- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Zukheli Sema v. Union Of India And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (H.K. Sema, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition is a habeas corpus filed by the wife of Shri Viyikhu Sema, aged about 70, alleging that he went missing from the custody of the 4th respondent (Commanding Officer, 5/3 Gorkha Rifles, Rangapahar Army Cantonment, Dimapur, Nagaland) on 11.4.1994. The petitioner says that on 11.4.1994 a contingent of 5/3 Gorkha Rifles led by Major Kartar Singh Sirohi searched Viyikhu Sema's house at about 7 AM, arrested him at gunpoint, and took him to the Army Cantonment, after which he could not be traced. The wife also reported the matter to the Officer-in-charge, Police Station (West) Dimapur on 16.4.1994. A written note from the Head Gaonbura of Zutovi village dated 22.4.1994 corroborated that Army personnel had arrested Viyikhu Sema on 11.4.1994 and that he could not be traced despite searches.
Respondent No. 4 filed two counters: the first (6.6.1994) denied that Viyikhu Sema was arrested or in Army custody; the second (15.6.1994) stated that the detenue accompanied the petrol party voluntarily to Rangapahar, that incriminating documents had been found during a casual search, and (according to the Army) the old man was requested to come to the post the next day but asked to accompany the party that day and after lunch left for town.
After hearing counsel, this Court on 11.6.1996 directed a CBI investigation into the mysterious disappearance and asked the CBI to report within six months. The Superintendent of Police, CBI submitted a report on 12.1.1998 concluding that no prima facie case was established against the 4th respondent for the disappearance. The court reviewed the CBI report and the record, found the investigation and some of the CBI conclusions unacceptable, and proceeded to make findings, issue directions (including compensation), and dispose of the petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Shri Viyikhu Sema was arrested by personnel of the 4th respondent (5/3 Gorkha Rifles) on 11.4.1994 and taken into Army custody.
- Whether, if the detenue was last seen in the custody of the 4th respondent, the 4th respondent has discharged the burden of proof to account for his whereabouts after that date.
- Whether there was an infringement of the detenue's fundamental rights (including life and personal liberty under Article 21) and, if so, whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation.
- Whether the CBI investigation into the disappearance was fair, impartial and adequate, and what further steps (if any) should be directed of the investigating agency.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Wife of the Detainee) Allegations and Supporting Statements
- The petitioner alleged that her husband, Shri Viyikhu Sema, was placed under arrest at gunpoint by personnel of 5/3 Gorkha Rifles on 11.4.1994 and taken away to Rangapahar Army Cantonment and subsequently could not be traced.
- The petitioner reported the matter to the local police and produced a letter from the Head Gaonbura of Zutovi village dated 22.4.1994 stating that Viyikhu Sema had been arrested by Jawans of the 4th respondent on 11.4.1994 and could not be traced despite vigorous search.
- Village headman, village secretary and other village elders gave statements to the Investigating Officer that they saw the detenue being picked up from his house by Army personnel at gunpoint.
Respondent No. 4 (4th Respondent / Army) — Counters and Version
- In the first counter (6.6.1994) the 4th respondent denied arresting the person named Shri Viyikhu or that he was in the custody of 5/3 Gorkha Rifles.
- In the subsequent counter (15.6.1994) the 4th respondent stated that incriminating documents were found in a casual search, that in view of the detenue's old age he was requested to visit the post the next day (12.4.1994), but he asked to accompany the petrol party to town on 11.4.1994 and was allowed to do so; after lunch at the camp he left for town on the same day.
Investigating Agency (CBI) — Findings as Reported
- The CBI report recorded both versions: Army personnel said the detenue accompanied the Army voluntarily and was not intended to be taken into custody; some villagers, Gaonbura and village secretary stated the detenue was picked up at gunpoint.
