- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
National Agricultural Corp. Marketing v. Reliance Polycrete Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed an application for contempt against the respondent/contemnor for deliberate noncompliance with this Court's order dated 2 April 2007. The respondent had admitted receipt of a loan of Rs. 18,38,75,000/-. The Court had directed the respondent to furnish an unconditional bank guarantee in favour of the Registrar General for the admitted amount within 30 days. The respondent failed to furnish the bank guarantee and the present contempt petition was filed. In reply the respondent stated inability to procure the bank guarantee because the bank required either 100% cash margin or 25% cash margin plus property security worth 150% of the guarantee, which the respondent did not possess.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent deliberately disobeyed the Court's order dated 2 April 2007 by failing to furnish the unconditional bank guarantee.
- Whether financial inability to furnish a bank guarantee is a defence to contempt proceedings for noncompliance with a Court order.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Applicant's counsel stated that the respondent/contemnor had deliberately not furnished the bank guarantee directed by the Court.
Contemnor's Arguments
- The contemnor denied wilful disobedience, asserting financial inability to obtain the bank guarantee because banks required either 100% cash margin or 25% cash margin plus property security worth 150% of the guarantee, and the contemnor lacked such resources.
- Counsel for the contemnor relied on Indian Overseas Bank v. Lalit Kumar Aggarwal, (2003) Company Cases 799 and R & N Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik, (2000) 4 SCC 400.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Indian Overseas Bank v. Lalit Kumar Aggarwal, (2003) Company Cases 799 | This information was not available in the provided opinion. |
This information was not available in the provided opinion. |
| R & N Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik, (2000) 4 SCC 400 |
The opinion reproduces the Supreme Court's observation that the weapon of contempt is not to be used in abundance or misused; it normally cannot be used for execution of a decree where an alternative remedy exists; contempt jurisdiction is to be exercised for maintenance of the Court's dignity and where there is wilful or deliberate disobedience. The extract emphasises that where there is no wilful or deliberate disobedience, initiation of contempt proceedings is unjustified. |
The Court applied this principle in assessing whether the contemnor's noncompliance was deliberate; finding no evidence of wilful defiance, the Court treated the contemnor's claim of inability as persuasive and dismissed the contempt petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted the respondent's admission of the loan and the prior direction to furnish an unconditional bank guarantee for the admitted amount within 30 days. The respondent's affidavit explained that banks required 100% cash margin or, alternatively, 25% cash margin plus property security worth 150% of the guarantee amount and that the respondent lacked such resources. The petitioner did not present any contrary facts demonstrating that the respondent had sufficient liquidity or property/security to obtain the guarantee. In light of the absence of contrary evidence and applying the principle that contempt should not be invoked where there is no wilful disobedience, the Court accepted the contemnor's account on its face and concluded the noncompliance was not deliberate.
Holding and Implications
Contempt Petition dismissed.
Direct effect: The contempt petition against the respondent/contemnor was dismissed and no punishment was imposed. The opinion does not discuss broader implications or establish a new precedent beyond applying the existing principle that contempt is inappropriate where noncompliance is not shown to be wilful.
1. By this order I shall dispose of this application for Contempt of the Court made by the petitioner against the respondent/contemnor on the ground that the respondent deliberately did not comply with the order of the Court dated 2nd April, 2007.
2. There was an admission made by the respondent about a sum of Rs. 18,38,75,000/- having received as a loan and not paid back. This Court vide order dated 2nd April, 2007 directed respondent/contemnor to furnish an unconditional bank guarantee in favour of the Registrar General of this Court to the extent of admitted amount within a period of 30 days. The respondent failed to furnish the bank guarantee hence the applicant filed present contempt petition against the respondent/contemnor. In the affidavit of reply to the petition, the proposed contemnor has submitted that the contemnor has not committed any wilful disobedience of the order or direction of the Court. It is stated that for issuance of the bank guarantee of Rs. 18.38 crores, 100% cash margin, i.e, of Rs. 18.38 crores was required by the bank or in alternative cash margin of 25% and property worth 150% of the value of the bank guarantee was required. The respondent did not have sufficient financial resources or the property to obtain a bank guarantee and there was no wilful disobedience of the order. The Counsel for the applicant stated that the respondent/contemnor had deliberately not furnished the bank guarantee.
3. Counsel for the contemnor argued that there was no deliberate noncompliance of the order and it was financial inability of the contemnor due to which order could not be complied with and because of this, the contemnor cannot be punished. He relied on Indian Overseas Bank v. Lalit Kumar Aggarwal, (2003) Company Cases 799 and R & N Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik, (2000) 4 SCC 400. The Supreme Court in R & N Dey (supra) had observed as under:
“We may reiterate that the weapon of contempt is not to be used in abundance or misused. Normally, it cannot be used for execution of the decree or implementation of an order for which alternative remedy in law is provided for. Discretion given to the Court is to be exercised for maintenance of the Court's dignity and majesty of law. Further, an aggrieved party has no right to insist that the Court should exercise such jurisdiction as contempt is between a contemnor and the Court. It is true that in the present case, the High Court has kept the matter pending and has ordered that it should be heard along with the first appeal. But, at the same time, it is to be noticed that under the coercion of contempt proceedings, appellants cannot be directed to pay the compensation amount which they are disputing by asserting that claimants were not the owners of the property in question and that decree was obtained by suppressing the material fact and by fraud. Even presuming that the claimants are entitled to recover the amount of compensation as awarded by the trial Court as no stay order is granted by the High Court, at the most they are entitled to recover the same by executing the said award wherein the State can or may contend that the award is a nullity. In such a situation, as there was no wilful or deliberate disobedience of the order, the initiation of contempt proceedings was wholly unjustified.”
4. I consider that in this case the contention of the respondent/contemnor has to be believed on the face of it since the petitioner has not brought to notice of this Court any fact contrary to the contention of the contemnor showing that the contemnor was having sufficient liquidity to furnish to the bank or had property/security with 25% amount which he could have furnished to the bank. It does not seem to be a case of the deliberate defiance of the order of the Court. The Contempt Petition is hereby dismissed.
Contempt Petition dismissed.
Alert