Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Amit Kumar Jain v. State Of Nagaland .

Gauhati High Court
Feb 15, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused-petitioner was prosecuted in GR Case No. 465/2004 (Dimapur East P.S. Case No. 161/04) under Sections 420, 464, 467 and 468 IPC for alleged fraudulent withdrawal of public deposits by forging signatures. On 25.10.2004 the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner (Judicial), Dimapur, granted interim bail subject to conditions that included (inter alia) deposit of Rs. 25 lakh in cash towards recovery of public money and an undertaking to deposit the remainder by 25.11.2004, attendance on investigation, furnishing a surety of Rs. 25 lakh with original patta, restriction on leaving Dimapur and execution of a bail bond for Rs. 25 lakh.

The 25.10.2004 order was challenged in Criminal Revision No. 670/04 on the ground that some conditions were harsh and untenable. This Court (on 17.11.2004 as referenced in the record) set aside the two conditions requiring the deposit of Rs. 25 lakh in cash and the undertaking to deposit the rest, but reaffirmed the remaining conditions. The accused-petitioner, unable to procure a local surety or one for the sum of Rs. 25 lakh, petitioned the learned Court below to modify the remaining conditions. The learned Court below considered modification requests and, by orders dated 7.1.2005 and 8.1.2005, refused to accept the accused's offered security valued at Rs. 4,45,388 (patta outside jurisdiction) and insisted on a local surety and the original higher amount. The accused then filed the present revision challenging those two orders (7.1.2005 and 8.1.2005).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conditions imposed by the learned Court below — specifically the insistence on a bail bond and surety amounting to Rs. 25 lakh — are excessive or onerous such that they amount to a denial of bail.
  2. Whether the learned Court below could lawfully insist that the surety be a local resident (i.e., from within the Court's jurisdiction), effectively preventing a non-local accused from procuring bail.
  3. What the appropriate quantum of bail bond and surety should be, having regard to Section 440 Cr.P.C. and the circumstances of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Accused-Petitioner's Arguments

  • The accused could not arrange the Rs. 25 lakh surety insisted upon and could only offer a surety valued at Rs. 4,45,388 (a patta for land and a building situated outside Dimapur jurisdiction).
  • The insistence on a local surety (from the State of Nagaland / Dimapur) is impracticable because the accused is not from Nagaland and therefore cannot obtain such a local surety; this requirement is, in effect, a denial of bail.
  • According to the accused, the conditions as imposed should be modified to permit release on more realistic bail terms.

State / Learned Court Below's Arguments (as reflected in orders)

  • The Public Prosecutor submitted that the re-affirmed bail terms required a surety amounting to Rs. 25,00,000 and that the offered security of Rs. 4,45,388 was inadequate compared to the alleged amount involved.
  • The learned Court below emphasized the seriousness of the case, citing that the accused had allegedly defrauded depositors and the public of an amount exceeding Rs. 50,00,000, and found it inappropriate in the interest of justice to release the accused on the offered lower security.
  • The learned Court below also observed that the offered security was situated outside the Court's jurisdiction and therefore was not acceptable; accordingly it rejected the petition to reconsider the conditions set in the earlier bail order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Keshab Narayan Banerjee v. The State of Bihar The principle that bail conditions must not be so onerous as to virtually amount to a denial of bail; amount of bail must be reasonable in the circumstances. The Court relied on this authority to hold that insisting on a Rs. 25 lakh surety was so onerous as to amount to refusal of bail and thus reduced the quantum of bail/security in the present matter.
Moti Ram and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh The principle that courts may not insist on a surety from a particular local area and that geographical or linguistic discrimination in insisting on local sureties is impermissible. The Court invoked this decision to conclude that the learned Court below's insistence on a local surety was not necessary and should not be required in the present case.
Sandeep Jain v. National Capital Territory of Delhi rep. By Secretary, Home Department (referenced) The opinion references this case alongside Moti Ram as a related authority; the opinion does not elaborate the principle from this case beyond associating it with the point on local sureties/geography. The Court cited it as a related example alongside Moti Ram; the opinion does not state further particulars of its application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first noting the statutory guidance in Section 440 Cr.P.C., which requires that the amount of every bail bond be fixed with due regard to the circumstances of the case and not be excessive. The Court interpreted this statutory provision as reflecting legislative intent that the bond amount be determined in light of the accused's means, and the nature and gravity of the offence, but that it must not be excessive or onerous.