- The CBI examined recovered documents and local witnesses and recorded a conclusion that the villagers who claimed a forcible abduction could not be entirely believed and that there was an understanding that the detenue might have gone underground as a close relative of an NSCN activist; the CBI concluded no prima facie case was established against the 4th respondent for mysterious disappearance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar and Another ((1983) 4 SCC 141 : AIR 1983 SC 1086) | Monetary compensation is an appropriate remedy for violation of life and liberty under Article 21; compensation deters administrative sclerosis and repairs damage done by State instrumentalities. | The Court relied on Rudul Sah to justify awarding monetary compensation for unlawful deprivation/infringement of fundamental rights in the habeas corpus context. |
| Smt. Nilabati Behera alias Lalita Behera v. State of Orissa and Others ((1993) 2 SCC 746 : AIR 1993 SC 1960) | Claims for compensation in public law are available for contravention of constitutional rights (Article 32/226); sovereign immunity does not bar such claims. | The Court invoked this precedent to reinforce that a constitutional remedy for violation of fundamental rights can include monetary compensation against the State and its servants. |
| D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal ((1997) 1 SCC 416) | The Supreme Court and High Courts can grant compensation under public law for breach of fundamental rights in addition to private law remedies. | The Court cited D.K. Basu to support its power to award compensation and to hold the State vicariously liable for acts of its instrumentalities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the record, the parties' pleadings, and the CBI report and proceeded through a fact-based legal analysis:
- Evaluation of factual assertions: The Court noted conflicting accounts—villagers and village elders said the detenue was picked up at gunpoint; the 4th respondent and some Army personnel maintained he accompanied the petrol party voluntarily and left after lunch on 11.4.1994.
- Assessment of the CBI report: The Court observed that the Investigating Officer in the CBI report had "brushed aside" eyewitness statements from the Headman, village Secretary and other elders without adequate reasons. The Court found that the CBI's acceptance of the Army version and its suggestion that the detenue might have gone underground were not adequately supported by evidence.
- Credibility and logic: The Court found it implausible that a man aged about 70 would "go underground" to lead a hard life, and found it equally improbable that Army personnel in an operational insurgency-affected area would invite a civilian into their vehicle and release him without custody formalities after finding incriminating materials. This reasoning led the Court to reject the CBI's subterranean theory and the Army's voluntary-accompaniment explanation.
- Burden of proof: Because the detenue was last seen in the camp of the 4th respondent on 11.4.1994 (as admitted by Army personnel in the record), the Court held that the burden of proof lay squarely on the 4th respondent to account for his whereabouts after that date.
- Statutory requirement: The Court invoked Section 5 of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958, which requires that any person arrested and taken into custody under the Act be handed over to the nearest police station "with the least possible delay" together with a report of the circumstances. The Court found no evidence of such handing over or any custody certificate, undermining the Army's version of release on 11.4.1994.
- Conclusion from combined facts and law: Weighing these considerations, the Court concluded that the CBI investigation was inadequate in important respects and that the Army had not discharged its evidentiary burden to show lawful release. Therefore the Court held that the detenue was arrested by personnel of the 4th respondent on 11.4.1994 at gunpoint and was taken to the camp; his subsequent disappearance from Army custody could not be accounted for by the respondents.
- Remedy reasoning: Applying the Supreme Court precedents relating to compensation for violation of fundamental rights (Rudul Sah, Nilabati Behera, D.K. Basu), and the established principle that the State is vicariously liable for acts of its instrumentalities, the Court determined that the petitioner should be awarded monetary compensation as a remedial measure.
Holding and Implications
Holding: This habeas corpus petition is disposed with a finding that Shri Viyikhu Sema was arrested by personnel of the 4th respondent on 11.4.1994 at gunpoint, was taken to the Army camp, and his subsequent disappearance from the custody of the 4th respondent remains unaccounted for by the respondents. The Court awarded compensation and directed further steps as below.
Direct orders and immediate consequences for parties:
- The respondents are directed to pay Rs. 2,00,000 (Rupees two lakhs) as compensation to the petitioner (described as "in the nature of palliative").
- The Union of India (Respondent No. 1) is vicariously liable and was ordered to deposit the compensation amount of Rs. 2,00,000 before the Registry within three months from the date of receipt of the order. On deposit, the Registry was to pay the compensation to the petitioner after proper identification.
- The Court recorded displeasure with the CBI investigation as conducted by the Superintendent of Police, CBI, SPE, SCB, Calcutta, describing it as one-sided, and directed that this Judgment and the CBI Report be sent to the Director of CBI, New Delhi.
