Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajesh Maan & Ors. v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation .

Delhi High Court
Nov 4, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Rajesh Maan & Ors. v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (Lead)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Writ Petitions with similar facts were heard together and disposed of by a common judgment with Writ Petition No. 3383/2008 (Rajesh Maan & Ors. v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC)) treated as the lead case. In September 2004 respondent DMRC invited applications for use of spaces on licence basis at Metro stations on a first-come-first-served basis at pre-determined rates. The petitioners applied, were allotted specified areas, and executed identical three-year licence deeds (although licence fees varied by station). Clause 18 of the licence deed provided that the agreement would terminate at the end of three years but could be terminated earlier in accordance with the deed.

The initial three-year licence period expired. In the lead matter, the petitioner (Rajesh Maan) had a 6 sq. m kiosk at Pitampura on a fixed licence fee; after expiry in October 2007 he was asked to vacate but was granted an extension to April 2008. By letter dated 17 April 2008 DMRC offered extension only on payment of an enhanced licence fee (quoted at Rs. 2,500 per sq. m per month for category A stations) and by subsequent communication sent new terms for re-allotment. The petitioner objected, and writ petitions were filed challenging the enhanced licence fee and the station categorisation underlying it.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Clause 18 of the licence deed creates any contractual right in favour of the licence holders to have the licence extended or re-allotted at a pre-determined or fixed rate after expiry of the initial three-year period.
  2. Whether the re-classification of Metro stations into categories A, B and C and the fixation of enhanced licence fees for such categories by respondent-DMRC is arbitrary, discriminatory or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  3. Whether the petitioners have a legally enforceable legitimate expectation to renewal/extension on the old terms or rates.
  4. What is the scope of judicial review under Article 226 in relation to State decisions on commercial/price-fixing policy such as licence fees for commercial kiosks?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The increase in licence fee demanded by DMRC is exorbitant, arbitrary and not based on rational or logical basis (petitioners refer to increases up to 600% from earlier rates in some instances).
  • DMRC, being an instrumentality/State, cannot act arbitrarily or discriminatorily in fixing licence fee.
  • Certain stations (for example, Kashmere Gate) have been wrongly categorized as category A despite no substantial increase in ridership; comparable stations have not been similarly graded.
  • Reliance on past allocations (for example, a licence purportedly issued to Living Media India Ltd) shows inconsistency and lack of application of mind in the categorisation and fixation of rates.
  • Some petitioners raised the plea of legitimate expectation based on their initial allotment and conduct of DMRC.

