- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Samiuddin @ Chotu v. The State Of Nct Delhi
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal arises from the judgment dated 28.02.2005 by the Additional Sessions Judge convicting the appellant, accused No. 1, and another in FIR No. 155/2001 under Sections 397/392/457 IPC at Darya Ganj Police Station, Delhi. On 15.03.2001, at approximately 10:30 PM, the complainant, Zaffar Hussain, was at his residence with family when the appellant and three others forcibly entered, intimidated the occupants, and stole ornaments and valuables. Later, they took cash from the complainant's son and locked the family in the bathroom before fleeing. The accused were arrested on 24.05.2001 and made disclosures of their involvement. After investigation and trial, the appellant and one other accused were convicted under Sections 397 read with 392 IPC and Section 457 IPC, receiving concurrent sentences totaling seven years and three years imprisonment respectively, along with fines.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the provision of Section 397 IPC is applicable in the absence of recovery or production of the weapon (knife) allegedly used by the appellant during the robbery?
- Whether the appellant's conviction under Section 397 read with Section 392 IPC should be modified to a conviction solely under Section 392 IPC?
- What is the appropriate sentence for the appellant considering the modification of conviction?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant’s counsel confined submissions to the order of sentence alone.
- Section 397 IPC is not applicable as the knife, the alleged weapon, was neither recovered nor produced during trial.
- In absence of recovery of the knife, it cannot be presumed to be a deadly weapon, a necessary element to establish Section 397 IPC.
- Reliance was placed on precedents to argue that without proof of a deadly weapon, conviction should only be under Section 392 IPC.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bishan v. State, 1984 (6) DRJ 78 | Non-recovery of weapon precludes presumption that it was deadly for Section 397 IPC charge. | Supported the appellant’s argument that without recovery or production of the knife, Section 397 IPC is not attracted. |
| Rakesh Kumar v. The State of NCT of Delhi, 2005 (1) JCC 334 | Absence of weapon recovery negates charge under Section 397 IPC. | Reinforced the principle that deadly weapon must be proved to sustain Section 397 IPC conviction. |
| Sunil @ Munna v. State (Govt. Of NCT), 2010 (1) JCC 388 | Proof of deadly weapon necessary for Section 397 IPC; mere allegation insufficient without recovery. | Used to bolster the argument that the appellant’s conviction under Section 397 IPC was unsustainable. |
| Balik Ram v. The State, 1983 Crl.L.J 1438 | Weapon must be shown to victim and identified to be considered deadly for Section 397 IPC. | Cited to emphasize that absence of victim’s description or recovery of weapon undermines charge under Section 397 IPC. |
| Charan Singh v. The State, 1988 Crl.L.J NOC 28 (Delhi) | Non-recovery of knife used in robbery precludes presumption of deadly weapon; conviction only under Section 392 IPC possible. | Followed to conclude that without recovery or proof of deadly weapon, Section 397 IPC charge cannot stand. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the applicability of Section 397 IPC which requires the use of a deadly weapon during robbery. It noted that the knife, alleged to be the weapon, was neither recovered nor produced during trial. Citing precedents, the Court observed that for a charge under Section 397 IPC, the prosecution must prove that the weapon used was deadly, either by recovery, production, or victim’s description. The absence of such evidence in the present case led the Court to conclude that the charge under Section 397 IPC was not established. Consequently, the Court agreed with the appellant’s counsel that the conviction should be modified to one solely under Section 392 IPC. The Court then considered the appellant’s sentence already undergone and modified the sentence accordingly to four years rigorous imprisonment under Section 392 IPC.
Holding and Implications
The appeal was disposed of by modifying the conviction. The appellant’s conviction under Section 397 read with Section 392 IPC was altered to a conviction under Section 392 IPC only. The sentence was reduced to four years rigorous imprisonment under Section 392 IPC. This decision directly affects the appellant by reducing the severity of the conviction and sentence. No new legal precedent was established by this ruling.
HIMA KOHLI, J. (Oral)
1. The present appeal arises out of the judgment dated 28.02.2005 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, convicting the appellant, accused No. 1 and one other in FIR No. 155/2001 lodged under Sections 397/392/457 IPC with Police Station: Darya Ganj, Delhi.
2. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that on 15.03.2001 at about 10:30 PM, when the complainant, Zaffar Hussain was at his residence on the second floor of premises No. 1669, Kucha Dhakni Rai, Daryaganj, Delhi, in the company of the members of his family, the door bell rang and the appellant with three other persons entered the room, intimidated the inmates and forced the women to hand over their ornaments. They opened the almirahs and removed certain valuable articles. Twenty minutes later, when the son of the complainant rang the door bell, the accused persons opened the door and surrounded the son and took away his cash. Thereafter, they locked the family in the bathroom and decamped with the stolen articles. On 24.05.2001, the accused persons were arrested and they made disclosure of their involvement in the robbery. Upon completion of investigation, the charge-sheet was filed, charges were framed and the accused persons pleaded innocence. The matter was taken up for trial. The prosecution examined 14 witnesses in support of its case. PW-3, Smt. Shehnaaz and PW-10, Waseem Ahmed identified the four accused, including the appellant.
