- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Baldeo Raj Bhatia v. Superintendent Of Central Excise
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was initially convicted by the Additional District Magistrate, Manipur, under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act, 1924 and under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947, and sentenced to imprisonment (three months and six months respectively). On appeal the Sessions Judge set aside the conviction and sentence under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act but maintained the conviction and sentence under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act. The petitioner filed the present revision.
On 26-10-1957 the petitioner, a passenger bound for Calcutta from Imphal, was detected at Koirengei Airport attempting to take a suitcase on board without registration or Customs check. Customs Inspector N.C. Banerji found 405 Parker 51 pencils (imported from England) in the suitcase. The petitioner initially refused to open the case but later did so and admitted ownership; he could not produce satisfactory documentary evidence of bona fide purchase or licit importation. The goods required permits and were liable to duty (stated to be over Rs. 4,000), and the suitcase was seized.
The petitioner received a show cause notice under relevant sections of the Land Customs Act and the Sea Customs Act (as made applicable). He replied that he had purchased the goods from a hillman for resale and claimed ignorance of any offence, but he did not attend the Collector's hearing. The Collector imposed a departmental penalty of Rs. 1,000/- on 3-6-1958 under Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act (applied to land customs). Later, a letter of authority was issued to the Superintendent of Central Excise and Land Customs to institute criminal proceedings under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act. A complaint was filed on 21-6-1960 (2 years 8 months after the seizure) under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act and Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act read with Section 9 of the Land Customs Act.
The Additional District Magistrate convicted the petitioner under both provisions. The Sessions Judge acquitted under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports Act on technical grounds (insufficient authorisation to prosecute) but confirmed the conviction under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act. The present opinion addresses the petitioner's revision against that confirmation and the sentence imposed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act, the complaint for criminal prosecution must be filed only by the Land Customs officer who actually seized the goods and must be filed immediately upon seizure (i.e., whether the officer must decide at the time of seizure whether departmental penalty under Section 7(1) is adequate or a criminal complaint should be made).
- Whether a criminal prosecution under Sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Land Customs Act remains available after Sections 167(8) and 187-A of the Sea Customs Act have been made applicable to the Land Customs Act (by amendment of Section 9), or whether prosecutions must in all cases proceed only under the Sea Customs provisions.
- Whether the complaint filed by the Superintendent of Central Excise and Land Customs was competent, given alleged requirements (for prosecutions under Sea Customs provisions) that complaints must be filed by a Collector or an officer not lower than an Assistant Collector authorised by the Chief Customs Officer.
- Whether the long delay (2 years and 8 months) in filing the criminal complaint after seizure and after departmental action should mitigate the criminal sentence or otherwise render the prosecution or punishment unjust.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Under Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act the Land Customs Officer who seized the goods must immediately determine whether the penalty under Section 7(1) is adequate; if he decides it is inadequate he must file a complaint before proceeding under Section 7(1). The complaint in this case was filed much later (2 years 8 months after seizure and 2 years after the departmental penalty), rendering it invalid.
- After amendment of Section 9 (making Sea Customs provisions applicable), the penal provisions in Sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Land Customs Act should be treated as no longer in force; prosecutions should proceed under Section 167(8) (and associated Sea Customs provisions) only, which have different procedural requirements (e.g., who may file complaint).
- For prosecution under Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act a complaint must be filed by the Collector or an officer of customs not lower than an Assistant Collector authorised by the Chief Customs Officer; the Superintendent who filed the complaint thus lacked authority and the Court should not have taken cognisance.
- There was a serious and unexplained delay in instituting the criminal prosecution, and neither lower court considered this delay when imposing imprisonment; imprisonment was therefore unnecessarily severe in the circumstances.
Government's Arguments / Respondent
- The State emphasised that Manipur is a border State where attempts to convey dutiable goods clandestinely are common, and that deterrent punishment is necessary to prevent such offences.
- The Government suggested the delay in filing the complaint arose from the need to obtain necessary authority to proceed under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947.
- It was also asserted (implicit in the prosecution) that the officer who filed the complaint had sufficient authority to prosecute under the relevant provisions.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court addressed the petitioner's contentions in a structured statutory-interpretation analysis, relying on the text and interplay of the relevant statutory provisions as set out in the record.
-
Who may file a complaint under Section 7(2):
- The court rejected the argument that only the exact Land Customs officer who detained the goods may file the complaint. It observed Section 5(3) of the Land Customs Act permits “any Land Customs officer duly empowered by the Chief Customs authority” to require production of permits and detain goods, and Section 3(1) authorises appointment of various Land Customs Officers (including Superintendents). Thus a Superintendent is a Land Customs Officer and may make a complaint under Section 7(2).
