Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Om Shri Jigar Association v. The Union Of India And Others

Gujarat High Court
May 5, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is described as a registered non-trading corporation. Its President, Shri Mahesh Kalubhai Bhatt, entered into an agreement on June 10, 1992 to purchase land (Final Plot No. 287) from the third respondent (Badhabhai Trust), a public charitable trust registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950. The Trust applied to the Charity Commissioner on February 25, 1993 for permission to sell the land. A public advertisement inviting objections and offers was published on June 4, 1993, and tenders were opened on June 30, 1993. Two offers were received; one offer for Rs. 22 lakhs was rejected as conditional, and the petitioner’s offer of Rs. 22 lakhs was accepted. An agreement to sell was executed on October 19, 1993, subject to (inter alia) sanction by the Charity Commissioner under section 36 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act and by the appropriate authority under the Income-tax Act. Form No. 37-I was submitted on November 3, 1993, and the Charity Commissioner approved the agreement on January 13, 1994.

The appropriate income-tax authority later issued a show-cause notice and, according to the opinion, passed an order (referred to in the opinion at one point as dated February 23, 1994 and elsewhere as dated February 23, 1993) holding that the land was fit for pre-emptive purchase under section 269UD(1) of the Income-tax Act on the ground that the apparent consideration was understated by more than 15 per cent., and ordering purchase. The petitioner challenged that order in the proceedings summarized by this opinion.

Note: The opinion itself contains two different year references for the impugned order (February 23, 1994 in an earlier paragraph and February 23, 1993 in the operative paragraph). The summary reflects both references as they appear in the text.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appropriate authority could invoke the provisions of Chapter XX-C of the Income-tax Act (specifically section 269UD(1)) to order pre-emptive purchase where the property was sold after public advertisement and an auction in which the petitioner’s highest bid was accepted and the Charity Commissioner sanctioned the sale under section 36 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act.
  2. Whether the show-cause notice issued by the appropriate authority complied with principles of reasonable notice and fair opportunity to be heard (i.e., whether the notice was sufficiently specific about the material and grounds for pre-emptive purchase, so that the affected parties could meaningfully show cause).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner purchased the land after a public auction/advertisement conducted by the Charity Commissioner, and its bid was the highest; therefore the agreed consideration should be treated as the market value.
  • The agreement to sell and the sale process were governed by and sanctioned under section 36 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act; consequently there was no question of undervaluation or tax evasion.
  • The show-cause notice issued by the Department was vague and illegal, failing to disclose reasons or grounds for compulsory purchase and thereby denying an effective opportunity to be heard.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the respondents (Mr. Shelat) contended that a public auction does not preclude the possibility of undervaluation; a sale by auction can still be undervalued.
  • The show-cause notice was sent to the address in Form No. 37-I but was returned "unserved" marked "not known"; the Department therefore contacted the association’s president by phone and asked him to collect the show-cause notice on February 1, 1994, but nobody collected it on behalf of the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.B. Gautam v. Union of India, [1993] 199 ITR 530 (Supreme Court) The provisions of Chapter XX-C (including section 269UD) can be invoked only where there is significant undervaluation of property (15% or more). Even if such undervaluation is established, any presumption of an attempt to evade tax is rebuttable, and affected parties must be given opportunity to show cause. There can be bona fide reasons for a sale below perceived market value. The court applied this ratio to conclude that it was difficult to hold there was undervaluation of 15% or more given the public auction process, Charity Commissioner’s involvement and sanction, and absence of findings of fraud; therefore Chapter XX-C powers should not have been exercised in this case.
Shri B.D. Gupta v. State of Haryana, AIR 1972 SC 2472 (Supreme Court) A show-cause notice must indicate the precise scope and points on which a reply is expected; vague general terms are insufficient. The notice must make clear the particular allegations and materials on which the authority relies so that the recipient can respond effectively. The court relied on this authority to hold that a vague show-cause notice (one that fails to specify provisional conclusions, material relied upon, or grounds for pre-emptive purchase) deprives affected parties of a reasonable opportunity to be heard under section 269UD and section 269UD(1A) procedures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court accepted the petitioner's factual account of the sale process: the trust applied for sanction, the Charity Commissioner published notice and invited offers, two offers were received, and the petitioner's offer of Rs. 22 lakhs was accepted as the highest bid. The agreement to sell was subject to Charity Commissioner sanction under section 36 and to approval by the appropriate income-tax authority.

