Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Intex Technologies (India) Ltd. v. Telefonaktiebolaget Lm Ericsson And Anr. S

Delhi High Court
Mar 24, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises against the order dated 17.02.2014 passed by a Single Judge of this Court in W.P(C) 1006/2014, which challenged an order dated 16.01.2014 issued by the Competition Commission of India (CCI). The Single Judge had observed that the CCI had entered into an adjudicatory process at the preliminary stage under Section 26(1) of the Competition Act, thereby rendering the remedy under Section 26(7) illusory. The Judge stayed any final orders or reports by the Commission or its Director General, while allowing the petitioner to provide information as requested. The order also restricted the summoning of officers stationed abroad without the Court's permission and clarified that the Commission’s observations would not affect ongoing negotiations or adjudications.

The present appeal follows this order and is linked to another writ petition (W.P(C) 464/2014) filed by Micromax Informatics Limited, which had challenged a similar order dated 21.01.2014 passed by a Single Judge on a related Competition Commission order dated 12.11.2013. Appeals arising from that writ petition (LPA Nos. 182/2014 and 185/2014) were disposed of on 24.02.2014 with a modification regarding the procedure for summoning officers stationed abroad.

The Competition Commission had also referred to the Micromax case in its order dated 16.01.2014, indicating that the present case and the Micromax case were being investigated jointly under Section 26(1) of the Competition Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Competition Commission’s order dated 16.01.2014, which recorded detailed reasoning at the Section 26(1) stage, constituted an adjudicatory and determinative process undermining the remedy under Section 26(7) of the Competition Act.
  2. Whether the procedural safeguards regarding the examination of officers stationed abroad by the Director General of the Competition Commission were appropriately framed and should be modified.
  3. Whether the present case should be clubbed with the Micromax case for investigation and treated consistently in terms of procedural directions.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the impugned order of the Single Judge which found that the Competition Commission had prematurely entered into an adjudicatory process at the Section 26(1) stage by recording detailed reasons, thereby making the statutory remedy under Section 26(7) illusory. The Court noted the procedural directions restricting the summoning of officers stationed abroad without Court permission and the preservation of the petitioner’s rights to negotiate and litigate unaffected by the Commission’s observations.

The Court further observed the linkage between the present case and the Micromax case, which had been similarly challenged and disposed of with modifications to procedural directions regarding investigation and examination of officers abroad. The Court found it appropriate to apply the same order and modifications from the Micromax appeals to the present appeal, given the Commission’s decision to club both investigations.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is disposed of.

The Court applied the same procedural modifications and directions issued in the appeals arising from the Micromax case (LPA Nos. 182/2014 and 185/2014) to the present appeal. This means that the Director General may call local officers for investigation but must notify the respondent before calling officers stationed abroad, who may challenge the reasonableness of such requests before the Single Judge. The decision maintains procedural safeguards without setting any new legal precedent beyond the immediate parties involved.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

BADAR DURREZ AHMED, J (ORAL)

CM 5245/2014

The exemption is allowed subject to all just exceptions.

LPA 255/2014

1. This appeal is directed against the order dated 17.02.2014 passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court in W.P(C) 1006/2014 which in turn was filed in respect of an order dated 16.01.2014 passed by the Competition Commission. The learned Single Judge by virtue of the impugned order dated 17.02.2014 has observed as under:-

“Upon a perusal of the impugned orders dated 28th November, 2013 and 16 January, 2014, this Court is also prima facie of the view that the Commission has entered into an adjudicatory and determinative process by recording detailed and substantial reasoning at the Section 26(1) stage itself. In fact, by virtue of the impugned order, this Court is prima facie of the view that, even though the Commission in the penultimate paragraph has stated that the impugned order shall not tantamount to a final expression of opinion on merit of the case, the petitioner's remedy under Section 26(7) has been rendered illusory.

Consequently, present petition is tagged with W.P(C) 464/2014 and is directed to be listed on 26 May, 2014 before Joint Registrar for completion of pleadings. Till the next date of hearing, while the petitioner may give information as called upon by the Director General of Commission, no final order/report shall be passed either by the Commission or by its Director General.

Though the Director General of Commission is free to call any local officer of the petitioner for investigation purposes, but no officer stationed abroad shall be called without taking specific leave of this Court.

It is also made clear that the observations made by the Commission shall not come in the way of the petitioner negotiating with third parties or in the adjudication of the proceedings filed by either of the parties in this Court. Further, documents referred to in the order dated 28 November, 2013 may be used by the Commission for its investigation purpose, but shall not be disclosed/released to any third party.”

2. The reference to W.P(C) 464/2014 in the above extract is to the writ petition filed in the case of Micromax Informatics Limited. We may point out at this stage itself that on the basis of a complaint by Micromax, the Competition Commission has passed an order on 12.11.2013, which became the subject matter of the above mentioned W.P(C) 464/2014. In that writ petition, an order was passed on 21.01.2014 by a learned Single Judge of this Court in terms similar to the order dated 17.02.2014 passed in the present proceeding. Against the order dated 21.01.2014, two appeals being LPA No. 182/2014 and LPA No. 185/2014 have been preferred by the Competition Commission and Micromax respectively. Those appeals (LPA No. 182/2014 and LPA No. 185/2014) were disposed of by this Court on 24.02.2014 in the following manner:-

“The learned counsel appearing in LPA 182/2014 states that respondent No. 2 has been wrongly shown as a party and that the corrected memo of parties shall be filed in the course of the day.

After hearing the learned counsel for the parties on both sides at great length, we dispose of these appeals by directing only one modification in the impugned order dated 21.01.2014 The learned Single Judge by virtue of the said order had inter alia directed that:- “Though the Director General of the Competition Commission of India is free to call any local officer of the petitioner for investigation purpose, but no officer stationed abroad shall be called without taking specific leave of this Court.” We modify the above direction by indicating that in case the Director General of the Competition Commission of India feels that it is necessary for the presence of an officer stationed abroad, he shall notify the respondent No. 1 about the same. In case respondent No. 1 feels that the request is unreasonable, it would be open to the respondent No. 1 to move an application before the learned Single Judge for appropriate directions.

The parties are also at liberty to move an application before the learned Single Judge requesting him to expedite the hearing in the writ petition.

The appeals stand disposed of as above.”

3. Another point that we may note at this juncture is that the Competition Commission in its order dated 16.01.2014 in paragraphs 18 and 19 had specifically referred to the Micromax case based on the prima facie view taken in the case. This would be evident from paragraphs 18 and 19 of the order dated 16.01.2014 passed by the Competition Commission which are reproduced hereinbelow:-

“18. It is a matter of record that the practice of Ericsson of imposing discriminatory royalty rates contrary to FRAND terms, was previously considered by the Commission in Case No. 50/2013. In Re: Micromax Informatics Limited v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ), wherein the Commission had already formed a prima facie opinion under section 26(1) of the Act and directed the Director General to conduct an investigation.

19. In view of above, the Commission is of the opinion that the present case be clubbed for causing an investigation to be made under proviso to Section 26(1) of the Act, with the Case No. 50/2013, currently being investigated by the Director General.”

4. It is, therefore, evident from the above that the two cases, that is, the present one and the one pertaining to Micromax have been clubbed together by the Competition Commission and they are following the same route. Consequently, we find it difficult to pass an order in the present appeal which would be different from the order passed by us in LPA Nos. 182/2014 and 185/2014. The order passed by us on 24.02.2014 in LPA Nos. 182/2014 and 185/2014 shall also apply to the present proceeding.

5. The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.