- The court also noted nothing in Section 7(2) requires the same officer who detained the goods to be the one to decide and file; superior officers may act on the seizing officer's report and decide whether to file a complaint.
-
Whether criminal prosecution must precede departmental action:
- The court found no language in Sections 7(1) and 7(2) indicating that criminal prosecution must precede departmental penalty under Section 7(1). It observed in the present case the departmental penalty and confiscation were in fact imposed under Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act (made applicable to land customs by Section 9), not under Section 7(1) specifically.
- Where a statute allows both departmental and criminal proceedings and does not specify which must come first, both actions can be taken independently. The affected party cannot insist that one action be taken earlier than the other.
-
Effect of making Sea Customs provisions applicable (Sections 167(8) and 187-A):
- The court rejected the contention that Sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Land Customs Act ceased to exist upon making Sections 167(8) and 187-A of the Sea Customs Act applicable. If repeal had been intended, the Land Customs sections would have been expressly repealed.
- The court compared the scope of Section 7(2) with Section 167(8): the Sea Customs provision is broader and more serious. The proper inference is that Land Customs authorities may proceed under Section 7(2) where appropriate (punishment up to six months' imprisonment), and may pursue the broader Sea Customs provisions (with heavier penalties) where warranted. Both paths remain available depending on the gravity of the offence.
-
Relationship between departmental penalty/confiscation and subsequent criminal proceedings:
- The court relied on Section 186 of the Sea Customs Act (made applicable to land customs) which provides that imposing confiscation, penalty or increased duty by a customs officer does not prevent infliction of any punishment under any other law. This supported the conclusion that criminal action can be taken in addition to departmental action and need not precede it.
-
Competence of the prosecution and delay:
- The Sessions Judge had acquitted the petitioner under the Imports and Exports Act on a technical ground that the authorisation (letter Ext. A/2) to prosecute was insufficient. The present court did not disturb that conclusion but considered the consequences of the delay in filing the criminal complaint (2 years 8 months after the seizure and more than 2 years after departmental action concluded).
- The court emphasised that an accused person is entitled to have the authorities decide promptly whether to pursue criminal prosecution; long unexplained delay undermines the deterrent purpose of prosecution and is relevant in sentencing.
- The court found the delay in this case to be inexcusable: the departmental action concluded on 3-6-1958 and the complaint was filed only on 21-6-1960. Even the Government's stated reason (to obtain authorisation to proceed under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports Act) did not justify such a long delay, particularly since the eventual authorisation proved invalid.
-
On guilt:
- The court accepted the findings of the lower courts on guilt. It noted the petitioner attempted clandestinely to carry dutiable goods without permit or payment of duty by placing them with postal mail for the plane; the defendant's plea of ignorance was rejected by the lower courts and not challenged before the revising court.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The conviction of the petitioner under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act is upheld, but the sentence of imprisonment is modified: the imprisonment originally imposed is set aside and substituted with a fine of Rs. 500/-, with default imprisonment for 3 months if the fine is not paid.
Immediate consequences for the parties:
- The petitioner remains convicted under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act.
- The earlier imprisonment sentence is replaced by a monetary penalty of Rs. 500/-, with default R.I. for 3 months, as the court considered imprisonment excessive in view of the long delay in instituting the criminal prosecution.
Broader legal implications (as articulated by the court):
- The court construed the Land Customs Act provisions to permit any authorised Land Customs officer (including a Superintendent) to detain goods and to initiate departmental or criminal proceedings; the statute does not require that only the seizing officer file criminal complaints.
- Departmental proceedings (penalty and confiscation) and criminal prosecutions are independent remedies; the statute does not mandate that criminal prosecution must precede departmental action.
- Making certain Sea Customs provisions (Sections 167(8) and 187-A) applicable to the Land Customs Act did not automatically repeal or displace Sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Land Customs Act; both routes remain available depending on the gravity of the offence.
- Excessive delay in bringing a criminal prosecution is a material factor in sentencing; long unexplained delays can negate the deterrent rationale and justify mitigation of punishment.
Note: This summary is confined to the material contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or legal holdings beyond the text of that opinion.
C.
1. The petitioner was convicted by the Additional District. Magistrate, Manipur, under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act, 1924 and under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947 and sentenced to 3 months' R.I. and 6 months' R.1. respectively. On appeal to the Sessions Judge, his conviction and sentence under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports Act, were set aside, but the conviction and sentence under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act were maintained by the Sessions Judge. Against that the petitioner has come up in revision.