Respondent (DMRC) Arguments

  • The enhanced licence fee was fixed after observing fees obtained from allotments between October 2004 and April 2008 and represents a considered decision based on market response and commercial factors.
  • DMRC re-classified stations into categories A, B and C after applying factors such as overall demand, commuter profile, presence of nearby commercial/residential areas, attractiveness, and existence of other kiosks — not solely ridership figures.
  • The rates for A/B/C stations (as of May 2008) were rationalized at Rs. 2,500, Rs. 1,500 and Rs. 1,100 per sq. m per month respectively, and the classification/re-categorisation of stations has been justified with station-specific features (e.g., proximity to Inter-State Bus Terminal, malls).
  • Clause 18 of the licence deed does not create a contractual right to renewal at prior rates; clause 14 (annual 5% compounding increase) applies only during the subsistence of the licence and not after expiry by efflux of time.
  • DMRC offered petitioners an option to accept allotment in category B or C stations at lower rates or to relocate subject to availability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bareilly Development Authority v. Ajay Pal, (1989) 2 SCC 116 State discretion in policy matters and fixation of costs/ licence fee for commercial properties; limited scope of judicial interference under Article 226. Used to underline that courts have limited power to interfere in commercial policy decisions of the State and that licence fee/costs can be struck down only if contrary to contract or per se arbitrary/discriminatory.
Sheela Wanti v. Delhi Development Authority, (2002) 7 SCC 135 Similar principle: State has wide discretion in policy matters relating to commercial property pricing; limited judicial interference. Relied upon together with Bareilly Development Authority to emphasize deference to commercial policy decisions of State instrumentalities like DMRC.
K.T. Corporation v. India Tourism Development Corporation (LPA No. 441/2008), decided 18 May 2009 In commercial matters the State instrumentality (ITDC) competing in open market should be given freedom to determine market licence fee; courts should not substitute their judgment unless the decision-making process is arbitrary or discriminatory. Cited to support the proposition that in commercial/financial decisions the court's role is limited to examining the decision-making process for arbitrariness or discrimination; DMRC entitled to seek market licence fee unless decision violates Article 14.
Ram Pravesh Singh v. State of Bihar, (2006) 8 SCC 381 Doctrine of legitimate expectation: it entitles a party to fair hearing and explanation but is not a legally enforceable right equivalent to promissory estoppel. Applied to reject petitioners' claim of a legal right to renewal; legitimate expectation only entitles hearing/explanation and cannot command mandamus for re-allotment.
C.P. Mittal v. Union of India & Anr., 2007 (9) AD (Del) 330 Enhancement of licence fee struck down where allotment was a social welfare/rehabilitative measure and bargaining power was unequal — standard of highest bidding inappropriate. Distinguished by the court: not applicable because petitioners here are commercial traders (profit-making) and initial allotment was not a social welfare measure; thus the ratio did not support petitioners.
DSIDC v. Yashpal Madan, 148 (2008) DLT 642 Decision on pricing must not be arbitrary or irrational; only relevant factors should be considered and actual expenditure/cost may justify price. Referred to affirm that pricing must be rational; court found DMRC's reasons to be relevant and not arbitrary in the present facts.
Palika Palace Traders Association v. New Delhi Municipal Corporation, W.P. No. 937/2000 (decided 7 Feb 2002) Allotments as rehabilitative measures made on no loss-no profit basis are distinguishable from commercial allotments. Declined to apply: that case concerned rehabilitation/squatters and is inapplicable to commercial licence holders like the petitioners.
Indian Oil Corporation v. Union of India, W.P. (C) No. 3823/1992 (decided 29 Nov 2006) Lease rent increase held arbitrary where it was based on an assumption of profitability unsupported by material. Referred as an example where increase was struck down for lack of supporting material; contrasted with present case where DMRC placed material and rationale for increase.
Food Corporation Of India v. M/s Kamdhenu Cattle Feed Industries, (1993) 1 SCC 71 Negotiations to obtain a significantly higher bid and giving all tenderers an opportunity to revise bids demonstrates non-arbitrariness in price enhancement. Distinguished as facts differ; cited to show circumstances where higher bids obtained through fair process satisfy non-arbitrariness.
Style (Dress Land) v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, (1999) 7 SCC 89 State authority entitled to charge market rent after expiry of lease; increase to market value can be justified and not arbitrary. Adopted as supporting authority: court noted Supreme Court upheld enhancement from a fixed past rent to market rent; used to justify DMRC charging market-based licence fees after expiry.
Chandigarh Administration v. Jagjit Singh, (1995) 1 SCC 745 An order in favour of a third person, if contrary to law, cannot be made the basis for compelling the authority to repeat illegal or unwarranted action; inaction for some cannot be made a basis for relief to others. Relied upon to reject petitioners' contention that prior lower licence fee granted to some third parties should preclude DMRC from charging market rates from others.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court took a step-by-step approach grounded on the licence deed's terms, the nature of DMRC's commercial decision-making and the scope of judicial review:

