- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ajay Jain v. Registrar Of Companies Nct Of Delhi & Haryana
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a petition under Section 482 Cr. P.C. by the petitioner seeking quashing of proceedings in Complaint No. 477 of 2002, filed by the Registrar of Companies under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act, 1956, alleging a false statement in a prospectus issued in 1995.
The petitioner argued that (a) the complaint did not show a false statement and at most raised an offence under Section 406 IPC for misapplication of funds, (b) the complaint was barred by limitation because limitation should run from the date of issue of the prospectus, and (c) the company's directors had resigned in 2000 and the company was under new management with no investor complaints.
The complaint alleged that the prospectus stated the company would undertake leasing and hire-purchase business, but the 1999-2000 balance sheet showed 70% of shareholders' funds (Rs. 2.05 crore) deployed as advance deposits to firms/companies of directors and others; leasing activity was almost nil; in 2000-01 the company transacted sale and purchase of shares exceeding Rs. 5 crore which was not an object of the public issue; and majority funds were diverted or siphoned for purposes other than those projected, thereby making untrue and misleading statements to investors.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the complaint discloses a false statement in the prospectus such that offences under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act, 1956 are prima facie made out, or whether the facts at best disclose an offence under Section 406 IPC.
- Whether the complaint is barred by limitation — specifically, whether limitation runs from the date of issuance of the prospectus or from the date of knowledge of the false statement (as when the balance sheet was filed).
- Whether resignation of directors (alleged to have occurred in 2000) precludes taking cognizance and is a matter to be decided at the quashing stage.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The complaint does not show that a false statement was made in the prospectus; it shows misuse of funds, which at most amounts to an offence under Section 406 IPC.
- The complaint is time-barred; limitation should start from the date of issuing the prospectus, so the complaint filed in 2002 was beyond the limitation period.
- Directors had resigned in 2000 and the company was taken over by other management; there was no complaint from investors, undermining the Registrar's case.
Complainant's Allegations (Registrar of Companies)
- The prospectus represented that the company would carry on leasing and hire-purchase business, but the company largely failed to undertake that business and instead deployed substantial funds as advances to firms/companies related to directors and invested in share trading not within the stated objects.
- These facts indicate the prospectus contained untrue and misleading statements and that funds were diverted for purposes other than those stated, supporting charges under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act, 1956.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the complaint and concluded that the prospectus contained statements that were prima facie false because the company represented an intention to undertake leasing business but, on the material placed, the company did not carry out that business and instead deployed the bulk of funds in advances to related firms and in share transactions not within the stated objects.
The Court explained that a false statement is one made deliberately to induce belief in a non-existent fact; where directors make statements of objects in a prospectus which they had no intention of performing, that constitutes a false statement. On the facts alleged, the Court found it prima facie apparent that the directors had no intention to carry out the stated business and intended to divert funds, so the case was not merely one of misappropriation under Section 406 IPC but one of deliberately making false statements under the Companies Act.
On limitation, the Court held that limitation for offences under Sections 63 and 628 begins from the date of knowledge of the false statement; the Registrar learned of the false statement after the filing of the 1999-2000 balance sheet, so limitation did not start from the date of issuing the prospectus. Regarding resignation of directors, the Court held that whether directors had resigned was a question of fact for the trial court and not for adjudication in this petition under Section 482 Cr. P.C.
Holding and Implications
Petition dismissed.
Direct consequences: the petition to quash Complaint No. 477 of 2002 was dismissed and the complaint proceedings may continue; the question of whether directors had resigned is to be decided by the trial court. The Court ordered dismissal of the petition with no orders as to costs.
No broader legal implications or new precedent were articulated in the opinion.
Shiv Narayan Dhingra, J.:— This petition under Section 482 Cr. P.C has been preferred by the petitioner for quashing the proceedings initiated in Complaint No. 477 of 2002 filed by Registrar of Companies under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act, 1956 for making false statement in the prospectus in 1995.
2. It is submitted by counsel for the petitioner that the complaint does not show that a false statement was made by the petitioner. It only shows that the petitioner has utilized the funds for different purposes than what was stated in the prospectus and at the most an offence under Section 406 IPC was made out and not an offence under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act. The other ground taken by the petitioner is that the period of limitation in filing the complaint had expired. The cognizance could be taken within three years from the date of knowledge of the offence and the period of limitation shall start from the date of filing of prospectus and the complaint was therefore beyond the period of limitation. The third ground taken by the petitioner is that the directors of the company of petitioner had resigned from the company during the year 2000 and the company was taken over by other management and there was no complaint from any of the investors.
3. A perusal of complaint filed by the complainant would show that the petitioner had issued prospectus being a public limited company and the prospectus informed the shareholders that the petitioner would undertake business of leasing activities and shall do business of hire purchase of the properties. However, the balance sheet for the year 1999-2000 showed that 70% of the shareholders funds amounting to Rs. 2.05 crore was deployed by the petitioner as advance deposits to the firms and companies pertaining to the directors and others and the leasing activities was almost NIL and not carried out by the company and if it was there it was much below the projections. The company in the year 2000-2001 indulged into sale and purchase of shares of more than Rs. 5 crore which was neither the object and business of the company as per public issue and the majority of valuable funds of the company have been diverted or siphoned off for objects other than the projected objects. It is submitted that the petitioner made untrue and misleading statement to the investors.
4. A false statement is a statement which has been made purposely so that people may believe existence of a fact which does not exist. In case of prospectus of a company, a statement of objects, which the directors had no intention to carry, amounts to false statement. The intention of making a false statement is to mislead or deceive the person to whom the statement is made. In this present case, the petitioner's company while issuing prospectus made a statement to intending investors that it would undertake the business of leasing and wanted people to subscribe to the shares for this purpose. It gave projections of profits and business of the company of only in the field of leasing. One can understand that the surplus funds of the company are deployed by the company in a businesslike and wise manner but one cannot understand that the business of the company is not even undertaken and the entire funds of the company are either invested in shares or in the firms and companies of the directors. It is thus prima facie apparent that from the very beginning, the directors had no intention to do business as set out in the prospectus and their intention was to mop up the funds from public and then to utilize the same for their own companies and firms in which they were directors or to invest in shares. It is thus obvious that the statement made in the prospectus was prima facie a false statement deliberately made knowing fully well that the funds were not going to be utilized for the purpose they were collected. I consider that the plea taken by the petitioner that the case falls under Section 406 IPC was not tenable and it was prima facie a case of deliberately making a false statement.
5. As far as limitation aspect is concerned, limitation of offences under Sections 63 and 628 of the Companies Act, 1956 starts from the date of knowledge of making a false statement. The Registrar of Companies learnt about making of false statement after filing of baláncesheet in the year 1999-2000, therefore, limitation would start only after the date of filing of balance sheet and not from the date of issuing prospectus and this plea, therefore, is not tenable. Whether the directors had resigned or not which is a question of fact which cannot be gone into by this Court and only the trial court, during trial can decide whether the directors had resigned or they continued to be the directors. I find no force in this petition. The petition is hereby dismissed with no orders to costs.
Alert