- The CBI was further directed to make additional efforts to trace out the missing person Shri Viyikhu Sema.
Broader implications and precedent-setting:
The Court applied established Supreme Court authority permitting awarding of monetary compensation for violation of fundamental rights. The decision enforces the principle that the State (Union of India) can be held vicariously liable for actions of its instrumentalities and that compensation is a recognized constitutional remedy where rights under Article 21 are violated. The judgment does not purport to create novel law but applies and follows the cited Supreme Court precedents to the facts of the case.
Other Observations Recorded by the Court
- The Court emphasized that agencies like the CBI are expected to investigate matters entrusted to them in a fair and impartial manner in order to build public confidence, and in this instance the Court found the investigation wanting.
- The Court specifically ordered procedural follow-ups (communication to the Director CBI and further tracing efforts) rather than closing the matter upon awarding compensation.
With these observations and directions, the habeas corpus petition was disposed.
H.K Sema, J.:— This habeas corpus petition relates to the missing of one Shri Viyikhu Sema, aged about 70 years from the custody of the 4th respondent, Commanding Officer 5/3 Gorkha JRifles, Rangapahar Army Cantonment, Dimapur Nagaland, C/o: 99 A.P.O on 11.4.1994 It is alleged that on 11.4.1994, the Contingent of 5/3 Gorkha Rifles under the leadership of one Major Kartar Singh Sirohi conducted search in and around the house of Viyikhu Sema at about 7 AM and he has been placed under arrest at gun point and taken away to the Army Cantonment at Rangapahar, and since then the husband of the petitioner was not traceable. This petition was espoused by his wife. Petitioner also reproted the matter to the Officer-in-charge of Police Station (West) Dimapur on 16th April, 1994, without any result.
2. An application dated 22.4.1994 addressed to the Addl. Deputy Commissioner, Dimapur by the Head Gaonbura of Zutovi village stating that Viyikhu Sema has been arrested by the Jawans of the 4th respondent led by one Major after searching his house thoroughly on 11.4.1994 at about 7 AM, and since then, he Could not be traced despite of vigorous search. Hence the present petition praying, inter alia, to produce the detenue before this Court.
3. After showing cause, respondent No. 4 filed two counters. One counter was filed on 6.6.1994 and the respondent No. 4 in paragraph 6 of the counter denied that person named Shri Viyikhu was arrested by 5/3 Gorkha Rifles nor the said individual is in the custody of 5/3 Gorkha Rifles. Subsequently, another counter was field on 15.6.94, and it is stated in paragraph 4 of the counter that the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema accompanied the petrol party to Rangapahar. The respondent, however, denied that the detenue has been arrested at gun point nor was he directed to accompany petrol party to the post at Rangapahar. It is further averred in paragraph 4 of the counter that, during the casual search of the detenue's house, some incriminating documents were recovered from the house of the detenue, but in view of his old age, he was requested to come to the post the next day, i.e, on 12.4.1994, however, as requested by the detenue, he was allowed to accompany the petrol party to the post that day itself, i.e, 11.4.1994, and after reaching the post, the petrol leader did not ask him any question, instead with due respect offered him lunch and after lunch the old man proceeded for his work to town on the same day, i.e, 11.4.1994
4. After hearing the counsel of both sides, this Court on 11.6.1996 directed a thorough probe by CBI in terms' of the following order in paragraph 6 of the judgment:—
“After hearing counsel of both sides, and after perusal of the documents on record, one thing is cleared in our minds that Shri Viyikhu Sema, as admitted by the 4th respondent was seen last With the 4th respondent on 11.4.94 Thereafter, the missing of Shri Viyikhu Sema in a mysterious circumstances calls for a thorough probe by an agency like CBI”
5. The CBI was directed to submit its report within 6 (six) months from the date of the receipt of the order.
6. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, Superintendent of Police CBI, SPE, SCB, Cal. submitted its report on 12.1.98 after completing the investigation holding that, no prima facie case is established against the 4th respondent for mysterious disappearance of the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema.
