Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd v. Satish Sharma & Ors

Delhi High Court
May 15, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Pradeep Nandrajog, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is directed against a Tribunal award dated 9.2.2005. On 30.11.2003, the injured, Satish Kumar, sustained serious injuries in a road accident alleged to have been caused by rash and negligent driving of a vehicle belonging to respondent No. 3, Nand Kishore. As per the Tribunal award, the appellant insurance company was directed to pay Rs. 10,34,850/- as compensation with the award breaking down into medical reimbursement (Rs. 25,000), pain and suffering (Rs. 1,00,000), permanent disability/loss of amenities (Rs. 2,00,000), loss of earning capacity (Rs. 6,76,350), conveyance/attendant charges (Rs. 7,500), future treatment/artificial implant (Rs. 1,000) and loss of marriage prospects (Rs. 25,000).

The injured was 26 years old at the time of the accident and worked as a daily wager. His right leg was amputated below the knee and permanent disability was assessed at 60%. He was hospitalized from 30.11.2003 to 24.2.2004. The insurer (appellant) challenged the quantum of compensation and filed the present appeal; the only issue before the Court was quantum.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal's award of Rs. 3,25,000/- as non-pecuniary damages (pain and suffering, permanent disability/loss of amenities, loss of marriage prospects) was excessive or just and reasonable.
  2. Whether the Tribunal correctly awarded Rs. 25,000/- as medical reimbursement given the medical bills on record and whether future medical/implant-related expenses were adequately considered.
  3. Whether the Tribunal applied correct legal principles in determining compensation for loss of earning capacity, including (a) the adoption of minimum wages as the basis for income, (b) treatment of future prospects/increase in wages, (c) choice of multiplier, and (d) assessment of functional disability percentage (Tribunal used 75% functional disability while permanent disability was 60%).
  4. Whether, on the correct appreciation of the above, the pecuniary award for loss of earning capacity should be reduced (Tribunal had awarded Rs. 6,76,350/- under this head).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The compensation awarded under non-pecuniary damages (in particular Rs. 2,00,000/- for permanent disability/loss of amenities) is excessive.
  • The Tribunal erred in awarding Rs. 25,000/- for medical expenses as the injured had produced medical bills totaling only Rs. 1,744/-.
  • The Tribunal applied incorrect principles of law in determining compensation for loss of earning capacity (contention as to income base, application of multiplier and assessment of functional disability).

