- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kamala Kanta Oza & Ors. v. State Of Assam & Ors
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Two Civil Rules (writ petitions) challenged the allotment of "ceiling surplus" land by the State to private respondents and sought quashing of those allotments with a direction restraining construction on the allotted land. The petitions were heard together because they raised similar questions of law on almost identical facts.
In CR No. 2568/92 the petitioners claimed ownership of the land purchased by a Sale Deed dated 12.11.1984 from proforma Respondent No. 10, Sri Bhabadeb Sarma. A Ceiling Case (ULC 343/76) had been initiated in 1976. A notification under section 10(1) of the Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1976 was issued on 16.5.1984 and published in the Assam Gazette on 27 June 1984 inviting claims. A final notification under section 10(3) declaring the land excess and acquired was issued on 1.1.1987 and published on 11 February 1987. The petitioners allege that private respondents began filling the land in early November 1992 and that by an impugned order dated 8.5.1992 the Deputy Secretary allowed areas of the petitioners' land to the private respondents.
In CR No. 459/93 an Association-petitioner challenged similar allotments, alleging that although the Association had repeatedly requested Government land to promote cultural activities, the land was allotted to private respondents who were government officials or relatives of officials.
The private respondents filed affidavits contesting the petitions. The State Respondents did not file a return, but relevant records (including the notifications) were placed before the Court. The Court heard counsel for petitioners, private respondents, and the Advocate General.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioners have locus standi / maintainability to challenge allotments of land that the State had already acquired under the Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1976.
- Whether a Sale Deed executed on 12.11.1984 (in favour of the petitioners) is valid where a notification under section 10(1) was published on 27 June 1984 and a final acquisition notification under section 10(3) was published on 11 February 1987.
- Whether allotments made under the State's Land Policy (1989) — which was not itself challenged in these petitions — can be attacked by the petitioners without specifically challenging the policy or the ceiling proceeding.
- Whether the writ petitions should be entertained in the exercise of the Court's discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226, given the procedural posture and the preliminary objections.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- In CR No. 2568/92 the petitioners asserted ownership based on a Sale Deed dated 12.11.1984 and that they were in possession of the land.
- They alleged that private respondents began filling the land in November 1992 and that an impugned order dated 8.5.1992 allocated parts of their land to private respondents; the petitioners claimed difficulty obtaining the copy of that order due to pressure from influential private respondents.
- In CR No. 459/93 the Association petitioners asserted that the land was required for cultural activities and that despite repeated requests, the Government allotted the land to private respondents who were government officials or their relatives.
Private Respondents' Arguments
- Raised a preliminary objection that the petitioners lacked locus standi because the lands had been lawfully acquired by the Government under the Act and subsequently allotted to private respondents as landless persons under Sections 23 and 24 of the Act.
- Argued that the Government had framed a Land Policy (1989) and the allotments were made within the competence of that policy; the validity of the Land Policy had not been challenged.
State Respondents / Advocate General
- The Advocate General (Mr. A.K. Phukan) stated that the Land Policy of 1989 was framed within the competence of the Government and was in conformity with the Act, and that all allotments of Government land in Assam were made in accordance with that policy.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined pleadings and the records placed before it. Key points of the Court's analysis are:
- The Ceiling Case (ULC 343/76) against the original owner (proforma Respondent No. 10) pre-dated the Sale Deed: the ceiling proceeding began in 1976.
- A notification under section 10(1) of the Act, proposing acquisition of the land, was issued on 16.5.1984 and published in the Assam Gazette on 27 June 1984. The Sale Deed in favour of the petitioners was executed on 12.11.1984, i.e., after the proposal notification but before the final acquisition notification.
- A final notification under section 10(3) declaring the land as excess vacant land and deeming it acquired by the State was issued on 1.1.1987 and published on 11 February 1987.
- The Court concluded that the Sale Deed dated 12.11.1984, executed in the period between the proposed acquisition notification and the final acquisition notification, was manifestly void and contrary to law. Nothing on record showed that the original pattadar had objected or claimed pursuant to the 16.5.1984 notification.
- Because of the above, the land was held to have vested in the Government by operation of law, and therefore the petitioners in CR No. 2568/92 had no subsisting claims to that land.
- The Court noted that the allotments had been made pursuant to the State's Land Policy (which had not been challenged) and that the ceiling proceeding itself had not been challenged in these writ petitions; the petitioners challenged only the settlement order dated 8.5.1992 (and had not annexed that order). Given these circumstances, the Court found no judicially enforceable right of the petitioners infringed by the allotments.
- The Court emphasized the discretionary nature of its power under Article 226 and the need to exercise that discretion within recognized lines and self-imposed limitations; it concluded that the circumstances did not call for exercise of writ jurisdiction in this matter and therefore was disinclined to entertain the petitions on merits.
