Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Satya Infrastructure Ltd. v. Satya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd.

Delhi High Court
Feb 7, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs filed a suit seeking a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from conducting business under the mark "SATYA" or any other mark or trading name identical or deceptively similar to the plaintiffs' "SATYA" logo/label. The plaintiffs also sought delivery of infringing materials, rendition of accounts, and recovery of damages amounting to Rs.21,00,000/-. Summons and notices for interim relief were issued and served on the defendant, but the defendant failed to appear despite multiple summons. Consequently, the defendant was proceeded against ex parte. The plaintiffs agreed to forgo reliefs other than the injunction for the interim hearing. The suit involves allegations that the defendant's use of "SATYA" infringes the plaintiffs' registered trademarks and causes likelihood of confusion among consumers.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant's use of the mark "SATYA" in its business name constitutes infringement of the plaintiffs' registered trademark rights under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
  2. Whether the defendant's business name is deceptively similar to the plaintiffs' mark and likely to cause confusion or passing off.
  3. Whether a permanent injunction should be granted restraining the defendant from using the mark "SATYA" or any deceptively similar mark.
  4. Whether the defendant should be granted time to rectify its company name in compliance with Section 20 of the Companies Act, 1956.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court found that the plaintiffs are the licensed users of the registered trademark "SATYA" in Classes 36, 37, and 43, having used the mark continuously for approximately 25 years with substantial business presence and turnover. The defendant's incorporation and use of the name "Staya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd." in similar business fields was held to be an infringement of the plaintiffs' registered trademark and likely to cause confusion among customers, suggesting an association with the plaintiffs' business. The Court rejected the necessity for plaintiffs to lead ex parte evidence beyond the verified plaint and affidavits already on record, considering that such evidence would be repetitive. The Court also noted the statutory prohibition under Section 20 of the Companies Act, 1956, against registration of a company name identical or deceptively similar to an existing registered trademark. Recognizing that rectification of the defendant's company name may take time, the Court granted a grace period of three months before the injunction becomes operative.

Holding and Implications

Decree for permanent injunction granted.

The Court permanently restrained the defendant from carrying on business under the name "Satya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd." or any other name identical or deceptively similar to the plaintiffs' trademark "SATYA" and from offering or selling goods or services under such marks. The injunction is to become operative after three months to allow the defendant time to rectify its company name as per the prescribed procedure under the Companies Act. The plaintiffs were granted liberty to serve the judgment and decree on the Registrar of Companies to enable enforcement actions, including coercive name change or striking off the defendant company if it fails to comply. No order as to costs was made since the defendant did not contest the suit. This decision directly affects the parties by protecting the plaintiffs' trademark rights and preventing the defendant's infringing use, but it does not establish any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

The plaintiffs have sued for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from carrying on business under the mark "SATYA" or any other Mark / trading name identical or deceptively similar to the logo / label "SATYA" of the plaintiffs and for delivery of infringing stationary, hoardings, boards, printed material, dies, block etc. and for rendition of accounts and recovery of damages of Rs.21,00,000/-.

2. Summons of the suit and notice of the application for interim relief were issued to the defendant. The plaintiffs filed affidavit of service with proof of delivery of summons on the defendant. However, vide order dated 12.10.2012, fresh summons of the suit were issued to the defendant. Another affidavit of service together with report generated from the website of DHL Couriers was filed and on perusal whereof, the Joint Registrar was satisfied that the shipment had been delivered on 16.11.2012. None appeared for the defendant. Accordingly, the matter has been placed before this Bench for appropriate orders against the defendant. Today also none has appeared for the defendant. The counsel for the plaintiffs presses for interim injunction.

3. The plaintiffs have given the address of the defendant of Bangalore, Karnataka. The affidavit of service dated 26.11.2012 has been filed by the Court Clerk of the Advocate for the plaintiffs to the effect that notice was sent to the defendant by Blue Dart Courier on 15.11.2012 and was delivered on 16.11.2012. There is no reason for this Court to disbelieve the said affidavit emanating from the chamber of the Advocate for the plaintiffs and it has to be presumed that the shipment which has been reported to be delivered to the defendant contained the summons of the suit and notice of the application together with copies of the plaint, application and other documents etc. If it is discovered otherwise, of course the Advocate for the plaintiffs would be accountable. The defendant is thus proceeded against ex parte.