The opinion does not set out any detailed arguments advanced by the respondent(s) in the appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B.N. Kumar v. D.T.C., 118 (2005) DLT 36 Quantum of non-pecuniary damages for amputation/continuing disability (example figures historically awarded). Used as a comparative precedent showing prior awards under non-pecuniary heads; contributed to the court's view about a trend in awards for amputation-related disabilities.
Fakkirappa v. Yallawwa & Anr., 2004 ACJ 141 Illustrative decomposition and quantum of non-pecuniary damages for leg amputation in a minor (pain, loss of amenities, amputation damages, etc.). Included among decisions reflecting amounts awarded for amputation and loss of amenities; used to inform whether the Tribunal's non-pecuniary award was reasonable.
K. Shankar v. Pallavan Transport Corporation, 2001 ACJ 488 Quantum of non-pecuniary damages for amputation and related heads (pain, loss of expectation of life, mental agony). Cited as comparative authority showing prior levels of awards under non-pecuniary heads for leg amputation and high percentage disability.
M. Jaganathan v. Pallavan Transport Corporation, 1999 ACJ 366 Non-pecuniary compensation for above-knee amputation (pain, continuing disability, mental agony). Used to show examples of substantial non-pecuniary awards, supporting the conclusion that the Tribunal's total non-pecuniary award was within acceptable range.
Bhagwan Singh Meena v. Jai Kishan Tiwari, 1999 ACJ 1200 Non-pecuniary damages for severe injuries leading to amputation (example quantum). Referenced among decisions indicating the scale of awards for amputation under non-pecuniary heads.
Dr. Gop Ramchandani v. Onkar Singh & Ors., 1993 ACJ 577 Award levels for non-pecuniary damages involving 50% disability after amputation (break-up provided in the judgment). Included in the comparative set of authorities demonstrating historical awards for non-pecuniary losses.
Jitendra Singh v. Islam, 1998 ACJ 1301 Non-pecuniary damages for amputation with 55% disability (quantum example). Cited as another example of awards for amputation and permanent disability contributing to the trend analysis.
Iranna v. Mohammadali Khadarsab Mulla & Anr., 2004 ACJ 1396 Non-pecuniary damages for a child with below-knee amputation (specific break-up and totals). Used to illustrate award levels for child victims with amputation and to inform the Court's assessment of non-pecuniary damages.
Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh, 2003 ACJ 12 Recognition that an artificial leg requires replacement every 2–3 years and that this justifies a substantial award for future expenses (Supreme Court example of Rs. 1,00,000/-). Relied upon to conclude that the Tribunal's award of only Rs. 1,000/- for future medical/artificial implant expenses was inadequate and to justify allowance for replacement costs; supported the view that Rs. 25,000/- medical reimbursement was not infirm.
K. Narsimha Murthi v. Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr., 2004 ACJ 1109 Principle that while estimating future loss of income, the court must take into account future prospects of the injured. Applied to uphold the Tribunal's approach of considering future increase in minimum wages as part of assessing loss of earning capacity.
U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra & Ors., (1996) 4 SCC 362 Principle on appropriate multiplier to be applied: highest multiplier of 18 for the age group 21–25 years. Relied upon to justify the use of multiplier 18 by the Tribunal (the Court concluded multiplier 18 was fair and reasonable for the injured despite his being aged 26).
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Vijay Kumar Mittal, MAC. APP. No. 228/2006 (decided 11.05.2007) Assessment of functional disability (example: injured aged 23–24 with functional disability assessed at 60%). Used as a recent comparable decision to conclude that the functional disability in the instant case should be assessed at 60% rather than the 75% adopted by the Tribunal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a structured assessment of quantum, beginning with general principles on compensation for bodily injuries: bodily integrity is a primary human right, damages must attempt to compensate to the extent money can, and awards should be substantial and proportionate to the gravity of injury. Damages are to be divided into pecuniary and non-pecuniary heads (paras 10–13).

Non-pecuniary damages:

The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 3,25,000/- under non-pecuniary heads (pain and suffering Rs.1,00,000; permanent disability/loss of amenities Rs.2,00,000; loss of marriage prospects Rs.25,000). The appellant argued excessiveness, particularly of the Rs.2,00,000 component for permanent disability. The Court reviewed a number of precedents showing historical awards for amputation-related injuries and concluded that awards in the range noted in those decisions (many around Rs.3,00,000 under non-pecuniary heads for similar serious amputations and disabilities) supported the Tribunal's total award. On that basis the Court found the Tribunal's non-pecuniary award of Rs.3,25,000 to be just, fair and reasonable (paras 14–18, 31–33).

Pecuniary damages — Medical expenses and future implant costs:

The appellant challenged the Rs.25,000/- medical reimbursement on the basis that bills produced amounted to only Rs.1,744/-. The Tribunal had separately allowed Rs.1,000/- for future medical/implant expenses. The Court noted that an artificial limb had been implanted and would require replacement every 2–3 years; it cited Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh where the Supreme Court awarded Rs.1,00,000 for such future expenses. Concluding that Rs.1,000 for future medical expenses was inadequate, the Court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's decision to award Rs.25,000 for medical expenses in the circumstances (paras 20–25, 38–41).

