- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pallavi Sharma v. College Of Vocational Studies & Anr. S
Judgment Summary — MS. G. Rohini, CJ
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was the unsuccessful petitioner in W.P. (C) No. 6398/2015 and challenges the dismissal by the learned Single Judge dated 06.07.2015. The writ petition arose from the first respondent College's refusal to admit the petitioner to the 1st Year B.A. (Vocational Studies) course despite the petitioner having secured 89% in the Senior School Certificate Examination (Class XII) of the Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi (Commerce stream). The petitioner sought a direction that the first respondent College admit her pursuant to the third cut-off list which had fixed the cut-off at 88% for B.A. (Vocational Studies).
The petitioner applied for admission through the University of Delhi's centralized registration system (OMR Pre-Admission Form). The petitioner did not include B.A. (Vocational Studies) among the courses she darkened on the OMR form; she listed other courses instead. The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition on the ground that a candidate cannot be admitted to a course to which she did not apply. The present appeal challenges that dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a candidate who meets the cut-off percentage for a course but did not select that course in the centralized OMR Pre-Admission Form can be directed by the court to be admitted to that course.
- Whether the admission process and the procedure prescribed in the Prospectus/Bulletin of Information (including requirements to select courses on the OMR form) are binding such that courts may not direct institutions to act contrary to those procedures.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The omission to mention B.A. (Vocational Studies) in the OMR form was a mere technical error and should not bar admission when the petitioner had secured marks (89%) above the declared cut-off (88%).
- Since the petitioner satisfied the eligibility criteria and no other candidate would be prejudiced, she ought to be admitted despite the omission.
- The purpose of the OMR was registration for admission on the basis of cut-off percentage; therefore, a candidate satisfying the cut-off should not be denied admission for failing to mention the specific course.
Respondents' Arguments
- The OMR Pre-Admission Form required applicants to choose both colleges and specific courses; the applicant is responsible for the information furnished on the form.
- A candidate who has not applied for a particular college or course cannot be directed to be admitted to it; directing admission would disrupt the admission process and prejudice those who applied for the course.
- The first respondent College stated that it is the only college conducting B.A. (Vocational Studies) and that all seats were already filled; no vacancies existed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Maharshi Dayanand University v. Surjit Kaur; JT (2010) 7 SC 179 | That the procedure prescribed in the Prospectus/Bulletin of Information issued by institutions is binding and no mandamus can be issued directing educational institutions to act contrary to their own procedure. | The court relied on this settled principle to uphold the rule that admission cannot be directed where the applicant did not follow the prescribed procedure (i.e., did not apply for the course) and to refuse relief to the appellant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the admission framework: the University of Delhi's Central Registration System and the OMR Pre-Admission Form procedure set out in the Information Bulletin, 2015-16.
The court noted that the first respondent College's Bulletin expressly required applicants to state both the choice of college and the choice of courses on the OMR form, and the Information Bulletin instructed candidates to darken bubbles for the courses they wished to pursue (with no limit on number of courses). The OMR form's Column 11 included B.A. (Vocational Studies) among the courses available.
Given those instructions, the court found that the petitioner had the opportunity and means to select B.A. (Vocational Studies) on the OMR form but failed to do so. The court treated the omission as the petitioner's responsibility, noting that information furnished on the Pre-Admission Form is the sole responsibility of the applicant.
The court accepted the Single Judge's conclusion that directing admission for a candidate who had not applied for the course would disrupt the admission process and be detrimental to candidates who had applied for that course. The court also recorded the first respondent College's statement that all seats for the B.A. (Vocational Studies) course were filled and no vacancies existed.
The court further applied the cited precedent (Maharshi Dayanand University v. Surjit Kaur) to underscore that institutions must follow their published procedures and that courts will not issue mandamus to contravene those procedures. For these reasons the court found no reason to interfere with the Single Judge's order.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED. The appeal was dismissed for lack of merit.
Direct effect: The appellant will not be admitted to the B.A. (Vocational Studies) course; the Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition is upheld. The court recorded that all seats were filled and ordered no costs.
No broader change in law was declared; the decision applies existing principles (including the binding nature of prospectus/bulletin procedures) to the facts of this case and does not purport to set new precedent.
JUDGMENT
MS. G. ROHINI, CJ
1. The unsuccessful petitioner in W.P (C) No. 6398/2015 is the appellant before us. The said writ petition was filed aggrieved by the action of the respondents in not giving admission to the petitioner in the course of B.A (Vocational Studies) as per the 3rd cut-off list declared by the first respondent College and seeking a direction to the respondent No. 1 to forthwith give admission to her in the 1st Year B.A (Vocational Studies). The writ petition was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by order dated 06.07.2015 and the same is under challenge in the present appeal.
2. The appellant/writ petitioner passed the Senior School Certificate Examination (Class XII) of the Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi in the stream of Commerce and secured 89% of marks. She desired to take admission in Under Graduate courses in the University of Delhi and accordingly she submitted the application form online.
3. It may be noted that the University of Delhi initiated a Central Registration System for students seeking admission in the Under Graduate courses in the University, according to which, the candidates need not submit the application form for each college of the University but it is suffice to submit the centralized registration form known as OMR Pre-Admission Form online or off-line at the Admission Information Centres mentioned in the Information Bulletin, 2015-16 issued by the University of Delhi.