  1. Contractual construction: Clause 18 of the licence deed was interpreted as not conferring any contractual right to extension or renewal at a pre-determined/fixed rate. The clause contemplated termination at three years with any extension being at DMRC's sole discretion and subject to mutually agreed terms; hence no vested contractual right to renewal existed.
  2. Applicability of clause providing annual increase: Clause 14 (5% compounding increase per year) was held to apply only during the subsistence of the licence term and not after expiry by efflux of time; therefore it could not operate to fix post-expiry re-allotment rates.
  3. Scope of judicial review in commercial policy: Relying on precedents, the Court explained that its power under Article 226 is limited in policy matters and commercial pricing. The State (or its instrumentality) has wide discretion in fixing licence fees for commercial properties, and judicial interference is warranted only when the decision is contrary to contract or is per se arbitrary or discriminatory.
  4. Evaluation of DMRC's rationale: DMRC's re-classification of stations into categories A, B and C and the fixation of different rates was found to have been based on a range of commercially relevant factors (ridership among other factors, commuter profile, demand, attractiveness of location, proximity to commercial facilities like ISBT and malls). The Court reviewed DMRC's explanations (including a chart of station re‑categorisation) and concluded the classification and rates were not arbitrary.
  5. Distinguishing adverse precedents: Cases relied on by petitioners (such as C.P. Mittal) were distinguished on the factual matrix — earlier cases involved rehabilitative or social-welfare allotments or unequal bargaining power; the petitioners here were commercial traders running profit-making enterprises and therefore not entitled to the protections applicable in those contexts.
  6. Legitimate expectation: The Court held the petitioners' plea of legitimate expectation had no merit — there was no past conduct of DMRC creating a legally enforceable expectation of renewal on old terms; legitimate expectation, even if made out, ordinarily entitles only to a fair hearing, not to a mandamus compelling re-allotment on prior terms.
  7. Practical considerations and equity: The Court noted that several other licence holders in similar locations had accepted and executed licence agreements at enhanced rates. It also observed that granting a benefit selectively to the petitioners would compel DMRC to extend the same benefit to others, undermining revenue and equality of treatment.
  8. Remedy fashioned: While dismissing the petitions, the Court provided petitioners an opportunity to accept the enhanced rates within a specified time or to relocate to category B or C stations subject to availability — a practical measure consistent with the Court’s assessment that DMRC's policy was not arbitrary.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Writ Petitions dismissed.

Direct consequences and implications for the parties:

  • The petitions were dismissed and no relief was granted to compel renewal or re-allotment at prior rates.
  • The petitioners were given four weeks to agree to pay the higher licence fee as demanded by DMRC.
  • The petitioners were also granted an option to relocate to kiosks at Category B or C stations (with lower licence fees) subject to availability; DMRC was to provide a list of such stations within two weeks and petitioners were to exercise option within two weeks thereafter.
  • There was no order as to costs in the facts and circumstances of the cases.
  • No new legal principle or precedent was formulated; the decision applies established principles limiting judicial interference in commercial policy decisions and confirms that licence-fee fixation will be sustained where a considered, non-arbitrary rationale is shown.

End of summary — this document is a faithful synthesis of the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond the opinion's text.

Show all summary ...

Sanjiv Khanna, J.— The Writ Petitions have similar facts and raise common questions of law. They were heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment, with Writ Petition No. 3383/2008 titled Rajesh Maan & Ors.… v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation…. (hereinafter referred to as DMRC, for short) as the lead case.

2. The respondent-DMRC in September 2004 had invited applications for usage of spaces on licence basis at Metro stations on pre-determined rates on first cum first served basis. The petitioners herein had applied for allotment/usage of spaces at Metro stations at pre-determined rates. Their applications were accepted and they were allotted the specified area for which they were liable to pay licence fee at pre-determined rates on per sq. mtr. basis. The licence deeds executed are identical though the quantum of licence fee being charged on per sq. mtr. basis was different depending upon the Metro station where the space is located. The licence deed was for a period of three years containing the following clause:

“18. That the Agreement provided herein shall terminate at the end of the period agreed to herein i.e three years reckoned from the days, 30 days after the date of issuance of letter of Acceptance by DMRC, except that the agreement may also be terminated earlier in accordance with the terms of this Deed.”

3. It is an accepted stand of the parties that the period of three years for which the initial licence was issued has expired.

4. In Writ Petition No. 3383/2008, the petitioner was permitted to use carpet area of 6 sq. mts for a kiosk at the Pitampura rail corridor station on fixed licence fee of Rs. 1200/- p. sq. mtr./p.m in addition to quarterly maintenance fee of Rs. 50/-. The area allotted to Mr. Rajesh Maan-the petitioner in Writ Petition No. 3383/2008 was increased on his request. When the licence period expired in October, 2007, the petitioner-Mr. Rajesh Maan was asked to vacate by notice dated 18th October, 2007. The Petitioner requested for extension of time and the said request was acceded to and the period of licence was extended to April, 2008. By letter dated 17th April, 2008, the respondent-DMRC informed Mr. Rajesh Maan that DMRC could extend the period of licence on payment of enhanced licence fee @ Rs. 2500/- p. sq. mtr/p.m By letter dated 25th April, 2008, new terms and conditions of re-allotment were sent by the respondent-DMRC to Mr. Rajesh Maan. The petitioner objects to the enhanced licence fee as demanded for extension/renewal of the licence.