The court reasoned that where a property owned by a public charitable trust is sold after a statutory process involving public advertisement, invitation of offers and sanction by the Charity Commissioner, the amount realized at auction ordinarily represents the market value unless there is evidence of fraud or other exceptional circumstances. It would be difficult, the court held, to conclude that the apparent consideration was lower than fair market value by 15% or more — the statutory threshold for invoking Chapter XX-C powers — in such circumstances.

The court relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in C.B. Gautam to emphasize that:

  • Chapter XX-C (section 269UD) should be invoked only on a clear finding of significant undervaluation (15%+);
  • any presumption of tax-evading intent is rebuttable and requires an opportunity for the affected parties to show cause; and
  • bona fide reasons (e.g., urgency of sale, title disputes, subsisting leases) may explain a sale below some estimate of market value.

Applying this ratio, the court concluded that the appropriate authority had not demonstrated fraud or bad faith in the auction process or that the petitioner's bid was not genuine; therefore the use of Chapter XX-C powers was not justified.

The court also analyzed the procedural adequacy of the show-cause notice. Drawing on Shri B.D. Gupta, the court held that a show-cause notice must specify provisional conclusions and the material basis for the authority's proposed action so that the transferee and transferor can meaningfully contest it. A vague notice that fails to disclose grounds and materials for pre-emptive purchase deprives the parties of a reasonable opportunity to be heard under section 269UD and section 269UD(1A). The court found the notice in this matter deficient in that respect.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was allowed and the court ordered relief. The court quashed and set aside the impugned order of the appropriate authority (the opinion refers to the impugned order as dated February 23, 1994 in one paragraph and as dated February 23, 1993 in the operative paragraph).

Direct consequences and orders issued by the court:

  • The impugned order dated February 23 (referred to in the opinion both as 1994 and 1993) was quashed and set aside.
  • The appropriate authority was directed to issue a "no objection" certificate under sub-section (1) of section 269UL of the Income-tax Act to the petitioner.
  • The rule was made absolute to that extent, with no order as to costs.
  • At respondents' request, the court stayed the operation of its order until August 1, 1994.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasizes procedural safeguards when invoking Chapter XX-C powers — significant undervaluation must be established (15%+), any presumption of tax-evading intent is rebuttable, and affected persons must receive a sufficiently specific show-cause notice and a fair opportunity to rebut the authority's provisional conclusions. The opinion does not indicate that it sets a new legal precedent beyond applying and following the principles laid down by prior Supreme Court authority.

Show all summary ...

1. It is the contention of the petitioner that it is a registered non-trading corporation and that its President, Shri Mahesh Kalubhai Bhatt, entered into an agreement on June 10, 1992, to purchase land bearing Final Plot No. 287 admeasuring 1,230 sq. mtr. (1,028.40 sq. mtr.) owned by the third respondent (Badhabhai Trust) for a sum of Rs. 20 lakhs. The third respondent is a public charitable trust registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 ("the Act", for short). The trust filed an application on February 25, 1993, before the Charity Commissioner for seeking permission to sell the said land. Pursuant to the said application a public advertisement was given in the newspaper on June 4, 1993, inviting objections, if any, to the said sale and inviting offers from the public at large for purchase of the said land. It is also contended that on June 30, 1993, the Charity Commissioner opened the tenders. Two offers were received. The Charity Commissioner found that the offer of one person to buy the said land for Rs. 22 lakhs was a conditional one and hence was not acceptable and, thereafter the petitioner offered to buy the said land for a consideration of Rs. 22 lakhs to the Charity Commissioner. The petitioner's offer was accepted and, therefore, an agreement to sell was executed between the petitioner and the said trust on October 19, 1993. The said agreement to sell was executed subject to certain conditions, inter alia, that the sale would be subject to sanction by the Charity Commissioner under section 36 of the Act as well as by the appropriate authority under the Income-tax Act. Thereafter, Form No. 37-I was submitted in the office of the appropriate authority on November 3, 1993. On January 13, 1994, the Charity Commissioner approved the said agreement to sell. It is the contention of the petitioner that, in spite of the aforesaid facts, without giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner the appropriate authority has passed an order on February 23, 1994, holding that the said land is fit for pre-emptive purchase under section 269UD(1) of the Income-tax Act, because the apparent consideration has been understated by more than 15 per cent. and, in exercise of the powers vested under section 269UD(1) of the Income-tax Act, ordered to purchase the said land. It is submitted that the petitioner has purchased the said land in the public auction held by the Charity Commissioner. The Charity Commissioner has found that the bid of the petitioner was the highest and, therefore, accorded sanction under section 36 of the Act. Therefore, in the present case, there is no question of undervaluing the land for its purchase. It is further contended by the petitioner that the notice given by the Department is absolutely vague and illegal and it does not disclose any reason or ground as to why the property was sought to be compulsorily purchased.

