Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dashmesh Mechanical Works v. Hari Singh & Anr.

Delhi High Court
Dec 23, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit under Section 106 of the Patents Act, 1970 seeking a declaration and permanent injunction restraining the defendants from issuing illegal threats related to Patent No.213823, along with damages. The plaintiff also applied for an interim injunction. The defendants responded with a written statement and an application under Order VII Rule 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), seeking return of the plaint on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction.

The plaintiff is a partnership firm conducting business at Rajkot Road, Malerkotla, Punjab, and the defendants are situated in Nabha, District Patiala, Punjab. The plaintiff invoked the territorial jurisdiction of the court on the basis that the threats were issued from the defendant’s counsel in Delhi and that the plaintiff’s goods are sold in Delhi, where the plaintiff apprehends interference with its business due to the alleged illegal threats.

The defendants contended that the court lacks territorial jurisdiction as both parties conduct business outside the court’s jurisdiction and that the legal notice was received outside the jurisdiction. They argued that the Patents Act does not confer jurisdiction based on the place of sale of goods, unlike provisions in the Trade Mark Act and Copyright Act, and that jurisdiction must be determined under Section 20 of the CPC.

The plaintiff maintained that it carries on extensive business within the court’s jurisdiction and that the cause of action arose there because the threats could prejudice its business in Delhi. The plaintiff acknowledged both parties reside and carry on business outside the court’s jurisdiction but relied on the issuance of threats from Delhi as the basis for jurisdiction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit filed under Section 106 of the Patents Act, 1970 based on threats issued from the defendant’s counsel in Delhi.
  2. Whether the plaint should be returned for lack of territorial jurisdiction under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC.
  3. What constitutes a "cause of action" for determining territorial jurisdiction in this context.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The court does not have territorial jurisdiction as the defendants and the plaintiff carry on business outside the court’s jurisdiction.
  • The plaintiff failed to produce evidence that the defendants conducted business within the court’s jurisdiction.
  • The legal notice forming the basis of the suit was received outside the jurisdiction of the court.
  • The Patents Act does not confer jurisdiction based on the place where the plaintiff’s goods are sold, unlike the Trade Mark Act and Copyright Act.
  • Jurisdiction must be determined under Section 20 of the CPC.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff carries on extensive business within the court’s jurisdiction through retail outlets.
  • The cause of action arose within the court’s jurisdiction as the threats are capable of prejudicing the plaintiff’s business there.
  • The threats were issued from the defendant’s counsel in Delhi, thus invoking jurisdiction.
  • The plaintiff apprehends further threats and disturbance to its business within the court’s jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express, (2006) 3 SCC 100 Principle that plaint cannot be rejected merely on defendant’s allegations; the plaint must disclose a cause of action on its face. The court applied this principle to hold that only the plaint is to be considered for jurisdictional questions at this stage, not the defense or evidence.
Om Prakash Srivastava vs. Union of India & Ors, 131(2006) DLT 557 (SC) Definition and explanation of "cause of action" as a bundle of facts necessary to support a right to judgment. The court relied on this to analyze whether a part of cause of action arose within its jurisdiction based on the plaintiff’s pleadings.
Rajasthan High Court Advocates' Association v. Union of India and Ors., 2001 (2) SCC 294 Judicially settled meaning of "cause of action" including facts necessary to be proved to support a right to judgment. Used to reinforce the understanding of cause of action in territorial jurisdiction context.
Union of India & Others vs. Advani Exports Ltd & Anr, AIR 2002 SC 126 Clarification that registered office location alone does not ipso facto confer territorial jurisdiction. The court distinguished this precedent to reject the defendants' claim that jurisdiction is absent merely because parties reside outside the court’s territory.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the plaint to determine if any part of the cause of action arose within its territorial jurisdiction, as required under Order VII Rule 10 CPC. It emphasized that at this stage, only the plaint is to be considered, not the defense or evidence. The court referred to the settled legal principle that a cause of action is a bundle of facts that must be proved to succeed in the suit.

The plaintiff’s pleadings stated that the threats were issued from Delhi, where the plaintiff carries on business and where the defendant’s counsel is based. The court accepted the plaintiff’s version prima facie that it conducts business within the court’s jurisdiction and that the threats could prejudice its business there. The court noted that the plaintiff is the dominus litis and entitled to choose the forum where part of the cause of action arose, unless such choice is opposed to public policy or an abuse of process.

