- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Haryana State And Another v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court-I And Another
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Kailash Gambhir, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner Management filed a writ petition challenging an award of the Labour Tribunal. The dispute had been referred by the Secretary (Labour), Delhi Administration to the Tribunal framed in the terms: “Whether dismissal of Shri Daya Nand from service is illegal and/or unjustified and if so, to what relief is he entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect?”
The Tribunal framed two issues on the parties' pleadings: (1) Whether the domestic inquiry held by the management is fair and proper? and (2) As in terms of reference. Issue No. (1) was treated as a preliminary issue. Both parties led evidence: the management examined J.P. Sharma (Inquiry Officer) and the workman examined himself and filed an affidavit.
At the stage after the preliminary evidence, the management moved an application seeking permission to adduce evidence on the merits in the event the domestic inquiry was held invalid. The Tribunal reviewed the Inquiry Officer's report and the evidence and concluded that there was serious violation of principles of natural justice: the workman had not been provided a defence representative nor supplied a copy of the report on which charges were framed. The Tribunal found the memorandum of 21.9.84 (offering access to official record) insufficient to satisfy natural justice.
Consequently, the Tribunal held the domestic inquiry vitiated, declared the termination illegal and unjustified, and awarded reinstatement with full back wages to the workman. The management challenged that award in the present writ petition, primarily contending that it was not given the opportunity to adduce evidence on the merits after the inquiry was held vitiated.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal erred in refusing the management's application to lead additional evidence on the merits after treating the validity of the domestic inquiry as a preliminary issue and finding the inquiry vitiated.
- Whether the impugned award should be set aside or remitted to the Tribunal so that the management may be permitted to adduce evidence and the matter be decided on the merits.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Management) — Counsel's Arguments
- The management had moved an application to adduce evidence immediately after arguments on the preliminary issue and before the proceedings concluded, and therefore should have been permitted to lead evidence on the merits if the inquiry was held invalid.
- The impugned order is internally inconsistent/perverse because it simultaneously states that no request was made in the written statement or during proceedings to adduce evidence, and yet records that an application to adduce evidence was moved after hearing the arguments.
- Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Neeta Kaplish v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, X (1998) SLT 52, which in turn referred to Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Ludh Budh Singh (1972) and laid down the propositions under which a Tribunal can permit an employer to adduce evidence.
Respondent (Workman) — Counsel's Arguments
- The application to adduce evidence was moved only after the hearing of arguments, and therefore the Tribunal rightly declined to call upon the management to adduce evidence.
- The management had already produced the Inquiry Officer, J.P. Sharma, in support of its case and could not have led better evidence than his testimony.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Neeta Kaplish v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, X (1998) SLT 52 | The judgment summarised and referred to principles (derived from earlier decisions) governing when an employer may be permitted to adduce evidence before a Tribunal if a domestic inquiry was not conducted or was found defective. These principles include when and how an employer must request permission and the Tribunal's duties in deciding the preliminary issue and, if necessary, hearing evidence on merits. | The Court relied on the clarification in this decision concerning the stage at which an employer may seek to adduce evidence — specifically that such an application can be moved after the Tribunal finally concludes that the domestic inquiry was vitiated. The present court applied that clarification to find the management's application timely and to set aside the Tribunal's refusal. |
| Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Ludh Budh Singh, (1972) 1 SCC 595 : AIR 1972 SC 1031 | The case laid down broad propositions under which a Tribunal can permit the employer to adduce evidence — for example, where no inquiry was held, where the employer does not rely on the inquiry, or where the Tribunal must decide validity of an inquiry as a preliminary issue and then permit evidence on merits if the inquiry is held invalid. | The principles set out in this decision were cited (via Neeta Kaplish) and applied to the facts: the court used these propositions to conclude that the management was entitled to an opportunity to adduce evidence after the Tribunal found the domestic inquiry vitiated. |
| Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co. of India Pvt. Ltd. v. The Management, (1973) 1 SCC 813 : AIR 1973 SC 1227 | The decision adopted the principles discussed in earlier cases (post-introduction of section 11A) and emphasised it is appropriate for the Tribunal to decide as a preliminary issue whether the domestic inquiry violated principles of natural justice; on that decision the management then decides whether to adduce evidence before the Tribunal. | The court noted this decision's observation that the Labour Court should first decide the preliminary issue as to the validity of the domestic inquiry. The present court applied that reasoning to hold that the Tribunal should have permitted evidence once it found the inquiry invalid. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first rehearsed the sequence of proceedings before the Tribunal: the framing and trial of the preliminary issue as to the fairness and propriety of the domestic inquiry, the evidence adduced by both sides, and the management's application seeking permission to adduce further evidence on merits in the event the inquiry was held invalid.
