- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sherasiya Saji Alavadi Momin And Others v. State Of Gujarat And Another
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The suit concerned the title to certain suit properties. Plaintiffs (appellants in the Second Appeal) alleged that the suit properties belonged to a public trust registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 and that the properties were entered in the Register of Public Trusts as belonging to that trust at the time the suit was filed. Defendants (including the State) contended that the properties were not trust property and that the lands had been resumed by the Government. The resumption order was passed in 1970 (confirmed in 1971) and the text indicates the lands may have been resumed earlier (possibly as early as 1958), before the trust was registered. At the time of admission of the Second Appeal, two substantial questions of law were formulated for decision: (1) whether the lower Appellate Court should have decided the question of title of the appellant trust to the suit property; and (2) whether, under S.56B of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, the questions in the suit could have been determined without issuing notice to the Charity Commissioner.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in view of the provisions of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, the lower Appellate Court should have decided the question of title of the appellant trust to the suit property against it?
- Whether, in view of the provisions of S.56B of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, the questions involved in the present suit could have been determined without issuing a notice to the Charity Commissioner?
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs / Appellants
- Plaintiffs filed the present suit asserting that the suit properties were owned by the registered public trust and that the properties were recorded in the Register of Public Trusts as belonging to the trust when the suit was filed.
- In the Second Appeal, plaintiffs raised for the first time a contention related to S.56B — that notice to the Charity Commissioner should have been issued before the courts determined questions in the suit.
Defendants / State
- Defendants asserted that the properties were not the property of the trust and that the Government had rightly resumed the lands.
- The State contended that the Charity Commissioner was a necessary party to the proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shri Adinath Tirthankar Jain Mandir v. Shantappa Dada Madnaik, AIR 1967 Bom 86 | Held that persons who are not parties to proceedings under S.19 of the Act can file a suit in Civil Court for partition and separate possession of properties gifted to a trust because the finding in the authority's proceeding will not be binding on them. | The opinion cites this Bombay High Court decision as showing an approach that entries in the Register may be challengeable by non-parties; the Court contrasts this view with later decisions of this Court. |
| Vithoba Balaji Ghodke v. Balkrishna Ganesh Bhalerao, AIR 1968 Bom 114 | Adopted a similar view to Adinath, while also holding that where such proceedings lead to grave irregularity the Charity Commissioner has power under S.70A to reopen previous proceedings under S.19. | Cited as another Bombay High Court view permitting challenge; the opinion notes that this decision was dissented from by a later decision of this Court (Charity Commr. Ahmedabad v. Maharajgiri Shadulgiri). |
| Ishwarlal Nanalal v. Chanchi Chimanlal R., (1963) ILR 4 Guj 767 | Held that decisions under the Public Trusts Act operate like a judgment in rem (by virtue of several provisions of the Act) and that the question whether a property is the property of a trust can only be decided by authorities under the Act; Civil Courts are not competent to decide such questions in view of S.80. | The Court relies on this decision to support the conclusion that Civil Courts lack jurisdiction to determine title to property said to belong to a public trust and that such matters fall to the authorities under the Act. |
| Charity Commr. Ahmedabad v. Maharajgiri Shadulgiri, (1972) 13 Guj LR 95-5 | Held that it was not necessary to issue public notice during inquiry proceedings under S.19; rights of interested persons are not prejudiced because suitable remedies exist under the Act; Deputy/Assistant Charity Commissioner may hold further inquiry under S.19 or S.22(3); dissented from the Bombay High Court decision mentioned above. | The opinion relies on this Court's decision to reject the view that entries made in the register after inquiry under S.19 are not binding on persons who were not parties; it supports the conclusion that entries in the Register are final and that interested persons have remedies under the Act rather than before Civil Courts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court addressed the two formulated questions in sequence.
On the second question (S.56B and notice to Charity Commissioner):
- The Court examined S.56B and observed that it requires a court to give notice to the Charity Commissioner only where "it appears to the Court that any question affecting a public religious or charitable purpose is involved."
- Here, the Court found that the question in the suit was whether the suit properties were the property of a public trust — a question of ownership — and that this did not amount to a question affecting a public religious or charitable purpose within the meaning of S.56B.
- The plaintiffs had not sought issuance of a notice at trial or on first appeal, and the State had contended that the Charity Commissioner was a necessary party; nevertheless, the Court concluded that S.56B did not require notice in the present circumstances and answered the second question in the negative.
On the first question (whether lower courts should have decided title of the trust):
- The Court referred to S.80 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, which bars Civil Courts from deciding questions that are by or under the Act to be decided by an officer or authority provided by the Act where that officer's decision is final and conclusive.
- The opinion noted relevant duties conferred by the Act (reference to Clause (b) of S.68) indicating that it is the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner who can decide whether any property is the property of a public trust.
- Given these statutory provisions, the Court held that Civil Courts are barred from entering into and deciding the question whether particular property is the property of a public trust; this was the principal question in the suit and the appeal before the District Court.