7. The findings of the CBI with regard to the arrest and release of Viyikhu Sema has been recorded in paragraphs 6 and 7 of its Report. Paragraph 6 of the Report is reproduced below:—
“6. It was learnt from the Army personnel that on 11.04.94, four Army personnel led by Major Sirohi of 5/3 G.R alongwith Gaon Bura and village Secretary of Zutovi and Pimla visited Viyikhu Sema's house (who was brother of S.S Captain Sikuto Sema). Major Sirohi talked to Viyikhu Sema and made a casual search of his house where he found certain documents/photograph, etc. Viyikhu Sema allegedly had expressed ignorence about the details of those documents. Seeing his age (around 70 years) and condition Mr. Sirohi did not intend to take him in custody, though he was having suspicion that Viyikhu Sema was a hard core NSCN supporter/sympathiser if not an active member. However, he requested Viyikhu Sema to visit Rangapahar Reserve Forest post next day, that is, on 12.4.94 Thereafter, Viyikhu Sema approached Sri Sirohi and expressed his desire to come along with them by getting a lift since he also had some work in town, for which Major Sirohi agreed and Mr. Sema accompanied the Army personnel. But on other hand, it was learnt from the statement from the Gaon Bura, Village Secretary and some other villagers that Viyikhu Sema was picked up from his house by the said Army personnel on gun-point. In order to come to a logical conclusion on this point we scrutinised the documents which were recovered from Viyikhu Sema's house by Army personnel and examined the local persons. Those documents indicate that there is a good league between the NSCN group and the villagers of Zutovi village and the village itself is insurgent affected with sympathisers of NSCN. It is the understanding of some witnesses that Viyikhu Sema after being discovered as a close relative of NSCN activist might have gone underground and his wife might have filed a petition in order to have monetary benefit, etc., on the instigation of the NSCN. Considering this fact it can be stated that though there are some persons who are speaking as eye witnesses of this incident stating that Viyikhu Sema was picked up by Army personnel on gun-point, they can not be believed in entirely as being true and unprejudiced. During CBI investigation no furthr evidence has come up to prove this version of forceful abduction by the Army.” (emphasis supplied)
8. A reading of the aforesaid paragraph would reveal that Investigating Officer totally brushed aside the statements of Gaonbura, village Secretary and other elders of the village that the detenue Viyikhu Sema was picked up from his house by the Army personnel at gun-point on 11.4.94 without assigning any reason and without any justification. In a situation surcharged, with the insurgency activist obtaining in this part of the country, it would be highly unbelievable that the detenue who was the brother of S.S Captain Sikuto Sema in the Insurgency organisatoin having found so many incriminating materials in his house, the petrol leader would pat the detenue on his back and would friendly ask him to come to the post the next day on 12.4.94 It is also highly unbelievable that the Army in operational area would gladly agree to carry the detenu in their vehicle on his own request. Because of the security reasons Army personnel in operational area never allow the civilians to travel in their vehicle unless they are arrested/apprehended for interrogration.
9. The Headman of the village, village Secretary and other villagers had stated before the Investigating Officer what they have seen. The 4th respondent also stated that they were accompanied by the Gaonbura and other village elders at the time of conducting search in the house of the detenue. The statement of the Headman and other village elders that they have seen the detenue being arrested at gun-point is a statement of facts, and therefore, such statements cannot be easily brushed aside without assigning any compelling reasons. So also the finding of the Investigating Officer that the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema might have gone underground have no basis and cannot be accepted. It is unimaginable that a man aged about 70 years would venture underground to lead a hard and difficult life. At the same time, if the detenu was treated with sympathy and friendly as claimed by the 4th Respondent, there is no reason ostensible or otherwise for the detenue to have chosen to go underground and lead a hard life at this advancing age. Therefore, the findings of the Investigating Officer recorded in paragraph 6 of its Report that the detenue Viyikhu Sema being a close relative of NSCN activist might have gone underground are perversed and cannot be accepted.
10. From the facts and circumstances as discussed above, we hold that detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema was arrested by the personnel of the 4th respondent on 11.4.94 at gun-point and took him to their camp in their own vehicle. The statement that the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema accompanied the petrol party voluntarily cannot be accepted.