2. Mr. Shelat, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respondents submitted that it cannot be held that merely because the land was sold in a public auction, there cannot be any undervalutaion. He further submitted that the notice was sent to the petitioner at the address mentioned in Form No. 37-I but it was returned "unserved" by the postal authorities with a remark "not known". As the correct address was not known to the Department, the officer of the second respondent contacted the president of the association on the phone and asked him to collect the show-cause notice on February 1, 1994, but nobody has turned up to collect the show-cause notice on behalf of the petitioner.

3. In our view, the contentions raised by the petitioner are required to be accepted. It is apparent that the petitioner has agreed to purchase the land as per banakhat dated June 10, 1992 (annexure "B" to the petition). Subsequently, an application was submitted by the trust before the Charity Commissioner to grant sanction for sale of the said land. Thereafter the Charity Commissioner issued a public notice and invited offers for purchase of the said land. Two offers were received by the Charity Commissioner, one of them for Rs. 22 lakhs was not acceptable because it was conditional. The petitioner thereafter offered Rs. 22 lakhs and its offer was accepted by the Charity Commissioner. Thereafter, an agreement to sell was executed between the trust and the petitioner and it was subject to sanction by the Charity Commissioner under section 36 of the Act as well as by the appropriate authority under the Income-tax Act. So, it is apparent that the petitioner entered into an agreement to purchase the property on the basis of advertisement issued by the Charity Commissioner for the sale of the said land. Offers were invited from the public at large. Except where it is alleged that there was fraud or for such other reasons, in normal circumstances, the amount offered by the petitioner is required to be considered as the market value of the land, that is to say, the highest price realised at the time of auction is required to be accepted as the market value of the land.

4. Further, in the present case, the land is owned by a public trust and the public trust is required to obtain the sanction of the Charity Commissioner under section 36(1) of the Act. The decision of the Charity Commissioner under section (1) of section 36 is required to be published in a local newspaper having circulation in the area where the property concerned is situated, as per rule 24(4) of the Bombay Public Trusts (Gujarat) Rules, 1961. Rule 24(4) further provides that the decision of the Charity Commissioner is required to be published in a manner sufficient to give information about the material particulars regarding the number of the application for sanction, the name of the pubic trust, the description of the property for the alienation of which sanction is accorded and the price at which it is proposed to be sold or mortgaged or the rent at which and the period for which it is proposed to be leased and the substance of such decision. After the said decision is published, if any person is aggrieved by such decision, he is entitled to file an appeal to the Gujarat State Revenue Tribunal within 30 days from the date of its publication.

5. Admittedly, it is the say of the petitioner that at present none has filed any appeal against the decision of the Charity Commissioner.

6. In the light of the aforesaid facts, it is apparent that there was no reason for the appropriate authority to resort to the provisions of Chapter XX-C of the Income-tax Act. It would be difficult to arrive at a conclusion that there is significant undervalutaion of property to the extent of 15 per cent, or more in the agreement of sale as evidenced by the apparent consideration being lower than the fair market value by 15 per cent or more. Further, the property was sold after inviting offers from the public at large by giving advertisement in the newspaper and that too after property verification by the statutory authority under the Bombay Public Trusts Act. Even after executing the agreement to sell, objections are invited as provided under rule 24. Hence, in such types of cases, even if some lower amount is received, it would not mean that power to purchase the said property under section 269UD of the Income-tax can be exercised by the authorities under Chapter XX-C as it would be difficult to draw a presumption that there was an attempt to evade tax. This is made abundantly clear by the Supreme Court in the case of C.B. Gautam v. Union of India [1993] 199 ITR 530. The relevant observations of the Supreme Court are as under (at page 553) :

"As we have already pointed out, the provisions of Chapter XX-C can be resorted to only where there is a significant undervalutaion of property to the extent of 15 per cent. or more in the agreement of ale, as evidenced by the apparent consideration being lower than the fair market value by 15 per cent. or more. We have further pointed out that, although a presumption of an attempt to evade tax may be raised by the appropriate authority concerned in case of the aforesaid circumstances being established, such a presumption is rebuttable and this would necessarily imply that the concerned parties must have an opportunity to show cause as to why such a presumption should not be drawn., Moreover, in a given transaction of an agreement to sell, there might be several bona fide considerations which might induce a seller to sell his immovable property at less than what might be considered to be the fair market value. For example, he might be in immediate need of money and unable to wait till a buyer is found who is willing to pay the fair market value for the property. There might be some dispute as to the title to the immovable property as a result of which it might have to be sold at a price lower than the fair market value or a subsisting lease in favour of the intending purchaser. There might similarly be other genuine reasons which might have led the seller to agree to sell the property to a particular purchaser at less than the market value even in cases where the purchaser might not be his relative."

