- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lalit Goel v. Commissioner Of Central Excise
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns the second bail application filed by the applicant under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.) for an offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962. The applicant was accused of diverting non-edible crude palm oil, imported at concessional duty for manufacturing washing soap, to the market for use by ghee manufacturers, thereby evading customs duty exceeding Rs. 1.25 crore. The applicant initially filed a compounding application and was in custody for about seven months. Investigation was complete, a complaint filed, and some witnesses examined. The applicant sought bail relying on a Supreme Court order in Avinash Bhosale v. Union of India and Anr, which held the offence under amended Section 135(1)(ii) to be bailable. The prosecution opposed bail, contending the offence was non-bailable under the unamended provisions applicable to the applicant’s case. The Court had earlier dismissed the applicant’s bail application and had taken the view that the offence was non-bailable. Subsequently, the Chief Commissioner passed an order allowing compounding of the offence subject to payment of a compounding fee of over Rs. 2.12 crore. The applicant refused to pay the compounding fee but applied for bail again.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962, as applicable to the applicant, is a bailable offence.
- Whether the Supreme Court’s decision in Avinash Bhosale, which held the offence under amended Section 135(1)(ii) to be bailable, applies to the facts of the present case under unamended provisions.
- The conditions under which bail may be granted in cases involving compounding of offences under the Customs Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The offence committed is bailable in light of the Supreme Court’s order in Avinash Bhosale, which held the offence under amended Section 135(1)(ii) to be bailable.
- The Punjab and Haryana High Court and this Court in previous cases have held the offence to be bailable or compoundable.
- The applicant has already filed a compounding application, demonstrating bona fide intent, and the prosecution may withdraw the case.
- The applicant has been in custody for seven months, the investigation is complete, and evidence is documentary, reducing risk of tampering.
- The applicant should be released to arrange funds to pay the compounding fee.
Prosecution's Arguments
- The Supreme Court’s order in Avinash Bhosale pertains to the amended Section 135(1)(ii) and is not applicable to the applicant’s case under unamended provisions.
- The Supreme Court’s decision was per incuriam and was not aware of prior conflicting judgments including a stay on the Mumbai High Court’s order holding the offence bailable.
- Several High Courts, including this Court in prior judgments, have held the offence to be non-bailable.
- The issue of bail under Section 135(1)(ii) is sub-judice before the Supreme Court in Criminal Appeal No. 189/2006.
- This Court had earlier dismissed the applicant’s bail application and reaffirmed the offence as non-bailable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Avinash Bhosale v. Union of India and Anr (Criminal Appeal No. 1138/07) | Held offence under amended Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act is bailable. | Applicant relied on this to argue offence is bailable; Court distinguished it as inapplicable due to unamended provisions in applicant’s case. |
| Kulbhushan Goyal v. Joint Commissioner of Customs (Punjab and Haryana High Court) | Held offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act is bailable. | Applicant cited this in support; Court noted but did not find it binding. |
| Sita Ram v. Customs | Granted bail on ground offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was made compoundable. | Applicant cited as precedent for bail; Court acknowledged but emphasized different factual and legal context. |
| A.R. Antuley v. R.S. Nayak | Principle that decisions per incuriam may be ignored. | Prosecution invoked to contend Avinash Bhosale decision was per incuriam. |
| West Bengal v. Tarun K. Roy | Similar principle on per incuriam decisions. | Prosecution cited to support argument that Avinash Bhosale should be disregarded. |
| Subhash Chaudhary v. Deepak Jyala and Ors (2004(64) RLT 651 (Bom)) | Mumbai High Court held offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act was bailable. | Matter stayed by Supreme Court; Court noted this and took a contrary view. |
| Mohan Lal Thapar v. Y.P. Dabara (2002(1) JCC 460) | Held offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was non-bailable. | Relied on by this Court to hold offence non-bailable. |
| Inderjeet Nagpal v. Director of Revenue Intelligence (ILR(2005) I Delhi 296) | Held offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was non-bailable. | Relied on by this Court in its prior decisions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the applicability of the Supreme Court’s decision in Avinash Bhosale, which held the offence under amended Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act to be bailable. It distinguished that the applicant’s case arose under the unamended provisions, and the Supreme Court’s order was based on material not present in the applicant’s case. The Court noted that the Supreme Court had stayed the Mumbai High Court’s order holding the offence bailable, thereby indicating the issue remains sub-judice. The Court relied on its prior judgments and those of other High Courts holding the offence as non-bailable. The Court also considered the applicant’s filing of a compounding application and the Chief Commissioner’s order allowing compounding subject to payment of a substantial fee. Balancing the facts that the applicant was in custody for seven months, the investigation was complete, and the offence involved white-collar crime causing significant loss to the public exchequer, the Court concluded that bail could only be granted on condition of depositing 50% of the compounding fee. This amount would be refunded if the applicant was found not guilty or adjusted against duty and penalties if found guilty. The Court imposed the condition of furnishing a personal bond with surety for bail release.