3. The trial court considered the entire evidence and concluded that there was no doubt that the robbery committed at the residence of the complainant by the accused persons. Taking into consideration the testimony of PW-3, PW-10 and PW-14, Mr. Shahabuddin, the involvement of the appellant and three other accused was confirmed by the impugned judgment. However, accused Nos. 2 & 3, Nazim and Mohd. Arif were given the benefit of doubt. The appellant/accused No. 1 and accused No. 4, Rakesh Chauhan were held guilty of the offence under Section 397 read with Section 392 IPC as also under Section 457 IPC, having intruded in the house at night by force. As per the order on sentence passed by the learned ASJ on 01.03.2005, the appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of seven years and to pay a fine of Rs. 500/- for committing the offence under Section 397 read with Section 392 IPC. For the offence punishable under Section 457 IPC, the appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of three years and to pay a fine of Rs. 500/-. In default of payment of fine, the appellant was required to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for a period of three months. Both the sentences were directed to run concurrently and the benefit under Section 428 Cr. PC was given to the appellant.
4. At the outset, counsel for the appellant submits that he shall confine his submissions in the appeal, to the order of sentence alone. He states that in the present case, the provision of section 397 ipc is not applicable as the knife, which was the weapon of offence and purportedly carried by the appellant, was not recovered or for that matter, produced during the trial. He relies on the judgments in the cases of Bishan v. State reported as 1984 (6) DRJ 78, Rakesh Kumar v. The State of NCT of Delhi reported as 2005 (1) JCC 334 and Sunil @ Munna… v. State (Govt. Of Nct)….) reported as 2010 (1) JCC 388 to submit that in the absence of recovery of the knife, allegedly used by the appellant at the time of commission of robbery/dacoity, it cannot be presumed that the knife used was a deadly weapon and in such circumstances, charge under Section 397 IPC cannot be established. Thus, he submits that the accused could be convicted only under Section 392 IPC.
5. In the case of Balik Ram v. The State reported as 1983 Crl.L.J 1438, a coordinate Bench of this Court had held as below:-
“….. Though the knife that was recovered from the accused a few hours of the occurrence was no doubt a deadly one on account of its size and design but it was not shown to the victim when he came to depose nor has he given any description of the knife so that it could be held that the knife alleged to have been placed by the accused on his abdomen was the one recovered or the one similar to that one. The accused can, therefore, legitimately claim that the weapon used by him has not been proved to be a deadly one……”
6. In the case of Charan Singh v. The State reported as 1988 Crl.L.J NOC 28 (Delhi), in a similar situation where it was not established that the knife used for committing the robbery was in fact a deadly weapon within the meaning of Section 397 IPC, the Court held that in the absence of recovery of the knife, which was allegedly used at the time of commission of the offence/dacoity, it could not be presumed that the knife so used was a deadly weapon. Following were the observations made by the Court in this regard:-
“At the time of committing dacoity one of the offenders caused injury by knife on the hand of the victim but the said knife was not recovered. In order to bring home a charge under S. 397, the prosecution must produce convincing evidence that the knife used by the accused was a deadly weapon. What would make knife deadly is its design or the method of its use such as is calculated to or is likely to produce death. It is, therefore, a question of fact to be proved by the prosecution that the knife used by the accused was a deadly weapon. In the absence of such an evidence and particularly, the non-recovery of the weapon would certainly bring the case out of the ambit of S. 397. The accused could be convicted under S. 392.” (emphasis added)
7. Even in the present case, it is an undisputed fact that the knife in question was not recovered, much less produced in the course of trial. In such circumstances, this Court is inclined to agree with the submission of the counsel for the appellant that the appellant could be sentenced under Section 392 IPC alone and the offence does not fall within the ambit of Section 397 IPC.
8. Counsel for the appellant submits that as per the nominal roll placed on the record, the appellant had undergone sentence for a period of three years, seven months and four days as on 23.05.2006 Thereafter, the appellant was undergoing conviction in some other case and now for the past three months, he is undergoing conviction in the present case. It is, therefore, submitted that the appellant has undergone conviction for a period of approximately three years 10 months in the present case.
9. Having regard to the fact that this Court has modified the conviction of the appellant to one under Section 392 IPC, the order on sentence is consequently modified and he is sentenced under Section 392 IPC, for a period of four years.
10. The appeal is disposed of.
(HIMA KOHLI) NOVEMBER 9, 2010 JUDGE rkb
Alert