Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jamirul Nisha And Another v. Union Of India .

Delhi High Court
Mar 5, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Appeal against Railway Claims Tribunal order dated 20.11.2006

Factual and Procedural Background

The present appeal challenges the Railway Claims Tribunal's order dated 20.11.2006 which dismissed a claim application under section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989. The appellants (the widowed mother and sister of the deceased) sought compensation of Rs. 6,00,000 for the death of Sarfaraj Khan, alleged to have occurred when he accidentally fell from EMU passenger train GDM 1 on 10.5.2003 while travelling from Nizamuddin to New Delhi Railway Station. The claim alleged that the deceased was a bona fide passenger who occupied a position near a compartment door due to overcrowding and that a sudden jerk caused him to fall and sustain fatal injuries.

The Railways defended the claim on the basis that the injuries were not accidental but self-inflicted or resulted when the deceased was run over while crossing the railway track, and that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger. The Tribunal examined oral evidence (AW1 — the mother; AW2 — Manik Mian) and documentary evidence (including DD entries, medical records, post-mortem and inquest reports, police statements and a final police report) and also heard Railway witnesses (Head Constable Yashpal Singh and Vinod Kumar). The Tribunal concluded that the deceased was neither a bona fide passenger nor had he died as a result of falling from a train, and therefore dismissed the claim. The appellants appealed this dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger and whether his death resulted from accidentally falling from the train (i.e., whether an "untoward incident" as defined in section 123(c)(2) had occurred).
  2. Whether the Railways had the burden to prove that the death was not the result of an "untoward incident" (i.e., whether the Railways failed to discharge any such burden once an untoward incident was alleged).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Tribunal failed to take proper account of DD entry No. 9A dated 10.5.2003 (Exh. AW1/2), which recorded information that a person had fallen from a train and which, according to counsel, corroborates the claim that the deceased fell from the train.
  • The Railways bore the burden of proving that the death was not the result of an "untoward incident" and in the present case they failed to discharge that burden. Counsel placed reliance on Union of India v. B. Koddekar (2003 ACJ 1286 (AP)) and Raj Kumari v. Union of India (1993 ACJ 846 (MP)).
  • Evidence led by the appellants: AW1 (mother) and AW2 (Manik Mian — witness and alleged co-passenger) and multiple documents including medical records, post-mortem, inquest, police statements and the final police report.

Railways' Arguments

  • The injuries leading to death were not accidental but self-inflicted or resulted when the deceased was run over while crossing the railway track (i.e., not caused by falling from the train).
  • The deceased was not a bona fide passenger of the train when the fatal incident occurred.
  • Railway witnesses (Head Constable Yashpal Singh and Vinod Kumar) gave evidence that the injured person was found on the railway track under the overbridge between two platforms at Tilak Bridge Station, and that the body was recovered at the station — facts which, the Railways contended, were inconsistent with the account that the deceased had fallen from a moving train.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. B. Koddekar, 2003 ACJ 1286 (AP) Relied upon by appellants for the proposition that the burden of proving that a death was not the result of an "untoward incident" lies upon the Railways. The court recorded that appellants relied on this authority but found that appellants had not first established that the deceased had fallen from the train; consequently the court held that the question of the Railways having to disprove an untoward incident did not arise in the facts of this case.
Raj Kumari v. Union of India, 1993 ACJ 846 (MP) Relied upon by appellants for the same burden-of-proof contention as above. The court noted the reliance but, for the same reason as stated with respect to the other precedent, held that because appellants failed to establish that the death resulted from falling from a train, the Railways' obligation to negate an untoward incident was not triggered.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a fact-focused analysis based on the testimony and documentary evidence before the Tribunal. The key steps of the court's reasoning are:

