Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Malkiat Singh Petitioner v. Union Of India & Anr. S

Delhi High Court
Jan 17, 2012
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary — ANIL KUMAR, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner joined the Assam Rifles on 29 May 1994 as a Rifleman (General Duty). While posted away from his family, differences arose between him and his wife, Smt. Asha Devi, who filed criminal complaints (sections 498A, 494 & 109 IPC) and an application under Section 125 CrPC; the latter resulted in a maintenance order dated 3 October 2000 awarding Rs. 500 per month to the wife.

The petitioner was alleged to have contracted a second marriage with Ms. Anju Devi on 28 February 1998 (or alternatively in June 1999 as various statements by the petitioner indicate), while his first wife Smt. Asha Devi was still living. Pursuant to a complaint, a departmental inquiry was proposed on 31 December 2001 under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965; articles of charge were served and the petitioner filed a written reply dated 7 January 2002 in which he admitted a second marriage and stated he had not obtained a divorce or prior Government permission under Rule 21 of the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1965.

The petitioner’s statement (recorded 9 May 2001) reiterated admissions of a second marriage and children from that marriage. On 1 December 2002 the disciplinary authority dismissed the petitioner from service under Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 for violation of Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965. The petitioner filed a statutory appeal (6 January 2003) which was directed to be decided by this Court by order dated 12 May 2008; the appellate authority dismissed the appeal on 3 November 2008. The petitioner sought revision under Rule 29 (dismissed on 1 March 2011 after a further direction of this Court dated 14 February 2011). The petitioner then filed the present writ petition under Article 226 challenging the dismissal and the subsequent appellate and revision orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal order dated 1 December 2002 (dismissal from Assam Rifles) for alleged violation of Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965 was legally sustainable.
  2. Whether the disciplinary process leading to dismissal complied with the rules of natural justice and Article 311 of the Constitution of India (i.e., whether the petitioner was afforded the required procedural safeguards, including service of charge sheet and opportunity to be heard).
  3. Whether the appellate order dated 3 November 2008 and the revision order dated 1 March 2011 upholding the dismissal were legally valid.
  4. Whether the dismissal could be negated by the criminal court's dismissal of the criminal complaint under Section 494 IPC for lack of evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The order of dismissal dated 1 December 2002 was passed without complying with the rules of natural justice and the constitutional safeguard under Article 311; specifically, the petitioner asserted he was not served with any charge sheet and no inquiry was held as contemplated under the rules.
  • The petitioner contended he was never "convicted" under Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and therefore dismissal under Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 could not be validly imposed.
  • Implied argument that the criminal court's dismissal of the complaint under Section 494 IPC affects the disciplinary findings (the petitioner relied on the criminal outcome as relevant).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents produced the departmental record showing that the charge sheet was served on the petitioner, that the petitioner filed a written reply dated 7 January 2002 admitting the second marriage and lack of prior permission or divorce, and that the petitioner’s statement dated 9 May 2001 similarly contained admissions.
  • The respondents maintained that the disciplinary authority correctly applied Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and that dismissal under Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was justified by the admitted facts.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a document-based review of the departmental record produced by the respondents and the orders under challenge. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. Verification of Procedural Steps: The Court found from the record that a charge sheet was in fact served on the petitioner and that the petitioner filed a detailed reply dated 7 January 2002 referring to his marriages and admitting facts relevant to the charge of contracting a second marriage without divorce or Government permission. The petitioner’s statement recorded on 9 May 2001 was also on record and signed by him after explanation in Hindi.
  2. Substance of Admissions: The petitioner’s written reply and recorded statement admitted contracting a second marriage (identifying Ms. Anju/Anju Kumari) and stated he had not obtained a legal divorce from his first wife nor prior Government permission as required by Rule 21. The Court treated these admissions as establishing the factual foundation for a violation of Rule 21.
  3. Applicability of Rule 21: The Court examined Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965—which restricts government servants from contracting marriage while a spouse is living unless permitted by the Government—and concluded that, on the admitted facts, the petitioner had contravened Rule 21.
  4. Appropriateness of Punishment under Rule 19(i) CCS (CCA) Rules: Because violation of Rule 21 was made out on the admitted material, the Court held that the disciplinary authority’s imposition of dismissal under Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 could not be faulted.
  5. Effect of Criminal Proceedings: The criminal complaint under Section 494 IPC filed by the first wife had been dismissed by the criminal court for lack of evidence regarding the solemnization of the second marriage; the Court held that that dismissal did not negate the petitioner’s admissions before the departmental authority nor the disciplinary decision in the facts of this case.
  6. Natural Justice and Article 311: The Court found no denial of natural justice or Article 311 safeguards because the charge sheet and opportunity to respond were on record and the petitioner had made substantive admissions which were not retracted in his appeal or revision.
  7. Proportionality and Excuses: The Court addressed the petitioner’s factual explanations (alleged deception in his first marriage, age and health of first wife, ignorance of rules) and rejected them as justifications for contravening Rule 21, noting ignorance of law is no excuse, and found no substantive case that punishment was disproportionate.
  8. Resultant Conclusion: On the totality of facts and documents, the Court concluded there was no illegality, irregularity, perversity or jurisdictional error warranting interference under Article 226 in the departmental orders dismissing the petitioner from service.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was dismissed. The Court held that the disciplinary proceedings and punishments imposed were valid on the material before it and that the appellant's contentions regarding procedural infirmities and the effect of the criminal court's dismissal did not persuade the Court to interfere.