Relying on precedents, the court concluded that the plaint discloses a cause of action within its jurisdiction and that the application for return of plaint on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction was not maintainable at this stage.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the defendants' application under Order VII Rule 10 CPC for return of the plaint on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction, with no order as to costs.

This decision allows the suit to proceed before the court, affirming the plaintiff's right to choose the forum based on the pleaded cause of action arising within the court’s territorial jurisdiction. The court did not establish any new precedent but applied established principles regarding territorial jurisdiction and cause of action in patent infringement threat cases.

Show all summary ...

1. The plaintiff has filed the suit under Section 106 of the Patents Act, 1970 for declaration and permanent injunction restraining the defendants from issuing illegal threats and for damages etc.

2. Along with the suit, the plaintiff has also filed an application for interim injunction.

3. The defendants filed their written statement and reply to the interim application. Along with the written statement, they have also filed an application under Order VII Rule 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as the CPC)for return of the plaint for lack of territorial jurisdiction.

4. According to the plaintiff, defendant No.1 Sh. Hari Singh is a resident of Nabha, District Patiala, Punjab and defendant No.2 is a private limited company which is also situated in Nabha.

5. The plaintiff is a partnership firm carrying on its business at Rajkot Road, Malerkotla, Punjab and is also carrying on business and work for gain in Punjab.

6. The Plaintiff has invoked the territorial jurisdiction of this court as set out in Para 29 of the plaint which reads as under:-

"That this Hon‟ble court has jurisdiction to try the suit as the threat in the form of notice has been issued from the defendant‟s counsel in Delhi. The goods of the plaintiff are sold in Delhi and threats may be made against such sales by the defendants in Delhi. The plaintiff apprehends that the defendants would disturb the business of the plaintiff in Delhi by issuing such illegal threats to the plaintiff."

7. The plaintiff has made similar statements in Paras 12, 14, 20, 22 and 29 of the plaint to the effect that the defendants are issuing illegal threats as regards Patent No.213823 and the whole purpose of issuing such notices which are not tenable in law is to harass and embarrass the plaintiff and the threats issued by the defendants are highly unjustifiable and illegal. The plaintiff has suffered irreparable injury and loss by issuance of such illegal threats by the defendants and this court may issue a declaration to the effect that the threats issued by the defendants in respect of Patent No.213823 are unjustifiable.

8. It was contended by the counsel for the defendants that this court does not have the territorial jurisdiction to entertain and try the present suit and that the admitted position of the facts between the parties is that the defendant is a firm which is carrying on its business at Rajkot Road, Maler Kotla, Punjab and the defendant No.1 is the Director of Defendant No.2 which is situated in Nabha, Punjab.

9. It was also argued that the plaintiff has failed to produce any evidence to show that the defendants were carrying on their business partly or otherwise within the territory of this court, nor has the same been contended by the plaintiff. The legal notice issued by the defendants on the basis of which the suit has been instituted by the plaintiff was also received by the plaintiff at a place outside the jurisdiction of this court.

10. Lastly, it has been argued by the counsel that the threat in the form of notice had been issued from the defendant‟s counsel in Delhi and on the said excuse the suit cannot be filed before this court as the Patents Act, 1970 does not provide a forum to the plaintiff to sue where its goods are being sold unlike Section 134(2) of the Trade Mark Act, 1999 and Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act, 1957. The jurisdiction in the absence of the same is to be conferred within the scheme of Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

11. The application is opposed by the learned counsel for the plaintiff who has stated that the plaintiff carries on extensive business through its retail outlets within the jurisdiction of this court as alleged in Para 29 of the plaint and that the cause of action has arisen within the jurisdiction of this court for the reason that the threats given by the defendants to the plaintiff are capable of prejudicing the plaintiff‟s business within the jurisdiction of this court and the plaintiff also apprehends that the defendants would disturb the business of the plaintiff by issuing such illegal threats to the plaintiff.

12. The learned counsel for the plaintiff has not denied the fact that both the parties i.e. the plaintiff and defendants are residing and carrying on business outside the jurisdiction of this court and has submitted that the plaintiff has invoked the jurisdiction of this court only on the basis of threat from the defendants in the form of the notice issued from the defendants‟ counsel, who is based in and works from Delhi.