4. The first respondent College i.e College of Vocational Studies which is affiliated to the University of Delhi offers B.A (Vocational Studies) Course for students of Commerce stream. The eligibility for admission into the said course is 40% of marks in 4 subjects (one language and three elective subjects) in Senior School Certificate Examination. The procedure of calculation of best of 4 percentage for B.A (Vocational Studies) has been prescribed in the Bulletin of Information, 2015-16 issued by the first respondent College as under:-
“Procedure of Calculation of Best of Four Percentage for B.A (Vocational Studies)
The following subjects have to be included in the calculation of the Best of Four percentage:
i.) One Language (Elective/Core/Functional)
ii.) Any three elective subjects can be chosen. A disadvantage of 3% may be imposed on the Best of Four percentage in case of change of stream.
iii.) For admission to B.A (Vocational) only, related vocational subjects may be treated at par with academic/elective subjects.”
5. It was pleaded in the writ petition that as per the third cut-off percentage list issued by the first respondent College for admission to B.A (Vocational Studies), the cut-off percentage was declared as 88% and above and as such the petitioner/appellant who secured 89% of marks is eligible and entitled to admission in B.A (Vocational Studies). It was alleged that the first respondent College refused admission to the petitioner/appellant on the ground that in the OMR Form submitted by her online in the Column “Courses” she had mentioned only (i) B.A (Hons.) Academics, (ii) B.A (Hons.) English, (iii) B.Com, and (iv) B.Com (Hons.) but not B.A (Vocational Studies). The said action of the respondents is assailed in the writ petition contending inter alia that the omission to mention B.A (Vocational Studies) in the OMR Form is a mere technical error for which the petitioner who had admittedly secured more than the cutoff marks of 88% cannot be denied admission.
6. The learned Single Judge did not agree with the said contention and dismissed the writ petition holding that -
“11. I am unable to find the petitioner to have made out any case whatsoever. The procedure for admission prescribed by the respondent no. 2 University of Delhi having provided for the admission seekers to fill up their choice of college and choice of courses in which they want to pursue graduation, admission of a candidate who has not applied for admission to a particular college or to a particular course cannot be directed. If the same is done, it will throw the entire admission process out of gear and create a chaos. As aforesaid, it is not as if the choice of subjects was left to be exercised by the students after the cut off lists are successively declared. It is for this reason only that the applicants, in the OMR Form were required to fill the subject/courses to which they sought admission. The counsel for the respondent no. 2 University of Delhi has rightly contended that it is not as if the petitioner could not have filled up the course of B.A (Vocational Courses) in which she now claims admission. The petitioner however did not and cannot now be directed to be admitted to the said course merely because she fulfils the criteria for admission thereto.”
7. Having heard the learned counsel for both the parties and having perused the material available on record, we do not find any justifiable reason to interfere with the order under appeal.
8. As noticed above, in the Bulletin of Information, 2015-16 issued by the first respondent College itself the procedure for admission was specifically mentioned. As could be seen, the applicants have to mention in the OMR Form both the choice of college and choice of courses. Admittedly, the appellant/petitioner failed to include B.A (Vocational Studies) in her choice of courses. Therefore, it is not open to her to claim admission in that course after the declaration of the cut-off percentage.
9. However, it is contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the fact that the appellant/petitioner having passed the Senior School Certificate Examination in Commerce stream is eligible for admission in B.A (Vocational Studies) apart from the other courses mentioned by her in the OMR and therefore there is no reason to deny admission to her on the ground of mere technical error committed by her while submitting the OMR. It is also contended that the purpose of filing OMR being the registration for admission in appropriate course on the basis of the cut-off percentage declared, a candidate like the appellant who satisfied the eligibility criteria and secured more than the cut-off percentage ought not to have been denied admission merely on the ground that she failed to mention the particular course in OMR. It is also submitted by the learned counsel that since the petitioner had admittedly secured more than the cut-off marks, no other candidate would be prejudiced if the petitioner is granted admission on the basis of the marks secured by her.
10. We may, at the outset, mention that all courses available in colleges for which registration is done through OMR Pre-Admission Form are included in the said Form itself at Column 11. The Information Bulletin, 2015-16 issued by the University of Delhi contained important instructions for candidates for filling up OMR Form wherein it was specifically mentioned -
“Select the course of study you would like to pursue by darkening appropriate bubble. The bubbles must be darkened properly. There is no limit on number of courses to be selected.”
11. It was also made clear in the instructions that information or data furnished on the Pre-Admission Form is the sole responsibility of the applicant.
12. A perusal of Column 11 of the OMR Pre-Admission Form shows that B.A (Vocational Studies) has also been included among the 25 different courses of Arts/Commerce and Science mentioned therein.
13. That being so, we do not find any substance in the contention that the appellant/petitioner failed to mention the course of B.A (Vocational Studies) in the OMR Form since she was not aware of the difference between a normal B.A course and B.A (Vocational Studies). The said plea appears to be only an after-thought to take advantage of the situation since the cut-off percentage has now been declared as 88% for B.A (Vocational Studies) in the 3 cut-off percentage list. Be that as it may, the fact remains that the appellant/petitioner failed to opt for the course of B.A (Vocational Studies) while submitting the OMR Pre-Admission Form. Therefore, as rightly held by the learned Single Judge, grant of admission to the appellant/petitioner who has not even applied for admission to the course would be detrimental to the students who had applied for admission to the said course. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant/petitioner that no other candidate would be prejudiced if the petitioner is granted admission on the basis of the marks secured by her is therefore untenable.
14. At any rate, the law is well settled that the procedure prescribed in the Prospectus/Bulletin of Information issued by the institutions is binding and no mandamus can be issued directing the educational institutions to act contrary to their own procedure (vide Maharshi Dayanand University v. Surjit Kaur; JT (2010) 7 SC 179).
15. It may also be added that the learned counsel appearing for the first respondent College, on instructions submitted that the first respondent College is the only College which conducts the course in B.A (Vocational Studies) and all the seats in the said course are already filled-up and as of today no vacant seats are available.
16. For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is devoid of any merit and the same is accordingly dismissed. No costs.
Alert