DISMISSED

Implications

  • Direct effect: The dismissal order dated 1 December 2002 and the subsequent appellate order dated 3 November 2008 and revision order dated 1 March 2011 were upheld; the petitioner remains dismissed from service as per those orders.
  • On broader law: The opinion does not announce or apply any novel legal principle beyond the application of existing rules (Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and Rule 19(i) and Rule 23/29 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965) to the admitted facts. The Court expressly treated the petitioner’s admissions as sufficient to establish breach of Rule 21 and rejected the contention that absence of criminal conviction precludes disciplinary consequences; the judgment does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the facts adjudicated.

This summary is strictly confined to the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond the opinion's text.

Show all summary ...

ANIL KUMAR, J.

1. The petitioner has sought the quashing of the dismissal order dated 1st December, 2002 from the service of the Assam Rifles by Commandant No. 15 on account of committing the violation of Section 21(i) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965 (Restriction regarding marriages) and for quashing the order dated 3rd November, 2008 dismissing the appeal filed by the petitioner against his order of dismissal dated 1 November, 2002. The petitioner has also sought the quashing of order dated 1 March, 2011 dismissing the revision petition of the petitioner.

2. Brief facts to comprehend the controversies are that the petitioner joined the Assam Rifles on 29th May, 1994 as a Rifleman General Duty. He contended that while being posted to the field area away from his family, certain temperamental and other differences arose between him and his wife. His wife, namely, Smt. Asha Devi had filed a case under sections 498a, 494 & 109 of the indian penal code. The wife of the petitioner had also filed an application seeking maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure which was decided by Sh. R.K Sharma, Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nurtu, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh by his order dated 3 October, 2000 awarding the maintenance of Rs. 500/- per month to the wife of the petitioner. The wife of the petitioner, Smt. Asha Devi filed a complaint against the petitioner contending that the petitioner has also married Ms. Anju Devi, resident of Village-Gangat, Tehsil-Nurpur, District Kangra on 28 February, 1998 though Smt. Asha Devi was the legally wedded wife of the petitioner. Pursuant to the complaint filed by the wife of the petitioner Smt. Asha Devi an inquiry was proposed against the petitioner by order 31 December, 2001 under rule 14 of the central civil services (classification, control & appeals) rules, 1965. The articles of charge were given to the petitioner and he was asked to file a reply/representation against the same.

