Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sunil Kumar. v. Uoi & Ors. S

Delhi High Court
Mar 7, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a Constable in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), availed sanctioned leave from 26.02.2008 to 11.03.2008 and rejoined duty on 12.03.2008. Subsequently, he left the unit on 17.03.2008 without formal sanction, claiming he verbally informed the Company Havaldar Major, which was denied by the respondents who also asserted that the Company Havaldar Major was not competent to grant leave. The petitioner did not submit any written leave application. He remained absent for 30 days until he rejoined on 16.04.2008. A charge sheet dated 26.03.2008 was served to him on 17.04.2008. During the inquiry, the petitioner offered no proof justifying his absence except his verbal statement that his wife had medical problems following a caesarean operation, for which leave had already been sanctioned. The Inquiry Officer indicted the petitioner, and the Disciplinary Authority imposed the penalty of removal from service by order dated 28.01.2009, reasoning that the petitioner had shown cowardice by absconding just before the unit was to move to a Maoist-affected area. The petitioner's appeal and revision were rejected by orders dated 21.05.2009 and 08.10.2009 respectively. The petitioner contended that he had to rush to his village due to the birth of a second female child, which was not approved by his parents, and his wife's mental distress post-operation. The writ petition challenges the revisional order and the penalty imposed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the penalty of removal from service imposed on the petitioner for unauthorized absence is justified given the circumstances of his absence and the nature of leave sanctioning authority.
  2. Whether the disciplinary action taken against the petitioner amounts to an act of cowardice or is disproportionate to the misconduct.
  3. How to balance the demands of discipline in paramilitary forces with compassion and justice in cases of unauthorized absence due to personal and social reasons.
  4. What is the appropriate penalty in cases of unauthorized absence by paramilitary personnel when mitigating circumstances exist.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner verbally informed the Company Havaldar Major about his absence, though no written leave application was submitted.
  • He left the unit due to urgent personal reasons: the birth of a second female child which was socially disapproved by his parents, and his wife’s mental distress after a caesarean operation.
  • The petitioner contended that his absence was not an act of cowardice, supported by his prior service record, including deployment in troubled areas.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Company Havaldar Major was not the competent authority to sanction leave, and the petitioner did not submit any written leave application.
  • The petitioner’s unauthorized absence disrupted discipline and was an act of cowardice, especially as the unit was to move to a Maoist-affected area.
  • Disciplinary action including removal from service was justified due to the breach of protocol and absence without proper sanction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.(C) 1917/2000 Const. P. Rajan v. UOI (29.04.2008) Balancing discipline with justice and compassion in cases of unauthorized absence due to personal emergencies. The Court referred to this case where dismissal was set aside and reconsidered to impose a lesser penalty, guiding the present case to avoid removal from service.
State of UP v. Ram Daras Yadav, (2010) 2 SCC 236 Discipline as backbone of police forces must be tempered with justice; penalties must be proportionate to misconduct. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that even serious misconduct should not attract disproportionate penalties and substituted dismissal with withholding increments and partial back wages.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the difficulty in applying precise legal norms or precedents given the unique facts of each case involving unauthorized absence by paramilitary personnel. It noted a recurring pattern where personnel from rural backgrounds face social pressures that influence their conduct. The Court examined the petitioner’s circumstances, including the birth of a second female child and his wife’s mental health issues, as mitigating factors. It rejected the respondents’ characterization of the petitioner’s absence as cowardice, citing his prior service in difficult areas as evidence of courage. The Court drew on prior decisions that blend discipline with compassion and proportionality in penalty imposition. It held that the penalty of removal was disproportionate and directed the Revisional Authority to impose a lesser penalty that does not result in loss of employment. The petitioner was to be reinstated without back wages for the period of dismissal but with service counted for all other purposes.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court quashed the revisional order dated 08.10.2009 and remitted the matter to the Revisional Authority to pass a fresh order imposing an appropriate penalty that does not lead to loss of employment. The petitioner is to be reinstated within six weeks, with no wages payable for the period from the original removal to reinstatement, though that period will count as service. This decision directly affects the parties by ensuring the petitioner retains his job with a suitably moderated penalty. The Court did not set a new precedent but reiterated the principle that discipline must be balanced with justice and proportionality in paramilitary disciplinary matters.

Show all summary ...

Pradeep Nandrajog, J. (Oral):— Assigned the roster to hear writ petitions pertaining to Para Military Forces, we are constrained to note that every 4th case dealt with by us pertains to a Constable or a Head Constable of a Para Military Force overstaying leave or leaving the unit in a state of distress and claiming that he told the Company Havaldar Major of the reason why he was going to his village and needless to state the Company Havaldar Major not being the competent authority to sanction leave, disciplinary action being taken against these Constables and Head Constables for the misdemeanour of unauthorized absence. Invariably, penalty imposed is of removal or dismissal from service or one of compulsory retirement.

