- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Coca Cola Company And Anr. v. Dwarkadhish Khandelwal Trading
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs filed a suit seeking injunction and damages for trademark infringement, alleging that the defendant's trademark "FACTA" was deceptively similar to their registered trademark "FANTA." Plaintiff No. 1 is a globally recognized company owning several trademarks including FANTA, which has been in use since 1941 and registered under various classes. The plaintiffs discovered the defendant's advertisement for "FACTA" on November 18, 2003, and subsequently filed a notice of opposition before the Registrar of Trade Marks. They claimed that the defendant's use of the mark FACTA for a similar aerated drink was a deliberate attempt to exploit the plaintiffs' goodwill. Despite the defendant's initial appearance, they failed to file a written statement or continue participation, resulting in an ex parte proceeding against them. The plaintiffs supported their case with affidavits, board resolutions, authorizations, annual reports, and trademark registrations.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendant's use of the trademark "FACTA" constitutes infringement of the plaintiffs' registered trademark "FANTA" due to deceptive similarity.
- Whether the defendant's adoption of the mark "FACTA" was in bad faith and intended to ride on the reputation and goodwill of the plaintiffs.
- Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to permanent and mandatory injunction, delivery up of infringing goods, rendition of accounts, and damages against the defendant.
- Whether damages should be awarded against a defendant who absents themselves from court proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The plaintiffs claimed ownership of the trademark FANTA since 1941 with extensive use and registration under various classes.
- The defendant's trademark FACTA is deceptively similar in appearance and used for similar aerated drinks.
- The use of FACTA is a deliberate attempt to deceive the public and benefit from the plaintiffs' goodwill and reputation.
- The similarity in labeling and the target consumer base, including children, increases the likelihood of deception.
- The plaintiffs sought permanent and mandatory injunctions, delivery up of infringing products, rendition of accounts, and damages valued tentatively at Rs. 20 lakh.
- They relied on prior judgments to support awarding damages against defendants who abscond from proceedings to prevent evasion of liability.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the defendant's legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Asian Paints (India) Ltd. v. Balaji Paints and Chemicals and Ors | Damages can be awarded against defendants who abscond from court proceedings to prevent evasion of liability. | The Court relied on this precedent to justify awarding damages against the absent defendant. |
| Relaxo Rubber Limited and Anr. v. Selection Footwear and Anr. | Damages awarded in trademark infringement cases to compensate the plaintiff. | Supported the principle that damages are an appropriate relief in such cases. |
| Hindustan Machines v. Royal Electrical Appliances | Damages as a remedy for trademark infringement. | Reinforced the award of damages in infringement suits. |
| CS (OS) 2711/1999 L.T Overseas Ltd. v. Guruji Trading Co. and Anr | Damages awarded to plaintiffs in infringement cases. | Used to substantiate the entitlement to damages. |
| Time Incorporated v. Lokesh Srivastava and Anr | Both compensatory and punitive damages can be awarded to discourage repeat infringement. | Supported awarding damages to deter violations with impunity. |
| Hero Honda Motors Ltd. v. Shree Assuramji Scooters | Damages should be awarded against defendants who stay away from court proceedings to prevent evasion of liability. | Applied to justify damages against the defendant who absented themselves from the suit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the facts and evidence presented by the plaintiffs, including the longstanding registration and use of the trademark FANTA and the defendant's adoption of the mark FACTA for similar products. The Court found the marks to be deceptively similar in word and label style, which could mislead the public, especially children. The defendant's mark appeared to have no independent meaning and was adopted in bad faith to ride on the plaintiffs' goodwill. The defendant's failure to defend the suit further supported this conclusion. The Court also considered precedents establishing that damages should be awarded against defendants who avoid court proceedings to prevent them from escaping liability. Based on these factors, the Court concluded that the plaintiffs were entitled to injunctions and damages.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF
The Court passed a decree in favor of the plaintiffs and against the defendant, granting permanent and mandatory injunctions as per prayer Clauses 'A' and 'B' of the plaint. The plaintiffs were awarded damages amounting to Rs. 5.00 lakh and entitled to costs of the proceedings. The decision directly affects the parties by restraining the defendant from using the infringing trademark and compensating the plaintiffs for the infringement. No new precedent was established; rather, the Court applied existing principles to the facts of the case.
Page 2325
1. The plaintiffs have filed a suit for injunction and damages for infringement of their trademark FANTA on account of a deceptively similar trademark FACTA, which is being used by the defendant in identical scheme.
2. The plaintiff No. 1 claims to be a world renowned company and proprietor of various trademarks including, COCA COLA, COKE, THUMS UP, FANTA, etc. The trademark FANTA is stated to be adopted since 1941 and the turnover runs into millions of dollars, the details of which have been set out in the plaint. The trademark FANTA is also registered under different classes as stated in paragraph 12 of the plaint.
Page 2326
3. The plaintiffs came across a general advertisement of the defendant's trademark FACTA on 18.11.2003, which was deceptively and confusingly similar to the trademark of the plaintiffs. Plaintiff No. 1 filed a notice of opposition before the Registrar of Trade Marks.
4. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the adoption of the trademark FACTA by the defendant is in respect of similar aerated drink and is a deliberate attempt of the defendant to ride piggy back on the reputation and goodwill of the plaintiffs.
5. The plaintiffs have, thus, sought a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction, delivery up and rendition of accounts. The claim for damages was tentatively valued at Rs. 20.00 lakh. 6.The summons and notices were issued to the defendant, who entered appearance but thereafter did not file the written statement and stopped appearing. The defendant was proceeded ex parte vide order dated 25.5.2007.
7. The plaintiffs, in order to establish their case, have filed the affidavit of Mr. Ullal Narendra Kini (PW-1) as exhibit PW-1/A affirming to the facts set out in the plaint. The letter of authorisation in his favor has been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/1.
8. The said witness has proved the certified copy of the Board Resolution dated 14.8.2006 of plaintiff No. 2 in favor of Mr. Joel Allan Peres. Mr. Joel Allan Peres has signed and verified the plaint and instituted the suit. A letter of authorisation by the Vice-President (Legal) of plaintiff No. 2 in favor of the deponent has been proved as PW-1/1. The delegation in favor of Mr. Steve Whaley, who has signed and verified the plaint and instituted the suit on behalf of plaintiff No. 1, has been proved in pursuance to the delegation dated 9.5.2006 (Exhibit PW-1/2).
9. The witness has deposed to the facts set out in the plaint and has proved the annual reports of the years 2003 to 2005 as Exhibit PW-1/5. The registration of the trademarks in favor of plaintiff No. 1 under different categories, which has been renewed from time to time, has been proved through the journal advertisements of these marks as Exhibit PW-1/8 collectively. The office copy of TM-46 has been proved as Exhibit PW-1/9.
10. The documents on record also show that the style of the label is similar. The word FANTA and FACTA are liable to cause deception in view of their similarity. It cannot be lost sight of that these aerated drinks are purchased by the public at large including children, who may not be well educated and thus the chances of deception are even higher.
11. In view of the aforesaid, I am satisfied that the adoption of the mark FACTA, which appears to have no meaning, when there is an existing trademark FANTA of the plaintiff is not bonafide and the object appears to deceive the public into purchasing the product of the defendant on the assumption that the same may emanate from the plaintiffs. The object is, thus, to ride piggy back on the reputation of the plaintiffs.
12. The defendant after initial appearance has not even cared to defend the present suit.
Page 2327
13. A decree is, thus, liable to be passed in favor of the plaintiffs and against the defendant in terms of prayer Clauses 'A' and 'B' of the plaint.
14. Insofar as prayer Clause 'C' is concerned, this Court has repeatedly held that the party, which absents itself from the court proceedings should not be able to avoid the rigours of damages as that would amount to giving an escape route to such absenting parties from the proceedings especially when compared to parties which joins the proceedings. It would be suffice to reproduce the observations made by this Court in Asian Paints (India) Ltd. v. Balaji Paints and Chemicals and Ors. , which are as under:
11. Learned Counsel for the plaintiff states that apart from the relief claimed for in paras (a) to (d) of para 33 of the plaint, the plaintiff is also entitled to damages. In this behalf, learned Counsel has relied upon the judgments of this Court in Relaxo Rubber Limited and Anr. v. Selection Footwear and Anr. 1999 PTC (19) 578, Hindustan Machines v. Royal Electrical Appliances 1999 PTC (19) 685 and CS (OS) 2711/1999 L.T. Overseas Ltd. v. Guruji Trading Co. and Anr. decided on 7.9.2003. In all these cases, damages of Rs. 3 lakhs were awarded in favor of the plaintiff. In Time Incorporated v. Lokesh Srivastava and Anr. 2005 (30) PTC 3 (Del) apart from compensatory damages even punitive damages were awarded to discourage and dishearten law breakers who indulge in violation with impunity. In a recent judgment in Hero Honda Motors Ltd. v. Shree Assuramji Scooters this Court has taken the view that damages in such a case should be awarded against defendants who chose to stay away from proceedings of the court and they should not be permitted to enjoy the benefits of evasion of court proceedings. The rationale for the same is that while defendants who appeared in court may be burdened with damages while defendants who chose to stay away from the court would escape such damages. The actions of the defendants result in affecting the reputation of the plaintiff and every endeavor should be made for a larger public purpose to discourage such parties from indulging in acts of deception.
15. In view of the aforesaid, I deem it appropriate that the plaintiffs should be held entitled to damages to the tune of Rs. 5.00 lakh apart from the costs of the present proceedings.
16. A decree is passed in favor of the plaintiffs and against the defendant in terms of prayer Clauses 'A' and 'B' of the plaint. The plaintiffs are further entitled to damages of Rs. 5.00 lakh and shall also be entitled to costs of the proceedings.
17. The decree sheet be drawn up accordingly.
Alert