Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Paltoo Ram Since Deceased Thr Lrs. & Ors. Petitioners v. Uma Devi

Delhi High Court
Jan 2, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Civil Revision under Section 115 CPC (Order dated 17 December 2012)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Section 115 CPC challenges the order dated 17 December 2012 by which objections filed by the petitioners in execution proceedings were dismissed with costs of Rs. 10,000.

Chronology (as stated in the opinion):

  • In 1974, Late Vinay Pal Sharma was shown as owner in revenue records. In March 1981 he filed CS (OS) No. 176/1981 against the MCD for permanent injunction as owner in possession of specified khasra numbers in village Chandrawali, Shahdara, Delhi.
  • Vinay Pal Sharma died on 8 April 1981. He was survived by his wife Smt. Krishna Devi and his mother Lt. Smt. Uma Devi.
  • Smt. Uma Devi (now respondent) filed a suit for possession and recovery of damages against the defendants on 23 August 1990; this suit was decreed by the Civil Judge on 7 January 2005.
  • The petitioners (judgment-debtors) filed a Regular First Appeal against the 7 January 2005 decree. During that appeal, Uma Devi died on 10 December 2005. Krishan Bal (K.B.) Sharma was substituted as her legal representative on the basis of a registered Will dated 16 December 1998.
  • The petitioners requested that Smt. Krishna Devi (daughter-in-law of Uma Devi) be impleaded as legal heir instead of Uma Devi. The petitioners also relied on alleged substitution and subsequent documents (Order XXII Rule 3 CPC application, amendment to plaint in 1982, mutation, agreements of sale and registered receipts from 1982–1983) to support their position.
  • Sh. K.B. Sharma's application for impleading him as legal representative was allowed by order dated 29 January 2007 and the order was upheld by a compromise order in CM(M) No. 755/2007 on 14 January 2008.
  • The petitioners' Regular Second Appeal against the eviction order was dismissed by this Court on 5 April 2011. Their Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court was dismissed as withdrawn.
  • During execution proceedings, the petitioners filed objections which were dismissed by the court of Sh. Anil Sisodia on 15 March 2010 with costs (Rs. 10,000). The petitioners' CRP No. 69/2010 was dismissed by this Court with costs of Rs. 40,000 on 15 September 2011.
  • An application under Section 340 Cr.P.C. against K.B. Sharma was dismissed on 1 June 2012.
  • Warrants of possession were issued in favour of the decree-holder and against the judgment-debtors. The judgment-debtors obstructed execution and raised objections to demarcation; the executing court allowed an application for demarcation on 22 July 2011 and the SDM's demarcation report dated 22 December 2011 favored the decree-holder.
  • The petitioners filed an objection under Section 47 CPC on 20 January 2012 seeking stay of execution until proper identification; this and other objections (Order 21 Rule 97 read with Section 47/151 CPC) were ultimately dismissed by Ms. Ravinder Bedi, SCJ, Delhi on 17 December 2012 with costs of Rs. 10,000.
  • Against that order of 17 December 2012 the present civil revision under Section 115 CPC was filed. The High Court dismissed the revision petition as misconceived and an abuse of process, and ordered the petitioners to deposit Rs. 20,000 with the Prime Minister's Relief Fund within four weeks.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a revision under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is maintainable against the order dated 17 December 2012 which dismissed the petitioners' objections in execution proceedings.
  2. Whether petitioners may re-agitate issues and rely upon documents not filed or proved during the original trial, particularly when those issues have been adjudicated up to the Supreme Court.
  3. Whether the petitioners can challenge the substitution/impleading of Krishan Bal Sharma as legal representative and related succession/Will matters after the order impleading him has been confirmed by consent.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted earlier procedural steps of substitution and mutation: an application under Order XXII Rule 3 CPC (3 July 1981) for substitution, an amended plaint dated 17 March 1982 signed by Lt. Uma Devi and Krishna Devi, and further affidavits and mutation leading to registration of the property in the name of Krishna Devi in August 1982.
  • They relied on documents showing Smt. Krishna Devi executed an agreement of sale and power of attorney dated 20 September 1982 in favour of the petitioners' predecessor, and produced registered receipts for payments (including amounts and dates) in 1982–1983.
  • They challenged the identification/demarcation of the suit property and sought to stay execution until proper identification as per the site plan.
  • The LR of judgment debtor No. 1 filed objections in execution under Section 47 CPC on 20 January 2012, and other judgment-debtors filed objections under Order 21 Rule 97 read with Section 47/151 CPC dated 17 February 2012, alleging fraud by the self-styled LR (Krishan Bal Sharma) and seeking prosecution.
  • In the present revision they relied on documents not filed or proved during the trial (some relating to separate litigation involving Uma Devi or Krishna Devi), which they sought to bring before the Court in the revision proceeding.