11. Regarding the release and whereabout of the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema has been recorded in paragraphs of its Report by the Investigating Officer. Para 7 of the Report is reproduced below:—
“7. During investigation we visited the Rangapahar Reserve Forest Army Camp, Dimapur, Nagaland and took photographs of that place. It was found that the said Army Camp is located in a no man area and as such we did not get any independent witness to verify this point. However, attempts were made to verify if by examining the Army personnel (specially Jawan level) of 5/3 G.R but they could not throw any light on it. It was only learnt from their statements thaton 11.4.94 at about 1.30 p.m Viyikhu Sema came to their camp alongwith Major Sirohi of “B” Coy., 5/3 G.R where he took lunch. The statement of Langarkhana in-charge of said Army camp also corroborate this version. The Company Havildar Major and Subedar L.B Ale are the persons who last saw Shri Viyikhu Sema at their camp. They were examined and they stated that after taking lunch Viyikhu Sema left the Army camp for Dimapur town. They also stated the route/direction of Shri Sema, i.e, the way he had gone to Dimapur. In course of investigation, we also visited the entire route and asked the local people by showing Shri Sema's picture as to whether they had seen that person during the relevant period or not, but no such positive information could be gathered from their side. So no evidence came forth to establish that Viyikhu Sema was kept in a jungle by his captors.” (emphasis supplied)
12. From the Report as reproduced above, it would clearly appear that the Army personnel of the 4th respondent admitted that the detenue was last seen at their camp on 11.4.94 Although the personnel of the 4th respondent had stated that the detenue had left their camp on 11.4.94 after lunch, nobody had seen the detenue thereafter. Also there is no evidence to show that the detenue has been released on 11.4.94 If that is so, the personnel of the 4th respondent are squarely responsible with regard to the mysterious disappearance of the detenue Viyikhu Sema. The detenue as already said was last seen in the camp of the 4th respondent on 11.4.94, and therefore, the burden of proof lies on the 4th respondent as to whereabout of the detenue after 11.4.94
13. Also from the Report of the Investigating Officer in paragraph 19 of its Report clearly shows that the detenue was interrogated at the Army camp of the 4th respondent. The relevant portion of the Report is reproduced below:
‘The Army personnel admitted that Viyikhu Sema voluntarily came to their Army Post on 11.4.94 and stated that Viyikhu left the Army Gamp in his own on the same day. This point could not be confirmed in course of investigation as the Army camp is situated in a no-man's area and therefore we could not get any other witness except Army personnel who saw Viyikhu Sema leaving the said camp. However, considering the old age of the victim and his willingness to accompany the Army personnel to their Camp suggests that the Army personnel could not have caused him any harm and they had no reason to do so. No evidence regarding his confinement in Army camp, his torture or his death in army custody could be collected during the investigation. No trace of Viyikhu Sema's whereabouts also, could be found in spite of the best efforts. It is most likely that Viyikhu Sema was asked to come to the Army camp and after some interrogation he was let off and thereafter he has gone underground, being the close ‘relative of a wanted NSCN leader.” (emphasis supplied)
14. There is yet another reason as to why the statement of the 4th respondent that the detenue was released on 11.4.94 and left the camp on that day cannot be accepted. Section 5 of the Armed Force (Special Powers) Act, 1958, Reads:—
“Any person arrested and taken into custody under this Act shall be made over to the Officer-in-charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay, together with a report of the circumstances occasioning the arrest”
15. Having seized so many incriminating materials connecting the detenue with the insurgency, the Army authority would not have let off the detenue without interrogation and without a report lodged before the Officer-in-charge of the nearest Police station. When Army authority handed over the arrested person to the Officer-in-charge of the nearest police station, there is always a certificate effecting handing over and taking over of the arrested person. We, therefore, hold that there is no evidence before us that the detenue Shri Viyikhu Sema has left the Army camp on 11.4.94 or released on 11.4.94 as stated by the 4th respondent.
16. Now remains to be seen is as to what relief the petitioner is entitled to. Missing of precious and valuable life from the custody of the 4th respondent is definitely an act of infringement of fundamental rights. Although precious life cannot be measured in terms of rupees, in the light of various Judgments of the Apex Court which we shall be referring hereinafter, the petitioner is at least entitled adequate compensation at this stage.