The Tribunal had found that the inquiry violated principles of natural justice (no defence representative and no supply of the report upon which charges were based) and consequently held the inquiry vitiated and awarded reinstatement with full back wages.
The court then examined the authorities relied on by the parties. It relied principally on the Supreme Court's exposition (as cited in Neeta Kaplish and the earlier Delhi Cloth line of authorities) which sets out seven propositions describing when and how an employer may adduce evidence before a Tribunal:
- Where no domestic inquiry was held or where the employer disavows reliance on it, the employer can adduce evidence directly before the Tribunal.
- Where an inquiry was held, the employer may either rely on it or simultaneously adduce additional evidence; the Tribunal must first consider validity of the inquiry.
- If the Tribunal holds the inquiry invalid, it derives jurisdiction to consider the merits and must consider any evidence adduced by the employer.
- The employer must make a suitable request for opportunity to adduce evidence while proceedings are pending and before they conclude.
Applying these principles, the court found that the management had made the application to adduce evidence immediately after the arguments on the preliminary issue (i.e., while proceedings were still pending) and therefore at a stage contemplated by the cited Supreme Court authority. The respondent's contention that the application was made only after hearing of arguments and therefore rightly rejected was not persuasive in the view of the court, because the Supreme Court had clarified that such an application can be moved after the Tribunal finally comes to the conclusion that the domestic inquiry was vitiated.
On that basis the court concluded that the Tribunal ought to have granted the management an opportunity to lead evidence on the merits once it found the inquiry invalid, and that refusal amounted to error requiring interference.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The impugned order dated 20.5.99 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Tribunal with directions that the petitioner management be given an opportunity to lead evidence as prayed in its application. After hearing both parties on the merits, the Tribunal is to decide the matter expeditiously in accordance with law.
Direct consequences implemented by the court's order:
- The impugned Tribunal order (dated 20.5.99) was set aside.
- The case was remanded to the Tribunal with a direction to permit the management to adduce evidence and to hear both parties on the merits.
- The parties were directed to appear before the Tribunal on 19.2.2007.
- The writ petition was disposed of; parties were left to bear their own costs; the rule was made absolute.
The opinion does not purport to lay down new legal precedent; it applied existing Supreme Court principles (as summarised in the cited authorities) to the facts and remitted the matter for further proceedings in accordance with those principles.
Kailash Gambhir, J. (Oral)— Feeling aggrieved with the impugned award the petitioner Management has filed the present writ petition. The main grievance of the petitioner in the present writ petition is that the petitioner was not given any opportunity to lead evidence on merits after the domestic inquiry was held as vitiated. The brief facts of the case germane to the controversy raised are that the Secretary (Labour), Delhi Administration, referred the dispute for its adjudication to the Tribunal as per the following terms:
“Whether dismissal of Shri Daya Nand from service is illegal and/or unjustified and if so, to what relief is he entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect?”
On the pleadings of the parties the issues were framed as under:
“1. Whether the domestic inquiry held by the management is fair and proper?
2. As in terms of reference.”
2. The Issue Number (1) was treated as a preliminary issue and both the parties led their respective evidence before the Tribunal. The management petitioner had examined Sh. J.P Sharma, Inquiry Officer while the respondent workman examined himself and filed an affidavit in evidence. At that very stage, the petitioner management had filed an application that they may be permitted to lead evidence on merits of the charge in the event of the inquiry held to be invalid or defective in any way. The Tribunal after having gone through the report of the Inquiry Officer and the evidence adduced by the respective parties came to the conclusion that there was serious violation of principles of natural justice as the delinquent officer/workman was not provided with any defence representative as well as he was not supplied copy of the report on the basis of which charges were framed against him. The Tribunal did not feel satisfied with the Memorandum dated 21.9.84 in which it was mentioned that the delinquent official could have access to the official record if he so wished and held that such a course would not satisfy the principles of natural justice.