  1. Evaluation of the DD entry (Exh. AW1/2): The DD entry recorded that information had been received that a person had fallen from a train. The court explained that such a wireless report could reflect a presumption by a person who observed an injured body on the track, and that subsequent police investigation did not yield evidence or traces corroborating that the deceased had fallen from a train. Instead, the material established that the deceased was crushed by a train and found on the track under an overbridge between two platforms.
  2. Assessment of AW2's (Manik Mian) testimony: The Tribunal and the court found AW2's evidence unreliable and likely "planted." The court highlighted multiple inconsistencies and implausibilities in his account:
    • AW2 claimed to have travelled with the deceased and to have witnessed him fall from the moving train, yet he did not report the matter to police and did not return to the spot to enquire about the deceased.
    • The witness gave inconsistent statements on whether he (AW2) had pulled the alarm chain or had asked other passengers to do so, and whether he informed a railway official or a passenger after the incident.
    • The court considered AW2's conduct — alighting at Tilak Bridge and simply walking away without investigating — to be unnatural if he had genuinely witnessed a fall causing grievous injury, undermining his credibility.
  3. Position of the recovered body and Railway witnesses' evidence: Testimony of Railway witnesses (Head Constable Yashpal Singh and Vinod Kumar) consistently indicated that the injured person was found on the railway track under the overbridge between two platforms, and that the body was recovered at the station itself. The Tribunal treated this physical location as inconsistent with the account of a person who had fallen from a moving train approaching the station.
  4. Consideration of the nature of the train and injuries: The court observed that the train in question was an EMU passenger train that travels at low speed and slows further when approaching a station; it would be unlikely for a person falling from such a train as it approached a station to sustain the grievous injuries recorded.
  5. Status of AW1 (mother): The court noted that AW1 was not an eyewitness; in cross-examination she admitted having no personal knowledge of the incident, reducing the evidentiary weight of her account.
  6. Statutory framework and burden of proof: The court referred to section 123(c)(2) (defining accidental falling as an "untoward incident") and section 124-A (providing compensation where injury/death results from an untoward incident unless exceptions apply). The court emphasized that as a sine qua non for claiming compensation the claimant must first establish that the victim had accidentally fallen from a train. Since appellants failed to establish that primary fact, the court held that the issue of the Railways' burden to prove that the death was not an untoward incident did not arise.

On the totality of evidence and credibility findings, particularly the unreliability of AW2 and the Railway witnesses' accounts of the body being found on the track at the station, the court found no basis to disturb the Tribunal's finding that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger who had died as a result of falling from a train.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF / Appeal Dismissed

The court affirmed the impugned order dated 20.11.2006 of the Railway Claims Tribunal and dismissed the appeal. The direct effects are:

  • The claim application under section 124-A for compensation was properly dismissed by the Tribunal and that dismissal stands.
  • No costs were awarded.

The opinion does not announce any new legal principle or bind future decisions; it rests on the application of statutory provisions (sections 123(c)(2) and 124-A) to the particular facts and credibility findings in this case. The court explicitly held that because the appellants failed to establish that the deceased had accidentally fallen from the train, the Railways were not required to discharge any burden to negative an "untoward incident" under section 124-A in this instance.

Show all summary ...

Pradeep Nandrajog, J.:— The present appeal lays a challenge to the order dated 20.11.2006 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi dismissing the claim application filed by the appellants.

2. Appellants had filed a claim applica tion under section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989, claiming compensation in sum of Rs. 6,00,000 on account of the death of Sarfaraj Khan (hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’) alleged to have been caused when he had accidentally fallen from a train. In the claim application it has been averred that on 10.5.2003 the deceased had boarded EMU passenger train GDM 1 from Nizamuddin Railway Station for a journey from Nizamuddin to New Delhi Railway Station. That since the train was overcrowded the deceased got a place near the door of a compartment of the train. That at around 8.45 a.m, when the train was approaching Tilak Bridge Railway Station there was a sudden jerk due to which the deceased fell down from the train and died of injuries received as a result thereof. That the deceased was a bona fide passenger and that the death of the deceased was a result of an ‘untoward incident’ which happened when he was travelling in EMU passenger train GDM 1. That the deceased was self-employed and earning his livelihood by working as a painter. That the appellants are the widowed mother and sister of the deceased and were dependent upon the earnings of the deceased.

3. The Railways defended the claim by pleading that the appellants are not entitled to any compensation as injuries which resulted in the death of the deceased were not accidental but self-inflicted injuries. That the deceased was not a bona fide passenger in the train. That the accident in question occurred when while trying to cross the railway track the deceased came into contact with the moving train. (Meaning thereby was run over while crossing the railway track).