Applying the jurisprudence cited, the Court recalled Keshab Narayan Banerjee's principle that bail conditions so onerous as to practically deny bail are impermissible; the Court summarized that the conditions imposed by the learned Court below — an insistence on Rs. 25 lakh bail/surety — were of such a character that they effectively amounted to refusal of bail.

The Court also considered Moti Ram (and an associated reference to Sandeep Jain) which condemned the practice of insisting on sureties from a particular local district and observed that requiring local sureties can produce geographic and linguistic discrimination contrary to equality principles. On that basis, the Court concluded that insisting on a local surety in the present case would operate as a practical denial of liberty for a non-local accused.

Balancing the statutory requirement (Section 440 Cr.P.C.), the precedents and the facts (allegations under Sections 420, 464, 467 and 468 IPC and the amounts involved as recorded in the lower court's rationale), the Court found the learned Court below's insistence on a Rs. 25 lakh local surety to be excessive and tantamount to denial of bail. Consequently, the Court exercised its supervisory jurisdiction to reduce the bail and to remove the local-surety requirement.

The Court's analysis limited itself to the question of bail conditions and did not adjudicate on guilt, civil recovery or merits of the underlying allegations.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court directed that the accused-petitioner be released on furnishing a bail bond of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) with a surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Court below. It was expressly stated that the surety need not be from the local area. With these modifications, the impugned orders dated 7.1.2005 and 8.1.2005 were altered and the revision was disposed of.

Implications:

  • Immediate effect on the parties: The accused-petitioner is to be released on bail upon compliance with the revised bond and surety requirements (bond Rs. 50,000 with a surety of Rs. 50,000), and is no longer required to produce a local surety.
  • Scope as precedent: The opinion applied established principles (Section 440 Cr.P.C., Keshab Narayan Banerjee, Moti Ram) to the facts at hand. The Court did not purport to lay down any novel general rule beyond applying those principles to reduce what it found to be an excessive bail condition and to remove the local-surety requirement in this case. The opinion does not state that it sets a new precedent beyond these applications.

This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion and does not include information beyond that contained therein.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard Mr. S. P. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the accused-petitioner, and Mrs. Aungla Aier, learned Junior Govt. Advocate, Nagaland.

2. This revision is directed against the orders, dated 7.1.2005 and 8.1.2005, passed by learned Additional Deputy Commissioner (Judicial) Dimapur, Nagaland, in GR Case No. 465/2004 (corresponding to Dimpaur East P. S. Case No. 161/04) under Sections 420/464/467/468 IPC.

3. Before coming to the directions contained in the orders impugned in the present revision, it is necessary to set out, in brief, hereinbelow, the various stages, which have led to the passing of the impugned orders aforementioned :-

(i) An order was passed, on 25.10.2004, by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner (Judicial) Dimapur, Nagaland, in G.R. 465/04, aforementioned granting bail in favour of the accused-petitioner subject to the following conditions:

(1) To deposit a sum of Rs. 25 lakh in cash towards recovery of public money misused by him.

(2) Undertaking to deposit the rest of the public money collected by him by 25.11.2004.

(3) Accused to attend I/O on summon to help complete the investigation.

(4) Furnish a surety as bailor for Rs. 25 lakh who shall deposit original patta in support of existence of the landed property.

(5) Accused shall not leave Dimapur without the permission of this Court during pendency of this case.

(6) Any fresh evidence if brought by the I/O the interim bail shall automatically stands cancelled.

(7) Execute a bail bond for Rs. 25 lakh. Bail till 25.11.2004 granted.

(ii) The above order was challenged in Criminal Revision No. 670/04 on the ground that the conditions aforementioned imposed on the accused-petitioner, white granting interim bail by the order, dated 25.10.2004, were harsh and untenable in law.

