- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Anil Saxena v. State .
Factual and Procedural Background
The proceedings concern FIR No. 479/1999 dated 22.11.1999. The opinion identifies two principal persons: respondent No. 2, Mr. S.S. Kulkarni (an accused), and the petitioner, named variously in the text as "Mr. Anil Sexena" and "Mr. Anil Saxena" (the charge-sheet shows the petitioner in column No. 2 as a person not sent to trial). The charge-sheet states that the petitioner and respondent No. 2 had opened a bank account in the name of M/s. Millinium Education Consultants and deposited a banker's cheque for Rs. 45 lakh, drawn by the Indian Overseas Bank on 15.11.1999; that instrument was found to be forged and not issued by the bank.
According to the charge-sheet, Mr. S.S. Kulkarni committed the offence. Kulkarni was summoned and charges were framed against him by the learned trial court under Sections 420, 464, 467, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code. While arguing on the point of charge, Kulkarni submitted that cognizance should be taken against Mr. Anil Saxena (or that further investigation be directed against him); the trial court rejected that submission by an order dated 05.08.2002.
Kulkarni filed a revision petition before the Additional Sessions Judge seeking summoning of Mr. Anil Saxena. Kulkarni did not implead Anil Saxena as a party to the revision. By order dated 24.05.2006 the revision was allowed and the order dated 05.08.2002 was partly set aside with a direction that the Metropolitan Magistrate should proceed after taking cognizance against Mr. Anil Saxena.
The court in the present opinion set aside the impugned order dated 24.05.2006 on the ground that it was passed without impleading and hearing Mr. Anil Saxena, and remanded the matter to the Additional Sessions Judge for fresh decision. The petitioner was directed to appear before the Judge-in-Charge, Patiala House Court on 09.08.2010; if required, notice to S.S. Kulkarni will be issued and the record will be returned immediately.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order dated 24.05.2006 of the Additional Sessions Judge directing the Metropolitan Magistrate to take cognizance against Mr. Anil Saxena can be sustained when Mr. Anil Saxena was not impleaded or heard in the revision proceedings initiated by respondent No. 2 (S.S. Kulkarni).
- Whether, despite the general principle that an order taking cognizance does not ordinarily require notice to the person arrayed as accused, the particular facts of this case (an accused seeking cognizance against another) required impleading and hearing the person sought to be charged before an adverse order was passed.
Arguments of the Parties
S.S. Kulkarni's Arguments
- While arguing on the point of charge before the trial court, Mr. S.S. Kulkarni submitted that cognizance should be taken against Mr. Anil Saxena or that further investigation should be directed against him. (The trial court rejected this submission in its order dated 05.08.2002.)
Petitioner's Arguments
- The counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Anil Saxena/Sexena, raised "a number of contentions" (the opinion does not specify those contentions). The court observed that the petitioner would be at liberty to raise all such contentions before the learned Sessions Judge and that this court did not express any opinion on their merits.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by analysing the procedural propriety of the Additional Sessions Judge's order dated 24.05.2006. The analysis followed these steps:
- Recognition of general principle: The court acknowledged the general principle that an order taking cognizance does not normally require notice to the person arrayed as an accused.
- Examination of factual particularity: The court found the facts of the case to be "peculiar" because the revision petition had been filed by Mr. S.S. Kulkarni (an accused) with a prayer that cognizance should be taken against Mr. Anil Saxena. That procedural posture changed the usual expectations surrounding notice and participation.
- Application of fairness and audi alteram partem: Given that the revision sought an adverse procedural order against a person not before the court, the court held that fairness required impleading Mr. Anil Saxena as a party to the revision and affording him an opportunity to be heard before any such order was made.
- Conclusion on legality of impugned order: Because Mr. Anil Saxena was not impleaded or heard, the impugned order dated 24.05.2006 could not be sustained and therefore had to be set aside.
- Procedural direction on further course: The court remanded the matter to the Additional Sessions Judge for a fresh decision, permitted the petitioner to press his contentions before that court, and directed immediate transmission of the record and an appearance date for the petitioner (09.08.2010). The court expressly refrained from expressing any view on the merits of the petitioner's contentions.