5. Learned Counsel for the petitioners submitted that the increase in licence fee by respondent-DMRC is exorbitant and is not based upon any rational or logic. It was submitted this constitutes 600% increase in the original licence fee of Rs. 400.p. sq. mtr/p.m It was further submitted that the respondent-DMRC being a State cannot act in an arbitrary manner and claim enhanced licence fee.

6. In the counter affidavit filed by the respondent-DMRC, they have submitted that the licence fee received from others who were allotted licences between October, 2004 and April, 2008 formed the basis and rationale for the increase in licence fee. It is stated that the respondents have re-classified Metro stations into categories A, B and C depending upon commercial viability and income from kiosks located in the said stations. It is stated that fee now fixed for A, B and C category Metro stations is a well informed and a considered decision which cannot be categorized as arbitrary.

7. In the rejoinder affidavit filed by the petitioners, additional and new allegations have been made against the said categorization of stations as A, B and C. It is stated that some of the Metro stations like Kashmere Gate have been wrongly categorized as stations falling under Category A and the ridership on line 1 is much lower than what is being projected. It is also stated that some of the kiosks are located in non-paid area i.e the area where a person need not have a valid ticket to travel. Reference is also made to the reply furnished by respondent-DMRC in response to RTI query in which licence issued in favour of Living Media India Ltd @ Rs. 2500/- p. sq. mtr./p.m is stated to be the basis for fixing licence fee payable in kiosks in Category A stations. In the rejoinder affidavit, it is pointed out that Shastri Nagar and other stations have similar ridership but have not been graded as category A stations. In the written submission filed by the petitioners, more allegations have been made to support the plea that there is lack of application of mind in categorizing the Metro stations into A, B and C categories. Respondent-DMRC has filed additional affidavit to meet the allegations in the rejoinder affidavit and has also filed written submissions.

8. Clause 18 of the licence fee, quoted above, does not give contractual right to the petitioners' claim for extension of licence period at a pre determined/fixed rate. Clause 18 stipulates that after expiry of licence period, the respondent-DMRC upon its sole discretion can extend the duration of the agreement on mutually agreed terms and conditions. There is no contractual right for extension of the licence period. Clause 14 of the License Deed provides for increase in licence fee by 5% after completion of each year on compounding basis. The said clause is applicable during the term of the licence and not after the licence period has expired by efflux of time as in the present case.

9. Respondent-DMRC is a State and cannot act in an arbitrary manner. Their actions should be guided by reason and cannot be discriminatory and arbitrary. Respondent-DMRC has explained that the petitioners were allotted kiosks in 2004 on fixed rate on first come first served basis at different railway stations on line 1. Respondent-DMRC had started operations in 2004 and this was their first attempt to generate revenue by allotting kiosks to third parties. Thereafter, kiosks were allotted on fixed rate basis in the years 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 at enhanced rates of Rs. 1260/-, Rs. 1323/- and Rs. 1390/- p. sq. mtr./p.m respectively with a clause for 5% increase every year. Good response was received to the invitation for offer of allotments and kiosks were allotted on the basis of fixed licence fee. It is pointed out that w.e.f May, 2008 a new policy was framed and different railway stations were graded as Category A, B and C stations and the rates were rationalized at Rs. 2500/-, Rs. 1500/-, Rs. 1100/- p. sq. mtr/p.m for category A, B and C Metro stations respectively. This categorization has been done keeping in view not only the total ridership but also the overall demand and other factors like the commuter profile in a particular location, demand of kiosks in the area, attractiveness of the area due to commercial and residential areas nearby. As per the chart filed by the respondent-DMRC, there has been re-categorization of the Metro stations and some Metro stations have been upgraded or down-graded.