13. Section 106 of the Patents Act, 1970 deals with the remedies available to a person aggrieved by groundless threats of legal proceedings by bringing a suit against the person who extends threats to obtain a decree for declaration, injunction, damages etc. Section 106 of the Patents Act reads as under:-

"106. Power of court to grant relief in cases of groundless threats of infringement proceedings.-(1) Where any person (whether entitled to or interested in a patent or an application for patent or not) threatens any other person by circulars or advertisements or by communications, oral or in writing addressed to that or any other person, with proceedings for infringement of a patent, any person aggrieved thereby may bring a suit against him praying for the following reliefs, that is to say - (a) a declaration to the effect that the threats are unjustifiable.
(b) an injunction against the continuance of the threats; and
(c) unless in such suit the defendant proves that the acts in respect of which the proceedings were threatened constitute or, if done, would constitute, an infringement of a patent or of rights arising from the publication of a complete specification in respect of a claim of the specification not shown by the plaintiff to be invalid the court may grant to the plaintiff all or any of the reliefs prayed for."

14. Thus, it is submitted by the plaintiff that the plaintiff has received the threats on receipt of legal notice issued by the defendants through counsel from Delhi and since the threats extended by the defendants are at a place where the plaintiff is carrying on its business, therefore, the suit filed by the plaintiff in an action to restrain groundless threats of legal proceedings is maintainable.

15. I have heard learned counsel for the parties. In order to decide as to whether any part of cause of action has arisen within the jurisdiction of this court it is not in dispute and even the parties were at ad idem while considering the application under Order 7 Rule 10 of CPC and at this stage the court cannot go into the defense of the defendants contained in the written statement or the documents filed by them as per well settled law only the plaint alone is to be seen. In the case reported in Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express,(2006) 3 SCC 100 it has been held as under:-

"12. From the aforesaid, it is apparent that the plaint cannot be rejected on the basis of the allegations made by the defendant in his written statement or in an application for rejection of the plaint. The court has to read the entire plaint as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause of action and if it does, then the plaint cannot be rejected by the court exercising the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code. Essentially, whether the plaint discloses a cause of action, is a question of fact which has to be gathered on the basis of the averments made in the plaint in its entirety taking those averments to be correct. A cause of action is a bundle of facts which are required to be proved for obtaining relief and for the said purpose, the material facts are required to be stated but not the evidence except in certain cases where the pleadings relied on are in regard to misrepresentation, fraud, wilful default, undue influence or of the same nature. So long as the plaint discloses some cause of action which requires determination by the court, the mere fact that in the opinion of the Judge the plaintiff may not succeed cannot be a ground for rejection of the plaint. In the present case, the averments made in the plaint, as has been noticed by us, do disclose the cause of action and, therefore, the High Court has rightly said that the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code cannot be exercised for rejection of the suit filed by the plaintiff-appellants."

16. In the case of Om Prakash Srivastava vs. Union of India & Ors, reported in 131(2006) DLT 557 (SC), the Supreme Court has laid down the principles to determine as to what constitutes the cause of action as under:-

"9. By "cause of action" it is meant every fact, which, if traversed, it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to a judgment of the Court. In other words, a bundle of facts, which it is necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order to succeed in the suit. (See Bloom Dekor Ltd. v. Subhash Himatlal Desai and Ors., (1994)6SCC322 ).
In a generic and wide sense (as in Section 20 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908) "cause of action" means every fact, which it is necessary to establish to support a right to obtain a judgment. (See Sadanandan Bhadran v. Madhavan Sunil Kumar, 1998CriLJ4066 ).
10. It is settled law that "cause of action" consists of bundle of facts, which give cause to enforce the legal inquiry for redress in a court of law. In other words, it is a bundle of facts, which taken with the law applicable to them, gives the plaintiff a right to claim relief against the defendant. It must include some act done by the defendant since in the absence of such an act no cause of action would possibly accrue or would arise. (See South East Asia Shipping Co. Ltd. v. Nav Bharat Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.,[1996]3SCR405 ).
11. The expression "cause of action" has acquired a judicially settled meaning. In the restricted sense "cause of action" means the circumstances forming the infraction of the right or the immediate occasion for the reaction. In the wider sense, it means the necessary conditions for the maintenance of the suit, including not only the infraction of the right, but also the infraction coupled with the right itself. Compendiously, as noted above the expression means every fact, which it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment of the Court. Every fact, which is necessary to be proved, as distinguished from every piece of evidence, which is necessary, to prove each fact. comprises in "cause of action". (See Rajasthan High Court Advocates' Association v. Union of India and Ors., 2001 (2) SCC 294.)
12. The expression "cause of action" has sometimes been employed to convey the restricted idea of facts or circumstances which constitute either the infringement or the basis of a right and no more. In a wider and more comprehensive sense, it has been used to denote the whole bundle of material facts, which a plaintiff must prove in order to succeed. These are all those essential facts without the proof of which the plaintiff must fail in his suit. (See Gurdit Singh v. Munsha Singh, [1977]2SCR250 ).
13. The expression "cause of action" is generally understood to mean a situation or state of facts that entitles a party to maintain an action in a court or a tribunal; a group of operative facts giving rise to one or more bases of suing; a factual situation that entitles one person to obtain a remedy in court from another person. (See Black's Law Dictionary). In. Stroud's Judicial Dictionary a "cause of action" is stated to be the entire set of facts that gives rise to an enforceable claim; the phrase comprises every fact, which if traversed, the plaintiff must prove in order to obtain judgment. In "Words and Phrases" (4th Edn.) the meaning attributed to the phrase "cause of action" in common legal parlance is existence of those facts, which give a party a right to judicial interference on his behalf. (See Navinchandra N. Majithia v. State of Maharashtra and Ors., AIR2000SC2966)."

