Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sushil Kumar Gupta v. Prem Gupta & Ors

Delhi High Court
Jan 31, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — Sanjay Kishan Kaul, J. (ORAL)

Factual and Procedural Background

The “Gupta” family conducted business under a partnership firm called Deoki Nandan & Sons. Disputes arose among family members concerning, inter alia, the immovable property where they resided at 1, Tughlak Lane, New Delhi. By an order dated 18.11.1985 in Suit No. 2164A/1985 the disputes were referred to sole arbitration by Mr. Justice Jaswant Singh (Retd.), who issued an award dated 8.6.1988. One of the issues before the arbitrator was whether equal physical division of the property among four parties with separate titles was possible or equitable.

The arbitrator obtained an architect's report and a response from the Land & Development Office (the perpetual lessor). The land was found earmarked for group housing and sub-division was not permitted; the arbitrator concluded that equal physical division with separation of title was not possible and, in absence of consent and feasible development alternative, the property should be disposed of by public auction with parties free to bid.

The award was filed in Court; objections were dismissed and the award was made rule of the court on 17.9.1990. Appeals were dismissed on 18.9.1991. Subsequent execution proceedings (Execution Petition No. 63/1993) followed. Prior to execution some co-owners entered into an agreement to transfer their rights under the decree, bringing respondent No. 10 (Titan Estates Private Limited) into the proceedings. The appellant held a 25% share and respondent No. 9 held the remaining 25% share (as recorded in the opinion).

Respondent No. 10 filed EA No. 590/2009 concerning stamp duty for preparation of the decree sheet arising from the award made rule of the court. The Single Judge (order dated 20.4.2011) issued notice to the Stamp Collector and the Chief Controlling Officer for a valuation report. A Tehsildar valuation report led to an impugned order dated 20.12.2011 fixing stamp duty at 1% of the reported value of Rs. 6,33,99,000 (amounting to Rs. 6,36,192).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the award/decree made rule of the court (which directs sale rather than division by metes and bounds because the property is not divisible) is an "instrument of partition" within the meaning of Section 2(15) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and thus required to be engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper.
  2. Whether the stamp duty calculation/order (based on the Tehsildar valuation fixing duty at 1% of Rs. 6,33,99,000) for preparation of the decree sheet was legally correct in the circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

Common submissions of learned counsel for the appellant and respondent No. 10

  • The calculation of stamp duty in the impugned order appears to proceed under a misconception of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and relevant judicial pronouncements of this Court.
  • Reference was made to Article 45 of Schedule I (relating to instruments of partition) and Section 2(15) of the Stamp Act (definition of “instrument of partition”).
  • It was submitted that the award made rule of the court cannot be treated as an instrument of partition because it does not divide or agree to divide the property in severalty; rather it directed sale (distribution of sale proceeds) because physical division by metes and bounds was not possible.

Position conveyed for the Government of NCT of Delhi / Collector of Stamps (as recorded)

  • After examining the matter in light of the cited judgment, the opinion of the Collector of Stamps (as reported to the Court) was that the award/decree in the present case would not require stamping as an instrument of partition; instead the sale deed executed post-auction would require proper stamping and registration.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.N. Khanna v. B.K. Khanna, 87 (2000) DLT 286 (DB) : 2000 (55) DRJ 544 (DB) The principle that only decrees which effect a division of property in severalty by metes and bounds constitute an "instrument of partition" under Section 2(15) of the Stamp Act and therefore must be engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper; decrees which merely provide for sale of the property (because partition by metes and bounds is not possible) are not instruments of partition and need not be drawn on stamp paper—the sale deed later will need stamping. The Court treated this authority as dispositive on the issue. It applied the reasoning that since the award/decree did not effect a division by metes and bounds but directed sale, it did not fall within the definition of an "instrument of partition" and therefore did not require engrossment on non-judicial stamp paper.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by comparing the facts in the present case to the discussion in K.N. Khanna v. B.K. Khanna. The key analytical steps, as recorded in the opinion, are:

