- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bessy Edison And Another v. Indira Gandhi National Open University
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
Two petitioners completed the Post Basic B.Sc. in Nursing from Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) with the study centre at Safdarjung Hospital in 2009 and 2008 respectively and were awarded degrees. In July 2010 they applied for admission to the M.Sc. Nursing course at Nightingale Institute of Nursing (respondent No. 4). Respondent No. 4 demanded a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Indian Nursing Council (INC). INC replied by letter dated 4 August 2010 stating it had approved only 11 IGNOU study centres for the Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing programme and that Safdarjung Hospital was not included, thereby denying registration for M.Sc. admission.
The petitioners sought relief directing INC to approve IGNOU's Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing programme with the Safdarjung Hospital study centre so they could pursue M.Sc. IGNOU confirmed its Degree and contested INC's position. Notice was issued, affidavits were filed by INC and IGNOU, additional documents were produced by IGNOU, and hearings were conducted. The Court ultimately considered the petition limited to the two petitioners and passed directions as set out below.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioners' Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing qualifications obtained through IGNOU's study centre at Safdarjung Hospital were valid for purposes of registration/admission to the M.Sc. Nursing course in view of INC's contention that Safdarjung was not an approved study centre.
- Whether, in the circumstances (including IGNOU's conduct and the timing of INC's actions), equitable relief should be moulded to require INC to issue the NOC for the petitioners despite the technical non-approval of that study centre.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Position
- The petitioners completed and were awarded the Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing degrees from IGNOU through the Safdarjung Hospital study centre and sought admission to M.Sc. Nursing.
- They were denied admission because INC stated that Safdarjung was not among approved study centres; they claimed to be caught between IGNOU and INC and sought a direction to INC to approve the course/centre or at least to issue the NOC so they could pursue M.Sc.
IGNOU's Arguments
- INC initially approached IGNOU (dating back to 1988) to commence the Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing programme and gave a blanket approval; the first batch commenced in 1997.
- INC never, at the relevant time, required IGNOU to obtain specific approval for each study centre; no restriction was placed when recognition was granted that limited recognition to specified centres.
- Safdarjung Hospital was independently approved/recognized by INC and the State Nursing Council for certain nursing programmes and acted as IGNOU's study centre since April 1997, producing graduates and M.Sc. students; practical training was provided there and the centre had a record of student achievement.
- INC sought inspection in 1999 but did not carry out inspection; in June 2000 INC issued a blanket recognition certificate without limitation; inspection was raised much later (2006).
- IGNOU contended it had reasonable belief that separate approvals for each study centre were not required and had no notice from INC that Safdarjung was not recognized.
INC's Arguments
- INC's statutory role under the Indian Nursing Council Act, 1947, includes deciding suitability of individual institutions to impart training for recognised qualifications; hence separate approval/suitability for each study centre is vital.
- IGNOU has a dual role (degree-conferring authority and course-runner) and where it runs the programme across the country, separate approval of each study centre was required; no approval was granted to Safdarjung Hospital when the petitioners pursued their studies.
- At the relevant time, Safdarjung Hospital was not eligible to conduct graduation classes; only 18 IGNOU centres were inspected and approved. The fact that IGNOU's Secretary or faculty members were present at Safdarjung did not absolve IGNOU from seeking prior permission from INC.