Pecuniary damages — Loss of earning capacity:

The Tribunal applied the multiplier method. In the absence of evidence of the injured's earnings, the Tribunal used notified minimum wages under the Minimum Wages Act as the income basis, placing the injured in the unskilled labour category at Rs.2,783/- per month as on 1.2.2003. To account for increases in cost of living and wage rises over time, the Tribunal assumed earnings would have doubled over the course of employment and thus fixed a mean average monthly income of Rs.4,175/-. The Court upheld the Tribunal's adoption of minimum wages and consideration of future increases as consistent with the settled principle that future prospects must be considered (citing K. Narsimha Murthi) (paras 28–31, 46).

The Tribunal used multiplier 18. The Court reviewed the authorities on choice of multiplier, noting that in U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra the Supreme Court identified 18 as the highest multiplier for ages 21–25. Although the injured was 26 at the time of the accident, the Court found multiplier 18 to be fair and reasonable and therefore acceptable (paras 32–34, 49–50).

The Tribunal had accepted a permanent disability of 60% but assessed functional disability at 75% and computed loss on that basis, resulting in Rs.6,73,350/- (computed in the judgment as 4,175 × 12 × 18 × 75%). The Court considered whether the 75% functional disability assessment was correct. Applying the principle that the effect of loss must be judged in light of the nature of the victim's occupation (here an unskilled labourer whose mobility would be seriously hampered), and having regard to a comparable decision (Oriental Insurance v. Vijay Kumar Mittal) where functional disability was assessed at 60% in a similar context, the Court reduced the functional disability assessment to 60% (paras 35–41). On that basis the Court recalculated loss of earning capacity as Rs. 4,175 × 12 × 18 × 60% = Rs.5,41,080 (paras 42–42).

Because the Tribunal had awarded Rs.6,76,350/- under loss of earning capacity, the Court reduced that head by Rs.1,35,270/-. The Court therefore allowed the appeal in part to the extent of this reduction (paras 43–44).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed in part: the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is reduced by a sum of Rs. 1,35,270/-. The Court expressly recorded "No costs" (paras 44–45).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's award of compensation is reduced by Rs.1,35,270/-. (The judgment does not state a recalculated total payable amount in express terms beyond this reduction.)
  • The Court affirmed the general approach and principles applied by the Tribunal in large measure — separate assessment of pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages, use of minimum wages in absence of proof of income, consideration of future prospects, use of multiplier method — while adjusting the percentage of functional disability based on comparative authority.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle; it applies established authorities to the facts and makes a fact-specific adjustment to the award.

Outcome Noted in the Opinion

The appeal is allowed to the extent of reducing the Tribunal's award by Rs. 1,35,270/-. No order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

Pradeep Nandrajog, J.— The appeal under Section 173 of the M.V Act 1988 is directed against the award dated 9.2.2005

2. On 30.11.2003, injured Satish Kumar, sustained serious injuries in a road accident stated to be caused by the rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle belonging to the respondent No. 3, Nand Kishore.

3. Vide award dated 9.2.2005, Tribunal has directed the appellant insurance company to pay compensation of Rs. 10,34,850/- to the injured. Break up of the compensation awarded is as follows:—

(i) Medical reimbursement : Rs. 25,000/- (ii) Pain and suffering : Rs. 1,00,000/- (iii) Permanent disability/loss of amenities : Rs. 2,00,000/- (iv) Loss of earning capacity : Rs. 6,76,350/- (v) Conveyance/attendant charges : Rs. 7,500/- (vi) Future treatment/artificial implant : Rs. 1,000/- (vii) Loss of marriage prospects : Rs. 25,000/- Total : Rs. 10,34,850/-

4. Aggrieved by the amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal, appellant insurance company has filed the present appeal.

5. Since the only issue involved relates to quantum of compensation, I shall only be noting such facts as are relevant for adjudication of said issue.

6. Injured was aged 26 years as on the date of the accident. He was a daily wager.

7. On account of injuries sustained by the injured, his right leg was amputated below the knee. Permanent disability was assessed at 60%.

8. It is an admitted fact that the injured was hospitalized for the period 30.11.2003 to 24.2.2004 in Safdarjung Hospital.