  1. The Stamp Act definition (Section 2(15)) and Article 45 of Schedule I were engaged because the parties questioned whether the decree/award must be stamped as an "instrument of partition".
  2. The Court noted the arbitrator's findings (from the award) and the subsequent proceedings: the land was earmarked for group housing, subdivision by metes and bounds was not permitted, and the arbitrator concluded that equal physical division with separate titles amongst the four parties was not feasible—therefore the property was to be sold by public auction and proceeds divided.
  3. Relying on the Division Bench judgment in K.N. Khanna, the Court emphasized that an instrument falls within the statutory definition of "instrument of partition" only where there is a conclusive determination of rights by actually partitioning the property by metes and bounds, thereby creating exclusive rights in specific portions.
  4. Where the decree/orders do not allot or vest particular shares in physical portions (i.e., there is no partition by metes and bounds) but instead direct sale of the property, such decrees do not amount to instruments of partition; consequently, such decrees need not be engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper. In such cases the sale deed (executed later) is the document that must be stamped and registered.
  5. The Collector of Stamps (as advised through Government of NCT of Delhi's counsel) concurred with the view that the decree here did not require stamping and that the sale deed post-auction would need proper stamping.
  6. Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the award/decree in the present matter did not effect partition by metes and bounds and therefore was not an instrument of partition requiring engrossment on non-judicial stamp paper.

Holding and Implications

Appeal allowed; impugned order set aside — the decree (award made rule of the court) is not required to be engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper because it does not effect division by metes and bounds (i.e., it is not an "instrument of partition").

Direct consequences of the decision (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The impugned order dated 20.12.2011 fixing stamp duty on the decree is set aside.
  • The decree/award made rule of the court need not be stamped as an instrument of partition because it directs sale rather than a metes-and-bounds partition.
  • Any sale deed executed after auction or other mode of disposal will require proper stamping and registration; the rights, title and interest of the parties will terminate upon execution of the sale deed as contemplated by the earlier authorities cited.
  • The appeal was allowed and the parties were directed to bear their own costs.
  • The Registry was directed to prepare the decree sheet accordingly.

The opinion relies on existing case law to resolve the legal question and does not state any broader or novel precedent beyond applying the authority cited to the facts before the Court.

Show all summary ...

Sanjay Kishan Kaul, J. (ORAL):— The “Gupta” family was carrying on business under a partnership firm known as Deoki Nandan & Sons. Disputes arose inter se the family members including qua immovable property where the parties were residing known as 1, Tughlak Lane, New Delhi. A reference was made vide order dated 18.11.1985 in Suit No. 2164A/1985 for resolution of disputes to the sole arbitration of Mr. Justice Jaswant Singh (Retd.) who made and published an award dated 8.6.1988 One of the issues framed before the arbitrator was as under:

“7. Whether equal physical division of the property namely I-Tughlak Lane, New Delhi amongst four parties with separate titles is possible/equitable? If not, in what manner it can be best sold/disposed off? (Onus on parties).”

2. The findings on this issue were recorded by the arbitrator after obtaining a report from an architect as also a response from the Land & Development Office, Government of India, being the perpetual lessor. The result of the aforesaid was that the land was found earmarked for group housing building and sub-division of the plot was not permitted. It was, thus, opined by the learned arbitrator that equal physical division amongst the four parties with separation of title was not possible. The alternative proposal for development of the property, in the absence of consent, was also not feasible and, thus, the only methodology for disposal of the property was by public auction in which even the parties would be free to offer their bids.

3. The aforesaid award was filed in Court to which objections were filed which were dismissed and the award was made rule of the court on 17.9.1990 in the earlier suit proceedings. The appeal against the same were dismissed on 18.9.1991

4. The matter did not end at this as second round of litigation started in the execution proceedings. It appears that prior to the execution proceedings, being Execution Petition No. 63/1993, some of the co-owners entered into an agreement to sell for transfer of their rights under the decree and that is how respondent No. 10 came into the picture. The appellant is holder of 25 per cent share while respondent No. 9 is the holder of remaining 25 per cent share. It is not, however, necessary to go into further details qua these execution proceedings but suffice it to say that an application came to be filed, being EA No. 590/2009; by respondent No. 10.Titan Estates Private Limited qua the issue of stamp duty to be filed for preparation of decree sheet arising from the award being made rule of the court.