7. Applying the aforesaid ratio in the present case, it cannot be said that there was an attempt to evade tax. The appropriate authority has not come to the conclusion that there was a fraud at the time of public auction or that the amount offered by the petitioners was not genuine for some reasons. Apparently, it was a bona fide sale of the property after inviting offers from the public at large by giving an advertisement in the newspaper. The public trust is not required to wait till it finds a buyer who is willing to pay the price of the property which the appropriate authority thinks to be the market value. Hence, on this ground, the impugned order passed by the appropriate authority requires to be quashed and set aside.

8. Mr. Soparkar, the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner, vehemently submitted that the show-cause notice issued by the appropriate authority is absolutely vague and it has not mentioned the grounds or the sale instances on which it seeks to place reliance for exercising the power of pre-emptive purchase. He further submitted that, except the appropriate authority in the State in Gujarat, the appropriate authorities in other States are issuing exhaustive show-cause notices so that the affected persons can represent their cases properly.

9. In our view, considering the findings given above, it is not necessary to deal with the aforesaid contention exhaustively. However, it should be noted that issuance of a show-cause notice is not an empty formality. Its purpose is to given a reasonable opportunity to the affected persons to contend that the apparent consideration as per the agreement to sell is the market price or that there is no undervaluation because of peculiar facts. Therefore, before taking any action under section 269UD(1) of the Income-tax Act, the appropriate authority should give to the person likely to be affected by the order proposed to be made a notice of the action intended to be taken, inform him about the material on the basis of which the appropriate authority proposes to take action for pre-emptive purchase and give a fair and reasonable opportunity to such person to represent his case and to correct or controvert the material sought to be relied upon against him. Hence, in the show-cause notice under section 269UD of the Income-tax Act, provisional conclusions are required to be briefly specified. If a vague show-cause notice is given without specifying anything or the grounds for holding that the property is required to be purchased under section 269UD of the Income-tax Act, then it can be held that reasonable opportunity of showing cause against an order for pre-emptive purchase being made by the appropriate authority was not given, because the transferor and the transferee would be totally unaware of the grounds which had prompted the appropriate authority to arrive at prime facie conclusion that the power under section 269UD(1) of the Income-tax Act was required to be exercised and the property should be compulsorily purchased. Issuance of a show-cause notice is the preliminary step which is required to be undertaken before giving opportunity of hearing under section 269UD(1A) of the Income-tax Act.

10. While considering the contents of show-cause notice in a matter arising in connection with a disciplinary proceeding under the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1952, the Supreme Court has in the case of Shri B.D Gupta v. State Of Haryana ., AIR 1972 SC 2472 observed as under (at page 2474) :

"There is nothing, however, in the 'show-cause notice' of October 26, 1966, to indicate clearly that the dissatisfaction of Government with the appellant's reply of December 18, 1956, had nothing to do with charge 1(a). The 'show-cause notice' merely states in vague general terms that the appellant's reply to the charges and allegations was unsatisfactory. Even if we were to assume, though there is no reasonable ground for this assumption, that Government did not have in mind the contents of charge 1(a) while serving this 'show-cause notice', there is nothing in the 'show-cause notice' to give any indication that the particular allegations regarding which the appellant had failed to furnish a satisfactory explanation were referable only to charge 1(b). The notice is vague on other grounds as well. As one reads the first paragraph of the notice, the questions that at once assail one's mind are many : In what way was the explanation of the appellant unsatisfactory ? Which part of the appellant's explanation was so unsatisfactory ? On what materials did the Government think that the appellant's explanation was unsatisfactory ? It is to our mind essential for a 'show-cause notice' to indicate the precise scope of the notice and also to indicate the points on which the officer concerned is expected to give a reply."

11. The same would be the position here. It would be difficult for the transferor and the transferee to show cause as to why the property should not be compulsorily purchased or to point out that there is no undervaluation of the property or even if there is undervaluation, it is because of the peculiar facts regarding the property.

12. In the result, the petition is allowed. The impugned order dated February 23, 1993 (annexure "A"), passed by the appropriate authority is quashed and set aside. The appropriate authority is directed to issue "no objection" certificate under sub-section (1) of section 269UL of the Income-tax Act to the petitioner. Rule made absolute to the aforesaid extent with no order as to costs.

13. At the request of the learned advocate for the respondents, operations of this order is stayed up to August 1, 1994.