3. In reply to the articles of charges, the petitioner sent a reply dated 7 January, 2002 contending that he was married to Ms. Asha Devi, however, she never wanted to stay with him and that she used to go to her parents' house time and again and also expected the petitioner to stay with her, by leaving his old parents. The petitioner in the said reply admitted that he had married to Smt. Anju Devi in June, 1999 without taking a legal divorce from Smt. Asha Devi as he was ignorant of this legal aspect. He also stated that he has two children, one son and a daughter from Smt. Anju Devi and that he cannot leave her and his children with her as well. He also admitted that he had married a second time without permission from the Govt. due to the ignorance of rules. The reply dated 7 January, 2002 filed by the petitioner to the articles of charge made against him is as under:-

“REPLY TO MEMORANDUM

Sir,

1. It is in response to memorandum No. A/153996.MS/2001 dated

2. I have the honour to submit that I was married to Smt. Asha Devi, daughter of Shri Mallu Ram of village Gangat, Tehsil Nurpur, District Kangra on 08 November, 1993. I have three children, two daughters and a son from her.

3. Smt. Asha Devi never wanted to stay with me. Time and again she would to her parents' house and expected me also to stay there with her leaving my old parents. Whenever I went to my home during my leave, I found that she was staying with her parents. I tried to explain but she did not understand. She was not willing to stay with me.

4. I married Smt. Anju Devi in June, 1999 without taking legal divorce from Smt. Asha Devi as I was ignorant of this legal aspect. I have two children, one son and a daughter from Smt. Anju Devi. I cannot leave her also as I have children from her too.

5. I married for the second time without obtaining a legal divorce from a court of law/prior permission from the Government due to ignorance of rules for which I unequivocally plead guilty.”

4. The statement of the petitioner as witness No. 1 was also recorded on 9 May, 2001 wherein he categorically admitted that he has married to Ms. Anju Kumari in June, 1999 in Jorhat Civil Court. To the question that had he obtained divorce from his wife Smt. Asha Devi, he replied ‘No’. He also deposed that he had two children from his marriage with Ms. Anju Devi and their names are Ms. Dinesh Bala date of birth being 6 February, 1999 and master Bhim Singh date of birth being 24 April, 2000. He deposed that his second wife Ms. Anju Devi and his children are living at Jorhat in Sharma Colony. The statement of the petitioner which was recorded was explained to him in Hindi and thereafter he had signed it as correct.

5. The petitioner in his statement recorded on 9 May, 2001 had also deposed that he had eloped with Ms. Anju Devi and with her consent had moved to Jorhat in the year 1998. The reason for the second marriage given by the petitioner in his statement was that Smt. Asha Devi is seven year older than him as her date of birth is 4 April, 1963 whereas the petitioner's date of birth is 3 October, 1970 and that his wife remains sick as she gets fits. He also complained that before the marriage he was shown a different girl but after the marriage he learnt that he and his parents had been cheated.

6. Rule 21 of the CCS Rules stipulates restriction on entering or contracting a marriage if such an employee has a spouse living. Rule 21 is as under:-

“21. Restriction regarding Marriage

(1) No Government servant shall enter into, or contract, a marriage with a person having a spouse living; and

(2) No government servant having a spouse living, shall enter into, or contract, a marriage with any person;

Provided that the Central Government may permit a Government servant to enter into, or contract, any such marriage as is referred to in clause (1) or Clause (2), if it is satisfied that—

(a) such marriage is permissible under the personal law applicable to such Government servant and the other party to the marriage; and

(b) there are other grounds for so doing.

(3) A Government servant who has married or marries a person other than of India nationality shall forthwith intimate the fact to the Government.”

