- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nandlal Agarwal And Another v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Assam.
Factual and Procedural Background
The reference arises from an order of this Court calling for a statement of the case from the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Calcutta Bench, and directing a question of law to be referred for opinion: “Whether, in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in assessing the income of the minors in the hands of the guardians as the income of a Hindu undivided family?”
Relevant facts taken from the opinion:
- Assessment year: 1954–55 (accounting year 1953–54).
- Kishanlal Agarwal carried on a business in the name of Shri Krishna Rice Mills; he was assessed as an individual for 1951–52 and died in 1950, leaving a widow and two minor sons, Basant and Ashok.
- The widow died in 1952, leaving the two minor sons as the family.
- An application for guardianship of the minors resulted in an interim appointment (1 June 1953) of Nandlal Agarwal; on 15 December 1953 the appointment was affirmed with modification so that Nandlal Agarwal and Dwarka Prosad Agarwal were appointed guardians of the person and property of both minors; the court directed the guardians to render half-yearly accounts.
- By an order dated 25 March 1958 the court ordered the guardians to keep and submit separate accounts for each minor (receipts, profit & loss and separate expenditure).
- Assessment history and returns:
- 1951–52: profit of the mill returned and assessed in the status of an individual; accepted without appeal.
- 1952–53: return filed after the widow’s death by Nandlal Agarwal as guardian describing status as an individual; assessment accepted without appeal.
- 1953–54: status described as Hindu undivided family in the return; the Income-tax Officer made assessment in the status of an “association of persons”.
- 1954–55: return filed by the two guardians giving status as Hindu undivided family; the Income-tax Officer assessed the two guardians under section 23(3) read with section 41 as an “association of persons” on a total income of Rs. 32,593.
- On appeal, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner held that sections 40 and 41 applied because the minors' shares were definite and ascertainable, directed separate proceedings for each minor; the department appealed to the Appellate Tribunal which reversed that decision and held that the guardians should be assessed as a Hindu undivided family (HUF) on the total income. The Appellate Tribunal accordingly modified the Income-tax Officer's order so that the status for assessment was HUF rather than “association of persons.”
- The present reference to this Court asks whether the Tribunal was justified in assessing the minors' income in the hands of the guardians as income of a Hindu undivided family.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in assessing the income of the minors in the hands of the guardians as the income of a Hindu undivided family (the precise question referred to this Court).
- Whether, under section 40 of the Indian Income-tax Act, guardians appointed for minors may be taxed in a status different from the beneficiaries (i.e., whether guardians may be assessed as a Hindu undivided family rather than being taxed only on the income received on behalf of each minor separately).
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments (Mr. Lahiri)
- Section 40 of the Income-tax Act is directly attracted and, by its plain language, makes guardians liable only for tax on income which comes into their hands as income of their beneficiaries (the two minors).
- It is not open to the department to assess the guardians as a Hindu undivided family; section 40 provides machinery for levy and recovery, creating vicarious liability co-extensive with the liability of the beneficiary, not a direct and independent liability of the guardian.
- The guardians received the minors' shares and separate accounts were opened in the names of the two minors; therefore guardians can only be taxed on the amounts received on behalf of each minor separately.
- Although the business was carried on by the guardians as a single unit, that does not convert the wards into a Hindu undivided family for the purposes of section 40; joint guardianship does not make the wards a single Hindu undivided family.
- As a matter of law, the Tribunal’s finding that a joint family came into existence after the deaths does not legally justify treating the business income as joint family property for the purposes of taxing the guardians under section 40.
Revenue's Arguments (Mr. Choudhary)
- On the Tribunal’s findings, if the minors were considered majors they would be liable to tax as a Hindu undivided family, and therefore the guardians appointed by the court should be liable to pay tax on the entire income from the business in the status of a Hindu undivided family.
- There is a presumption that property inherited by the two minor sons (the business run by Kishanlal) will be treated as ancestral (joint family) property in the absence of evidence that it was treated as separate property; hence the income should be viewed as joint family income.
