- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rajiv Chopra Petitioner v. State
Case Summary — Extracted from the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This summary is confined strictly to facts and procedures stated in the provided opinion.
The petitioner was convicted by the Trial Court by judgment dated 14.09.2011 and sentenced by order on sentence dated 17.09.2011 to undergo simple imprisonment for six months with a fine of Rs. 1,000 for an offence under Section 279, Indian Penal Code, 1860, and to undergo simple imprisonment for one year with a fine of Rs. 1,000 for an offence under Section 304A, Indian Penal Code, 1860. Both sentences were directed to run concurrently.
The petitioner appealed against the sentence before the Sessions Court. By order dated 20.01.2012 the learned Additional Sessions Judge partly allowed the appeal in that the conviction was maintained but the sentence under Section 304A was reduced from one year to nine months.
The petitioner, through counsel, did not challenge the conviction but sought modification of the sentence to give credit for the period already undergone. The petitioner also offered to compensate the deceased's parents with Rs. 8.00 lakhs; the parents and brother of the deceased appeared in court and accepted the offer. Two cheques (Rs. 5,00,000 and Rs. 3,00,000) drawn by the petitioner’s brother-in-law were handed over in court. The court recorded assurances about realisation of the cheques and imposed directions for deposit and usage of the amount by the deceased's parents.
The court, referring to the authority of Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika, modified the sentence to the extent of the period already undergone (from 20.01.2012 to 04.02.2012), partially allowed Criminal Revision Petition No. 57/2012 and disposed of related applications; bail bonds were cancelled and the petitioner’s surety discharged.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order on sentence could be modified to give the petitioner benefit of the period already undergone, where the petitioner did not challenge the conviction but offered compensation to the deceased's parents.
- Whether the facts and offer of compensation permitted the court, in light of the authority cited (Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika), to modify the sentence despite conviction being maintained.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (through Ms. Rebecca M. John)
- The petitioner was not challenging the conviction dated 14.09.2011 but prayed for modification of the sentence order dated 17.09.2011 (as later modified on 20.01.2012) to the extent of the period already undergone.
- The petitioner offered to compensate the parents of the deceased with Rs. 8.00 lakhs so that they may live comfortably; this offer included handing over two cheques amounting to Rs. 8.00 lakhs (issued by the petitioner’s brother-in-law on the petitioner’s instructions).
- Counsel relied on Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika (Crl. Appeal No. 2064/2011, decided 14.11.2011) for the proposition that, in certain circumstances, continuation of prosecution or sentence may be prevented under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to avoid abuse of process where complainants are no longer supportive.
Respondent / State (Learned APP)
- The learned APP acknowledged that a life had been lost and that the conviction was established and affirmed on appeal, but, considering that the petitioner was compensating the parents of the deceased and taking into account the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the State had no objection to the petitioner’s prayer for modification of sentence.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika | The opinion cites the proposition that "the cases of non-compoundable nature can be compounded, certainly not after the conviction" and includes the observation (quoted in the opinion) that where a complainant is not ready to support allegations and witnesses are no longer supportive, continuation of prosecution may be futile and Section 482 Cr.P.C. could be invoked "to prevent abuse of the process of law and thereby preventing a wasteful exercise by the Courts below." | The court relied upon Shiji @ Pappu as a guiding authority to justify modification of the sentence to the extent already undergone while maintaining the conviction; this formed part of the factual and legal basis for partially allowing the criminal revision petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded on the basis that the petitioner accepted the guilt as determined by the trial court and appellate court (conviction not being challenged) but sought relief purely in relation to sentence to account for the period already served. The petitioner's counsel placed on record an offer of compensation (Rs. 8.00 lakhs) to the deceased's parents; the parents and brother of the deceased appeared in court and accepted the offer.
The court recorded that the two cheques had been issued by the petitioner’s brother-in-law on the petitioner’s instructions and noted the brother-in-law’s assurance that the cheques would be honoured, with a legal consequence stated in case of dishonour. The court directed that the Rs. 8.00 lakhs be kept in the form of a joint fixed deposit receipt (in the names of the deceased’s parents) for an initial period of five years at a specified bank branch, with annual interest available for daily needs and limited withdrawal provisions for exigencies.
The court considered the authority of Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika and, in view of the facts — acceptance of compensation by the deceased's parents, assurances regarding payment, and the State’s lack of objection to the modification — exercised its discretion to modify the sentence to the extent of the period already undergone (specified as from 20.01.2012 to 04.02.2012) while maintaining the conviction.
The court recorded consequential directions: partial allowance and disposal of Criminal Revision Petition No. 57/2012, disposal of Criminal M.B. No. 226/2012 as unnecessary of further adjudication, cancellation of bail bonds and discharge of the petitioner’s surety, and administrative directions to the bank branch for compliance.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Criminal Revision Petition No. 57/2012 was partially allowed and disposed of. The court maintained the conviction but modified the order on sentence to the extent of the period already undergone by the petitioner (from 20.01.2012 to 04.02.2012). Bail bonds were cancelled and the surety discharged.
Implications and direct effects:
- The deceased's parents received two cheques totaling Rs. 8.00 lakhs in court; the court directed that the amount be deposited as a joint FDR in their names for an initial period of five years at the State Bank of India, Kashipur Ramnagar Branch, with conditions for interest usage and limited yearly withdrawals for exigencies.