(iii) Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties and upon perusal of the materials on record, this Court observed and directed, in GR Case No. 465/2004 aforementioned, as follows :

"The accused-petitioner abovenamed is alleged to have fraudulently withdrawn the money from the Dimapur Post Office by forging the signatures of the depositors. In a situation, such as the present one, all the conditions imposed by the impugned order, dated 25.10.2004, aforementioned cannot be said to be unreasonable and/or untenable in law. However, as regards the condition Nos. 1 and 2, namely, (1) that the accused-petitioner above-named shall deposit a sum of Rs. 25 lakh, in cash, towards recovery of public money misused by him and that (2) he shall give an undertaking that he shall deposit the rest of the public money collected by him by 25.11.2004, it is reluctantly conceded even by the learned Govt. Advocate that the conditions No. 1 and 2 could not have been imposed, while granting interim bail, for, imposing of such conditions for granting of bail will be tantamount to holding, without trial, the accused-petitioner guilty of the offences allegedly committed by him.

Considering, therefore, the matter in its entirety, the condition Nos. 1 and 2 aforementioned contained in the impugned order, dated 25.10.2004, are hereby set aside, but rest of the conditions imposed while granting interim bail are hereby maintained.

With the above modification in the impugned order, dated 25.10.2004, aforementioned, this revision shall stand disposed of."

(iv) Unable to offer any surety from the local area and also on failing to find a surety, who could offer the surety amount of as much as Rs. 25 lakh, a petition was moved, on behalf of the accused-petitioner in the learned Court below, to modify the conditions aforementioned. On this petition, the learned Court below passed the order, dated 7.1.2005, aforementioned. The relevant portion of the order, dated 7.1.2005, is quoted hereinbelow :

"The learned counsel for the accused-petitioner submits that

(a) the condition Nos. 1 and 2 of this Court's order dated 25.10.04 was set aside by the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court's order dated 17.11.2004 and re-affirmed the other conditions set therein.

(b) that the accused is unable even to fulfil the other conditions of the bail order dated 25.10.2004 and the accused remained in the judicial custody till date.

As such it is prayed to relax the order dated 25.10.2004 of this Court and thereby enabling the accused to furnish a patta for a plot of land lying at Didyapara Pt.I, Dhubri Circle Assam which is valued at Rs. 2,45,388 with one Assam Type Building standing therein which is valued at Rs. 2,00,000/- (total value Rs. 4,45,388/-).

The learned Public Prosecutor for the State submits that the re-affirmed term of the bail order dated 25.10.2004 is that the accused has to furnish a surety amounting to Rs. 25,00,000. The surety offered to be furnished is amounting to Rs. 4,45,388.

The accused has fraudulently drawn public deposit from the post office and public from the market, which amounts to more than Rs. 50,00,000.

As such it may not be in the interest of justice to release the accused at this stage."

(v) When the accused-petitioner, once again, moved a petition praying for modifying the conditions aforementioned, the learned Court below, after hearing the learned counsel for both the sides, observed and directed, by its order, dated 8.1.2005, aforementioned as follows:

"I do not find any efforts being made by accused petitioner to refund the public money he had collected by unfair means.

The fact that the case is serious involving large number of depositors, it is needless to mention that adequate surety from a permanent resident of Dimapur having immovable property and capacity to secure presence of accused before the I/O and later face trial has to be furnished.

The offered security, which is situated outside the jurisdiction of this Court is not acceptable giving the facts of the case at hand.

Accordingly the petition is rejected to the extent that the conditions set up by this Courts order dated 25.10.2004 and reaffirmed by order dated 17.11.2004 of the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court cannot be reconsidered."

4. In the present revision, the grievance of the accused-petitioner is that since the amount of surety as much as Rs. 25 lakh could not be arranged by the accused-petitioner and he could only offer a surety, which valued at Rs. 4,45,388 lakh, the learned Court below refused to reduce the amount of surety to be offered by the accused-petitioner for his release on bail and, in consequence thereof, the accused-petitioner could not be released on bail. It is also submitted by the accused-petitioner that since he is not from Nagaland, he is unable to offer any local surety from, the State of Nagaland and, hence, in such a situation, the insistence by the learned Court below that the surety to be offered must be a local one is as good as denying the accused-petitioner the liberty of bail. The amount of bail, so insisted upon, is, according to the accused-petitioner, impossible to be arranged by the accused-petitioner and, hence, the conditions, so imposed, need to be modified.