- Referred to authorities (Vedathanni; Commissioner v. Gomedalli Lakshminarayan; Commissioner v. Lakshmanan Chettiar; Commissioner v. Dhannalal Devilal) to support the contention that a joint family may, in some circumstances, consist of a single male member (argument bearing on the characterization of family and property for tax purposes).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Saifudin Alimohamed v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1954] 35 I.T.R. 337 | Establishes that sections 40 and 41 are machinery provisions; they do not impose new liability but provide a means to recover tax by making guardians/ trustees vicariously liable to the extent of beneficiary's liability. | The Court expressly agreed with this observation and relied upon it to interpret section 40 as providing only vicarious/machinery liability; therefore guardians are liable only for tax co-extensive with the beneficiaries' liability (i.e., on amounts received for each minor separately). |
| Vedathanni v. Commissioner of Income-tax; Commissioner of Income-tax v. Gomedalli Lakshminarayan [1935] 3 I.T.R. 367; Commissioner of Income-tax v. Lakshmanan Chettiar [1940] 8 I.T.R. 545; Commissioner of Income-tax v. Dhannalal Devilal [1956] 89 I.T.R. 165 | Invoked by the Revenue in support of the proposition that a joint family may consist of a single male member (relevance to characterization of property and family). | The Court noted these cases were cited by the Revenue but held that they were not necessary to decide the present point and did not decide the issue on the basis of these precedents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds from the textual interpretation of section 40 and from the authoritative exposition in Saifudin Alimohamed, which treats sections 40 and 41 as machinery provisions creating vicarious liability. The key steps in the Court's reasoning are:
- The Court accepted the Bombay High Court’s dictum in Saifudin Alimohamed that sections 40 and 41 are machinery provisions; they do not create a new substantive liability but allow the tax to be levied and recovered from a guardian or trustee in the same manner and to the same extent as it would be leviable upon the beneficiary were the beneficiary of full age and sound mind.
- Applying this construction, section 40 makes the guardian vicariously liable only to the extent of the liability of the beneficiary. Thus, where a guardian receives income on behalf of a minor, the tax recoverable from the guardian is co-extensive with the tax that would have been leviable on the beneficiary had the beneficiary been of full age and sound mind and in direct receipt of the income.
- In the present case, the guardians (Nandlal Agarwal and Dwarka Prosad Agarwal) received shares of profit of the business on behalf of the two minors. The court-ordered separate accounts in the names of the two minors show that the receipts and expenses relating to each minor were separately adjusted.
- Consequently, the guardians were liable only for tax on the amounts received for each minor separately; they were not appointed as guardians of a joint family as such, and their wards are the two minors separately rather than a single Hindu undivided family.
- The fact that the guardians carried on the business as a single unit, or that the guardians' responsibility is joint, does not transform the legal position of the wards into a Hindu undivided family for the purpose of section 40. Joint guardianship does not make the beneficiaries themselves a single joint family entity for taxation under section 40.
- The Court therefore rejected the Revenue's contention that the guardians could be taxed as a Hindu undivided family on the total income. The Court also observed that the subsidiary question whether the property inherited by the minors should be treated as ancestral (joint family) property need not be decided because section 40, properly interpreted, precludes taxing the guardians in respect of the total income as a Hindu undivided family.
- On this basis the Court answered the referred question in the negative: the Tribunal was not justified in assessing the income of the minors in the hands of the guardians as the income of a Hindu undivided family.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The question referred to this Court was answered in the negative. The guardians cannot be assessed in the status of a Hindu undivided family for the total income; under section 40 they are liable only for tax on the separate shares of income received on behalf of each minor.
Implications and immediate consequences (as stated in the opinion):
- The guardians are liable to pay tax only on the amounts they received on behalf of each minor, assessed separately in accordance with section 40.
- The Tribunal's decision to assess the guardians as a Hindu undivided family on the total income is not sustained by the Court's interpretation of section 40.
- The Court awarded costs to the assessees in the amount of Rs. 200 (inclusive of hearing fee and other costs), as expressly stated in the opinion.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new rule of law beyond the application of section 40 to the facts; the Court limited its analysis to the interpretation of section 40 and did not decide subsidiary questions about the ancestral character of the property.
Mehrotra, C.J:— By an order of this court, a statement of the case was called for from the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Calcutta Bench, and the Tribunal was directed to refer the following question of law for opinion to this court:
“Whether, in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in assessing the income of the minors in the hands of the guardians as the income of a Hindu undivided family?”
2. The assessment year is 1954–55 and the accounting year is 1953–54. One Kishanlal Agarwal was assessed as an individual in respect of the income arising from the business carried on in the name of Shri Krishna Rice Mills. Kishanlal died in the year 1950 leaving his widow and his two minor sons—Basant and Ashok.