3. The Tribunal, therefore, held that the inquiry proceedings and the enquiry report had been vitiated and consequently passed the award holding the termination of the respondent/workman as illegal, unjustified and consequently held that the workman is entitled to reinstatement with full back wages.
4. Counsel for the petitioner says that although the petitioner management moved an application for adducing evidence just at the stage after the arguments on the preliminary issue but still the Tribunal declined the request of the petitioner management. Counsel for the petitioner further contends that the order of the Tribunal is perverse as on the one hand the Tribunal has observed that no request has been made by the petitioner management either in the written statement or by moving any specific application during the course of proceedings to adduce evidence in support of the charges while on the other hand has also held that petitioner management has moved an application to adduce evidence after hearing the arguments. Counsel for the petitioner says that the said contradiction in the impugned order itself shows complete non-application of mind on the part of the Tribunal. In support of his arguments Counsel for the petitioner management has relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Neeta Kaplish v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, X (1998) SLT 52. In the said judgment the Supreme Court has referred the judgment in the case of Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Ludh Budh Singh, (1972) 1 SCC 595 : AIR 1972 SC 1031, wherein the Supreme Court has broadly laid down the prepositions under which the Tribunal can permit the employer management to adduce evidence. The Supreme Court held as under:
“…………….Where no inquiry was conducted by an employer or the inquiry itself was found to be defective, the employer shall have to be given a chance to adduce evidence before the Tribunal for justifying his action provided the employer asks for the permission of the Tribunal to adduce fresh evidence to justify its action. Such request has to be made ‘while the proceedings are pending’ and not after the proceedings had come to an end. The following prepositions were laid down—
(1) If no domestic inquiry had been held by the management, or if the management makes it clear that it does not rely upon any domestic inquiry that may have been held by it, it is entitled to straightaway adduce evidence before the Tribunal justifying its action. The Tribunal is bound to consider that evidence so adduced before it on merits, and give a decision thereon. In such a case, it is not necessary for the Tribunal to consider the validity of the domestic inquiry as the employer himself does not rely on it.
(2) If a domestic inquiry had been held, it is open to the management to rely upon the domestic inquiry held by it in the first instance, and alternatively and without prejudice to its plea that the inquiry is proper and binding, simultaneously adduce additional evidence before the Tribunal justifying its action. In such a case no inference can be drawn, without anything more, that the management has given up the inquiry conducted by it.
(3) When the management relies on the enquiry conducted by it, and also simultaneously adduces evidence before the Tribunal, without prejudice to its plea that the enquiry proceedings are proper, it is the duty of the Tribunal, in the first instance to consider whether the inquiry proceedings conducted by the management are valid and proper. If the Tribunal is satisfied that the inquiry proceedings have been held properly and are valid, the question of considering the evidence adduced before it on merits no long survives. It is only when the Tribunal holds that the inquiry proceedings have not been property held, that it derives jurisdiction to deal with the merits of the dispute and in such a case it has to consider the evidence adduced before it by the management and decide the matter on the basis of such evidence.
(4) When a domestic inquiry has been held by the management and the management relies on the same, it is open to the latter to request the Tribunal to try the validity of the domestic inquiry as a preliminary issue and also ask for an opportunity to adduce evidence before the Tribunal, if the finding on the preliminary issue is against the management. However, elaborate and cumbersome the procedure may be under such circumstances, it is open to the Tribunal to deal with, in the first instance, as a preliminary issue, the validity of the domestic inquiry. If its finding on the preliminary issue is in favour of the management, then no additional evidence need be cited by the management. But if the finding on the preliminary issue is against the management, the Tribunal will have to give the employer an opportunity to cite additional evidence and also give a similar opportunity to the employee to lead evidence contra, as the request to adduce evidence had been made by the management to the Tribunal during the course of the proceedings and before the trial has come to an end. When the preliminary issue is decided against the management and the latter leads evidence before the Tribunal, the position, under such circumstances, will be that the management is deprived of the benefit of having the finding of the domestic Tribunal being accepted as prima facie proof of the alleged misconduct. On the other hand, the management will have to prove, by adducing proper evidence, that the workman is guilty of misconduct and that the action taken by it is proper. It will not be just and fair either to the management or to the workman that the Tribunal should refuse to take evidence and thereby ask the management to make a further application, after holding a proper inquiry, and deprive the workman of the benefit of the Tribunal itself being satisfied, on evidence adduced before it, that he was not guilty of the alleged misconduct.