9. In the light of afore noted backdrop facts, I shall determine the ‘fairness’ of the compensation assessed by the Tribunal.

10. The possession of one's own body is the first and most valuable of all human rights and while awarding compensation for bodily injuries this primary element is to be kept in mind. Bodily injury is to be treated as a deprivation which entitles a claimant to damages. The amount of damages varies on account of gravity of bodily injury. Though it is impossible to equate money with human suffering, agony and personal deprivation, the Court and Tribunal should make an honest and serious attempt to award damages so far as money can compensate the loss. Regard must be given to the gravity and degree of deprivation as well as the degree of awareness of the deprivation. Damages awarded in personal injury cases must be substantial and not token damages.

11. The general principle which should govern the assessment of damages in personal injury cases is that the Court should award to injured person such a sum as will put him in the same position as he would have been in if he had not sustained the injuries.

12. Broadly speaking, while fixing an amount of compensation payable to a victim of an accident, the damages have to be assessed separately as pecuniary damages and non pecuniary damages. Pecuniary damages are those which the victim has actually incurred and which is capable of being calculated in terms of money. Whereas, non pecuniary damages are those which are incapable of being assessed by arithmetical calculations.

13. As noted herein above, damages have to be assessed separately as pecuniary damages and non pecuniary damages. In the instant case, Tribunal has awarded Rs. 7,09,850/- under the head ‘pecuniary damages’ and Rs. 3,25,000/- under the head ‘non-pecuniary damages’. I shall deal with each head separately.

Non-pecuniary Damages:

14. Tribunal has awarded Rs. 3,25,000/- under this head. Break-up of the compensation awarded under this head is as follows:—

(i) Pain and suffering : Rs. 1,00,000/- (ii) Permanent disability/Loss of amenities of life : Rs. 2,00,000/- (iii) Loss of marriage prospects : Rs. 25,000/-

15. Learned counsel for the appellant contends that compensation awarded by the Tribunal under this head is excessive. He particularly stresses that award of Rs. 2,00,000/- for permanent disability/loss of amenities of life is excessive.

16. In order to properly appreciate the contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant, I note the following judgments:—

(i) B.N Kumar v. D.T.C, 118 (2005) DLT 36. In said case, injured sustained crush injuries on his right leg leading to its amputation above knee in a road accident on 5th November 1987. He suffered a permanent disability of 85%. Noting various judgments wherein Courts had awarded Rs. 3,00,000/- under the head non-pecuniary damages, a Single Judge of this Court awarded Rs. 75,000/- for ‘pain and suffering’ and Rs. 2,00,000/- for ‘continuing disability suffered by him’. Thus, a total of Rs. 2,75,000/- was awarded under this head.

(ii) Fakkirappa v. Yallawwa & Anr., 2004 ACJ 14 1: In said case, a minor male child sustained grievous injury in a road accident which occurred on 8.5.2000 resulting in amputation of his left leg below knee. Considering the gravity of injury suffered the injured, Division Bench of Karnataka High Court awarded following compensation under the head ‘non-pecuniary damages’:—

(i) Pain and suffering : Rs. 50,000/- (ii) Loss of amenities of life : Rs. 1,00,000/-. (iii) Loss of marriage prospects : Rs. 50,000/-. (iv) Damages for amputation of legbelow knee. : Rs. 1,50,000/-. (v) Loss of expectation of life : Rs. 50,000/-. Total : Rs. 4,00,000/-

(iii) K. Shankar v. Pallavan Transport Corporation, 2001 ACJ 488: In said case, injured sustained serious injuries on his right leg in an accident on 14.2.1989 His right leg was amputated and he suffered permanent disability of 80%. A learned Single Judge of Madras High Court awarded the following compensation under the head ‘non-pecuniary damages’.