- Accepting IGNOU's contentions would undermine INC's statutory function of ensuring adequate teaching, clinical and infrastructural facilities at each study centre.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shiv Shakti Educational Society v. State of Punjab (Division Bench, Punjab & Haryana HC, 19.12.2007) (CWP 17254/2007) | Relied on by INC (as cited by INC's counsel) to support the position that study centres require approval/inspection. | The Court noted the case was relied upon by INC but did not decide the larger question; IGNOU sought to distinguish it. The Court proceeded to decide the petition limited to the two petitioners without resolving or adopting that precedent's broader implications. |
| Laxmi Sharma v. V.C., Chhatrapati Shahuji Maharaj University, (2006) 9 SCC 138 | Permitted students to take examinations where there was an expectation of affiliation; used as a comparative precedent where students were allowed to avoid penalisation despite institutional irregularity. | The Court found the present facts to be on a stronger footing than in Laxmi Sharma and used it as persuasive support for granting relief to students who had a reasonable belief that the course and degree were recognized. |
| State of West Bengal v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, (2010) 3 SCC 571 | Article 226 confers wide powers on High Courts to reach injustice and to mould relief to meet peculiar requirements. | The Court invoked this principle to justify moulding relief in equity for the petitioners given the particular facts, reinforcing the High Court's latitude under Article 226. |
| B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, (1995) 6 SCC 749 | High Courts should do complete justice and mould relief where necessary; absence of a provision parallel to Article 142 for High Courts is not a barrier to doing complete justice. | Relied upon to support the proposition that the High Court may mould relief to do complete justice between the parties in the present factual matrix. |
| FCI v. S.N. Nagarkar, (2002) 2 SCC 475 | Authority cited for the same general proposition about moulding relief to do justice (as applied in B.C. Chaturvedi). | Cited as part of a cluster of Supreme Court authorities underscoring the High Court's power to mould equitable relief; supported the Court's willingness to fashion relief in favour of petitioners. |
| ESI Corporation v. Jardine Henderson Staff Association, (2006) 6 SCC 581 | Similarly cited for the proposition that courts can and should mould relief to accomplish complete justice. | Used to bolster the Court's reliance on equitable powers under Article 226 to grant the limited relief requested by petitioners. |
| A. Sudha v. University of Mysore, (1987) 4 SCC 537 | Where a candidate reasonably relied on information supplied by institute authorities, the student should not be penalised for institutional failings. | The Court applied the analogy that petitioners had a justified reliance on representations and recognition and therefore ought not to be penalised; this supported granting relief to the petitioners. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court confined its decision to the two petitioners and expressly declined to decide the broader legal question whether INC's recognition of IGNOU without specifying study centres necessarily required separate approval of each study centre. The analysis proceeded as follows:
- Examination of documentary record: The Court found that in the recognition granted to IGNOU and in correspondence around the relevant time there was nothing indicating that approval of individual study centres was mandatory or that recognition carried such a limitation.
- Chronology of inspections and recognition: Although inspection was raised in 1999, no inspection of study centres was carried out then; a recognition certificate without limitation was issued in June 2000. The requirement or insistence on inspection emerged formally only in November 2006, after the petitioners had already joined the programme at Safdarjung Hospital.
- IGNOU's bona fide belief: Based on the history of interactions and the documents, the Court accepted that IGNOU had a bona fide belief that it need not seek separate approval for each study centre and that it conducted admissions representing that successful completion would lead to an INC-recognised degree.
- Conduct of INC: INC did not, during the relevant period, disturb the position or indicate to IGNOU or the students that the Safdarjung centre lacked recognition. The Court observed that INC, bound by statutes, rules and regulations, could not itself grant an ad hoc exception but had not acted earlier to invalidate students' reasonable expectations.
- Equitable considerations specific to nursing: The Court placed weight on the nature of the nursing profession (practical and service-oriented), the large and premier status of Safdarjung Hospital as a training ground, absence of material showing that the centre was incapable of imparting necessary practical training, and the fact that examination standards were uniform across centres and the petitioners had cleared those examinations.
- Precedential support for moulding relief: The Court relied on Supreme Court authorities (e.g., Laxmi Sharma; State of West Bengal v. CPDR; B.C. Chaturvedi; others) emphasizing the High Court's broad remedial powers under Article 226 and the principle that students should not be penalised for institutional deficiencies when they reasonably relied on representations or the institutional position.
- Narrow tailoring of relief: Given these findings and equitable considerations, the Court opted to grant relief limited to the two petitioners rather than resolve the broader legal dispute about the necessity of study centre approvals in general.
Holding and Implications
PETITION ALLOWED TO THE AFORESAID EXTENT
Holding (directives):
- Respondent No. 2 (Indian Nursing Council) is directed to issue the requisite NOC to the two petitioners within 10 days to enable them to gain admission to the M.Sc. Nursing course.
- Respondent No. 4 (Nightingale Institute of Nursing) is directed to admit the petitioners to the M.Sc. Nursing course in the current academic year. The Court noted that respondent No. 4 had been represented and had not raised any objection.
- The petition is disposed of and there is no order as to costs.
Implications and limits of the decision:
- The relief is strictly limited to the two petitioners and is granted on the peculiar facts and equities of the case (bona fide belief, timing of INC's inspection requirement, the petitioners' qualification and examination success, and the nature of the Safdarjung Hospital as a training centre).