- Because the Court disposed of the matter on the preliminary issue of maintainability (lack of subsisting proprietary rights and the effect of prior acquisition notifications and unchallenged Land Policy), it did not address the merits of the petitioners' substantive contentions.
- Regarding CR No. 459/93, the Court observed that it is within the Government's domain to allot land as per the Land Policy and suggested the Association may approach the competent authority for consideration of allotment if so advised.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
BOTH WRIT PETITIONS ARE DISMISSED.
Implications and consequences:
- Direct effect on the parties: The petitioners' claims were held not to subsist because the land was deemed acquired by the State by operation of law; the petitions were dismissed on the ground of maintainability and lack of a judicially enforceable right to challenge the allotments.
- The Court declined to adjudicate the substantive merits because it disposed of the cases on preliminary grounds (acquisition notifications, nullity of the Sale Deed executed after the proposal notification, and the fact that the Land Policy was unchallenged).
- The Court recorded that the Association/petitioners in CR No. 459/93 may seek allotment through the competent administrative authority if so advised — indicating an administrative remedy avenue rather than judicial interference in the allotment process under the current facts.
- No order as to costs was made by the Court.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; it is a decision applying the existing statutory framework (the Act and the administrative Land Policy) to the facts before the Court.
This summary is strictly limited to information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or legal authorities not present in that text.
1. In both these Civil Rules the respective Writ Petitioners mainly challenged the allotment of ceiling surplus land by the State-Respondents in favour of private respondents arrayed in these writ petitions seeking a direction from this Court for quashing of those allotments with a further direction restraining the private respondents from making any construction over the so allotted land in question. Since the question of law based on almost identical facts involved in these writ petitioners are similar, I propose to hear these writ petitions analogously and dispose of the same by this common order.
2. Heard Mr. P.C Deka, learned sr. counsel, Mr. M.K Choudhury and Mr. N. Dutta, the learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. A.S Bhattacharyya, Mr. G.N Sahewalla, Mr. C. Choudhury, Mr. J. Roy and Mr. K. Paul, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the private Respondents. Also heard Mr. A.C Buragohain, learned Addl. Sr. Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the State Respondents. I have also heard Mr. A.K Phukan, learned Advocate General who has been requested to assist the Court in proper interpretation of the Land Policy of the Government.
3. The Facts in CR No. 2568/92 in brief, are that the petitioners are the owners of the land in question which they purchased in the year 1984 from the proforma Respondent No. 10, Sri Bhaba Deb Sarma. A new patta being K.P Patta No. 594 was issued in favour of their vendor Sri Bhaba Deb Sarma for a period from 1.4.1986 to 31.3.2001 (Annexure-2 to the writ petition). While the land has been possessed and occupied by the petitioners it was found that in the early part of November, 1992 the private respondents started fill up the land. On enquiry and on being asked, the petitioners were surprised to learn that by impugned order dated 8.5.1992 the Deputy Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, Revenue Department, Dispur in connection with ULC 343/76 under Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 (herein-after referred to as ‘the Act’) allowed different areas of the petitioners' land to the private respondents. It is contended that they tried to obtain the copy of the order dated 8.5.1992 but due to the pressure of the private respondents, who are influential persons exercising the official powers, the petitioners could not obtain the copies of the respective orders for which those were not annexed to this writ petition.
4. In other writ petition, i.e, CR No. 459/93 the writ petitioners being an Association has also challenged such allotments of the acquired land to the private respondents on the ground that notwithstanding their repeated requests to the Government for allotment of land which has been needed acutely in order to promote cultural and creative activities of the Association, ignoring their prayer, the Government land in question has been allotted to the private respondents who are none but certain Government Officials as well as close relatives of Official mandarin.
5. The private respondents contested both the Civil Rules filing their respective affidavits. Thought no return has been filed by the State Respondents, some relevant records have been placed before this Court at the time of hearing of the case.
6. Raising the preliminary objection as regards the maintainability of the writ petitions it is pleaded on behalf of the respondents that the petitioners have no locus standi to challenge the allotments of the lands which have already been duly acquired by the Government under the Act and it is only after acquisition, the same has been duly allotted to the private respondents being the landless persons in accordance with the provisions of Sections 23 and 24 of the Act. It is also stated that the Government of Assam has framed a Land Policy, i.e, Land Policy of 1989 which is in vogue and within the competence of the said Land Policy, the present allotments have made. Moreso, the validity of the present Land Policy has not been questioned. It is contended that without having challenged the said Land Policy, the present petitioners have no legal right to challenge the allotment of the said land to the private respondents and accordingly no reliefs as prayed for, be granted to them.
7. Mr. A.K Phukan, the learned Advocate General has sated that the said Land Policy has been framed within the competence of the Government and the same is in conformity with the Act. All the allotments of the Government land whatsoever in the State of Assam have done in accordance with the said Land Policy being presently in force.
