- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hindustan Industrial Resources Ltd v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax.
Case Summary — Opinion of Badar Durrez Ahmed, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The assessee company purchased a piece of land situated in Tugalpur, Tehsil of Greater Noida, on 15.03.1989. The land was thereafter acquired by the Greater Noida Authority under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894; the Award in the acquisition proceedings was passed by the District Collector (Land Acquisition), Greater Noida, on 01.04.1992 and, according to that Award, the land was agricultural land.
The Assessing Officer charged capital gains of Rs. 18,57,932 on the view that the assessee had purchased the land with the intention of setting up an industry and had not carried out agricultural operations nor declared agricultural income, and therefore the land was not agricultural in the hands of the assessee. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) confirmed this view. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) also rejected the assessee's appeal: although the ITAT noted the Award established the land was agricultural, it concluded that a presumption of non-agricultural character arose because of the acquiring authority's intention for planned industrial development and the assessee's alleged intention and non-use for agriculture. The present appeal challenges the ITAT's order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal holding that the land acquired from the ownership of the appellant was not agricultural land, is perverse?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The intention to use a piece of land for a non-agricultural purpose in the future cannot by itself alter the character of the land; what matters is the nature and character of the land on the date it was acquired.
- The Award (dated 01.04.1992) established that the land was agricultural, and the land was agricultural at the time of the assessee's purchase; therefore the land should be treated as agricultural land for income-tax purposes.
- Relied on prior decisions of this Court (cited as D.L.F. Housing and Construction (P) Ltd v. Commissioner of Income-tax Delhi (Central): 141 ITR 806; D.L.F. United Limited v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 161 ITR 714; and D.L.F. United Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 217 ITR 333) for the principle that mere intention to develop or sell later does not convert agricultural land into non-agricultural land where till the date of the Award or acquisition the land continued to be used for agriculture.
Revenue's Arguments
- The facts of the present case are distinguishable from the D.L.F. decisions because, although the land was agricultural when purchased, the assessee did not carry out agricultural operations nor declare agricultural income; this non-use altered the nature of the land.
- Relied upon G. Venkataswami Naidu and Co. v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 35 ITR 594, for the proposition that purchase made solely and exclusively with intent to resell at a profit is a relevant factor and can raise a presumption that the transaction is an adventure in the nature of trade; such a presumption is strong unless offset by other facts.
- Submitted that intention (to use for non-agricultural purpose and to resell) is a relevant factor which, given the attendant facts, justified concluding that the land was not agricultural in the hands of the assessee.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| D.L.F. Housing and Construction (P) Ltd v. Commissioner of Income-tax Delhi (Central): 141 ITR 806 | Principle that mere purchase with a view to later development or resale does not, by itself, convert land used for agriculture into a non-agricultural/trading asset where there was no attempt to alter the character of the land before the date of the Award/acquisition. | The Court treated this decision as directly applicable and persuasive for the proposition that the character of land is to be judged by its nature on the relevant dates (purchase and acquisition) and that mere intention to develop later is insufficient to change that character. |
| D.L.F. United Limited v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 161 ITR 714 | Followed the principle in 141 ITR 806 regarding the irrelevance of mere future intention to change use where no change in actual use occurred before acquisition. | Relied upon by the appellant and considered by the Court as consistent authority supporting the appellant's position. |
| D.L.F. United Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 217 ITR 333 | Reaffirmation of the principle that character of land depends on its actual use up to the date of acquisition/Award, not on undeveloped intentions. | Relied upon by the appellant; the Court viewed these decisions collectively as controlling and persuasive. |
| G. Venkataswami Naidu and Co. v. The Commissioner of Income-tax: 35 ITR 594 | Where purchase was made solely and exclusively with intent to resell at a profit and purchaser had no intention of holding or using the property, existence of such intention is a relevant factor raising a presumption of an adventure in the nature of trade; the presumption is rebuttable. | Relied upon by the revenue to show intention is a relevant factor; the Court observed the decision but noted it addresses the nature of the transaction (adventure in trade) and that the presumption is rebuttable; the Court found it not strictly applicable to the present question of whether land is agricultural. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first set out the essential factual findings in the record: (a) the Tribunal itself had found that on the date of purchase (15.03.1989) the land was agricultural; and (b) the Award dated 01.04.1992 in the acquisition proceedings established beyond doubt that the land was agricultural on the date of acquisition. The Court reasoned that where both those clear findings exist, it is not open to the Tribunal to conclude that the nature and character of the land changed in the intervening period without record support for such a change.
The Court emphasized that mere intention of the purchaser (the assessee) to use the land for industrial purposes in the future does not, by itself, alter the character of the land. The Court noted further that the fact the assessee did not carry out agricultural operations after purchase did not equate to an alteration of the land's character: there was no evidence that any industrial operations (such as erection of plant or machinery) were undertaken to show conversion of the land's character from agricultural to industrial.