(i) For permanent disability : Rs. 80,000/-. (ii) Pain and suffering : Rs. 50,000/-. (iii) Loss of expectation of life and proper marital alliance : Rs. 50,000/-. (iv) For mental agony : Rs, 1,00,000/- Total : Rs. 2,80,000/-

(iv) M. Jaganathan v. Pallavan Transport Corporation, 1999 ACJ 36 6: In said case, injured aged 45 years sustained injuries in an accident on 21.6.1990 The injury sustained by the injured resulted in the amputation of his left leg above the knee. Division Bench of Madras High Court awarded following compensation under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’:—

(i) Pain and suffering : Rs. 1,00,000/- (ii) Compensation for continuing permanent disability. : Rs. 2,00,000/-. (iii) Mental agony, torture and humiliation because of amputation : Rs. 75,000/-. Total : Rs. 3,75,000/-

(v) Bhagwan Singh Meena v. Jai Kishan Tiwari, 1999 ACJ 1200: In said case, the injured sustained severe and serious injuries on account of the road accident. His right leg was amputated. A learned Single Judge of Rajasthan High Court awarded a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- under the head non-pecuniary damages.

(vi) Dr. Gop Ramchandani v. Onkar Singh & Ors., 1993 ACJ 577: In said case, in an accident which had occurred on 17.12.1985, injured sustained injuries because of which his left leg was amputated resulting in 50% permanent disability. A Single Judge of Rajasthan High Court awarded a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’. Break-up of the compensation under the said head is as under:—

(i) Physical and mental agony : Rs. 1,00,000/-. (ii) Permanent disability : Rs. 1,00,000/-. (iii) Loss of social life and loss in profession : Rs. 1,00,000/-. Total : Rs. 3,00,000/-

(vii) Jitendra Singh v. Islam, 1998 ACJ 1301: In said case, in an accident which had occurred on 14.02.1992, injured sustained injuries because of which his left leg was amputated resulting in 55% permanent disability. A Single Judge of Rajasthan High Court awarded a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’.

(viii) Iranna v. Mohammadali Khadarsab Mulla & Anr. 2004 ACJ 1396: In said case, on 19.4.2000, injured aged 7 years met with an accident. Due to the said accident, he sustained grievous injuries resulting in amputation of his left leg below knee. Tribunal awarded following compensation to him under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’:—

(i) Pain and suffering : Rs. 50,000/- (ii) Loss of amenities, happiness, frustration : Rs. 1,00,000/-. (iii) Loss of marriage prospects : Rs. 50,000/-. (iv) Amputation of leg below knee and knee dis-articulation : Rs. 1,50,000/- Total : Rs. 3,50,000/-

17. From the afore noted judicial decisions, a trend which emerges is that between the years 1985 to 1990, Courts have been awarding about Rs. 3,00,000/- under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’ for amputation of leg resulting in permanent disability of 50% and above.

18. In the instant case, Tribunal has awarded Rs. 3,25,000/- under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’. Thus, award of the Tribunal under the head ‘non pecuniary damages’ is just, fair and reasonable.

Pecuniary damages:

19. Tribunal has awarded Rs. 7,09,850/- under the head ‘pecuniary damages’. Learned counsel for the appellant challenges the award under pecuniary damages on two counts. One, compensation of Rs. 25,000/- awarded by the Tribunal for medical expenses is excessive. Two, Tribunal has applied incorrect principles of law while determining compensation to the injured for loss of earning capacity.

20. On the issue of medical expenses, learned counsel contended that injured had placed on record medical bills totaling Rs. 1,744/-. But, counsel stated that Tribunal committed an error by awarding Rs. 25,000/- to the injured for medical expenses.

21. It is relevant to note that compensation in sum of Rs. 1,000/- has been awarded by the Tribunal for future medical expenses.

22. An artificial limb was implanted on his right leg. The same would require replacement every 2 or 3 years.

23. In the decision reported as Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh 2003 ACJ 12, noting that artificial leg implanted on the leg of the injured would have to be changed every two to three years, Supreme Court awarded compensation in sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- to meet the said future expenses.