10. Keeping these aspects in mind, the stand of the respondent-DMRC in categorization of different Metro stations into category A, B and C and fixation of different licence fee for the said Metro stations cannot be held to be arbitrary. The respondent-DMRC is performing a public function by operating Metro in the city of Delhi. The travel fare has to be kept low and attractive so that large number of persons can utilize public transport. The respondent-DMRC is earning money by giving kiosks on licence fee basis at the railway stations. The licence fee earned augments and adds to the income of DMRC and is a relevant factor while fixing fares/ticket charges.

11. The petitioners are commercial traders/retailers who have taken space on licence fee basis because they find it to be a viable business proposition. The licence fee has to be fixed on the basis of market forces. The petitioners cannot claim any concession or right to concession in fixing of licence fee. It may be appropriate here to mention that several others similarly situated licence holders have agreed to and have executed licence agreement on the basis of the enhanced licence fee.

12. On the question of fixation or quantum of costs or rate of licence fee, Court's power to interfere while exercising power of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is limited. In policy matters relating to costs and fixation of licence fee, the State has wide discretion and flexibility especially when it relates to commercial properties (refer, Bareilly Development Authority v. Ajay Pal, (1989) 2 SCC 116; Sheela Wanti v. Delhi Development Authority, (2002) 7 SCC 135. License fee/costs can be struck down only if it is contrary to the contract and is per se arbitrary and discriminatory when different licence fees are being charged from identically situated persons without any rationale. The explanation and reasoning given by the respondent DMRC does not disclose arbitrariness and discrimination.

13. In K.T Corporation v. India Tourism Development Corporation (LPA No. 441/2008) decided on 18th May, 2009, it was observed as under:

“12. ITDC does not enjoy monopoly and is in open and direct competition with privately run hotels which are in abundance in Delhi. ITDC does not enjoy any special privilege or advantage being an instrumentality of the State, unlike Development Authorities or housing boards under special statues constituted for social and public purpose and obligations in mind. Appellants per force because of statutes of ITDC as a State are not compelled to negotiate, deal and interact with the ITDC. ITDC does not enjoy a dominating position or substantial market share to control market rents/licence fee for floor spaces in five star hotels. In a competitive market, ITDC is competing with others and cannot charge exorbitant licence fee. Market or licence fee is per se determined and fixed by market forces. Letting of shops and offices is a part of the business of ITDC and constitutes a portion of its profits and commercial activity. ITDC being a hotel and in hospitality business has to be given full freedom and play in joints to determine and decide what is more beneficial and commercially profitable for them, unless for some justified public reason ITDC being a State should not be permitted to do so or act in a discriminatory manner in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution. ITDC while taking commercial or financial decision have to be given freedom of play in joints. It is for ITDC to determine how and in what manner they want to manage and run the hotel including shops and offices which are let out/given to third parties on licence fee basis. Renting out is a part of the commercial venture and contributes to their income. In purely commercial or financial matters, the Courts should not substitute their judgments for that of ITDC. The Court cannot supplant its own views for they are more equitable, reasonable, better suited or viable. The Court is only concerned with the decision making process and whether extraneous matters have been taken into consideration for reaching the final conclusion and whether the decision falls foul of Article 14 being arbitrary or discriminatory. The action of the ITDC cannot be faulted on the said grounds and its desire and attempt to get market licence fee is not arbitrary or unreasonable.”

14. The contention of the petitioners is that increase in rates of unpaid area in Line 1 is completely unjustified as there has not been any substantial increase in the ridership on the said line. It is pointed out that the rates quoted by the respondent: DMRC are in respect of lines 2 and 3 where there has been a substantial increase in the ridership by 530% but the said increase in the ridership cannot be applied to Line 1 where in fact there has been an increase of 69.3%. It is claimed that there is no increase in footfalls between 2004-2008 in the Kashmere Gate Metro station. The aforesaid argument of the petitioners cannot be accepted because the rates have not been fixed only on the basis of ridership but by taking into consideration several other factors like commuter profile, existence of other kiosks and attractiveness of the area due to its location. Kashmere Gate station is a well known and is frequented not only by the railway commuters but also by others who go to the said area for shopping purposes and to visit Inter-State Bus Terminal. The Metro station at Kashmere Gate is a prime property in the said area and the Inter-State Bus Terminal which is one of the largest in the country is also located next to it. The respondent-DMRC has therefore justified why Kashmere Gate station has been classified as category A station. Respondent-DMRC has also justified why Rithala, Netaji Subhash Place and Inderlok stations have been classified as category A stations due to their locations which are high in demand and have commercial viability. Also, Netaji Subhash Place and Inderlok stations have special features like malls and shopping centres.