2. These cases have a cry for justice on the part of the petitioners who render a tale of woes with reference to the social conditions in their village. We highlight that each and every case dealt with by us in this category pertains to a Constable or a Head Constbale from a rural area.

3. On the other hand is the call of discipline raised by a Para Military Force. We are told that the command structure would be adversely affected if jawans are allowed to decide for themselves as to when should they avail leave.

4. It is next to impossible to find a legal norm on which these cases can be decided with precisions or with previous cases being used as precedents.

5. Each case has its own story to tell and whatever we can find with reference to past precedents is that, on case to case basis, Hon'ble Judges of this Court and other High Courts as also the Supreme Court have tried to blend compassion and justice with discipline.

6. Having joined as a Constable with CRPF, petitioner availed leave from 26.02.2008 till 11.3.2008 He rejoined duty on 12.3.2008 but left the unit on 17.3.2008 He claims that he verbally informed the Company Havaldar Major a fact denied by the respondents, who additionally claim that the Company Havaldar Major was not the competent officer to whom leave application could be made. In any case, respondents state that the petitioner never claims to have submitted any written application seeking leave. He claims that he verbally informed the Company Havaldar Major.

7. Be that as it may, petitioner joined back on 16.4.2008 and in the meanwhile a charge sheet had been drawn up on 26.3.2008, which was served upon the petitioner on 17.4.2008 i.e the day next to his joining back.

8. It be noted that the petitioner remained absent for 30 days.

9. Unfortunately, for the petitioner, before the Inquiry Officer, he gave no proof to justify his remaining absent, save and except his verbal statement that he did so on account of his wife having medical problems post caesarean operation; for which he had already availed leave from 26.2.2008 till 11.3.2008

10. The Inquiry Officer indicted the petitioner and accepting the report of the Inquiry Officer the Disciplinary Authority levied the penalty of removal from service vide order dated 28.1.2009

11. The Disciplinary Authority took the view that the petitioner had shown cowardice inasmuch as the unit concerned was to move to Chattisgarh, a Maoist affected area on 18.3.2008, and opined that this was the probable reason for the petitioner to abscond on 17.3.2008

12. Appeal filed by the petitioner was rejected vide Appellate Order dated 21.5.2009 Revision filed has been turned down vide revisional order dated 8.10.2009

13. That the wife of the petitioner had a caesarean operation is not in dispute. That a second female child was born to the petitioner is also not in dispute. That the child was born during period when petitioner was sanctioned leave is also not in dispute.

14. The petitioner who is personally present in Court informs us that he had to rush to his village inasmuch as the birth of a second female child was not to the liking of his parents and his wife who had undergone a caesarean operation was mentally disturbed and this was adversely affecting her health. On the one hand he had the call of his duty. On the other hand he had a commitment to his ailing wife and the newly born female child.

15. No doubt, the petitioner is in default, but we feel that the authorities have unnecessarily read into the conduct of the petitioner, an act of cowardice.

16. It is not in dispute that after he was employed as a Constable on 15.9.2001, petitioner has served in various parts of India, including the troubled State of Tripura. It is apparent that the petitioner is not a coward.

17. In a somewhat similar situation, pertaining to a Constable in CRPF who left for his hometown without sanctioned leave; on account of the medical sickness of his mother, in the decision dated 29.4.2008 W.P(C) 1917/2000 Const. P. Rajan v. UOI, a Division Bench of this Court set aside the penalty order and directed the Revisional Authority to reconsider the matter and impose an appropriate penalty. In said case order passed was of dismissal from service.

18. Pertaining to a Constable in the Provincial Armed Constabulary (UP), in the decision (2010) 2 SCC 236, State of UP v. Ram Daras Yadav, the Supreme Court held that notwithstanding discipline being the backbone of the police force requiring highest degree of discipline to be maintained for the smooth functioning of a police force, justice had to be tempered with said requirement. For an act of using abusive language against his companion while on security duty and adopting threatening postures with a rifle against another companion; the threatening posture being akin to a prepatory act to eliminate the companion, the Supreme Court set aside the penalty of dismissal from service and substituted that same to one of withholding two increments. The respondent therein was reinstated in service with only 50% back wages paid. It was held that the penalty was squarely disproportionate.

19. We dispose of the writ petition quashing the revisional order dated 8.10.2009 and remit the revision petition filed by the petitioner before the Revisional Authority requiring the Revisional Authority to pass a fresh order levying an appropriate penalty upon the petitioner, which would not be of a kind where the petitioner loses his job. The petitioner would be reinstated in service and an appropriate penalty would be levied. For the period post 28.1.2009 till he is reinstated, and for which we fix the time limit as 6 weeks from today, no wages would be paid to the petitioner. However, said period would be reckoned in service for all other purposes.

20. The penalty levied upon the petitioner would be of a kind where the petitioner does not lose his job.

21. No costs.