3. In the year 1952, his widow died, and, after her death, the family consisted of her two sons—Basant and Ashok—who were minors. An application was, therefore, made before the Subordinate Judge, Nowgong, praying that a guardian be appointed of the minors' person and property and an interim appointment was made by the court by its order dated the 1st June, 1953, appointing one Nandlal Agarwal as the guardian of both the minors. Thereafter, this order was affirmed on the 15th December, 1953, with the modification that both Nandlal Agarwal and Dwarka Prosad Agarwal were appointed as guardians of the person and property of the two minors. They were directed to render accounts half-yearly to the court. On the 25th March, 1958, the guardians applied to the court asking for permission to show the accounts of the two minors separately. The court ordered the guardians to keep and submit separate accounts for each of the minors together with the accounts of profit and loss and separate expenditure of each minor. For the appreciation of facts it will be necessary to note the status in which the father of the minors was previously assessed. For the assessment year 1951–52, the profit of the mill was returned in the status of an individual. For the assessment year 1952–53 the return was filed after the death of the widow by Nandlal Agarwal as the guardian of the minors describing the status as an individual. For the next year 1953–54, the status was described as Hindu undivided family. The assessments for the years 1951–52 and 1952–53 were made on the basis of the declared status and were accepted without an appeal being filed. For the year 1953–54, the assessment was made by the Income-tax Officer in the status of an “association of persons”. Return was filed for the year 1954–55 giving out the status as Hindu undivided family by the two guardians. The Income-tax Officer assessed the two guardians, Nandlal Agarwal and Dwarka Prosad Agarwal, under section 23(3) read with section 41 of the Indian Income-tax Act as an “association of persons” on a total income of Rs. 32,593. On appeal, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner took the view that the case was covered by sections 40 and 41 of the Income-tax Act since the shares of the two minors were definite and ascertainable. He, therefore, set aside the order of the Income-tax Officer and directed him to start proceedings for each of the two minors separately. The department went up in appeal to the Appellate Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal reversed the decision of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The Tribunal came to the following finding: Firstly, that up to the time of his death in 1950 Kishanlal Agarwal was assessed as an individual. There was no joint family in existence at that time and thus the two minor sons acquired no right in the property of Kishanlal by virtue of birth. After the death of Kishanlal, the joint family consisted of the widow and the two minor sons. After the death of the widow, the shares of the minors were enlarged and they continued to be the members of the joint family. The Tribunal was of the opinion that the guardians were to be assessed in the same manner as beneficiaries and as the beneficiaries could have been assessed as Hindu undivided family on the income from the business, the guardians were liable to be assessed as Hindu undivided family. On that basis, the appeal was allowed and the order of the Income-tax Officer was modified only to the extent that the status in which the assessment was to be made was that of a Hindu undivided family instead of an “association of persons”. On these facts, the present question has been referred to us for opinion.
4. Mr. Lahiri has contended that on plain interpretation of section 40 of the Income-tax Act which is attracted to the facts of the present case, the guardians were liable to pay the tax only on the income which came into their hands as the income of their beneficiaries, namely, the two minors, of whom they were appointed as guardians. It is not open to the department to assess the guardians as Hindu undivided family. Section 40 of the Act reads as follows:
“40. (1) Where the guardian or trustee of any person being a minor, lunatic or idiot (all of which persons are hereinafter in this subsection included in the term ‘beneficiary’) is entitled to receive on behalf of such beneficiary, or is in receipt on behalf of such beneficiary of, any income, profits or gains chargeable under this Act, the tax shall be levied upon and recoverable from such guardian or trustee, as the case may be, in like manner and to the same amount as it would be leviable upon and recoverable from any such beneficiary if of full age or sound mind and in direct receipt of such income, profits or gains, and all the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly.
(2) Where the trustee or agent of any person not resident in the taxable territories and not being a minor, lunatic or idiot (such person being hereinafter in this sub-section referred to as a beneficiary) is entitled to receive on behalf of such beneficiary, or is in receipt on behalf of such beneficiary of, any income, profits or gains chargeable under this Act, the tax, if not levied on the beneficiary direct, may be levied upon and recovered from such trustee or agent, as the case may be, in like manner and to the same amount as it would be leviable upon and recoverable from the beneficiary if in direct receipt of such income, profits or gains, and all the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly.”
5. Section 40 deals with the specific case of guardians while section 41 deals with the cases of managers and trustees. The relevant portion of section 40 is as follows:
“…. the tax shall be levied upon and recoverable from such guardian or trustee, as the case may be, in like manner and to the same amount as it would be leviable upon and recoverable from any such beneficiary if of full age or sound mind and in direct receipt of such income, profits or gains and all the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly.”