15. The contention of the petitioners that some of the allottees, who happen to be multi-national conglomerates, have withdrawn their bids because of high licence fees may be correct, however this does not answer the contention of the respondent-DMRC that there are several others who are paying the same licence fee in the same location from where the petitioners are running their kiosks. In case benefit of lower licence fee is granted to the petitioners, the respondent-DMRC will be compelled to grant the same benefit to others. The petitioners like others enjoy considerable flexibility as per the terms of the licence deed, in respect of products they can retail. The licence deed provides that a licence holder can use the space for commuter related services like bookshops, communication services, mineral water, medical shops, etc. Kiosks are therefore not allotted for one particular or specific retail item. The licence holders can change the usage within the specified categories and commuter related services.

16. It is important to state here that the respondent-DMRC has made an offer that the petitioners that if they so desire, can be allotted kiosks in category B and C stations and thereby they will have to pay a lesser licence fee. The petitioners were however reluctant to accept the said offer.

17. In the written submissions, the petitioners claim that M/s. Planet Advertisers were allotted kiosks for three years in February 2006 by way of a private contract @ Rs. 200 p. sq. mtr/p.m for Line 1, Rs. 450 p. sq. mtr/p.m for Line 2 and Rs. 200 for Line 3. No such allegations have been made in the writ petitions. During the course of arguments, it has been explained that M/s. Planet Advertisers were allotted space to sell mineral water only at a pre-determined rate of Re. 1/- per glass. It was stated that earlier attempts to sell packed mineral water at a pre-determined rate in the interest of the consumers had failed as the allottees refused to accept the said offer as it was economically unviable to sell packaged water @ Re. 1/- per glass. In these circumstances, M/s. Planet Advertisers were permitted to sell water @ Re. 1/- per glass on payment of licence fee @ Rs. 200-450/- p. sq. mtr/p.m It is further pointed out by the respondent DMRC that the said rates have been fixed for only 2 sq. mt. area and for the balance area occupied by the said Planet Advertisers, they are charged identical higher licence fee. Accordingly, M/s. Planet Advertiser have been permitted to sell beverages, biscuits, etc. from the said kiosks. Similarly, the petitioners cannot be equated with parties who have been allotted substantially large areas.

18. The plea of legitimate expectation raised by the petitioners has no merit. There is no past conduct of the respondent-DMRC on which the petitioners rely. The initial period of the licence has expired and it is the first case of allottees claiming renewal/re-allotment. Further legitimate expectation by itself only entitles a party to fair hearing and is not a legal right to ask for issue of mandamus to re-allot and extend the licence period.

19. In India Tourism Development Corporation (supra), the Court dealt with the doctrine of legitimate expectation. It was observed that legitimate expectation is not a legal right but a benefit, relief or a remedy which may ordinarily flow from a promise or an established practice. The term “established practice” refers to regular, consistent and practicable certain conduct, process or activity of the decision making authority. However, the expectation should be legitimate i.e logical, reasonable and valid. As legitimate expectation is not a right, it is not legally enforceable as such and is given a class just above “fairness in action” but below promissory estoppel. The said principle was referred in Ram Pravesh Singh v. State of Bihar, (2006) 8 SCC 381, wherein the Supreme Court has observed that legitimate expectation can only entitle a person to seek opportunity to show cause before the expectation is dashed or ask for explanation as to the cause of denial.