4. In support of the claim appellants examined appellant No. 1, Jamirul Nisha, mother of the deceased as AW 1 and one Manik Mian as AW 2 who claimed to have witnessed the said untoward incident.

5. In her testimony the appellant No. 1 deposed on the lines of the claim application. She further deposed that on the un-fateful day, i.e, 10.5.2003 the deceased left his residence situated at Sarai Kale Khan, Delhi at about 8.15 in the morning. That the deceased told her that he is going to Delhi for taking payment from some contractor. She also deposed how her son died.

6. Manik Mian, AW 2 stated that the deceased was travelling under a valid ticket and that the death of the deceased was a result of an untoward incident. He deposed that on 10.5.2003 at about 8.15 a.m he met the deceased near the booking counter of the Nizamuddin Railway Station. That he purchased two tickets for a journey from Nizamuddin Railway Station to New Delhi Railway Station and gave one ticket to the deceased. That thereafter they boarded the EMU passenger train GDM 1. That since the train was overcrowded they both got a place near the door of the compartment. That when the train was approaching Tilak Bridge Railway Station there was a sudden jerk due to which the deceased fell down from the train. That after the deceased fell down from the train he cried and requested other passengers to pull the alarm chain but the train did not stop. That thereafter he got down at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station and while going out of the platform he informed one railway official regarding the said incident.

7. It is relevant to note that in cross-examination AW 2 gave reason why he and the deceased were co-passengers. He stated as under:

“Mandawali is near Mother Dairy, Patparganj, Delhi. I was accompanying the deceased as I was to take him to Mandawali. He had met at the station itself. I had not taken any money from the deceased for purchasing the ticket nor I received it after I had given the ticket to him. I was taking him to Mandawali for whitewashing my house. I had pulled the chain after the deceased had fallen from the train, but the train did not stop. The deceased had fallen at a short distance from the Tilak Bridge Railway Station. I did not report the matter to the police. I had informed one of the passengers about this incident and left. I got down at I.T.O and did not go back to the spot to enquire as to what had happened to the deceased. It is incorrect to suggest that I was not accompanying the deceased or that I am deposing falsely.”

8. On behalf of the appellants following 17 documents were filed:

(i) Exh. AW1/2—True copy of the DD entry No. 9A dated 10.5.2003 which was recorded after the occurrence of the accident.

(ii) Exhs. AW1/3 and AW1/4—True copies of the medical records of LNJP Hospital where the deceased was admitted.

(iii) Exh. AW1/5—True copy of the DD entry No. 20A dated 14.5.2003 which was recorded after the death of the deceased,

(iv) Exh. AW1/6—True copy of the death report of the deceased.

(v) Exh. AW1/7—True copy of the post-mortem report of the deceased.

(vi) Exh. AW1/8—True copy of the inquest report.

(vii) Exhs. AW1/9, AW1/10, AW1/11, AW1/12, AW1/13, AW1/14 and AW1/15—True copies of the statements of SI Jagdish Singh, Krishan Mohan, Vinod Kumar, Head Constable, Yashpal Singh, Jamirul Nisha and Nasim Khan recorded before the police.

(viii) Exh. AW1/16—True copy of the final report made by the police.

(ix) Exh. AW1/17—True copy of the ration card.

(x) Exh. AW1/18—True copy of the guard's memo.

9. Exh. AW1/2 records the wireless information received regarding the happening of the said accident. The wireless information stated to be received is that one person had fallen from a train.

10. Exhs. AW1/3 and AW1/4 records the injuries suffered by the deceased.

11. Exh. AW1/5 records that the deceased died on 14.5.2003

12. Exh. AW1/9 is the statement of SI Jagdish Singh. It has been recorded that on 10.5.2003 the deceased was crushed by a train. How the deceased came into contact with the train has not been recorded.

13. Exh. AW1/10 is the statement of one Krishan Mohan who was running a food cart at Tilak Bridge Railway Station. It has been recorded that on 10.5.2003 he found that the deceased has been lying near the railway line in an injured condition.