Holding and Implications
The court's core ruling: The impugned order dated 24.05.2006 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge in Criminal Revisions No. 1/2005 (S.S. Kulkarni v. State) is set aside and the petition is allowed.
Practical consequences and immediate implications:
- The matter is remanded to the Additional Sessions Judge for a fresh decision. The Additional Sessions Judge must consider the revision afresh after giving appropriate notice and an opportunity to be heard to Mr. Anil Saxena (who was not impleaded or heard earlier).
- The petitioner is directed to appear before the Judge-in-Charge, Patiala House Court on 09.08.2010. The court ordered that, if required, notice will be issued to S.S. Kulkarni as well and that the record will be sent back immediately.
- The court expressly did not decide the merits of the petitioner's contentions and left those issues open for consideration by the Additional Sessions Judge on the remand.
- No new precedent or alteration of substantive law was articulated; the decision concerns the procedural necessity of impleading and hearing a person against whom cognizance is sought where an adverse order is moved by an existing accused. The effect is limited to the parties and the remand process described above.
Petition allowed.
1. In spite of the second call none has appeared on behalf of the respondent No. 2, Mr. S.S Kulkarni.
2. Respondent No. 2 herein is an accused facing prosecution in the charge-sheet filed in FIR No. 479/1999 dated 22.11.1999 The petitioner herein Mr. Anil Sexena has been shown in column No. 2 in the said charge-sheet as a person who has not been sent to trial. In the charge-sheet it is stated that the petitioner and respondent No. 2 had been opened a new bank account in the name of the partnership firm M/s. Millinium Education Consultants and had deposited a banker's cheque of Rs. 45 lakh drawn by the Indian Overseas Bank on 15.11.1999 This instrument was found to be forged and not issued by the said bank.
3. As per the charge-sheet, the said offence was committed by Mr. S.S Kulkarni. Mr. S.S Kulkarni was summoned and thereafter charge was framed against him by the learned trial Court. While arguing on the point of charge, Mr. S.S Kulkarni had submitted that cognizance of the offence should be taken against Mr. Anil Saxena or further investigation should be directed against him. The said argument was rejected by the learned trial Court in its order dated 5.8.2002 Charges were directed to be framed under Sections 420/464/467/468/471 of Indian Penal Code against Mr. S.S Kulkarni.
4. Mr. S.S Kulkarni filed a Revision Petition against the said order before the Additional Sessions Judge for summoning Mr. Anil Saxena. He did not make Mr. Anil Saxena a party to the said revision petition. By order dated 24.5.2006, the revision petition has been allowed and the order dated 5.8.2002 has been partly set aside with the direction that the Metropolitan Magistrate should proceed with the matter after taking cognizance against Mr. Anil Saxena.
5. The impugned order dated 24.5.2006 cannot be sustained as the same was passed without impleading and hearing Anil Saxena. It is correct that normally an order taking cognizance does not require or mandate notice to the person who has been arrayed as accused. However, the facts of the present case are peculiar. Mr. S.S Kulkarni who has been arrayed as an accused had filed a revision with a prayer that cognizance should be taken and Mr. Anil Saxena should also be summoned. In these circumstances, I feel that Mr. Anil Saxena should have been impleaded as a party to the revision petition and should have been heard before any adverse order was passed.
6. The Counsel for the petitioner Mr. Anil Saxena has raised a number of contentions. It will be open to the petitioner to raise all contentions before the learned Sessions Judge. This Court has not expressed any opinion on merits of these contentions.
7. The impugned order dated 24.5.2006 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge in Criminal Revisions No. 1/2005 titled S.S Kulkarni v. State is set aside and the present petition is allowed. The matter is remanded back to the Additional Sessions Judge for a fresh decision. The petitioner will appear before the Judge-in-Charge, Patiala House Court on 9.8.2010 If required, notice will be issued to S.S Kulkarni also. That record will be sent back immediately.
Petition allowed.
Alert