- The court relied on the precedent Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika in reaching its decision to modify sentence while maintaining conviction; the opinion does not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond its application to the facts of this case.
No order as to costs was made.
SURESH KAIT, J. (Oral)
1. Vide instant petition, the petitioner has challenged the impugned judgment dated 14.09.2011 and order on sentence dated 17.09.2011 whereby he has been sentenced to undergo SI for six months with fine of Rs. 1,000/- for offence punishable under Section 279 Indian Penal Code, 1860. Further sentenced to undergo SI for one year with fine of Rs. 1,000/- for the offence punishable under Section 304A Indian Penal Code, 1860. Both the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
2. Being aggrieved, the applicant/convict assailed the aforesaid judgment and order on sentence before the Sessions Court; whereupon vide order dated 20.01.2012, learned Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi allowed partially and maintained the conviction; however reduced the sentence from one year to nine months only under Section 304A Indian Penal Code, 1860.
3. Ms. Rebecca M. John, learned counsel for petitioner, on instructions, submits that petitioner is not challenging the impugned judgment dated 14.09.2011 whereby he was held guilty and convicted. However, she has prayed for modification of order on sentence dated 17.09.2011 passed by learned Trial Court and subsequently modified by learned Additional Sessions Judge, vide order dated 20.01.2012 to the extent of period already undergone.
4. She further submits that in the instant case, one precious life has been lost. It was a sad accident. The deceased belonged to a poor family. She does not dispute this fact. Therefore, petitioner wants to compensate the parents of deceased for a sum of Rs. 8.00 Lacs; so that the parents may live comfortably at their fag end.
5. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a case of Shiji @ Pappu v. Radhika in Crl. Appeal No. 2064/2011 decided on 14.11.2011 by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the cases of non-compoundable nature can be compounded, certainly not after the conviction observing as under:-
‘…… That being so, continuance of the prosecution where the complainant is not ready to support the allegations which are now described by her as arising out of some “misunderstanding and misconception”; will be a futile exercise that will serve no purpose. It is noteworthy that the two alleged eye witnesses, who are closely related to the complainant, are also no longer supportive of the prosecution version. The continuance of the proceedings is thus nothing but an empty formality. Section 482 Cr.P.C could, in such circumstances, be justifiably invoked by the High Court to prevent abuse of the process of law and thereby preventing a wasteful exercise by the Courts below.’
6. Vide order dated 03.02.2012, SHO, police station Defence Colony, New Delhi was directed to ensure the presence of father, mother and wife of the deceased.
7. Consequently, Shri Mukand Lal, Smt. Basanti Devi, parents and Mr. Prakash Chand, younger brother of the deceased, all residents of Village Ajoli Talli, PO Ajoli Malli, District Almorha, Uttaranchal have appeared.
8. They informed that deceased was a bachelor. Therefore, only they have appeared; and accepted the offer advanced by learned counsel for petitioner.
9. Learned APP for State on the other hand, submits that though a precious life has been taken by the act of petitioner, which has been duly proved during trial and affirmed in appeal before learned Additional Sessions Judge, however, since petitioner is compensating the parents of deceased, considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, he has no objection to the prayer of petitioner.
10. Accordingly, two cheques bearing No. 506309 for Rs. 5.00/- Lacs and No. 506310 for Rs. 3.00/- Lacs both dated 01.03.2012 drawn on Citi Bank in favour of Shri Mukand Lal, father of deceased have been handed over to parents of deceased today in the Court. Both the said cheques have been issued by Mr. Raman Kapur, brother-in-law of petitioner.
11. Here I make it clear that both the cheques have been issued by Mr. Raman Kapur, brother-in-law of petitioner in favour of Mr. Mukand Lal. Mr. Raman Kapur is present in the Court, who stated that both the cheques would be realised on presentation and have been issued on the instructions of Mr. Rajiv Chopra, petitioner herein, who is his brother-in-law. Mr. Raman Kapur has assured this Court that both the cheques shall be honoured by his banker, failing which he shall be liable for the action in accordance with law.
12. The parents of deceased are hereby directed to keep the amount of Rs. 8.00/- Lacs in the form of joint FDR (in the name of Sh. Mukand Lal and Smt. Basanti Devi) with option of ‘Either or survival’ initially for a period of five years in their bank account maintained in State Bank of India, Kashipur Ramnagar Branch, Uttaranchal and annual interest accrued thereon shall be utilised by the parents of deceased as per their daily need.
13. In case of any financial exigencies, the parents of deceased shall move an application to the concerned Bank at Kashipur Ramnagar Branch, and may withdraw the maximum amount of Rs. 25,000/- once in a year only.
14. In the facts and circumstances and in view of the Shiji @ Pappu (Supra) while maintaining the conviction of petitioner, the order on sentence dated 17.09.2011 passed by learned Trial Court and modified by learned Additional Sessions Judge vide order dated 20.01.2012, are hereby modified to the extent of period already undergone by petitioner i.e from 20.01.2012 to 04.02.2012
15. Consequently, Criminal Revision Petition No. 57/2012 is partially allowed and stands disposed of.
16. In view of above order, Criminal M.B No. 226/2012 does not require any further adjudication and stands disposed of. Bail bonds are cancelled and surety of petitioner stands discharged.
17. A copy of this order be sent to concerned Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Kashipur Ramnagar Branch, Uttaranchal for compliance.
18. Copy of order be also given to both the parties.
19. No order as to costs.
20. Dasti.
Alert