an agreement for appointing a common Arbitrator, failing which each party shall appoint its own Arbitrator. Thereafter, the matter shall proceed in accordance with the provisions of the new act. In view of the above, the hearing of Arbitration Petition No. I of 1996 shall stand adjourned to Sept. 22, 1997.

18. In the result, Appeal From Order No. 224 of 1996 is hereby dismissed. Civil Misc. Application No. 113 of 1995 on the file of the Court of learned Civil Judge (S.D.), Nadiad is hereby allowed and the proceedings of Spl. Civil No. 114 of 1995 shall remain stayed during the pendency of the arbitration proceedings.

Since the appeal is disposed of, Civil Application for stay also stands disposed of.

There shall be no order as to costs.

Order accordingly.