The Court criticized the ITAT for treating as decisive the intentions of the acquiring authority and the assessee, when the Tribunal had also recorded the two clear findings about the land's agricultural character at purchase and at acquisition. The Court concluded that the Tribunal's ultimate conclusion was contrary to its own record — a conclusion amounting to perversity. On that basis the Court held the Tribunal's order unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The central ruling is stated as: APPEAL ALLOWED; the impugned order of the ITAT is set aside.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The decision is in favour of the appellant/assessee; the ITAT's finding that the land was not agricultural is reversed and the impugned order is set aside. The appeal was allowed with costs in favour of the appellant.
- Scope of the ruling: The Court vacated the Tribunal's conclusion because it was contrary to its own recorded findings (i.e., it was perverse). The Court relied on the principle that the character of land is to be judged by its nature on the relevant dates (purchase and acquisition), and that mere undeveloped intention to use land for non-agricultural purposes does not by itself convert agricultural land into non-agricultural land.
- Broader precedent: The opinion does not purport to establish a new principle beyond applying and following existing authorities (the D.L.F. decisions and related jurisprudence). The Court did not make any additional broad pronouncements beyond reversing the ITAT for perversity and reiterating that intention alone, without physical or demonstrable change in use, is not determinative of the land's character.
This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or legal conclusions beyond those contained in the opinion itself.
Badar Durrez Ahmed, J.— The substantial question of law which arises in this appeal is:—
“Whether the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal holding that the land acquired from the ownership of the appellant was not agricultural land, is perverse?”
2. The issue which arose before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was with regard to the treatment to be given to the land owned by the assessee company with the future intention of setting up an industry thereon. The said land was acquired under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The Assessing Officer charged capital gains thereon to the extent of Rs 18,57,932/-. The assessee has throughout maintained that the land in question was land falling within the definition of agricultural land given in Section 2 (14)(iii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the said Act). It was therefore, contended by the assessee that no capital gains could be charged in respect of the land.
3. The land in question which is situated in Tugalpur, Tehsil of Greater Noida, was purchased by the assessee company on 15.03.1989 Shortly thereafter it was acquired by the Greater Noida Authority and compensation was paid to the assessee company. It may be relevant to note that the Award was passed by the District Collector (Land Acquisition), Greater Noida, U. P. on 01.04.1992 and that the Award clearly established that the land in question was agricultural land.
4. According to the Assessing Officer, the assessee company had purchased the said land under long term planning to set up an industry and no agricultural operations had been carried out by the assessee since the purchase of land in the year 1989-1990. The Assessing Officer also noted that no agricultural income had been shown by the assessee in its returns of income. The Assessing Officer was of the view that the land ceased to be agricultural land when the assessee company purchased it from the agriculturist for setting up an industry. He, therefore, rejected the assessees contention that the land in question was exempt from capital gains inasmuch as the Assessing Officer was of the view that the same was not agricultural land in the hands of the assessee company.
5. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the assessment order. He was of the view that the land in question ceased to be agricultural land on 15.03.1989 when it was purchased with the intention of setting up an industry. He noted that no agricultural operations had been carried out by the assessee on the land in question as no income from that source had been declared. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) also noted that the assessee had never intended to carry out any agricultural operations on the land in question. Consequently, he confirmed the finding of the Assessing Officer that the said land was not agricultural land and, therefore, liable to capital gains.
6. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal also upheld the view taken by the authorities below. However, while doing so, the Tribunal noted in paragraph 7 of its order that the Award dated 01.04.1992 passed in the acquisition proceedings, is a document which clearly establishes beyond doubt that the land in question was agricultural land. However, the Tribunal did not follow up this conclusion with any decision in favour of the assessee merely on the plea that the purpose of acquisition itself was for the establishment of planned industrial development. Consequently, the Tribunal held that, though to begin with, prior to its purchase by the assessee in 1989, the land in question was agricultural land, notice under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued by the Land Acquisition Collector and by that time the intention of the acquiring authority was clear that the land sought to be acquired was for the purposes of planned industrial development. The Tribunal took the view that though the intention of the assessee might not have been paramount, the fact remained that all through no agricultural operations had been carried out. The Tribunal was also impressed by the fact that the acquisition was also for the very same purpose, that is, for planned industrial development. The Tribunal was of the view that while the presumption did arise that the land in question was agricultural land, the same stood amply rebutted because, according to the Tribunal, the assessee never used the same as agricultural land. Moreover, the intention of the assessee was to develop the land for industrial purposes. The Tribunal was also of the view that the intention of the land acquisition authorities for acquiring the land was for planned industrial development. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the intention in respect of this land, both of the assessee as well as of the acquiring authorities, was to use it for industrial purposes. The Tribunal held that it is this intention which had acquired the status of a presumption and even if it be construed as a rebuttable presumption, the assessee had failed to rebut this presumption. Consequently, the assessees appeal was rejected.
7. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. The learned counsel for the assessee/appellant submitted that intention to use a particular piece of land for a non-agricultural purpose cannot by itself alter the character of the land. It was submitted by him that what is to be seen is what was the nature and character of the land on the date the same was acquired. The learned counsel submitted that this issue had been considered by this Court on several occasions, as indicated in the decisions reported in D.L.F Housing and Construction (P) Ltd v. Commissioner of Income-tax Delhi (Central): 141 ITR 806; D.L.F United Limited v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 161 ITR 714 and D.L.F United Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax: 217 ITR 333. The decision in 141 ITR 806 (supra) has been followed in the other two cases. In 141 ITR 806 (supra), this Court, in similar circumstances, observed that the assessee therein had not, till the date of the Award, made any attempt to convert or alter the character of the land as it was used for agriculture alone throughout. The Court observed that the mere circumstance that the land in question may have been purchased with a view to develop it later on and sell it at a profit in the shape of plots would be hardly enough to justify the inference that it was a trading asset or a venture in the nature of trade. On the strength of these decisions, the learned counsel for the appellant/assessee submitted that the intention to use the land in a particular way in future was not what was relevant. The important point to be noted was what was the character of the land on the date when it was acquired.
8. Mrs Bansal, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the revenue, submitted that the facts of the present case were distinguishable from the facts of the three decisions cited by the learned counsel for the appellant. She submitted that in all those cases although the intention was to use the land for non-agricultural purposes, but nothing had been done till the date of acquisition for altering the manner in which the land had hitherto been used i.e, for agricultural purposes. She submitted that in the present case although it is true that the land, when purchased by the assessee, was agricultural land, the assessee did not carry out any agricultural operations thereon. Thus, according to her, the nature of the land stood altered by this fact. This, according to her, was a distinguishable factor between the present case and the three decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant/assessee. She also placed reliance on G. Venkataswami Naidu and Co. v. The Commissioner of Income-tax: 35 ITR 594, wherein the Supreme Court observed that in cases where the purchase had been made solely and exclusively with an intention to resell at a profit and the purchaser had no intention of holding the property for himself or otherwise enjoying or using it, presence of such an intention is no doubt a relevant factor and unless it is offset by the other factors, it would raise a strong presumption that the transaction is an adventure in the nature of trade. The Supreme Court, however, held that the presumption was not conclusive and it was quite conceivable that, on considering all the facts and circumstances in the case, the court may, despite the said initial intention, be inclined to hold that the transaction was not an adventure in the nature of trade. The Supreme Court held that such a presumption was rebuttable. Mrs Bansal submitted that this decision of the Supreme Court makes it clear that intention is a relevant factor. At this juncture itself we may point out that we are not so much concerned with the nature of the transaction as to whether it was an adventure in the nature of trade or not but whether the land in question was agricultural land or not Therefore, the observations of the Supreme Court would not be strictly applicable to the case at hand. However, we do note that the Supreme Court itself has observed that despite the said intention, even while considering the question of whether the transaction was or was not an adventure in the nature of trade, the Court may arrive at a different conclusion considering the attendant facts and circumstances of each case. The presumption, in any case, was rebuttable. 9. Having considered the arguments advanced by the counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the assessees contentions deserve to be upheld and the findings returned by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ought to be reversed. We are conscious that we are not merely reversing a finding of fact, what we are intending to do is to point out that the Tribunals finding of fact is contrary to its own record and, therefore, is in the realm of perversity. This is so because the Tribunal clearly held that at the point of time when the assessee purchased the said land, it was agricultural land. There is no dispute with regard to this. The Tribunal also noted that the Award passed on 01.04.1992 by the District Collector (Land Acquisition), Greater Noida, Bulandshar, was a document which established beyond doubt that the land in question was agricultural land. Thus, on the date of purchase, the land in question was agricultural land and on the date of acquisition, the character of the land continued to be agricultural. When these two clear findings have been returned, it is apparent that in the transitional period, that is, between purchase and acquisition, the nature and character of the land did not change. The fact that the appellant/assessee intended to use the land for industrial purposes did not in any way alter the nature and character of the land. The further fact that the appellant/assessee did not carry out any agricultural operations did not also result in any conversion of the agricultural land into an industrial land. It is nobodys case that the appellant/assessee carried out any operations for setting up any plant or machinery or of the like nature so as to lead to an inference that the nature and character of the land had been changed from agricultural to industrial. The mere fact that the appellant/assessee did not carry out any agricultural operation did not alter the nature and character of the land. In any event, this discussion is not relevant in the backdrop of the clear finding given by the Tribunal that on the date of the purchase and as also on the date of acquisition, the land in question was agricultural land. Having come to such a conclusion, the Tribunal ought not to have gone into question of intention of the appellant/assessee and definitely not into the question of intention of the land acquiring authority, the latter being a wholly irrelevant consideration.
10. In these circumstances, we decide the question in favour of the appellant/assessee and against the revenue. The appeal is allowed with costs. The impugned order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal is set aside.
Alert