Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

National Insurance Co., Ltd. v. Smt. Nathibai Chaturbhuj And Others

Gujarat High Court
Feb 12, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These three appeals arise from awards made by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal in three cases connected to the same accident. The insurer challenged the awards. The matter was previously referred to a Full Bench on the question of the insurer's liability under statutory insurance provisions, resulting in the judgment in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Nathiben Chatrabhuj, [1984] 55 Comp Cas 568 (Guj) [FB]. The specific question referred was whether a passenger paying for carriage on a vehicle not covered by a permit to ply for hire or reward on the date of the insurance contract is entitled to the benefit of statutory insurance.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a passenger carried for hire or reward on an insured vehicle not covered by a permit to ply for hire or reward on the date of the insurance contract is entitled to the benefit of statutory insurance.
  2. Whether the insurer can disclaim liability under statutory insurance by proving that the vehicle was not permitted to carry passengers for hire or reward and that the policy contained a condition excluding such use, which was breached.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Nathiben Chatrabhuj, [1984] 55 Comp Cas 568 (Guj) [FB] Interpretation of statutory insurance liability under Motor Vehicles Act sections 95(1)(b)(i), 95(1)(b)(ii), 95(2), and disclaimer under section 96(2)(b)(i)(a). The Full Bench clarified that liability for death or bodily injury to a passenger carried for hire or reward is covered by statutory insurance unless the insurer successfully disclaims liability by proving the vehicle was not permitted for such use and the policy excluded it, and that such use occurred in breach of the policy condition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court relied on the Full Bench ruling which established the conditions under which an insurer may disclaim liability for passengers carried for hire or reward. The insurer must prove three elements: (1) the insured vehicle was not covered by a permit to carry passengers for hire or reward on the date of the insurance contract; (2) the insurance policy contained a condition excluding such use; and (3) the vehicle was used in breach of this condition on the occasion of the accident. In the present case, the insurer failed to produce or prove the relevant permit to demonstrate that the vehicle was not authorized to carry passengers for hire or reward. Without this proof, the insurer could not disclaim liability. Consequently, the insurer's contention to avoid liability was rejected, and no other defense was available.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the insurer remains liable under the statutory insurance for the claims arising out of the accident, as it failed to establish the necessary grounds to disclaim liability. No costs were ordered against the insurer. The opinion does not set any new precedent beyond reaffirming the Full Bench’s established principles.

Show all summary ...

Mehta, J.:— These three appeals by the insurer challenge the awards made by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal in three cases arising out of the same accident. The matter had gone to the Full Bench on the question of liability of the insurance company and that judgment is New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Nathiben Chatrabhuj, [1984] 55 Comp Cas 568 (Guj) [FB] and the question which was referred to the Full Bench was as under (at p. 570):

“Where the vehicle is on the date of the contract of insurance a vehicle not covered by a permit to ply for hire or reward, whether a passenger on payment will get the benefit of the statutory insurance?”

2. And the. Full Bench has answered the question as under (at p. 589):

“The liability in respect of the death of, or bodily injury to, a passenger carried for hire or reward on the insured vehicle when the accident giving rise to the claim occurred, including the liability in respect of the owner or hirer of the insured vehicle or his bona fide employees within the permissible limit, will be covered by the statutory insurance either by virtue of section 95(1)(b)(i) read with the second clause of the proviso or by reason of section 95(1)(b)(ii) of the Act. In such a case, the insurer will have to pay to the person entitled to the benefit of the award, the sum assured, which shall not be less than the sum specified in section 95(2), subject, however, to the right of the insurer to disclaim the liability, inter alia, under section 96(2)(b)(i)(a). The insurer, in order to successfully disclaim his liability on that ground, will have to establish:

1. that on the date of the contract of insurance, the insured vehicle was expressly or impliedly not covered by a permit to carry any passenger for hire or reward;

2. that there was a specified condition in the policy which excluded the use of the insured vehicle for the carriage of any passenger for hire or reward, and

3. that the vehicle was, in fact, used in breach of such specified condition on the occasion giving rise to the claim by reason of the carriage of the passenger therein for hire or reward.

If all these facts are established by the insurer, the benefit of statutory insurance will not be available in respect of such passenger.”

3. In the present case, the insurer has not got produced and proved the permit to show that the permit did not provide for carrying passengers for hire or reward.

4. In absence of the same, the insurer cannot avoid the liability and hence the contention in the present case must fail. There is no other defence available to the insurer in the present appeal and hence the appeals fail and are dismissed with no order as to costs.