Respondent / Decree-holder's Position

  • The decree-holder (respondent) filed detailed replies to the execution objections and to the allegations made by the petitioners, opposing the stay and challenging the petitioners' contentions.
  • The decree-holder relied on the SDM demarcation report (22 December 2011) and on previous judicial determinations (including the order impleading K.B. Sharma and subsequent confirmations) to assert that the petitioners' attempts to re-open adjudicated issues were improper.
  • The decree-holder opposed considering the additional documents the petitioners sought to rely upon in the revision, noting those were not filed or proved during the original trial and related to different property litigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shiv Shakti Co-operative Housing Society, Nagpur v. Swaraj Developers, AIR 2003 SC 2434 Restatement of the scope of Section 115 CPC: (a) Section 115 is a supervisory power of the High Court and does not confer a substantive right of appeal; (b) revision under Section 115 is maintainable only when the impugned order would give finality to the suit or proceeding; interim orders or orders not finally deciding the lis are not ordinarily revisable; (c) legislative distinctions between procedural amendments and substantive rights (paras quoted: 13, 14, 15, 32, 33 in the opinion). The court relied on the principles in Shiv Shakti to conclude that the present revision under Section 115 was not maintainable because the impugned order did not give finality to the lis and the matters sought to be raised were procedural or already adjudicated; accordingly the revision was held to be misconceived and an abuse of process.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court proceeded by first setting out the factual and procedural matrix of prolonged litigation: original suit(s), substitution of representatives, appeals up to this Court and attempts to challenge identification and title during execution.

The Court then applied settled law on the scope and limits of revision under Section 115 CPC, principally relying on the Supreme Court decision in Shiv Shakti Co-operative Housing Society v. Swaraj Developers. The quoted passages emphasize that Section 115 is a supervisory power and does not create a substantive right to approach the High Court. The critical test established is whether the impugned order would have given finality to the suit or proceeding; if not (i.e., the order is interim or does not dispose of the lis finally), revision is generally not maintainable.

Applying that framework, the Court observed:

  • The petitioners were attempting to reopen matters already adjudicated through multiple rounds of litigation, including up to the Supreme Court.
  • Many of the documents relied upon in the present revision were not filed or proved in the original trial and related to separate litigation concerning a different property; such material could not be considered in the revision of the execution order.
  • The petitioners had earlier lost in the trial court, before this Court in the second appeal, and in other proceedings; they could not be permitted to re-agitate issues (including challenges to the registered Will and substitution) after a consent order confirming impleading of K.B. Sharma had been passed.
  • Because the impugned order dismissed objections in execution proceedings (and did not finally decide the entire lis in the sense contemplated by the test under Section 115), the revision under Section 115 was not an appropriate remedy and amounted to an abuse of process.

On this basis the Court found the revision to be "totally misconceived and an abuse of the process of law" and proceeded to dismiss it with a costs order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The civil revision under Section 115 CPC was dismissed as misconceived and an abuse of process, and the petitioners were ordered to pay costs of Rs. 20,000 to be deposited with the Prime Minister's Relief Fund within four weeks.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioners' challenge to the executing court's order of 17 December 2012 (dismissing their objections with costs) has been rejected and the execution process stands advanced in favour of the decree-holder subject to the existing orders (including warrants of possession and the SDM's demarcation report favoured by the decree-holder).
  • The Court reiterated and applied settled Supreme Court authority concerning the limited, supervisory nature of Section 115 CPC; it did not lay down novel legal principles or depart from existing precedent. The decision emphasizes that parties cannot use Section 115 to re-agitate issues finally adjudicated (including those adjudicated up to the Supreme Court) nor to introduce documents that were not part of the trial record in an attempt to derail execution.
  • No new precedent was created; the Court followed established law (as summarized from Shiv Shakti) to refuse revision against an order that did not give finality to the lis and to deter abuse of process by repetitive litigation.

All information in this summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text and does not include any external material or inference beyond what the opinion explicitly states.

Show all summary ...

MANMOHAN SINGH, J.

1. The petitioners have filed the present petition under Section 115 CPC against the order dated 17th December, 2012 whereby objection filed by the petitioners were dismissed with cost of Rs. 10,000.

2. Admittedly, the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners came into the possession of the disputed property through one Late Sh. Vinay Pal Sharma whose name was reflecting in the revenue record to be the owner in the year 1974. In March, 1981 Lt. Sh. Vinay Pal Sharma filed a suit being CS (OS) No. 176/1981 against MCD for permanent injunction, as owner in possession of Khasra Nos. 587, 586, 584 and 588 situated in village Chandrawali, Shahdara, Delhi.