5. While considering the present revision, it needs to be noted that a criminal proceeding is not a substitute for a civil proceeding, for, these two proceedings are totally different from, and independent of, each other. Hence, if a person is alleged to have dishonestly misappropriated an amount of Rs. 1 lakh and has thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 406 IPC, it will be impermissible under the law to insist that the accused shall execute bail bond of Rs. 1 lakh and offer surety of such an amount. The learned Court below, as the orders passed hereinabove indicate, has made an attempt to realize the money, allegedly misappropriated by the accused-petitioner, by way of insisting on an amount of Rs. 25 lakh as the value of bail bond and of the surety.

6. While dealing with this revision, it is also of immense importance to note that Section 440 Cr.P.C. provides that the amount of every bail bond to be executed shall be fixed with due regard to the circumstances of the case and shall not be excessive. Thus, it is clear that the legislative intent is that the amount of bond should be fixed with due regard to means of the accused, the nature and gravity of the offence, but the amount, asked for, shall not be excessive and/or onerous.

7. In Keshab Narayan Banerjee v. The State of Bihar, , while considering correctness of the order whereby the Court had directed that the accused shall furnish security of rupees one lakh in cash or in fixed deposit in any Nationalised Bank, in Bihar, with two sureties residing in the State of Bihar, each for a like amount, it was held by the Apex Court, thus : "... in the circumstances of this case, it virtually amounts to denial of bail itself." The Apex Court, therefore, reduced the amount of bail to Rs. 25,000 (Rupees twenty five thousand) with two sureties each for the like amount.

8. In short, the conditions imposed for granting of bail cannot be so onerous that it virtually amounts to denial of the bail itself. This is the principle underlying the decision of Keshah Narayan Banerjee (supra).

9. It is also important to note that in Moti Ram and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh wherein the trial Court had insisted on producing a surety from a particular local area, the Apex Court observed and held as follows :

"To add insult to injury, the magistrate has demanded sureties from his own district (we assume the allegation in the petition). What is a Malayalees, Kannadiga, Tamil or Telegu to do if arrested for alleged misappropriation or theft or criminal trespass in Bastar, Port Blair, Pahalgam or Chandni Chowk? He cannot have sureties owning properties in these distant places. He may not know any one there and might have come in a batch or to seek a job or in a morcha. Judicial disruption of Indian unity is surest achieved by such provincial allergies. What law prescribes sureties from outside or non-regional language applications? What law prescribes the geographical discrimination implicit in asking for sureties from the Court district? This tendency takes many forms, sometimes, geographic, sometimes linguistic sometimes legalistic. Article 14 protects all Indians qua Indians, within the territory of India. Article 350 sanctions representation to any authority, including a Court, for redress of grievances in any language used in the Union of India. Equally before the law implies that even a vakalat or affirmation made in any State language according to the law in that State must be accepted everywhere in the territory of India save where a valid legislation to the contrary exists. Otherwise, an adivasi will be unfree in Free India and likewise many other minorities. This divagation has become necessary to still the judicial beginnings, and to inhibit the process of making Indians aliens in their own homeland. Swaraj is made of united stuff."
(see also - Sandeep Jain, appellant v. National Capital Territory of Delhi rep. By Secretary, Home Department, respondent).

10. Thus, in an appropriate case, as the decision in Moti Ram and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh (supra) lays down, Court may not even insist on local surety.

11. In the case at hand, the offences allegedly committed by the accused-petitioner are under Sections 420, 464, 467 and 468 IPC. In the present case, the insistence by the learned Court below that the accused shall offer the surety of an amount of Rs. 25 lakh is so onerous that it virtually amounts to refusal to allow the accused to go on bail. Similarly, the insistence of the learned Court below that the surety has to be from the local areas is as good as denying the accused-petitioner the liberty of bail.

12. Considering, therefore, the matter in its entirety and in the interest of justice, it is hereby directed that the accused-petitioner be released on his furnishing bail bond of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) with a surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Court below. It is, however, made clear that the surety need not be from the local area.

13. With the above modifications in the impugned orders, dated 7.1.2005 and 8.1.2005, aforementioned and the directions contained hereinabove, this revision shall stand disposed of.