- The Court expressly clarified that nothing in its order should be read as a holding that INC's approval of individual IGNOU study centres is not necessary; the order does not entitle other students of the said study centre to similar benefits. No broad precedent was laid down nullifying INC's regulatory function.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to and derived from the content of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the opinion text.
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.:— The two petitioners filed this petition pleading that they had in the year 2009 and 2008 respectively completed and passed the course of Post Basic B.Sc in Nursing from the respondent No. 1 Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) with study centre at Safdarjung Hospital and were awarded the Degrees therefor; that they had in July, 2010 applied for admission to the course of M.Sc Nursing in respondent No. 4 Nightingale Institute of Nursing; that the respondent No. 4 demanded NOC of the respondent No. 2 Indian Nursing Council (INC) for confirmation of admission of the petitioners; that the petitioners accordingly applied to INC but INC vide its letter dated 4th August, 2010 informed the petitioners that INC had only approved 11 study centres for Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme through distance learning by IGNOU and Safdarjung Hospital was not included therein and thus denying registration to the petitioners for M.Sc Nursing Course in the respondent No. 4 College. The petitioners claim that they, thereafter approached the IGNOU which confirmed that it was recognized for granting Degree for Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Course and the Degree awarded to the petitioners was valid. The petitioners averring that they are caught between IGNOU and INC filed this petition claiming the relief of issuance of direction to INC to approve the Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Course of IGNOU with study centre at Safdarjung Hospital to enable the petitioners to pursue M.Sc Nursing course at the respondent No. 4 College.
2. Notice of the petition was issued. The counsel for IGNOU on 10th September, 2010 contended that the Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme of IGNOU was recognized by INC. It was further contended that while granting the said recognition no restriction was placed that the recognition was granted for the programme/course only with respect to a particular study centre. The counsel for INC however contended that in pursuance to recognition, IGNOU was required to seek approval for each study centre and no approval for the study centre at Safdarjung Hospital was sought and thus the course/programme conducted by IGNOU at the said study centre and the Degree awarded therefor is not valid. In view of the said competing claims, both IGNOU and INC were directed to file affidavits. The counsel for IGNOU, during the hearing on 6th October, 2010, produced certain additional documents and opportunity was given to INC to respond to the same.
3. It is the case of IGNOU that it was the INC itself which had approached IGNOU as far back as in the year 1988 to commence the Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme with a duration of three years through distance education; that after compliance of various formalities, the first batch of the course commenced in the year 1997; that between the years 1988-97, INC, at no point of time required IGNOU to have approved its study centres where the education in the said course/programme was to be imparted and a blanket approval had been given by INC to IGNOU. With respect to Safdarjung Hospital it is pleaded that the same is independently approved and recognized by INC and State Nursing Council for conducting GNM Programme and now B.Sc Nursing Programme; that it has been acting as a study centre for IGNOU for B.Sc Nursing Programme since April, 1997; that from 1997 to 2009, 150 students had graduated from the said centre and of which one has already completed M.Sc Nursing and two are in the final year of M.Sc Nursing and three others are in the first year of M.Sc Nursing. It is also pleaded that two students from the centre at Safdarjung Hospital have been awarded gold medal for securing highest marks in the country. It is yet further pleaded that Safdarjung Hospital is also a centre for practical training sessions of RAK College of Nursing. It is also the plea of IGNOU that in the year 2005 the Secretary of INC was part of the faculty of the School of Nursing, Safdarjung Hospital for the course of Post Basic B.Sc in Nursing being run by IGNOU. It is further the case of IGNOU that INC in 1999 sought inspection of IGNOU programme and IGNOU accordingly intimated the School of Nursing at Safdarjung Hospital also of the inspection but INC for reasons best known to it did not carry out the inspection; that in June 2000, INC again gave a blanket approval to IGNOU to run the programme without setting out therein any list of approved study centres. It is pleaded that in the circumstances IGNOU had no cause, reason or justification to assume that its study centre at Safdarjung Hospital was not approved by INC and the letter dated 4th August, 2010 (supra) of INC came as a bolt from the blue to IGNOU also a that prior thereto INC had never intimated to IGNOU that its study centre at Safdarjung Hospital was not recognized. It is also informed that besides the study centre at Safdarjung Hospital, IGNOU has 50 other study centres for Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme and no approval with respect to other centres also had been given. IGNOU further pleads that the study centres having been independently approved by INC and State Nursing Council, are not required to be inspected again for the purposes of recognition as aforesaid. IGNOU thus supports the case of the petitioners.