3. The erstwhile owner, Lt. Sh. Vinay Pal Sharma expired on 8 April, 1981. He was survived by his wife Smt. Krishna Devi and mother Lt. Smt. Uma Devi.

4. Smt. Uma Devi (now respondent) filed suit for possession and recovery of damages against the defendants (now petitioners) on 23rd August, 1990 which was decreed by learned Civil Judge on 7 January, 2005.

5. The petitioners filed Regular First Appeal before District Judge, Delhi against the said judgment and decree dated 7 January, 2005.

6. During the pendency of first appeal, Smt. Uma Devi expired on 10 December, 2005. Sh. K.B Sharma is the real nephew and only LR of Smt. Uma Devi filed an application for substitution in her place in the first appeal on the basis of registered Will dated 16 December, 1998.

The petitioners made request that Smt. Krishna Devi, the daughter in law of Smt. Uma Devi who is admittedly remarried should be impleaded as legal heir in place of Smt. Uma Devi.

7. The case of the petitioners before the learned Trial Court was that on 3 July, 1981 an application under Order XXII Rule 3 CPC was moved by Lt. Smt. Uma Devi and Smt. Krishna Devi duly supported by an affidavit signed by Uma Devi for substitution in the said Civil Suit. An amendment plaint was filed on 17 March, 1982 in CS No. 176/1981 by newly substituted plaintiffs, Lt. Smt. Uma Devi and Krishna Devi, duly signed by both of them. The respondent i.e legal representative of Lt. Smt. Uma Devi filed an affidavit in July, 1982 claiming himself to be ‘Parokar’ for and on behalf of Smt. Krishna Devi and Lt. Smt. Uma Devi. On 3 August, 1982 an application was moved by Smt. Krishna Devi wife of Lt. Vinay Pal Sharma on basis of which the mutation and the property came to be registered in the name of Smt. Krishna Devi.

8. Smt. Krishna Devi executed an agreement of Sale and Power of Attorney on 20 September, 1982 in favour of predecessor in interest of the petitioners. She issued a receipt of payment of Rs. 14,800/- for the disputed land and the same is registered with the concerned Sub Registrar. The receipt for payment of Rs. 3000/- and Rs. 6500/- dated 17 January, 1983 on account of disputed land was issued by Smt. Krishna Devi in favour of Sushil Kumari and Chandrawati. The same was duly registered with the Sub Registrar.

9. The prayer of the petitioner was disallowed and Sh. K.B Sharma's application for impleading him as LR of Smt. Uma Devi was allowed vide order dated 29 January, 2007.

The said order was duly confirmed and upheld in CM(M) No. 755/2007 by order dated 14 January, 2008 when the said petition of the petitioners' was dismissed by a compromise order by Pradeep Nandrajog, J.

10. In the meanwhile, the petitioners filed Regular Second Appeal before this Court against the Eviction Order dated 7 January, 2005 and the said second appeal was also dismissed by this Court by order dated 5 April, 2011.

11. The said orders were also challenged by the petitioners before Supreme Court and the SLP filed by them was dismissed as withdrawn.

12. During the execution proceedings, the petitioners filed objections which were dismissed by the court of Sh. Anil Sisodia, SCJ, Delhi with cost of Rs. 10,000/- vide order dated 15 March, 2010.

13. The petitioners challenged the said order by filing CRP No. 69/2010 which was dismissed by this Court with cost of Rs. 40,000/- by order dated 15 September, 2011.

14. The petitioners thereafter filed another application under Section 340 Cr.P.C against Sh. K.B Sharma which was also dismissed by the court of Sh. Anil Sisodia, SCJ, vide order dated 1st June, 2012.

15. Thereafter, warrants of possession were issued by the executing court in favour of the decree holder and against the judgment debtors.

16. The judgment debtors/petitioners have not allowed to the court bailiff to execute warrant of possession and raised objections for the demarcation of the property by revenue department.

17. The said application was allowed by the executing court vide order dated 22nd July, 2011. The concerned SDM gave his report on 22 December, 2011 in favour of decree holders/respondent herein and against the judgment debtors/petitioner. The SDM has alleged in his report that there is no dispute about the identification of the property as per the site plan filed by the decree holder.

18. The identification of the property in question was also challenged by the petitioners during the pendency of the first appeal and the said defence was also rejected by the court of ADJ, Delhi when he dismissed first appeal of the petitioners vide order dated 9 July, 2008 which was later on confirmed upto Supreme Court.