4. The next question which arises is whether this Court should consider the application for interim relief and direct the plaintiffs to lead ex parte evidence. The counsel for the plaintiffs states that the plaintiffs are willing to give up the reliefs of delivery, of rendition of accounts and of recovery of damages, if the suit for the relief of injunction alone were to be heard today.

5. I am of the opinion that no purpose will be served in such cases by directing the plaintiffs to lead ex parte evidence in the form of affidavit by way of examination-in chief and which invariably is a repetition of the contents of the plaint. The plaint otherwise, as per the amended CPC, besides being verified, is also supported by affidavits of the plaintiffs. I fail to fathom any reason for according any additional sanctity to the affidavit by way of examination-in-chief than to the affidavit in support of the plaint or to any exhibit marks being put on the documents which have been filed by the plaintiffs and are already on record. I have therefore heard the counsel for the plaintiffs on merits qua the relief of injunction.

6. The plaintiffs have pleaded:

(i) that the three plaintiffs viz. Satya Infrastructure Ltd., Satya Developers Pvt. Ltd. and Satya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. have been incorporated in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and all belong to what is known as the „Satya Group‟, which commenced business operations in the year 1986 under the word mark "SATYA" and is now providing services in financial affairs, integrated townships, group housing and villas, hospitality, service sector, commercial complexes, IT parks, shopping complexes, multiplexes, real estate, mall development and management and infrastructure development etc.
(ii) The "SATYA" Group is associated with a shopping mall-cum-
commercial complex in the name of Centrum Plaza, another shopping mall in the name of City Centre, a township in the name of Malwa County, a five star hotel-cum-shopping mall in the name of Galaxy Hotel Shopping and Spa and apartments, penthouses etc. in the name of The Legend etc.
(iii) That the plaintiffs businesses are spread across India particularly in the National Capital Region of Delhi and Madhya Pradesh.
(iv) That the combined annual turnover of the plaintiffs for the year 2009-10 was approximately Rs.3219.13 lakhs.
(v) The Trademark "STAYA" was coined by the Promoter Director of the plaintiffs‟ companies and the plaintiffs are the licenced users thereof.
(vi) That the mark "SATYA" has been continuously used in the trading name and as a house mark and / or service mark for all business activities of the plaintiffs.
(vii) That all the projects of the plaintiffs have been promoted and sold under the trademark "SATYA" for the last approximately 25 years.
(viii) That the plaintiffs have secured Registration under the Trademark Act, 1999 for the exclusive use of the Trademark "SATYA", its variants and most of its group marks and has already obtained registration on 02.01.2006 and 04.07.2006 of "SATYA & Logo" and "SATYA Group & Device"
respectively and as many as 14 other applications are pending.
(ix) That the Trademark "SATYA" features prominently in print and electronic media having wide circulation and the promotional and developmental expenses incurred by the plaintiffs since the year 2006 onwards are in the region of Rs.1.5 crores.
(x) "SATYA" has attained the distinction of a well known mark.
(xi) That the defendant Company was incorporated on 05.09.2009 to carry on business inter alia of real estate development and construction.
(xii) That the name of the defendant containing the word "SATYA"
constitutes infringement / violation of the statutory and common law rights of the plaintiffs.
(xiii) That the defendant has used the name "SATYA" in its name to gain unfair advantage over the goodwill of the plaintiffs.
(xiv) That though a legal notice dated 11.10.2010 was issued to the defendant but no reply was received thereto.
(xv) That the use of the mark "SATYA" of the plaintiffs by the defendant in its trade name is intended to pass off the services of the defendant as that of the plaintiffs.