4. INC in its counter affidavit, with reference to the provisions of the Indian Nursing Council Act, 1947 has pleaded that INC has been set up not only to grant recognition of qualifications but also to decide the suitability of individual institutions to impart training for awarding the said recognized qualifications. It is pleaded that IGNOU has a dual role of an authority conferring Degrees and of running its own course; that since IGNOU was to run the Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme all across the country, separate approval/suitability from INC of each study centre was vital. It is pleaded that no approval was granted to Safdarjung Hospital at the relevant time when the petitioners pursued Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Programme therefrom. It is informed that at that time Safdarjung Hospital was having only a School of Nursing and was not eligible to conduct graduation classes in nursing; that only 18 centres of IGNOU were inspected and approved. With respect to the RAK College of Nursing, it is explained that the students thereof were pursuing their studies from RAK College of Nursing and doing only their clinical studies from Safdarjung Hospital. It is further stated that its Secretary who was stated by IGNOU to be a part of its study centre in Safdarjung Hospital in the year 2005 did not seek any permission from INC and was not expected to join the faculty of IGNOU without prior permission. It is further contended that if the contentions of IGNOU were to be accepted, it would lead to all study centres of IGNOU whether they have proper teaching; clinical and infrastructural facilities or not being competent to impart education and award Degrees and which it is contended cannot be permitted.
5. From the additional documents filed by IGNOU it transpires that INC only in November, 2006 directed IGNOU to have its study centres inspected and demanded fee therefor.
6. The counsels for the petitioners and the counsel for IGNOU in their respective submissions reiterated the aforesaid pleadings. The learned ASG appearing for INC also relied on the judgment dated 19th December, 2007 of the Division Bench of High Court of Punjab and Haryana in CWP 17254/2007 titled Shiv Shakti Educational Society v. State of Punjab. The ASG has also contended that it was always understood by IGNOU that its study centres were required to be approved by INC and as and when IGNOU paid fee for inspection of the study centres, the same were inspected. Reference is also made to Sections 10(2), 11, 12 and 13 of the INC Act to contend that it is the obligatory function of INC to adjudge the suitability of the institution imparting education. The counsel for IGNOU in his rejoinder has sought to distinguish the judgment of the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court by contending that in the present case there is prior approval of INC to the Degree of IGNOU and without requiring approval of the study centres. The senior counsel subsequently appearing for IGNOU has also argued that IGNOU has been established under a Central enactment viz. IGNOU Act, 1985, is the largest University in the world and the Degree is granted by the University and not by the individual study centre. It is further urged that INC was always aware of the Safdarjung Hospital being a study centre of IGNOU and never objected to the same.
7. In the facts of the present case I do not feel the need to go into the larger question of whether the recognition granted by INC to IGNOU without specifying any study centre required approval of each of the study centre or not. Nor is it deemed necessary to consider the larger relief claimed of grant of approval of Post Basic B.Sc Nursing Course of IGNOU with study centre at Safdarjung Hospital. The matter has been considered qua the two petitioners only. On the facts and documents it is clearly established that in the recognition granted to IGNOU and/or in any of the correspondence/documents of the corresponding time there is nothing to indicate that approval of study centre was to be taken. Though the question of inspection did come up in the year 1999 after the grant of recognition in 1997 but admittedly no inspection of any of the study centre was carried out. The recognition certificate without any such limitation was; issued in June, 2000. The question of inspection was thereafter raised only in November, 2006 and by which time the petitioners had already joined the course/programme with the study centre at Safdarjung Hospital.
8. It thus appears that IGNOU was under a bona fide belief that it was not required to obtain any approval for each of its study centres. IGNOU continued to admit students to the said course/programme with study centre at Safdarjung Hospital representing that upon successful completion of the course/programme Degree recognized by INC will be awarded. INC also did lot take any steps to disturb the said position. The petitioners thus joined the said course with the hope of enhancing their qualifications and prospects a life. It also cannot be forgotten that IGNOU is not a private enterprise which can be said to be lured by profit or other considerations into deceiving or admitting students. The question which thus arises is as to whether in these circumstances the petitioners should be granted relief or not. Finding he facts and circumstances loaded in favour of the petitioners, at one time the learned ASG was asked to take instructions on whether, even if the stand of INC was correct, an exception could be made in favour of the petitioners. The INC, of course, bound by its Statutes, Rules and Regulations could not give any such consent.