8. I have carefully perused the pleadings of the parties in both the writ petitions and the materials available on records and also have given my anxious consideration to the submissions on behalf of the rival parties.
9. It appears from the records made available in CR No. 2568/92 that the petitioners purchased the land by execution of Sale Deed dated 12.11.1984 but Ceiling Case being No. ULC 343/76 has been commenced long back in the year 1976. Notification under section 10(1) of the Act regarding proposed acquisition of land in question belonging to Sri Bhabadeb Sarma, the original owner of the petitioners, proforma respondent No. 10, and thereby inviting the claims from all the interested persons in the said land, was issued on 16.5.1984 which was published in the Assam Gazette on 27th June, 1984. The said Notification is quoted hereunder:—
“…. Assam Gazette, 27th June, 1984
The 16th May, 1984
Whereas the Land specified in the Schedule below belonging to Sri Bhabadev Sarma, resident of Assam Government Press, Bamunimaidan has been determined as the vacant land in excess of the ceiling limit prescribed under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 and that the said land is to be acquired by the State Government under the provisions of the said Act.
All persons interested in such land may make their claims personally or by their agents giving particulars of the nature of their interest in such land within 39 days from the date of publication of the notification in the Gazette.
SCHEDULES
S.N Mouza Village Patta No. Dag No. Area Sq.M 1. Ulubari Ulubari 493 1008 7706.88 town 1011 - New town 665 498 274.60 Sarani Total 7981.48 Sq. Mtrs
10. Thereafter, the final Notification declaring the land in question belonging to the proforma respondent No. 10 as excess vacant land and acquiring the same by the Government U/S 10(3) of the Act was issued on 1.1.1987 and the same was published in Assam Gazette published on 11th February, 1987 is also quoted hereunder:—
‘The Assam Gazette 11th February, 1987
The 1st January, 1987
Ref:— U.L.C Case No. 343/76
Whereas the land specified in the Schedule below belonging to Shri Bhabadeb Sarma, Assam Government Press Road, Guwahati, has been declared as excess vacant land and the said land shall be deemed to have been acquired by the State Government U/S 10(3) of the Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1976 with effect from the date of publication of this notification.
SCHEDULE
S.N Mouza Village Patta No. Dag No. Area Sq.M 1. Ulubari Ulubari 493 1008 7706.88 town 1011 2. - New town 685 498 274.60 Total 7981.48 Sq. Mtrs
11. Be it noted that in the aforesaid Notification dated 1.1.1987 the Land Ceiling Case being ULC 343/76 had been referred. After going through the Notifications above mentioned, it becomes abundantly clear that during the period between the proposed acquisition and the final acquisition of the land in question, the Sale Deed dated 12.11.1984 was executed in favour of the writ petitioners in CR No. 2568/92 which was manifestly void and contrary to the law More importantly nothing has come on record that the original pattadar proforma respondent No. 10 has ever made any objection or claim pursuant to the Notification dated 16.5.1984 Therefore, the land in dispute has been legally vested upon the Government by operation of law and the claims of the writ petitioners in C.R No. 2568/92 cannot subsist.
12. It is seen that the land in question had been allotted to the private respondents as per Land Policy which has not been challenged before this Court. It also appears that the Ceiling proceeding has also not-been challenged in this writ petitions; so much so the writ petitioners have challenged in the present petition the order of settlement dated 8.5.1992 only, that too without annexing the same.’ Situated thus, I am of the considered view that since the land in question has already been duly acquired by the Government under the provisions of the Act and in conformity without (sic) existing Land Policy of the Government, the writ petitioner have no judicially enforceable right to challenge the impugned allotments of that surplus Ceiling Land in favour of the private respondents. By such allotments no substantive rights of the petitioners have ever been infringed. Further unless it is a public interest litigation, the Court is not needed to decide an issue which has not been specifically raised in the pleadings inasmuch as in the instant case, the Land Policy as such has, as already noticed, not been specifically challenged but only the individual actions have been agitated. Be it noted that though it is settled that the powers of the High Court under Article 226 are discretionary and no limits can be placed upon that discretion, it must be exercised along recognised lines and subject to certain self-imposed limitations as a matter of prudence and policy. The gamut of entire situation does not call for exercise of such discretionary power under writ jurisdiction of this Court and consequently, I am disinclined to entertain these writ petitions. Since the matter has been decided taking on the preliminary issue of maintainability, the contentions on merit advanced on behalf of the petitioners, need not detain this Court any further.
13. As regards the prayer of the writ petitioner in C.R No. 459/93, it is the wisdom and domain of the Government to allot Government land as per the Land Policy above referred and accordingly the Association/Writ petitioners may approach the competent authority to consider their case for allotment of land, if so advised.
14. For the reason, discussion and observations indicated above, both the writ petitioner stands dismissed. However I pass no order as to costs.
Alert