5. The learned Single Judge in terms of the order dated 20.4.2011 considered it appropriate to issue notice to the Stamp Collector, Delhi and the Chief Controlling Officer to give a valuation report. It is this valuation report submitted by the Tehsildar from the Office of the DC, New Delhi which has given rise to the impugned order dated 20.12.2011 The learned Single Judge opined that on the basis of the valuation the stamp duty would have to be calculated on 1 per cent of the value referred to of Rs. 6,33,99,000.00 and, thus, Rs. 6,36,192.00 has to be paid as stamp duty.

6. The common submission of the learned counsel for the appellant and respondent No. 10 is that the calculation of the stamp duty payable appears to be under misconception of legal provisions of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘said Act’) as also the judicial pronouncements of this Court.

7. In respect of the aforesaid a reference has been made to Section 3(a) of the said Act, which reads as under:

“3. Instruments chargeable with duty

Subject to the provisions of this Act and the exemptions contained in Schedule I, the following instruments shall be chargeable with duty of the amount indicated in that Schedule as the proper duty therefor, respectively, that is to say—

(a) every instrument mentioned in that Schedule which, not having been previously executed by any person, is executed in [India] on or after the first day of July, 1899;”

8. Learned counsels have thereafter invited our attention to Article 45 of Schedule 1 which deals with instruments of partition and states that the stamp duty is payable as is payable on a bond under Article 15. Learned counsel has thereafter in the aforesaid context referred to section 2(15) which defines an ‘instrument of partition’ as under:

“2. Definitions

xx.xxxx

(15) “Instrument of partition” means any instrument whereby co-owners of any property divide or agree to divide such property in severalty, and includes also a final order for effecting a partition passed by any revenue-authority or any civil court and an award by an arbitrator directing a partition;”

9. It is, thus, the submission of the learned counsels that in the present case the award which is made rule of the court cannot be treated as an instrument of partition as it does not divide or agree to divide a property in severalty. It is submitted that, in fact, even the shares of the parties were not in dispute but the assets of the partnership were to be divided and what has to be found out whether the immovable property was divisible by metes and bounds and if such division by metes and bounds had been occasioned then only the decree would be required to be stamped as an instrument of partition.

10. Learned counsels have relied upon the judgement of the Division Bench of this Court in K.N Khanna v. B.K Khanna., 87 (2000) DLT 286 (DB) : 2000 (55) DRJ 544 (DB) to advance the said proposition. The factual matrix was quite similar inasmuch as property known as No. 22, Amrita Shergil Marg, New Delhi being a leasehold property was subject matter of dispute. The matter was referred to arbitration where the arbitrator so appointed opined that the property was not capable of being partitioned by metes and bounds and, thus, the only course open was to sell the property and divide the sale proceeds (again an identical fact). The house had been built for a single family and, thus, could not have been divided into two halves. A specific issue was framed and a conclusion reached that it was not feasible to divide the property into two portions. In the execution proceedings a specific issue was framed whether the decree had been engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper and, thus, could it be put to execution unless so engrossed. The specific issue No. 4 framed is as under:

“(4) What is the effect of the decree if the same has not been engrossed on a non-judicial stamp paper?”