17. In Rudul Sah, petitioner v. State of Bihar and Another, respondents, (1983) 4 SCC 141 : AIR 1983 SC 1086, there the petitioner was acquitted by the Court of Session Muzaffarpur Bihar on June 3rd, 1968 in criminal trial, but he was released from jail only on October 16, 1982 after more than 14 years after he was acquitted. He has filed habeas corpus petition asking his release on the ground that his detention in the jail is unlawful. He also prayed for compensation for the illegal incarceration. While disposing of the petition, the Apex Court pointed out as under:—
“Article 21 which guarantees the right to life and liberty will be denuded of its significant content if the powers of the Supreme Court were limited to passing orders of release from illegal detention. One of the telling ways in which the violation of that right can reasonably be prevented and due compliance with the mandate of Article 21 secured, is to milch its violaters in the payment of monetary compensation. Administrative sclerosis leading to flagrant infringements of fundamental rights cannot be corrected by any other method open to the judiciary to adopt. The right to compensation is some palliative for the unlawful acts of instrumentalities which act in the name of public interest and which present for their protection the powers of the State as a shield. Respect for the rights of individuals is the true bastion of democracy. Therefore, the State must repair the damage done by its officer to the petitioner's rights. It may have recourse against those officers.”
18. In Smt. Nilabati Behera alias Lalita Behera, petitioner v. State of Orissa and Others, respondents, (1993) 2 SCC 746 : AIR 1993 SC 1960, there the petitioner's son aged about 22 years died in police custody, and the petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution, inter alia, claiming the compensation on the death of the petitioner's son. It was pointed out by the Apex_ Court as under:—
“A claim in public law for compensation for contravention of human rights and fundamental freedoms, the protection of which is guaranteed in the Constitution is an acknowledged remedy for enforcement and protection of such rights, and such a claim based on strict liability made by resorting to a constitutional remedy provided for the enforcement of a fundamental right is distinct from, and in addition to, the remedy in private law for damages for the tort resulting from the contravention of the fundamental right. The defence of sovereign immunity being inapplicable, and alien to the concept of guarantee of fundamental rights, there can be no question of such a defence being available in the constitutional remedy. It is this principle which justifies award of monetary compensation for contravention of fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution, when that is the only practicable mode of redress available for the contravention made by the State or its servants in the purported exercise of their powers, and enforcement of the fundamental right is claimed by resort to the remedy in public law under the Constitution by recourse to Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution.”
19. In D.K Basu, petitioner v. State of West Bengal, respondent, (1997) 1 SCC 416, it has been held by the Apex Court that compensation can be granted under the public law by the Supreme Court and the High Courts in addition to private law remedy for tortious action and punishment to wrong doers under criminal law for established breach of fundamental rights.
20. In the facts and circumstances as stated above, and in view of the law laid down by the Apex Court, we would think that the petitioner is entitled adequate compensation. Accordingly, we direct the respondents to pay a sum of Rs. 2,00,000 (Rupees two lakhs) as compensation to the petitioner in the nature of pelliative. The Union of India (Respondent No. 1) is vicariously liable for any acts or commission of its instrumentalities even if they acted beyond their authority. Union of India shall deposit the compensation amount of Rs. 2,00,000 (Rupees two lakhs) before this Registry within a period of three months from the date of receipt of this order. On being deposited, this Registry shall pay the compensation amount to the petitioner after proper identification.
21. Before parting with the record, we record our displeasure the manner in which the present investigation has been conducted by the Superintendent of Police, CBI, SPE, SCB, Cal. Agency like CBI, being primary investigation agency, it is expected to investigate into any matter entrusted to them in a fair and impartial manner so as to build public confidence in the agency. In the instant case, we are of the view that the investigation is completely one sided.
22. Registry shall send a copy of this Judgment along with the Report submitted by the Superintendent of Police, CBI, SPE, SCB, Cal. to the Director of CBI, New Delhi. We further direct the CBI to make further effort to trace out the missing person Shri Viyikhu Sema.
With the aforestated observations and directions, this habeas corpus petition is disposed.
Alert