7. Taking these facts into consideration, the respondents passed an order dated 1 December, 2002 holding that the petitioner has violated Rule 21 of the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and that consequently his further retention in the public service is undesirable. Therefore, in exercise of the power conferred under rule 19(i) of the central civil service (classification, control & appeals) rules, 1965, the petitioner, Rifleman General Duty bearing No. 153996N was dismissed from the service w.e.f 1 December, 2002 (AN). Aggrieved by the order of dismissal dated 1 December, 2002, the petitioner filed a statutory appeal dated 6 January, 2003 under Rule 23 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

8. The appeal of the petitioner was not decided in the year 2003 expeditiously. Consequently, the petitioner filed a writ petition being W.P(C) No. 6004/2003. The said writ petition was disposed of by order dated 12 May, 2008 directing the respondents to dispose of the statutory appeal of the petitioner by a speaking order and to communicate the order to the petitioner, as well as, his counsel.

9. In the meantime, a criminal case filed against the petitioner by his wife Smt. Asha Devi, under sections 494, 498a & 109 of the indian penal code was dismissed by Sh. Amit Mandial, Chief Judicial Magistrate, 1 Class, Court No. 2, Nurpur, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh. In the said criminal case the Court had held that the petitioner's first wife failed to lead any evidence regarding the marriage conducted by the petitioner with Smt. Anju Devi as per the customs prevailing in their religion and caste. In the absence of any such evidence, the Court held that there was no evidence that the marriage with Smt. Anju Devi was performed as per the customs and therefore, held that the petitioner is not liable to be convicted for an offence under Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code.

10. In the statutory appeal dated 6 January, 2003, the petitioner asserted that the order of dismissal dated 1 December, 2002 was passed without complying with the rules of natural justice and that the petitioner was never served with any charge sheet, nor was any inquiry held as contemplated under the rules. The petitioner's assertion was that he has not been convicted under Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and therefore, the order of dismissal under Rule 19(i) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 could not be passed.

11. The appeal of the petitioner was, however, dismissed by the Director General, Assam Rifles by order dated 3 November, 2008 holding that the charge of contracting second marriage had been established. While dismissing the appeal, it was noticed by the Appellate Authority that a number of statements/applications had been filed by the petitioner showing that he had contracted plural marriages which amounted to misconduct under Rule 21 of the CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965.

12. Aggrieved by the dismissal of his appeal, the petitioner filed a revision petition under Rule 29 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 contending inter-alia that the order of dismissal had been passed without complying with the rules of natural justice and the provisions of the statutory rules. It was also asserted that the petitioner was never convicted under Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965.

13. The petitioner, thereafter filed another writ petition being W.P(C) No. 3639 of 2010, titled as ‘Malkiat Singh v. Union Of India & Anr…. S’ which was also disposed of by order dated 14 February, 2011 directing that the revision petition filed on 23 December, 2000 be disposed of by the respondents within a period of 12 weeks. The petitioner was also given the liberty to avail his remedies as per law if the decision in the revision petition would be adverse to the petitioner.

14. The revision petition of the petitioner pursuant to order dated 14 February, 2011 passed in W.P(C) No. 3639 of 2010, titled as ‘Malkiat Singh v. Union Of India & Anr…. S’, was dismissed by order dated 1 March, 2011 holding that the charge of contracting plural marriages against the petitioner violating Rule 21(i) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, contracting the second marriage was made out and that in the circumstances, the order of dismissal of the petitioner is just and legal.

15. The petitioner has challenged his order of dismissal dated 1 December, 2002, order dated 3 November, 2008 dismissing his appeal and order dated 1 March, 2011 dismissing his revision petition in the present writ petition inter-alia on the ground that the order of dismissal dated 1 December, 2002 was passed without complying with the rules of natural justice as also the constitutional safeguard enshrined in Article 311 of the Constitution of India. It is also contended that no charge sheet was served on the petitioner, nor was any inquiry conducted as contemplated under the rules. It has also been asserted that the petitioner was never ‘convicted’ under Rule 21 of CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965 and consequently, the order of dismissal pursuant to exercising the power under rule 19(i) of ccs(classification, control & appeals) rules, 1965 could not be passed. The petitioner himself categorically asserted that no conviction is contemplated for violation of Rule 21 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1965.