7. The plaintiffs along with the plaint have inter alia filed:

(i) Certificates of Incorporation together with Memorandum and Articles of Association of the three plaintiffs which show that the plaintiff No.2 was incorporated on 05.09.1995 in the name of Khushahali Farms Pvt. Ltd. and with effect from the year 2005 changed its name to SATYA Developers Pvt. Ltd; that the plaintiff No.3 Satya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. was incorporated under the same name on 15.12.1986; and, the plaintiff No.1 Satya Infrastructure Ltd. was incorporated on 15.07.2005 as Prabhatam Developers Ltd and on 08.03.2006 changed its name to Satya Infrastructures Ltd.
(ii) The brochures of the real estate projects developed by the plaintiffs prominently bearing the name SATYA Group.
(iii) The four Registration Certificates dated 02.01.2006 and 04.07.2006 of the following logos:
in Classes 42, 36, 37 and 41 respectively.
(iv) The copies of other pending applications of the plaintiffs for registration of trademark.
(v) The advertisements published by the plaintiffs again under the mark SATYA Group.
(vi) Ex parte order dated 28.02.2011 in CS(OS) No.483/2011 filed by the plaintiffs against the Satya Builders Pvt. Ltd., restraining the defendants therein from carrying on business under the trading name containing the mark SATYA (on enquiry it is told that the said suit is still pending for ex parte evidence).
(vii) Printout from the website www.satyagroup.com and www.satyadevelopers.com detailing the activities of the plaintiffs.

8. The counsel for the plaintiffs during the hearing has informed that the Promoter Director of the plaintiffs on 18.07.2012, 27.07.2012 and 28.07.2012 has also been granted registration of the name SATYA in Classes 37, 43 and 36 respectively. Copies of the Registration Certificates have been handed over in the Court and are taken on record.

9. Though no document to show that the defendant was incorporated only in the year 2009 as pleaded have been filed but the defendant having chosen not to contest the suit, there is no reason for this Court to disbelieve the said pleading duly supported by affidavit of the plaintiffs

10. Once it is found that the plaintiffs have obtained registration of the mark in Classes 36, 37 & 43, the carrying on business by the defendant in the name and style of Staya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd. is clearly an infringement of the registered Trademark of which the plaintiffs are licensed users. Even otherwise from the documents I am satisfied that the plaintiffs are carrying on business under the Mark / Label / Logo "SATYA" and carrying on business by the defendant in the name and style Staya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd. in the same fields / areas / sphere in which, plaintiffs are carrying on business is likely to cause confusion and which in the minds of the customers/patrons of the said business, likely to cause confusion and convey an impression of the defendant belonging to the group under aegis of which the plaintiffs are carrying on business and of the business of the defendant being that of the plaintiffs.

11. I am therefore of the view that the plaintiffs have made out a case for injuncting the defendant from carrying on business in the name of Staya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd. and / or from, in the course of its business, use the trademark "SATYA" of the plaintiffs or any other mark deceptively similar thereto.

12. Section 20 of the Companies Act, 1956 also prohibits registration of a company in a name which is identical with or too nearly resembles the name by which a company in existence has been previously registered or a registered trade mark, or a trade mark which is subject of an application for registration, of any other person under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

13. However, since the defendant would be required to rectify its name by following the prescribed procedure and which process may take some time, it is deemed expedient to grant three months time to the defendant and to make the injunction operative after the said time.

14. A decree for permanent injunction is accordingly passed in favour of the plaintiffs and against the defendant, to be operative after three months herefrom, restraining the defendant from carrying on business in the name of Satya Infra & Estates Pvt. Ltd. or in any other name identical to or deceptively similar to or containing the trademark "SATYA" of the plaintiffs and / or from offering, selling or offering for sale any goods or services under the trade name or mark "SATYA" or any other trade name or mark deceptively similar to the trademark / label/ logo "SATYA" of the plaintiffs.

15. Decree sheet be drawn up.

16. The defendant however having not contested the suit. No order as to costs.

17. The plaintiffs are given liberty to serve a copy of this judgment and decree upon the Registrar of Companies with which the defendant is registered to enable the said Registrar of Companies to, upon failure of the defendant, undertake steps for rectification of defendant‟s name and coercively change the name of the defendant in compliance with this judgment and/or strike off the defendant from the Register of the Companies.

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J FEBRUARY 07, 2013 „gsr‟..