2. The facts are beyond dispute. On 26-10-1957, the petitioner, who was a Calcutta bound passenger from Imphal was attempting to take a suit-case in the Plane without it. being registered or checked by the Customs Officer. It was detected by the Customs Inspector - Sri N.C. Banerji at the Koirengei Airport when it was seen without any label under the postal mail, which was ready for despatch by the plane. When questioned by the Customs Inspector, the petitioner admitted his ownership of the baggage and when he was asked to open it for inspection he at first refused to open it, but ultimately it was opened and 405 Parker 51 pencils made in England were seen inside the suit-case for which the petitioner was not able to produce any satisfactory documentary evidence showing bona fide purchase or licit importation. The import of such pencil required a permit under Section 5 of the Land Customs Act and an import licence under the notification of the Government of India, issued under Section 3(1) of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947 and they were also liable to payment of doty, which for the 405 pencils would amount to over Rs. 4,000/-, The suit-case containing the pencils was therefore seized by the Customs Inspector and the matter was reported to the Higher Authorities.
3. Then the petitioner was given a show cause notice under Sections 5(3) and 7(i) of the Land Customs Act, TQ 24 and under Section 167(8) read with section to of the Sea Customs Act, 1878 as made applicable by Section 3(2) of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947, why penalty should not be levied on him and the goods confiscated. The petitioner filed a reply stating that he purchased the goods from a hillman, expecting a reasonable return by re-selling them, without any knowledge, that he was committing an offence and that his case may be considered sympathetically. But he did not appear at the time of the hearing of the murder before the Collector of Central Excise and Land Customs, Shillong, An order was passed by the Collector on 3-6-1958. confronting the gnnris and imposing a penalty of Rs. 1.000/- under Section 167(8) of the Sea Custom Act, 1878.
4. Thereafter, a letter of authority was given by the Collector of Central 'Excise and Land Cuctotnc to the Superintendent. Central Excise and Land Customs to institute a criminal case under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947 against the petitioner as it was left that the gravity of offence committed required prosecution under Section 5 of the said Act. Then a complaint was filed by the Superintendent, Central Excise and Land Customs on 21-6-1960, i.e. 2 years: and 8 months after the seizure of the goods against the petitioner under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act and Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, read with Section 9 of the Land Customs Act. Charges were framed under the two sections. The Additional District Magistrate, as I said, convicted the petitioner under both the sections. But the learned Sessions Judge acquitted the petitioner of the charge under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act on a technical ground, namely, that the letter of authorisation:- Ext. A/2 given by the Collector of Central Excise and Land Customs for the prosecution was not sufficient and that under Section 6 of the said Act, as it then stood, an Officer authorised by the Central Government had to file the complaint and there was no evidence that the Superintendent, Central Excise was so authorised. But the conviction under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act was confirmed by the Sessions Judge.
5. It is now argued in revision for the petitioner that under Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act, the Land Customs Officer, who seized the goods, had to apply his mind and decide whether the penalty provided under Section 7(1) of the Act was adequate or inadequate, that if he was of opinion that it was inadequate, he has to file the complaint before the Magistrate, that he has to do so immediately alter the seizure and before proceedings are taken under Section 7(1) of the Land Customs Act or Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, to impose penalty, that the complaint filed by the Superintendent of Central Excise and Land Customs 2 years and 8 months after the seizure and two years after levying the penalty and forfeiture of the goods was not valid, that, in any case, after the amendment of Section 9 of the Land Customs Act, by which the provisions in Sections 167(81) and 187-A of the Sea Customs Act, have been made applicable, the penal provision in Section 7(2) and (3) of the Land Customs Act, must be treated as no longer in force, that, therefore, if at all, there was to be a prosecution, it can only be under Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act, that for such a prosecution under Section 167(81), the complaint had to be filed by the Collector of Land Customs or any other Officer of Customs not lower in rank than an Assistant Collector of Customs authorised in that behalf by the Chief Customs Officer and that the complaint filed by the Superintendent of Central Excise and Land Customs should not have been taken cognizance of by the Court and the whole prosecution was, therefore without authority. Lastly, it was argued that the serious delay in filing the criminal prosecution was not considered by either of the lower Courts in imposing the punishment of imprisonment which was unnecessarily severe under the circumstances.