11. The discussion qua the aforesaid issue is contained in paragraphs 40 & 41 which are reproduced here in under:

“40. There is no manner of doubt that in a suit for partition after a preliminary decree is passed declaring rights, title or interest of the parties, which decree makes a provision for partition of the suit property by metes and bounds and of separate possession in terms of the rights declared under the said decree, which has to be treated as preliminary, further inquiry is required to be held to enable the Court to finally and conclusively determine rights of the parties by actually partitioning the said property by metes and bounds. In order to do so, usually the task is assigned to a Commissioner to suggest mode of partition, who usually suggests the mode and manner of dividing the property. On receipt of such a report and deciding objections of the parties, if any, the Court then proceeds to pass a final decree declaring the persons entitled to separate shares, which enable the parties thereafter to hold and enjoy the property separately. Such a division of the property has the effect of creation of an exclusive right of a person in that portion of the property, which falls to his share and extinguishes his right, title or interest in those portions, which fall the exclusive shares of the others. This decree of course would be covered by the definition of “instrument of partition”, as defined in Clause (15) of Section 2 of Indian Stamp Act. “Instrument of partition” is defined therein to mean any instrument whereby co-owners of any property divide or agree to divide such property in severality, and include also a final order for effecting a partition passed by any Revenue Authority or any Civil Court and an award by an Arbitrator directing partition. In case partition is effected of a property even by an Arbitrator by his award, the same would fall in the definition of “instrument of partition”. So also a decree of Civil Court affecting partition of the property would fall in the said definition and the same would be required to be stamped according to the provisions of Indian Stamp Act.

41. But it is not that every decree in a partition suit would be required to be drawn up on a stamp paper. Only those decrees will be required to be drawn up on a stamp paper, which divide any property in severality amongst co-owners. In the instant case neither by award made by C.K Daphtary nor by order dated 15-4-1983 the property has been ordered to be divided or agreed to be divided in severality. Only a tentative arrangement was made for enjoying the property separately, which was only a temporary measure whereby the parties continued to be the joint owners of each and every part of the property though separately enjoying separate portions. The decree nowhere provided for separation or division of the property in severality since it was held that the property is incapable of being divided in two equal shares or that the division by metes and bounds was not possible. Therefore, the mode suggested was to sell the property and then divide sale proceeds in equal shares. Such an award or a decree would not come within the definition of “instrument of partition”, pursuant to the said decree passed in the suit, in case the property is sold, the rights, title and interest of the appellant and the respondents would come to an end, on sale deed being drawn and executed on a stamp paper, after the sale is confirmed by the Court. Only the said instrument of sale will be required to be stamped and thereafter got registered. Such a decree as was passed on 15-4-1983, is not required to be drawn on a stamp paper. Only such of the decrees are required to be drawn on a stamp paper, which allot and vest particular share in each co-sharer and not those decrees, which only make a provision for sale of the property. In later decrees only the instrument of sale would be required to be drawn on a stamp paper so as to vest exclusive rights in the property in favour of the auction purchaser.”

(emphasis supplied)

12. In our view the issue raised in the present appeal is really no more res integra in view of the aforesaid discussion. It has already been held in the aforesaid judgement that there has to be conclusive determination of rights by actually partitioning the property by metes and bounds for it to be engrossed on non-judicial stamp paper. This would facilitate holding an enjoyment of property separately and exclusive rights in the respective portions which would amount to an instrument of partition. Every decree in partition suit would not require to be drawn up on stamp paper and if there is no such division but on the other hand the property is sold, the rights, title, and interest of the property would come to an end on the sale deed being drawn and executed on a stamp paper. It is only such instrument of sale which would be required to be stamped and thereafter got registered.

13. In fact, learned counsel for the Government of NCT of Delhi fairly states, on instructions received, that haying examined the matter in the conspectus of the aforesaid judgement the opinion of the Collector of Stamps is also that the award/decree in the present case would not require to be stamped but it is the sale deed which would have to be executed post auction or any other mode of disposal for it to be required to be properly stamped.

14. The result of the aforesaid is that the impugned order is set aside holding that there would be no requirement of the decree being engrossed on a non-judicial stamp paper as it is not an instrument of partition, there being no division by metes and bounds of the property.

15. At request of learned counsel for respondent No. 10 we clarify that though initially there were two aspects to be examined in the appeal as noticed in the order dated 22.2.2012, the subsequent order dated 14.3.2012 records that the other aspect does not remain alive as the property is now to be put to public auction.

16. The appeal is accordingly allowed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

17. The Registry to prepare the decree sheet accordingly.