14. Exh. AW1/11 is the statement of one Vinod Kumar who was working as a Keyman at Tilak Bridge Railway Station. It has been recorded that on 10.5.2003 he found that the deceased has been lying near the railway line in an injured condition.

15. Exh. AW1/12 is the statement of Head Constable Yashpal Singh. It has been recorded that on 10.5.2003 the deceased was crushed by a train. How the deceased came into contact with the train has not been recorded.

16. Exhs. AW1/13 and AW1/14 are the statements of the mother and brother of the deceased respectively. Said statements pertain as to how they received the information regarding the death of the deceased.

17. On behalf of the Railways, Head Constable Yashpal Singh and one Vinod Kumar were examined as RW 1 and RW 2 respectively.

18. Head Constable Yashpal Singh, RW 1 deposed that on receiving the information regarding the occurrence of the said accident he went to the Tilak Bridge Railway Station where he was informed that a person met with an accident under the overbridge between the two platforms and had already been removed to the hospital.

19. Vinod Kumar, RW 2, who was working as a Keyman at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station deposed that on 10.5.2003 when he was conducting a routine inspection of the line near the platform at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station he found that an injured person lying on the railway track under the overbridge between the platforms.

20. After noting the respective stand of the parties and the evidence led the learned Railway Claims Tribunal has held that the deceased was neither a bona fide passenger nor had died of injuries alleged to have been sustained by him after accidentally falling from a train and thus dismissed the claim application of the appellants. The Tribunal has opined as under:

“Since decision of both these issues mainly depends upon the evidence of AW 2, we have taken these issues together. From the body of the deceased ticket has not been recovered. It is not unusual that when a passenger falls down from the train his ticket may be lost but in the present case we find that except for the statement of AW 2, there is no other evidence to prove that deceased was allegedly travelling in the train or he had purchased any ticket. In his affidavit AW 2 has stated that on 10.5.2003, the deceased met him near the booking counter of Nizamuddin Railway Station and he purchased two tickets, one for himself and one for the deceased for going to New Delhi. The witness was allegedly taking the deceased to his house for the purposes of whitewash whereas AW 1, namely, applicant No. 1 in her affidavit has stated that the deceased as going to New Delhi for getting payment from some contractor. The evidence of AW 2 does not inspire confidence inasmuch as while it is stated by him that when the train was approaching Tilak Bridge Railway Station, the deceased fell down from the moving train due to sudden jerk given by the train and in his statement before the Tribunal also he states that the deceased had fallen at a short distance from Tilak Bridge Railway Station, the body of the deceased was found at the station itself between the two platforms. Though the witness was allegedly travelling with the deceased and was taking him to his house for whitewashing, he neither informed the police about the same nor informed any railway official. He also did not go back to the spot, where the deceased had allegedly fallen, to enquire as to what had happened to him. This evidence is clearly contrary to the evidence produced by the Railways. Head Constable Yashpal Singh, who had visited the spot and investigated the matter has stated that when he reached Tilak Bridge Railway Station, he was informed that a person had met with an accident under the overbridge between two platforms and had already been removed to the hospital. Vinod Kumar, who was posted as Keyman at Tilak Bridge Railway Station has in his statement stated that while he was on routine inspection of the line, he found an injured person lying on the railway track under the overbridge between the two platforms. The statement of the witness produced by the Railways clearly shows that the body was recovered at the railway station itself between the two platforms under the overbridge which connects the two platforms. The fact that body was recovered between the two platforms at the railway station, in our view clearly shows that the deceased had not fallen from the train as has been stated by RW 2. In our opinion AW 2 was not travelling with the deceased and is a procured witness. We are thus clearly of the opinion that the deceased was neither a bona fide passenger nor had died of injuries alleged to have been sustained by him after falling from the train. Both these issues are accordingly decided against the applicants.”

21. Learned counsel for the appellants challenges the impugned order on follow ing two counts:

I. Learned Tribunal failed to take note of the DD entry No. 9A dated 10.5.2003 Exh. AW1/2 which according to her clearly establishes that the deceased had fallen from the train.