16. The writ petition is opposed by the learned counsel for the respondents who has appeared on advance notice. Leaned counsel for the respondents has produced the entire record pertaining to the issuance of the charge sheet to the petitioner, reply filed by the petitioner to the charge sheet dated 7 January, 2002 and the statement of the petitioner recorded by the respondents which were read over to the petitioner in Hindi and were signed by him endorsing them to be correct.

17. This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties in detail and has perused the entire record pertaining to the petitioner produced before this Court, as well as, the orders challenged by the petitioner. From the perusal of the record, it is apparent that the charge sheet was served on the petitioner and that he had filed the reply dated 7 January, 2002 which is reproduced hereinabove. The petitioner in his reply to the charges framed against him regarding the allegation of a second marriage, had categorically stated that he had married Ms. Anju Devi, resident of Village Gangat, Tehsil-Nurpur, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh though his legally wedded wife Smt. Asha Devi is alive. He had rather justified the second marriage to Ms. Anju Devi in June, 1999 without taking legal course on the ground that he was not aware about legal requirement to obtain prior permission for contracting the second marriage from the Govt. due to the ignorance of the rules. Since the petitioner in the reply to the articles of charge had admitted that neither he had taken permission for his second marriage from the Govt. under Rule 21 of CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965, nor had he obtained a divorce from his first wife Smt. Asha Devi who was also alive at the time, it cannot be held that violation of Rule 21 of CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965 is not made out. Since the violation of Rule 21 of CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965 was made out, the Disciplinary Authority awarding the punishment to the petitioner under rule 19(i) of ccs(classification, control & appeals) rules, 1965 cannot be faulted. Learned counsel for the petitioner in the circumstances, has failed to show violation of any statutory rule or denial of principle of natural justice. The word ‘convicted’ is not to be understood so as to mean that if the charged officer is acquitted of the offence of bigamy the same would also absolve him of any consequences of violation of Rule 21 of the CCS(Conduct) Rules, 1965.

18. The statement given by the petitioner on 9 May, 2001 admitting his marriage to Smt. Anju Devi his second wife and the justification given for the marriage has not been denied in the appeal and the revision petition filed by the petitioner. It is also not the plea of the petitioner that he was coerced into giving such statements or was forced to give such statements during the inquiry. Reply dated 7 January, 2002 to the charge sheet has also not been denied by the petitioner either in the appeal or the revision petition filed by him which were dismissed by order dated 3 November, 2008 and 1 March, 2011. In the present writ petition also it has not been denied that the petitioner had filed the reply dated 7 January, 2002 to the charge sheet admitting second marriage to Smt. Anju Devi and the fact that he has two children from the said marriage as well as the reasons for contracting the second marriage stipulated in the reply.

19. The Disciplinary proceedings initiated against the petitioner were not stayed on account of the criminal complaint filed by the wife of the petitioner, Smt. Asha Devi under Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code on 29 April, 1998. In the criminal proceedings, just because the first wife of the petitioner could not produce the necessary evidence regarding the solemnization of the marriage by the petitioner with Smt. Anju Devi, the admissions made by the petitioner before the Disciplinary Authority will not be negated on account of it, nor will the decision of the Disciplinary Authority be impacted in the present facts and circumstances on account of the dismissal of the complaint under Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code filed by the first wife of the petitioner on account of lack of evidence.

20. Learned counsel for the petitioner is also unable to substantiate that the punishment is disproportionate to the charges made out against the petitioner. The petitioner cannot take shelter under the plea that he was cheated into entering into the matrimony since he was allegedly shown some other girl, but was married off to Smt. Asha Devi and also that she is older to her and is suffering from illnesses and is not fit and had allegedly declined to live with him and his parents, as she was insisting on living with her parents. The petitioner is also not entitled for any relief on account of the fact that he was ignorant of the rules of obtaining legal permission before entering into a second marriage as admitted by him in his reply dated 7 January, 2002 to the articles of the charge as ignorance of law is no excuse.

21. In the totality of the facts and circumstances, there is no illegality, irregularity or any such perversity or jurisdictional error which will require any interference by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in respect of the orders passed by the respondents dismissing the petitioner from service. The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.