24. Thus, compensation in sum of Rs. 1,000/- awarded by the Tribunal for future medical expenses is inadequate.

25. Therefore, I find no infirmity in Tribunal awarding Rs. 25,000/- to the injured for medical expenses.

26. Tribunal has awarded Rs. 6,76,350/- to the injured for loss of earning capacity.

27. Tribunal has assessed damages for loss of earning capacity by applying the multiplier method.

28. I note that injured had stated that he was a labourer. In absence of any evidence, documentary or otherwise, to establish the earnings of the injured, Tribunal has rightly determined the income of the injured on the basis of the minimum wages notified under the Minimum Wages Act. Tribunal has placed injured in the category of unskilled labour. Minimum wages for an unskilled labour as on 1.2.2003 were Rs. 2,783/- per month. This figure has been adopted by the Tribunal as the monthly income of the deceased at the time of the accident.

29. Noting that to neutralize increase in cost of living and price index, minimum wages increased from time to time, Tribunal has assumed that earnings of the deceased would have doubled by the time he would have left gainful employment. Thus, mean average income of the deceased has been determined as Rs. 4,175/- per month.

30. It is now well settled that while estimating future loss of income, the court has to take into account future prospects of the injured (See K. Narsimha Murthi v. The Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr., 2004 ACJ 1109). Thus, Tribunal has rightly considered future increase in minimum wage while awarding compensation for loss of earning capacity. I note that minimum wage tend to increase by 100% every 10 years.

31. Increase in minimum wages is not akin to future prospects for the reason inflation eats into the purchasing power of the rupee and to neutralise the falling power of the rupee, wages are increased.

32. Considering that the injured was aged 26 years at the time of the accident, multiplier of 18 has been applied by the Tribunal.

33. In the decision reported as U.P State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra & Ors., (1996) 4 SCC 362, Supreme Court has held that the highest multiplier of 18 has to be applied for the age group of 21 years to 25 years.

34. In the instant case, injured was aged 26 years at the time of the accident. Noting the Trilok Chandra's case (supra), correct multiplier in the instant case is 18. Thus, multiplier of 18 adopted by the Tribunal is fair and reasonable.

35. Admittedly, injured had suffered 60% permanent disability. Tribunal has taken functional disability suffered by the injured as 75%. Thus, total compensation is determined by the Tribunal as Rs. 4,175 × 12 × 18 × 75% = Rs. 6,73,350/-.

36. The question is whether Tribunal is right in assessing functional disability suffered by the appellant as 75%.

37. While estimating future loss of income, the effect of the earning capacity ought to be judged in the light of the importance of the loss of permanently impaired limb in the vocation or profession or employment career of the injured person. The nature of work or business has to be considered and the extent of disablement cannot be indifferent to the nature of the work.

38. In the instant case, injured was working as a labourer. The nature of business of the injured is such that amputation of left leg will seriously hamper his earning capacity as his movement would be restricted.

39. However, in my opinion, functional disability of 75% as assessed by the Tribunal is on the higher side.

40. At this stage, I note decision of this court in MAC. APP. No. 228/2006, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Vijay Kumar Mittal decided on 11.05.2007 In said case, an injured aged 23-24 years sustained grievous injuries in a road accident which occurred on 13.6.2001 resulting of his right leg below knee. Injured was working as a scrap dealer at the time of the accident. Functional disability suffered by the injured was assessed at 60%.

41. Noting the afore-noted decision, functional disability suffered by the injured in the instant case is assessed at 60%.

42. Therefore, loss of earning capacity suffered by the injured comes to Rs. 5,41,080/-. (Rs. 4,175 × 12 × 18 × 60%)

43. Tribunal has awarded compensation in sum of Rs. 6,76,350/- under the head ‘loss of earning capacity’. Thus, compensation under the said head is reduced by a sum of Rs. 1,35,270/-.

44. Appeal is accordingly allowed to the extent that compensation as awarded by the Tribunal is reduced by a sum of Rs. 1,35,270/-.

45. No costs.