(5) The management has got a right to attempt to sustain its order by adducing independent evidence before the Tribunal. But the management should avail itself of the said opportunity by making a suitable request to the Tribunal before the proceedings are closed. If no such opportunity has been availed of, or asked for by the management, before the proceedings are closed, the employer can make no grievance that the Tribunal did not provide such an opportunity. The Tribunal will have before it only the inquiry proceedings and it has to decide whether the proceedings have been held properly and the findings recorded therein are also proper.
(6) If the employer relies only on the domestic inquiry and does not simultaneously lead additional evidence or ask for an opportunity during the pendency of the proceedings to adduce such evidence, the duty of the Tribunal is only to consider the validity of the domestic inquiry as well as the finding recorded therein and decide the matter. If the Tribunal decides that the domestic enquiry has not been held properly, it is not its function to invite suo motu the employer to adduce evidence before it to justify the action taken by it.
(7) The above principles apply to the proceedings before the Tribunal, which have come before it either on a reference under Section 10 or by way of an application under Section 33 of the Act.”
These principles were adopted in the workmen or Firestore Tyre & Rubber Co. of India Pvt. Ltd. v. The Management, 1973 (1) LLJ 278 : AIR 1973 SC 1227 : 1973 (3) SCR 587 : (1973) 1 SCC 813, which was decided after the introduction of section 11a in the act. The Court observed—
“In our considered opinion it will be most unnatural and unpractical to expect a party to take a definite stand when a decision of jurisdictional fact has first to be reached by the Labour Court prior to embarking upon an inquiry to decide the dispute on its merits. The reference involves determination of the larger issue of discharge or dismissal and not merely whether a correct procedure had been followed by the management before passing the order of dismissal.”
The Court further observed:
“We are, therefore, clearly of opinion that when a case of dismissal or discharge of an employee is referred for industrial adjudication, the Labour Court should first decide as preliminary issue; whether the domestic inquiry has violated the principles of natural justice. When there is no domestic inquiry or defective inquiry is admitted by the employer, there will be no difficulty. But when the matter is in controversy between the parties, that question must be decided as a preliminary issue. On that decision being pronounced, it will for the management to decide whether it will adduce any evidence before the Labour Court if it chooses not to adduce any evidence, it will not be thereafter permissible in any proceeding to raise the issue.
This decision makes it clear that the ‘stage’ at which the employer has to ask for an opportunity to adduce evidence for justifying its action is the stage when the Tribunal finally comes to the conclusion that domestic inquiry was invalid.”
5. On the other hand Counsel for the respondent has contended that the application was moved by the petitioner after the hearing of the arguments and therefore, the Tribunal rightly did not call upon the petitioner management to adduce the evidence. Counsel for the respondent has further contended that the management petitioner had already produced the Inquiry Officer Mr. J.P Sharma in support of its case and the management petitioner could not have led any better evidence than that of him.
6. I do not find any force in the contention of the Counsel for the respondent. Moreover, the Supreme Court in the judgment referred above has already clarified the ‘stage’ at which an employer management can ask for an opportunity to adduce evidence so as to justify its action. The Supreme Court has held that such an application can be moved after the Tribunal finally comes to the conclusion that the domestic inquiry was vitiated.
7. In the present case the petitioner moved an application just after the arguments were heard on the preliminary issue and therefore, going by the said decision of the Supreme Court, the Tribunal ought to have granted opportunity to the petitioner management to adduce evidence after the Tribunal found that the domestic inquiry was illegal and invalid.
8. The impugned order dated 20.5.99 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the Tribunal with the directions that petitioner management be given opportunity to lead evidence as prayed by it in the application and after hearing both the parties on merits the matter be decided expeditiously in accordance with law.
9. The parties are directed to appear before the Tribunal on 19.2.2007
10. With these directions, writ petition is disposed of. Parties are left to bear their own cost.
11. Rule is made absolute.
Writ Petition disposed of.
Alert