9. However, this Court finds equity heavily loaded in favour of the petitioners. The petitioners belong to the nursing profession which is an arduous and a noble profession. It is not merely an occupation to earn a giving but a benevolent Service. Nursing of the sick, said Florence Nightingale is a vocation as well as a profession. Nurses live in the midst of distressing atmosphere and the Tribunals/Courts cannot shut their minds to the said reality while dealing with the issues relating to the nursing profession. They have toiled for three years to obtain qualification of Post Basic Graduation in Nursing and now are desirous of having post graduation. Safdarjung Hospital where from the petitioners have done their graduation is also a large premier government hospital with thousands of patients everyday and with most eminent persons in its faculty. No particular fact has come on record to show that the study, centre of IGNOU it Safdarjung Hospital even if having no formal approval, was not equipped to impart the necessary education/training to the petitioners. Nursing is a profession with much more emphasis on practice and experience than on theory. I find it hard to believe that the petitioners in their three years graduation course at study centre in Safdarjung Hospital would not have imbibed the necessary practical experience and education for graduation in nursing. Even otherwise, the examination for conferring the Degree is held by the University. According to INC also some of the study centres of IGNOU and the Degree in B.Sc Nursing of IGNOU were approved. The examination held by IGNOU for students of the approved and unapproved study centres was the same. The very fact that the petitioners have cleared the said examination shows that the petitioners did not lack in any theoretical knowledge also of the subject. The Supreme Court in Laxmi Sharma v. V.C, Chhatrapati Shahuji Maharaj University, (2006) 9 SCC 138 in a somewhat similar situation and where there was only an expectation in the mind of the college authorities that permanent affiliation would be granted to the college and which had also encouraged students to take admission in the hope of being granted affiliation allowed the students to take examinations even in the absence of affiliation. Even though the judgment is not to be treated as a precedent but I find the facts of the present case to be on a much higher pedestal. Here, there was a belief as distinct from an expectation that the Course and the Degree are recognized.
10. The Supreme Court in State of West Bengal v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, (2010) 3 SCC 571 reiterated that Article 226 is designedly couched in a wide language in order not to confine the power conferred by it only to the power to issue prerogative writs but to enable the High Courts to reach injustice wherever it is found and to mould the relief to meet the peculiar and complicated requirements of this country. Similarly in B.C Chaturvedi v. Union of India, (1995) 6 SCC 749 it was held that the mere fact that there is no provision parallel to Article 142 relating to the High Courts can be no ground to hold that the High Courts have not to do complete justice and if moulding of relief would do complete justice between the parties the same cannot be ordered. To the same effect are the judgments in FCI v. S.N Nagarkar, (2002) 2 SCC 475 and ESI Corporation v. Jardine Henderson Staff Association, (2006) 6 SCC 581. Mention may also be made of A. Sudha v. University of Mysore, (1987) 4 SCC 537 where even though the candidate was held ineligible for admission to MBBS Course but finding the candidate to have been justified in relying upon the information supplied by the Principal of the Institute and holding that in these circumstances the student ought not to be penalized, was allowed to continue pursuing the MBBS Course.
11. The petition is therefore allowed to the aforesaid extent. The respondent No. 2 INC is directed to within 10 days hereof issue the requisite NOC to the petitioners to enable the petitioners to gain admission for M.Sc Nursing. Though the NOC for the reasons aforesaid could not be submitted by the petitioners within the time directed by the respondent No. 4 but the respondent No. 4 has been represented before this Court and has not raised any objection. The respondent No. 4 is directed to admit the petitioners to M.Sc Nursing Course in the current academic year. It is however clarified that nothing contained in this order shall tantamount to this Court holding that the approval as contended by INC to be necessary of study centres of IGNOU is not so-necessary or entitle any other student of the said study centre to any benefit from INC the relief to the petitioners having been granted in the peculiar facts aforesaid. The petition is disposed of. No order as to costs.
Alert