6. I am not convinced with the petitioner's argument that a complaint for prosecution under Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act can be filed only by the Land Customs Officer who actually seized the goods in question. My attention was drawn to Section 5(3) of the Land Customs Act, by which any Land Customs officer duly empowered by the Chief Customs authority may require any person to produce the permit granted for the goods and if the permit is not produced, any goods which are dutiable and which are not accompanied by a permit can be detained, as was done in the present case. My attention was next drawn to Section 7(1) of the Act authorising the imposition of the penalty of Rs. 1,ooo/- in the case of dutiable goods and confiscation of such goods. Section 7(2) of the same Act, provided that if the Land Customs Officer was of opinion that an offence under Section 7(1) had been committed in respect of such goods and that the penalty provided in that sub-section was inadequate, he may make a complaint to the Magistrate having jurisdiction.
7. It was argued that Sections 5(3) and 7(1) and (2) should be read together and that if they are read together, it would be clear that the Lane-Customs Officer had to make up his mind when seizing the goods whether it was sufficient to impose the penalty under Section 7(1) or not and if he was of opinion that, the penalty provided therein was not adequate, he has to make the complaint to the Magistrate and that he cannot first proceed under Section 7(1) and get the penalty imposed and that the Superintendent of Land Customs cannot subsequently proceed under Section 7(2) after the imposition of the penalty under Section 7 (i) and file a complaint for criminal prosecution.
8. There is nothing under Section 7(2) which states that the same Land Customs Officer, who detained the goods under Section 5(3) of the Land Customs Act, must file the complaint. Section 3(1) of the Act authorised the Central Government to appoint a person to be the Collector of Land Customs and such other persons, as it thinks fit, as Land Customs Officers. Among the Land Customs Officers so appointed, are the Superintendent of Land Customs, Deputy Superintendent of Land Customs, Inspector of Land Customs etc. Thus, the Superintendent of Land Customs is certainly a Land Customs Officer within the meaning of Section 7(2) of the Act and therefore a superintendent of Land Customs can certainly file a complaint under Section 7(2). There is nothing in the section to show that the same Land Customs Officer who detained the goods has to make up his mind as to whether the penalty provided under Section 7(1) of the Act was adequate or inadequate. On the report of the Officer who detains the goods, any other Land Customs Officer superior to him can also decide whether the penalty provided under Section 7(1) was adequate or not.
9. Nor is there anything in Section 7(1) and (2) which would indicate that the criminal prosecution must take place before proceeding under Section 7(1). Actually, I find in this case that no proceedings were taken under Section 7 (r) of the Land Customs Act, The penalty and confiscation were under Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, which had been made applicable to the Land Customs Act by Section 9 of the Land Customs Act and the Schedule attached thereto. No doubt Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act authorised the Magistrate before whom a complaint is filed to com-fiscate the goods in addition to convicting and sentencing the person found guilty of the offence under Section 7(1) and the power of confiscation is also given under Sections 5(3) and 7 (I) of the Land Customs Act; and under Section 3 : 67 (8) of the Sea Customs Act which has been made applicable) in addition to imposing the penalty. But this by itself does not mean that the criminal prosecution, if it is decided upon, should precede the departmental action under Section 7(1) of the Land Customs Act or Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act. Where the statute gives the right to proceed de-partmentally by imposing penalty and confiscation and also to file complaint for criminal prosecution, it is clear that both actions can be taken independently of one another, and where the statute does not specifically provide as to which of the actions should be taken first, the party affected cannot insist that any one action should be taken earlier than the other.
10. But my attention was specifically drawn to Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act which provides that the complaint may be made to the Magistrate, if the Land Customs Officer is of opinion that the penalty provided in Section 7(1) was inadequate. From this it was argued that this opinion had to be formed even before proceeding under Section 7 (1) of the Act. It was pointed put that if that was not the intention of the Legislature and if criminal action was only to follow the imposition of the penalty, the provision would Have been under Section 7 (1) that the complaint may be filed if the Land Customs Officer was of opinion that the penalty imposed under Sub-section (1) and not "provided" under Sub-section (1) was inadequate. I am unable to accept this contention. It only means that the criminal action has nothing to do with the actual imposition of the penalty under Section 7(1), but that criminal action may be taken if the penalty provided under Section 7(1) was found inadequate having regard to the gravity of the offence. In that connection I may refer to Section 186 of the Sea Customs Act, which has been made applicable to the Land Customs Act also by which the awarding of any confiscation, penalty or increased rate of duty under the Sea Customs Act by an Officer of Customs shall not prevent the infliction of any punishment to which the person affected thereby is liable under any other law. Section 186 would, therefore, mean that criminal action can be taken in addition to the imposition of any penalty and this would indicate that criminal action need not precede departmental action. This plea of the petitioner therefore has to fail.