17. In another matter reported in Union of India & Others vs. Advani Exports Ltd & Anr. reported in AIR 2002 SC 126 Para 10 the Apex court has held as under:-

"10. We are unable to accept this finding of the High Court. The view of the High Court that this Court in the case of Oswal Woollen (supra) had held that the existence of the registered office of a Company would ipso facto give a cause of action to the High Court within whose jurisdiction the registered office of such Company is situated, is not correct. As a matter of fact in the case of Oswal Woollen (supra), the question of territorial jurisdiction in the sense with which we are concerned now, did not arise at all. In that case, the observations of the Court were as follows:
"Having regard to the fact that the registered office of the Company is at Ludhiana and the principal respondents against whom the primary relief is sought are at New Delhi, one would have expected the writ petition to be field either in the High Court of Punjab and Haryana or in the Delhi High Court. The writ petitioners, however, have chosen the Calcutta High Court as the forum perhaps because one of the interlocutory reliefs which is sought is in respect of a consignment of beef tallow which has arrived at the Calcutta Port. We do not desire to probe further into the question whether the writ petition was field by design or accident in the Calcutta High Court when the office of the Company is in the State of Punjab and all the principle respondents are in Delhi."
18. From the above said decisions given by the Supreme Court while examining the expression „cause of action‟ the court has to see the factual situation that gives rise to an enforceable claim made by the plaintiff in the plaint which is to be read collectively to constitute a bundle of facts that form the basis of institution of the present suit filed by the plaintiff.

19. In the present case the plaintiff has specifically made a statement in the plaint that the plaintiff is carrying on business in Delhi where the threat has been extended by the defendant though counsel, therefore, it cannot be held that no part of cause of action has arisen in Delhi within the jurisdiction of this court in the absence of filing of any evidence.

20. At this stage the court has to believe the version pleaded by the plaintiff in the plaint that the plaintiff is carrying on its business within the territorial jurisdiction of this court and that the defendant would disturb the business of the plaintiff in Delhi and embarrasses the plaintiff. A statement has also been made in the plaint that the plaintiff apprehends to receive threats from the defendants within the jurisdiction of this court.

21. It is settled law that the plaintiff is a dominus lites i.e. master of or having dominian over the case. He has a right to have his forum of convenience by approaching the court where part of cause of action arises. Actually he is the person who has to control all his actions unless the said forum is opposed to public policy or will be an abuse of the process of law. The plaintiff has every right to choose the forum best suited to him. No doubt, the plaintiff during the trial has to prove that the court has territorial jurisdiction after producing evidence in this regard. At this stage in the present matter, prima facie it cannot be said that this court lacks the inherent jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The mere failure to mention in the paragraph stating the cause of action that the plaintiff has been threatened in Delhi is not enough to return the plaint because while deciding the application of the defendants, the whole plaint has to be taken into consideration.

22. In view of the foregoing discussion, the present application filed by the defendants under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure for returning of plaint is dismissed. No costs.

List before the Joint Registrar on 19th April, 2010.

MANMOHAN SINGH, J.

DECEMBER 23, 2009