- The Court observed that although resumption orders and historical facts (resumption in 1958; order in 1970 and confirmation in 1971) were on the record, the critical point for jurisdiction was the status of the properties as entered in the Register at the time of the suit. S.21 makes entries in the Register final and conclusive subject to the Act, and therefore such entries cannot be questioned in Civil Court proceedings.
- The opinion acknowledged conflicting Bombay High Court authorities that allowed non-parties to challenge register entries, but contrasted those with the decisions of this Court (including Ishwarlal and Charity Commissioner Ahmedabad v. Maharajgiri Shadulgiri) which treat entries and decisions under the Act as binding and akin to judgments in rem and which provide statutory remedies (e.g., further inquiry under S.19 or S.22 and powers under S.70A) rather than resort to Civil Courts.
- Concluding from these provisions and precedents, the Court held that the trial Court and the District Court erred in deciding the title question: that question was one for the authorities under the Act and was barred from Civil Court determination by S.80 and related provisions.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal was DISMISSED (the opinion concludes: "Appeal dismissed.").
Implications:
- The direct effect on the parties is that the Civil Courts (trial court and first appellate court) erred in adjudicating the question of title to the suit lands as against the trust; that issue cannot be gone into in these Civil Court proceedings because jurisdiction to determine such questions is vested in the authorities under the Bombay Public Trusts Act (notably the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner) and S.21 makes entries in the Register final and conclusive for the purposes indicated in the Act.
- The Court held that notice under S.56B was not required in the circumstances of this suit because the dispute was about ownership of property by a trust and not a question affecting a public religious or charitable purpose within the meaning of S.56B; plaintiffs had also not sought such notice earlier in the proceedings.
- The opinion does not purport to set out a new wider precedent beyond applying the statute and existing authorities to the facts at hand. The practical consequence is that parties challenging entries or decisions under the Act must pursue the remedies provided within the Act (approach the Charity Commissioner or Deputy Charity Commissioner, seek further inquiry under the Act, or rely on powers such as S.70A), rather than seeking to litigate title in Civil Courts.
Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.
1. to 4. xxxxxx
5. At the time of admission of this Second Appeal, the following two questions have been formulated as substantial questions of law involved in this appeal: -
1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in view of the provisions of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, the lower Appellate Court should have decided the question of title of the appellant trust to the suit property against it?
2. Whether, in view of the provisions of S. 56B of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, the questions involved in the present suit could have been determined without issuing a notice to the Charity Commissioner?
6. Now, so far as the second question as regards issuance of notice to the Charity Commissioner is concerned, a mere look at S. 56B will show that there is no substance in this contention raised by the plaintiffs for the first time in this Second Appeal. S. 56B provides that in any suit or legal proceedings in which it appears to the Court that any question affecting a public religious or charitable purpose is involved, the Court shall not proceed to determine such question until after notice has been given to the Charity Commissioner. The question involved in this suit is whether the suit properties are of the ownership of the public trust. No question affecting a public religious or charitable purpose is involved in this suit and hence it is difficult to accept the contention raised for the first time in this Second Appeal that the suit could not have been proceeded further without issuing notice to the Charity Commissioner. It may be mentioned here that the plaintiffs who filed the present suit did not make any request to the trial Court or to the first appellate Court that notice may be issued to the Charity Commissioner. In fact, the State contended that the Charity Commissioner was a necessary party and even then the plaintiffs did not make any request that at least a notice 10 may be issued to the Charity Commissioner as, per S. 56B of the Act. But any way it is clear, reading S. 56B of the Act that the second question which is formulated in this appeal should be answered in negative,
7. So far as the first question formulated by this, Court is concerned, that question does not appear to have been raised or decided by the Courts below. This, however, being a pure question of law can be considered and decided in light of the provisions of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950. Before going to the discussion of this question it will be proper to refer to some of the relevant provisions of the Act which have a bearing upon the question of jurisdiction. S. 80 of the Act reads as follows : --
Save as expressly provided in this Act, no Civil Court shall have jurisdiction to decide or deal with any question which is by or under this Act to be decided or dealt with by any officer or authority under this Actor in respect of which the decision or order of such officer or authority has been made final and conclusive.