II. Learned Tribunal has acted contrary to the settled law that the burden of proving that the death of a victim of a train accident is not the result of an ‘untoward incident’ is upon the Rail ways. That in the instant case Railways failed to discharge the burden that the death of the deceased was not the result of an ‘untoward incident’. Reliance has been placed upon the judgments report ed as Union of India v. B. Koddekar, 2003 ACJ 1286 (AP) and Raj Kumari v. Union of India, 1993 ACJ 846 (MP), in support of this contention.

22. No doubt DD entry No. 9A dated 10.5.2003, Exh. AW1/2, records that in formation has been received that a person had fallen from a train. It is quite possible that after seeing the deceased lying in an injured condition on the railway track some person might have presumed that the deceased had fallen from the train and informed the police on that basis. After the accident was investigated by the police there has been no evidence or even traces of the fact that deceased had fallen from the train. All that is established is that the deceased was crushed by a train and that he was lying on the railway track under the overbridge between the two platforms.

23. The learned Tribunal has rightly disbelieved the testimony of AW 2. In my opinion, AW 2 was a planted witness.

24. If testimony of AW 2 is believed, he was not obviously a fortuitous co-passenger with the deceased. As per his testimony AW 2 was taking the deceased to his house for the purpose of getting his house whitewashed by the deceased. In his examination-in-chief he has deposed that he cried after seeing the deceased falling from the train. In his cross-examination he has deposed that after the deceased fell off from the train he got down at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station and did not go back to the spot where the deceased had allegedly fallen to enquire as to what had happened to him. If AW 2 was so distress ed that on seeing the deceased falling from the train, he cried, he would have definitely gone to the spot where the deceased had allegedly fallen to enquire as to what had happened to him. Even otherwise, it was expected of him that after getting down at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station he would have gone to the spot where the deceased had allegedly fallen to enquire as to what had happened to him. The conduct of AW 2 in getting down at the railway station and just walking, without enquiring about the deceased, is unnatural human conduct if indeed he had witnessed the accident.

25. Testimony of AW 2 suffers from two contradictions.

26. AW 2 in his examination-in-chief has deposed that on seeing deceased falling from the train he requested other passengers to pull the alarm chain while in his cross-examination he has deposed that he had himself pulled the chain.

27. AW 2 in his examination-in-chief has deposed that after getting down at the Tilak Bridge Railway Station he informed one railway official regarding the said incident while in his cross-examination he has deposed that he informed one of the passengers about the said incident.

28. Learned Tribunal has rightly opined that the positioning of the body of the de ceased also belies the testimony of AW 2.

29. Additionally I note that had the deceased fallen from the train when it was approaching Tilak Bridge Railway Station as stated by AW 2 the deceased would not have suffered such grievous injuries for the reason train in question was an EMU passenger train which travels at a very less speed and the speed of EMU train further slows down when the train is approaching the station.

30. Testimony of AW 1 as to the manner in which the deceased died is of no consequence for the reason she was not an eyewitness to the said accident. In her cross-examination she has categorically deposed that she has no personal knowledge about the said incident.

31. Second contention advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants is predicated upon the assumption that the death of the deceased was a result of an ‘untoward incident’.

32. Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989 provides that accidental falling of any passenger from a train carrying passengers is an ‘untoward incident’. Section 124-A provides that when a person suffers injury or dies due to an untoward incident it is incumbent upon the Railways to pay compensation to the injured or to the dependants of the deceased as the case may be provided the injury or the death does not fall within any of the five exceptions indicated in the section.

33. From a perusal of the sections 123(c)(2) and 124-A it is clear that sine qua non for claiming compensation on account of death or injury sustained in a train accident is that the victim of a train accident or his dependants as the case may be must first establish that the victim or the deceased had accidentally fallen from a train.

34. In the instant case appellants have failed to establish that the deceased had accidentally fallen from the train, therefore, the question of proof by the Railways that the death of the deceased was not the result of untoward incident does not arise.

35. In view of above discussion I find no merits in the instant appeal.

36. Impugned order dated 20.11.2006 is affirmed.

37. The appeal is dismissed. No costs.

38. Appeal dismissed.