20. Learned Counsel for the petitioners heavily relied upon the decision of the Delhi High Court in C.P Mittal… v. Uoi & Anr.…, 2007 (9) AD (Del) 330. In this decision, a Single Judge of this Court had struck down enhancement of licence fee by 102% payable by PCO operators in the railway station platform. In the said case, the PCO operators were given agency as a measure of rehabilitation and on compassionate basis like disability and unemployment. The allotment was a social welfare measure. In these circumstances, it was observed that standard of highest bidding would be inappropriate because the underlining social welfare measure would be undermined. With regard to the facts, the Court considered it to be unconscionable to have a take it or leave it attitude adopted by monopolistic State, especially when the bargaining powers of the petitioners therein was unequal. The State must act reasonably and in a non-arbitrary manner even in contractual and commercial subjects. The ratio of the said decision does not support the petitioners who are pure and simple commercial persons and are engaged in profit making activities. Lower licence fee in fact, will cause prejudice to the social purpose for which the respondent-DMRC has been established i.e to provide public transport in Delhi at a reasonable cost. Subsidizing commercial establishments of the petitioners for their personal gains at the cost of DMRC's revenue would violate Art. 14 of the Constitution of India.

21. In DSIDC v. Yashpal Madan, 148 (2008) DLT 642 it was held that a decision in respect of pricing should not be arbitrary or irrational and only relevant factors should be taken into consideration. In the said case, Division Bench of this Court has held that it would be wrong to conclude, that the cost of land as demanded was not appropriate. Actual expenditure had been incurred by DSIDC towards the cost of development. The decision in the case of Palika Palace Traders Association v. New Delhi Municipal Corporation, Writ Petition No. 937/2000 decided on 7th February, 2002, is also inapplicable to the present case in hand as in the said case the allotment was made as a rehabilitative measure to persons who were squatting. The allotment was to accommodate squatters and allotment was made on no loss-no profit basis. In the case of Indian Oil Corporation v. Union of India, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3823/1992 decided on 29th November, 2006, it was held that the lease rent was increased arbitrarily on the assumption that the business was profitable but the said assumption was arbitrary in the absence of any material and therefore was struck down.

22. Similarly, decision in Food Corporation Of India v. M/S Kamdhenu Cattle Feed Industries., (1993) 1 SCC 71 is also not applicable. In the said case, the respondent's highest tender was superseded by a significantly higher bid made during the negotiations, with all tenderers been given an equal opportunity to compete by revising their bids. The Supreme Court observed as under:

“….the fact that it was a significantly higher bid obtained by adopting this course was sufficient to demonstrate that the action of the appellant satisfied the requirement of non-arbitrariness, and it was taken for the cogent reason of inadequacy of the price offered in the highest tender, which reason was evident to all tenderers invited to participate in the negotiations and to revise their bids.”

23. In fact, the Supreme Court in Style (Dress Land) v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, (1999) 7 SCC 89, upheld the increase in lease money from Rs. 2,671/- p.m to Rs. 14,000/- p.m after expiry of the earlier lease period. Referring the stand taken by Union territory of Chandigarh that the shops in question were occupied by private individuals and some of them were further let-out, the Supreme Court agreed that the State Authority was entitled to charge market rent and the same was justified, reasonable and constitutional. The judgment of the High Court was upheld and it was held that the procedure adopted and made basis for enhancing the rent to market value cannot be said to be arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable. In the said case, the Supreme Court also reiterated the principle that inaction in respect of some individual/tenants cannot be made basis for setting aside action initiated against others. Similarly in Chandigarh Administration v. Jagjit Singh, (1995) 1 SCC 745 it has been held that if an order in favour of a third person is found to be contrary to law, such illegal or unwarranted order cannot be made the basis for issuing a writ compelling the authority to repeat the illegality or to pass another unwarranted order. In such cases, a party cannot urge violation of Article 14 of the Constitution alleging discrimination.

24. In view of the aforesaid, I do not find any merit in the present Writ Petitions and the same are liable to be dismissed.

25. The petitioners are however given an opportunity to agree to payment of higher licence fee as demanded by the respondents within four weeks. The petitioners are also given opportunity to exercise option and relocate themselves at some other Metro stations of their choice subject to availability. A list of such stations for exercising their choice will be made available to the petitioners within two weeks and the petitioners will have a right to exercise their option within two weeks thereafter. In the facts and circumstances of the cases, there will be no order as to cost.

Writ Petition dismissed.