11. Nor am I impressed with the arguments advanced for the petitioner that no criminal action could be taken under Sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Land Customs Act after Section 167(81) and Section 187-A of the Sea Customs Act have been made applicable to the Land Customs Act. If that was the intention of the Legislature, Sections 7 (2) and 7 (3) of the Land Customs Act would have been repealed when Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act was made applicable to the Land Custorns Act also. If we read both Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act, and Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act, It will be seen that the criminal action provided under Section 167(81) is far more serious and covers a much wider range of offences than what is provided under Section 7(2) of the Land Customs Act. Thus, it can only mean that after the amendment to Section 9 of the Land Customs Act, by which various sections of the Sea Customs Act were made applicable to the Land Customs Act, the Land Customs Authorities can proceed under Section 7 (2) of the Land Customs Act if they find that the penalty provided under Section 7(1) of the said Act, was not adequate and prosecute him and get him punished for imprisonment upto 6 months, but if they consider that even a higher punishment than six months' imprisonment of either description is necessary having regard to the gravity of the offence, they can proceed under Section 167(81) read with Section 187A of the Sea Customs Act and have a complaint filed in writing as provided under Section 187-A. It cannot be said that Section 7(2) and (3) of the Land Customs Act have Ceased to exist and no action could be taken thereunder. In the present case, all that we can say is that the Land Customs Authorities did not consider the offence in this case as of sufficient gravity to proceed under Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act, but only for a criminal prosecution under Section 7(2) and (3) of the Land Customs Act. This objection has therefore to fail.
12. It follows that the conviction of the petitioner under Section 7 (3) of the Land Customs Act has to be upheld. It was not argued before me that the offence committed by the petitioner did not come under Section 7(1) of the Land Customs Act. The matter has been elaborately discussed by both the lower Courts and it is unnecessary for me therefore to go into the details of the evidence. It is clear that the petitioner was trying to carry the said goods containing dutiable goods without a permit clandestinely by placing the said goods along with the postal mail to be boarded in the Plane. His plea that he did not know that the goods cannot be taken without a permit and without payment of duty was rightly rejected by both the lower Courts. The petitioner is clearly guilty.
13. It was next argued that there has been very serious delay in filing this complaint. For the Government, it was stressed that Manipur being a border State, such offences of attempting to convey dutiable goods without declaration and without payment of duty and without valid licence or permit have became common offences which have to be put down with a firm hand and hence deterrent punishment was, therefore, necessary to prevent such offence being committed. I quite agree that such offences have to be discouraged by deterrent punishment. But, if that was the object of this prosecution, the very delay of 2 years and 8 months after the commission of the offence to file the complaint completely negatives the whole purpose of the prosecution. If the object is to dete : others, promptness in taking action is absolutely necessary. Otherwise., it will only mean harass ment or punishment for the particular person con cerned. As I said, the offence in this case tool place on 26-10-1957. The departmental action was itself over on 3-6-1958. For more than 2 years after the departmental action was over, the petitioner was kept in the dark as to whether the Land Customs Authorities contemplated taking any criminal action against him. The complaint was filed only on 21-6-1960, Such long delay in filing a criminal complaint which did not require the permission of any Higher Authority and which could have been filed by the Land Customs Officer himself has to be taken into account by a Court in deciding what punishment should be awarded, It was contended for the Government that the delay was to get the necessary authority to proceed under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947 and that the complaint itself was filed not only under Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act, but also under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports Act, 1947. I fail to understand why there should have been such delay in authorising the filing of the complaint even under Section 5 of the Imports and Exports Act, 1947. We also see that even after such long delay, the authorisation turned out to be invalid. An accused person has a right to expect that the authorities concerned would decide as expeditiously as possible whether they would proceed against him in a criminal Court. It is atrocious that a criminal complaint should be filed 2 years and 8 months after the commission of the offence. It will look as if the authorities had originally decided not to proceed against him criminally and after very long delay were trying to resuscitate the matter by filing this much delayed complaint. Section 7(3) of the Land Customs Act provides for imprisonment upto 6 months or for fine not exceeding Rs. 1,000/,-or for both. It seems to me that after such a long delay, it will be too much of an harassment to the petitioner to make him suffer imprisonment for an offence which he committed years ago. Under the circumstance, a punishment of fine will meet the ends of justice. If the Land Customs Authorities desire punishment of imprisonment to be given, they will have to be more alert in such matters and come forward with criminal prosecutions promptly. The sentence of imprisonment passed on the petitioner is, therefore, set aside and a sentence of fine of Rs. 500/- is imposed upon him in modification. In default of payment of fine, the petitioner will suffer R.I. for 3 months.
Alert