Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shub Lata Petitioner v. Bimla Devi & Ors. S

Delhi High Court
Mar 1, 2012
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was filed for partition and permanent injunction in respect of a plot bearing No. 20, B-VI Extension, Safderjung Enclave, Arjun Nagar, New Delhi. The plot had been acquired by Smt. Satya Devi from her late husband Ram Dass. Smt. Satya Devi died intestate in 2009. At the time of death of Ram Dass and Smt. Satya Devi there were no Class-I legal heirs, and the property therefore devolved upon the petitioner and the respondents as Class-II legal heirs.

The petitioner and respondent No. 2 are nieces of late Ram Dass; respondent No. 1 is his sister. After Satya Devi's death the petitioner sought a settlement over the suit property, but the respondents did not act on that request, leading the petitioner to file the present petition.

The petition was first listed on 05.04.2010 and registered as an independent petition. The court called for a report from the SDM concerning the petitioner's resources and referred the matter to the Joint Registrar to enquire whether the petitioner was an indigent person under the provisions noted in the record (Order 33 Rules 4 and 5 of the CPC). On 29.04.2011 the Joint Registrar recorded the petitioner's statement under Order 33 Rule 4 and passed an order under Order 33 Rule 5 finding no ground to reject the application to sue as an indigent person, fixing further inquiry dates, and directing respondents to file replies and rejoinders within specified periods.

Respondent No. 1 challenged the Joint Registrar's order dated 29.04.2011 by way of the present appeal, contending that the inquiry should examine the validity of the cause of action and not only the petitioner's resources. The petitioner filed a reply, stating the impugned order was passed in accordance with law and expressing no objection to the petitioner being cross-examined on the point of cause of action. The court dismissed the appeal and disposed of it.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 29.04.2011 of the Joint Registrar—proceeding with an inquiry into the petitioner's indigency and fixing dates for evidence—should be set aside on the ground that the inquiry must also examine the validity of the cause of action on which the suit is founded, and not consider only the petitioner's resources.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Respondent No. 1) Arguments

  • The order dated 29.04.2011 of the Joint Registrar is liable to be set aside because, during the inquiry, the Court must also examine the validity of the cause of action on the basis of which the suit was filed, and not restrict the inquiry merely to the petitioner's resources.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The impugned order was passed by the Joint Registrar in accordance with law.
  • The learned counsel for the petitioner stated there was no objection if the petitioner was cross-examined by the respondent on the point of cause of action.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the challenge to the Joint Registrar's order and the petitioner's reply. The petitioner expressly stated (through counsel) that she had no objection to being cross-examined on the question of cause of action. In light of that position and the material before the court (the Joint Registrar's order recording the petitioner's statement and directing further inquiry and filings), the court concluded that no additional order was necessary. The opinion is brief: having noted the parties' positions and the procedural steps already ordered by the Joint Registrar (including calling the SDM report, recording the petitioner's statement under Order 33 Rule 4, and fixing dates for detailed inquiry under Order 33 Rule 5), the court dismissed the appeal without further intervention.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Direct effect: The appeal against the Joint Registrar's order dated 29.04.2011 was dismissed and the impugned order stands. The procedural directions in that order (including proceeding to evidence on indigency, allowing the respondents to file replies and rejoinder within the timelines specified, and the prospect of cross-examination on cause of action as accepted by the petitioner) remain in force.

Broader implications: The opinion does not elaborate on or announce any broader legal principle or precedent beyond the disposition of the appeal; it addresses the immediate procedural dispute and leaves the Joint Registrar's order undisturbed.

Show all summary ...

MANMOHAN SINGH, J. (Oral)

1. The present petition has been filed for partition and permanent injunction. The brief factual matrix of the case is that a plot bearing No. 20, B-VI Extension, Safderjung Enclave, Arjun Nagar, New Delhi, was acquired by Smt. Satya Devi from her late husband Ram Dass. Smt. Satya Devi died intestate in the year 2009. Since at the time of death of Ram Dass and his wife Smt. Satya Devi, there were no Class-I legal heirs of both of them, therefore, the property devolved upon the petitioner and the respondents, Class-II legal heirs.

2. The petitioner and respondent No. 2 are the nieces of late Ram Dass whereas respondent No. 1 is his sister. After the death of Satya Devi, the petitioner asked for settlement over the suit property, but the respondents did not act on the same. Hence, the petitioner filed this petition.

3. The present petition was listed for the first time on 05.04.2010 and the same was ordered to be registered as an independent petition. The report from the SDM was also called with regard to the resources of the petitioner. The matter was sent to the Joint Registrar for the purpose of holding enquiry, as to whether the applicant/petitioner was an indigent person or not. In view thereof, the Joint Registrar on 29.04.2011 has passed the following order:-

“The number found on plaint as IPA no. 6/2010 be deleted. The plaint remains un-numbered. The IPA no. 6/2010 by way of interlocutory application is found in part II.

The report of SDM, Ludhiana is on record. Though notices were ordered to the respondents, no reply is filed. The petitioner/indigent person is present. Her statement is being recorded for the purposes of Order 33 Rule 4 of CPC. Heard the ld. counsel for the petitioner.

ORDERS UNDER ORDER 33 RULE 5 OF CPC

After considering the statement on oath made by Indigent person Shubh Lata and further having taken note of the report of the SDM, Ludhiana which is now marked as Ex. C-1, I find that there is no ground to reject this application filed by the petitioner to sue as an indigent person.

In view of the above, the dates for inquiry in detail is fixed to be on 16th August, 2011 for which the counsel appearing for respondent no. 1 is notified. Let court notices be issued to the respondent no. 2 without PF. Notices be also issued to the Govt. Pleader intimating the next date.

Put up for evidence of the petitioner on indigency. In the meantime the respondents shall also file their replies to the application within two weeks and rejoinder within two weeks thereafter.”

4. The separate statement of the petitioner was also recorded on 29.04.2011 The same reads as under:-

“Statement of Petitioner (as under Order 33 Rule 4 of CPC) Mrs. Shub Lata W/o Mr. Ashok aged about 55 years, R/o 2202, Gali No. 5/1, Mohalla Adarsh Nagar, Samrala Chowk, Ludhiana, Punjab.

On S.A

I have filed an original suit for the partition. I am an indigent person. I am not supported by anyone else. I am unable to pay the court fee. I may be permitted to file the suit as an indigent person.

Sd/- Sd/-

RO & AC A.S Jaya Chandra

NR Joint Registrar

Dated 29.04.2011”

5. It appears from the order dated 29.04.2011 that the matter has now been put up for evidence of the petitioner on indigency. In the meanwhile, the respondents were directed to file replies to the application. The said order dated 29.04.2011 has been challenged by the respondent No. 1.appellant by way of the present appeal. It is stated in the appeal that the order dated 29.04.2011 of the Joint Registrar is liable to be set-aside, as under the inquiry the Court has also to see the validity of the cause of action on the basis of which the present suit has been filed and not merely as per the report with regard to the resources of the petitioner to consider the petition on indigency.

6. The reply has been filed by the petitioner wherein, it is stated that the impugned order has been passed by the Joint Registrar in accordance with law. The learned counsel for the petitioner has referred the impugned order, by which the matter is put up for evidence of the petitioner. The learned counsel has no objection, if, the petitioner may also be cross-examined by the respondent on the point of cause of action.

7. In view of above, I do not think that any further order in the present appeal is required to be passed. Therefore, the same is dismissed.

8. The appeal is accordingly disposed of.

IPA No. 6/2010

List before the Joint Registrar on 10.05.2012