6. As observed by their Lordships of the Bombay High Court in the case of Saifudin Alimohamed v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1954] 35 I.T.R 337. “…these two sections…. are undoubtedly machinery sections and they do not impose any new liability, nor do they in any way reduce or minimise the liability which is already there upon the assessee under the other provisions of the Income-tax Act. Section 40 deals with a case of minor, lunatic or idiot and where a guardian or trustee is appointed, and what it provides is that when you have a guardian or a trustee and he receives or is entitled to receive on behalf of his ward or beneficiary any income, he is liable to pay tax upon that income in the like manner and to the same amount as it would be leviable upon and recoverable from any such beneficiary if of full age and sound mind and in direct receipt of such income, profits or gains, and all the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly. Therefore, to use simple language, section 40 imposes a vicarious liability upon a guardian and trustee and that vicarious liability is co-extensive with the liability of the ward or the beneficiary of whom the assessee is the guardian or the trustee. It is not the liability of the guardian or the trustee himself; it is the liability of the minor or the beneficiary. But the law provides a machinery whereby the taxing department by this option, instead of recovering the tax from the minor or the ward or the beneficiary, may recover it from the guardian or the trustee.” We are in complete agreement with the above observation. Section 40 provides only the machinery for levy and recovery of the tax in respect of the income in the hands of the guardian which he receives for and on behalf of the minor. In the present case, Nandlal Agarwal and Dwarka Prosad Agarwal were appointed guardians of the two minors. They received the shares of these minors in the profit of the business as their income. By the order of the court, separate accounts in the name of the two minors were opened in which the receipts and expenses relating to each of the minors were separately adjusted. The guardians were thus only liable to pay tax on the amount which they received on behalf of these two minors separately. It cannot be said that they were appointed guardians of any joint family as such, so that their beneficiary was the joint family as such and thus they were liable to pay tax on the total income received by them on behalf of the Hindu undivided family, their ward. The beneficiaries were the two minors separately. The two minors are the wards of the guardians. The guardians will, in our opinion, be liable to pay tax on the separate income of each of the minors. The business was, no doubt, carried on by the guardians as a single unit and the integrity of the business was not broken, but the guardians are not taxed under section 40. As joint guardians they had to carry on the business on behalf of the minors but the minors cannot be said to be carrying on the business as a Hindu undivided family. The income which comes into the hands of the guardians on behalf of their wards is the share of the profit of each of them separately. That the responsibility of the guardians is joint does not mean that their ward is the Hindu undivided family and not the minors separately. It is contended by the learned counsel for the department that on the findings arrived at by the Tribunal, it is not open to the assessee to say that the status of the assessee will be anything different from that of a Hindu undivided family. His contention is that if these minors were majors, they would have been liable to pay tax as Hindu undivided family, and, therefore, the guardians appointed by the court will also be liable to pay tax on the entire income from the business in the status of Hindu undivided family. In our opinion, the question of the status is not relevant for the purpose of section 40 of the Income-tax Act. Under section 40, as we have already pointed out, the income of the minor of whom the guardian is appointed is liable to be taxed in the hands of the guardian. The guardian, therefore, cannot be taxed as a “Hindu undivided family”. Mr. Lahiri has further contended on behalf of the assessee that on the findings arrived at by the Tribunal, as a matter of law, no inference can be drawn that the business was a joint family bnsiness, and, therefore, the income of the business could not be assessed in the hands of the guardian as the income of the Hindu undivided family. His contention is that it is the finding of the Tribunal that at the time of the death of Kishahlal Agarwal, there was no joint family. In the past he had all along been assessed as an individual. The finding of the Tribunal is that after the death of Kishanlal these two members constituted a joint family. From this it does not necessarily follow that the income of the business run by Kishanlal will be a joint family property in the hands of his sons which they get by inheritance. Mr. Choudhary, who appears for the department, has contended that the presumption will be that the property inherited by the two minor sons—namely the business run by Kishanlal—will be treated to be an ancestral property in the hands of the two sons and thus it will in the absence of any evidence that it was treated as a separate property by the members of the joint family be presumed to be a joint family property. This question is relevant only if the minors were directly assessed as Hindu undivided family. As in our opinion on the interpretation of section 40 of the Income-tax Act, the guardians cannot be taxed in respect of the total income as Hindu undivided family, it is not necessary to go into that question at all. On the plain language of section 40, a guardian can be held liable to pay tax only on the share of the profit received by him of each of the minors separately. In this view of the matter, we answer the question referred to us in the negative.
7. Mr. Choudhary referred to cases of Vedathanni v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Commissioner of Income-tax v. Gomedalli Lakshminarayan [1935] 3 I.T.R 367., Commissioner of Income-tax v. Lakshmanan Chettiar [1940] 8 I.T.R 545., Commissioner of Income-tax v. Dhannalal Devilal [1956] 89 I.T.R 165., in support of his contention that a joint family may consist of a single male member. It is not necessary to deal with these cases at length as they do not decide the point for consideration before us.
8. The assessees will be entitled to their costs which we assess at Rs. 200, inclusive of the hearing fee and other costs.
S.K Datta, J.:— I agree.
9. Question answered in the negative.
Alert