19. The LR of judgment debtor No. 1 (petitioner herein) filed objections in the execution proceedings dated 20 January, 2012 under Section 47 CPC praying therein that the demarcation report of SDM dated 22 December, 2011 but the same was rejected as threshold wherein the prayer for the stay of the execution proceedings was made till the proper identification of the suit property as per site plan Ex.PW-1/2.

20. The decree holder has already given the detailed reply against the said objections and ultimately the said objections has been dismissed by the court of Ms. Ravinder Bedi, SCJ, Delhi with cost of Rs. 10,000/- by order dated 17 December, 2012.

21. Against the said order, the present civil revision has been filed before this Court.

22. The legal position as it stands today has been well-settled since the Supreme Court ruling of Shiv Shakti Co-operative Housing Society, Nagpur v. Swaraj Developers, AIR 2003 SC 2434. The Apex Court analysed the position both prior as well as post amendment acts of 1976 and 1999 and very well reiterated the difference between an appeal and a revision in the following paragraphs:

“13…It is fairly well-settled position in law that the right of appeal is a substantive right. But there is no substantive right in making an application under Section 115.

15. ..Language of Sections 96 and 100 of the Code which deal with appeals compared with Section 115 of the Code. While in the former two provisions specifically provide for right to appeal, the same is not the position vis-à-vis Section 115. It does not speak of an application being made by a person aggrieved by an order of subordinate court. As noted above, it is a source of power of the High Court to have effective control on the functioning of the subordinate courts by exercising supervisory power.”

The court summed up the present legal position in the following paragraphs:

“14…. Section 115 is essentially a source of power for the High Court to supervise the subordinate courts. It does not in any way confer a right on a litigant aggrieved by any order of the subordinate court to approach the High Court for relief. The scope for making a revision under Section 115 is not linked with a substantive right.”

“32. …..A plain reading of Section 115 as it stands makes it clear that the stress is on the question whether the order in favour of the party applying for revision would have given finality to suit or other proceeding. If the answer is ‘yes’ then the revision is maintainable. Suit on the contrary, if the answer is ‘no’ then the revision is not maintainable. Therefore, if the impugned order is of interim in nature or does not finally decide the lis, the revision will not be maintainable. The legislative intent is crystal clear. Those orders, which are interim in nature, cannot be the subject matter of revision under Section 115. There is marked distinction in language of Section 97(3) of the Old Amendment Act and Section 32(2) (i) of the Amendment Act. While in the former, there was clear legislative intent to save applications admitted or pending before the amendment came into force. Such an intent is significantly absent in section 32(2)(i). The amendment relates to procedures. No person has a vested right in a course of procedure. He has only the right of proceeding in the manner prescribed. If by a statutory change the mode of procedure is altered the parties are to proceed according to the altered made, without exception, unless there is a different stipulation.”

“33…Section 6 of the General Clauses Act has no application because there is no substantive vested right available to a party seeking revision under Section 115 of the Code.”

23. Judgment debtors No. 2 to 4 (petitioner Nos. 2 to 4 herein) also filed their separate objections under Order 21 Rule 97 read with Section 47/151 CPC dated 17 February, 2012, praying therein that the present execution be proceeded in accordance with law and so called self styled LR of Smt. Uma Devi namely Krishan Bal Sharma and his attorney be prosecuted for playing fraud before the court in accordance with law. The reply was filed by the decree holder.

The said objections has also been dismissed by the learned execution court by order dated 17 December, 2012 passed by Ms. Ravinder Bedi, SCJ, Delhi, with cost of Rs. 10,000/-.

24. The petitioners have relied upon the documents in the present civil revision petition which were not filed or proved during the trial of the case i.e between the litigation of Uma Devi or Krishna Devi against MCD in respect of another property which is not subject matter of the present dispute. Thus, the same cannot be considered in the present revision petition as all the disputed issues/questions which have already been adjudicated and decided upto Supreme Court. These cannot be re-agitated in the present petition by the judgment debtors/petitioners.

25. The petitioners/judgment debtors who lost their case in three rounds of litigation can be allowed to raise their objection with regard to registered Will dated 16 December, 1998 executed by Late Smt. Uma Devi in favour of Sh. Krishan Bal Sharma after the consent order dated 14 January, 2008 passed by Pradeep Nandrajog, J. in CM(M) No. 755/2007 confirming the order dated 29 January, 2007 passed by learned ADJ, Delhi impleading Sh. Krishan Bal Sharma as legal heir of Smt. Uma Devi.

26. In view of the abovesaid reasons and settled law, the present revision petition filed by the petitioners is totally misconceived and an abuse of the process of law. There is no merit in the petition. The same is dismissed with costs of Rs. 20,000/- which shall be deposited by the petitioners with Prime Minister Relief Fund within four weeks from today.