Clause (b) of S. 68 of the Act, which is relevant for our purpose, reads as follows:
"For the purposes of this Act, the following shall be the duties and functions to be performed and powers to be exercised by the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner for the region or sub-region for which he is appointed, namely-
8. The above provisions of the Act clearly show that it is only the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner who can decide whether any property is the property of a public trust. They also go to show that the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to entertain that question is barred. In view of this, it is clear that the Civil Court cannot enter into and decide the question whether a particular property is the property of a public trust or not. That was the main question raised in the present suit and the appeal before the District Court. It is clear that neither the trial Court nor the first appellate court could have decided the question of title because on one hand, it is the allegation of the plaintiffs that the suit properties are of the ownership of the public trust which is again duly registered under the Act, while, on the other hand, it is the say of the defendants that the properties were not of the ownership of the trust and that they have been rightly resumed by the Government. It is true that the order of resumption was passed in the year 1970 and confirmed in the year 1971 by the Special Secretary to the Government. It even appears that the suit lands were resumed long back before July 1970 sometime in the year 1958. In any way, it is clear that the resumption order was passed before the trust was registered and before the suit properties were entered in the Register of Public Trust as properties belonging to the trust. But the fact remains that when the suit was filed the properties were shown in the register or public trusts as belonging to this trust and the question of title was raised in the suit as well as in the first appeal. We are not concerned while deciding the question of jurisdiction whether the lands were rightly resumed by the Government. The question is about the ownership of the lands on the date of the suit and that can be decided only by the authorities competent to decide that question as per the provisions of the Act which I have reproduced a little earlier. The trial Court as well as the District Court, on the face of it, clearly erred in deciding the question of title to the suit lands. Hence this substantial question of law formulated in this appeal has to be decided accordingly.
9. The next question which arises for consideration is as to what will be the effect of this on this question in this appeal. Now, so far as the question of title is concerned, it cannot be gone into in these proceedings because of the bar of S. 80 of the Act. The properties having been entered in the Register of the Public Trusts as belonging to the trust. S. 21 of the Act comes into play, which reads as follows: -
"(1) The Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner shall make entries in register kept under S. 17 in accordance with the findings recorded by him under S. 20 or if appeals or applications are made as provided by this Act, in accordance with the final decision of the competent authority provided by this Act.
(2) The entries so made shall, subject to the provisions of this Act and subject to any change recorded under the following provisions, be final and conclusive."
In view of the fact that the entries in the Register are final-and conclusive, one has to proceed on the assumption that the properties are of the public trust. The said entries in the register cannot be questioned in these proceedings before the Civil Court. It is true that neither the State Government nor defendant had any opportunity of having their say when the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner made inquiry and reached the conclusion that the suit properties were of the ownership of the public trust. But when S. 21 says that these entries are final and conclusive, they cannot be questioned in a Civil Court. There are two decisions of the Bombay High Court which go to show that persons who are not parties to such proceedings before the authorities under the Act can challenge the entries in the Register because they are not binding to them. The first is reported in Shri Adinath Tirthankar Jain Mandir v. Shantappa Dada Madnaik, AIR 1967 Bom 86, while the other is reported in Vithoba Balaji Ghodke v. Balkrishna Ganesh Bhalerao, AIR 1968 Bom 114. In the first decision, it has been held that persons who are not parties to proceedings under S. 19 of the Act can file a suit in Civil Court for partition and separate possession of properties which are gifted and in respect of which trust is created, because the finding will not be binding to them and, therefore, the suit will not be barred under S. 80 of the Act. So far as the second decision is concerned, same view has been taken relying upon an earlier decision of the same High Court but it has also been held in that case that since such a proceeding leads to miscarriage of justice and grave irregularity, the Charity Commissioner has powers under S. 70A to reopen the previous proceedings and make inquiries under S. 19 of the Act. As against these two decisions of the Bombay High Court, we have a decision o C this Court reported in Ishwarlal Nanalal v. Chanchi Chimanlal R., (1963) ILR 4 Guj 767, wherein it is held that the decisions given under the Public Trusts Act have the effect of a judgment in rem by virtue of several provisions of the said Act. In that case also it is held that the question whether a particular property is the property of a trust or not can only be decided by the authorities under the Act and that the Civil Court is not competent to decide any such question in view of the provisions of S. 80 of the Act.
10. In the case of the Charity Commr. Ahmedabad v. Maharajgiri Shadulgiri, (1972) 13 Guj LR 95-5, a question arose whether notices are required to be issued to public during the inquiry proceedings under S. 19 of the Act. This Court held in the above case that it was not necessary to issue any such notice to the public. It is held therein that the rights of persons having interest are not prejudiced as suitable remedy is provided by other provisions of the Act. It is held the-rein that even after an inquiry under S. 19 has concluded and entries are made in the register under S. 21 or S. 22, it is open to the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner to hold a further inquiry if, it appears to him that any particular relating to any public trust which was not the subject matter of the inquiry under S. 19 or sub-section (3) of S. 22, has remained to be inquired into. It is held therein that the rights of the persons having interest are in any way prejudiced by holding inquiries under S. 19 and other relevant sections of the Act, without issuing any public notice. The decision of the Bombay High Court in Vithoba Balaji Ghodke v. Balkrishna (supra) was dissented from in the above case decided by this Court. In view of the two decisions of this Court, it is not possible to take the view that the entries made in the register of public trusts after inquiry under S. 19 are not binding to the defendants, because they were not parties to these proceedings. They have a remedy to approach the Charity Commissioner or Deputy Charity, Commissioner or any other competent officer under the Act to hold further inquiry into the matter and decide whether these properties, in fact, belonged to the public trust or not. x x x x
11. xxxxxxx
12. Appeal dismissed.
Alert