Holding and Implications
The bail application is allowed conditionally. The applicant is granted bail on the condition that he deposits 50% of the compounding fee as ordered by the Chief Commissioner of Central Excise and furnishes a personal bond of Rs. One lac with one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the Trial Court.
The bail is granted without prejudice to the rights of the applicant and subject to adjustment or refund of the deposited amount depending on the trial's outcome. The Court reaffirmed its earlier position that the offence under unamended Section 135(1)(ii) is non-bailable, and the Supreme Court’s decision in Avinash Bhosale does not apply to the present facts. The decision does not set a new precedent but resolves the applicant’s bail application on specific conditions balancing the interests of justice and the applicant’s rights.
1. This second application for bail has been filed by the applicant under Section 439 Cr.P.C. on the ground that the offence committed by the applicant is a bailable offence in view of the latest order of Supreme Court in Avinash Bhosale v. Union of India and Anr. in Criminal Appeal No. 1138/07 arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 4421/07 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court granted bail on the ground that the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was bailable. The order of the Supreme Court reads as under:
On the material placed on record, and the amended Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962 it appears to us that apparently the offence which is alleged to have been committed is a bailable offence and thus the Magistrate has rightly granted bail to the Appellant. In view of this, the order of the High Court is set aside.
2. It is also stated that Punjab and Haryana High Court in its order dated 6th March, 2006 in case of Kulbhushan Goyal v. Joint Commissioner of Customs in Crl. Misc. No. 71789-M/05 also held that offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act, 1962 is a bailable offence. This Court in Sita Ram v. Customs granted bail to the applicant on the ground that the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was made compoundable. It is stated that applicant has already filed a compounding application dated 14th August, 2007 as a result of which the prosecution itself may be ordered to be withdrawn by the Chief Commissioner. The scheme of compounding has been formulated by the Government keeping in view the reformative penal jurisprudence. The applicant was required to arrange appropriate funds for compounding fee and for this purpose the applicnat should be out of custody. Filing of compounding application shows bonafide of the applicant. It is submitted that investigation in this case has been completed and after completion of investigation, a complaint has already been filed with ACMM, New Delhi. 04 witnesses out of total 82 witnesses have already been examined and examination of remaining witnesses will be a long drawn process. Applicant was in custody for about 07 months, the maximum sentence was 03 years. The entire evidence was record based and there was no possibility of tampering with the record.
3. In reply to the application, it is stated that the order of the Supreme Court cited by the applicant would not apply to facts and circumstances of the present case. The order pertains to amended Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act, 1962 and was passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on the basis of material placed before it while case of applicant was under unamended provisions. It is further submitted that order of Supreme Court in Avinash Bhosale's case was per incuriam. It was not brought to the notice of the Supreme Court. Hon'ble Supreme Court had already stayed the order of Mumbai High Court holding that the offence was bailable, in Criminal Appeal No. 189/2006. It was stated that in view of the judgment of Supreme Court in A.R. Antuley v. R.S. Nayak , if the decision is per incuriam, the Court should ignore it. Similar observation was made by Supreme Court in West Bengal v. Tarun K. Roy . The Supreme Court has yet to decide the issue if the offence was bailable or not in Criminal Appeal No. 189/2006. It is further pointed out that for the first time Mumbai High Court in case of Subhash Chaudhary v. Deepak Jyala and Ors. 2004(64) RLT 651 (Bom) had held that offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act was bailable. The matter was agitated in Supreme Court by Union of India and the judgment of Mumbai High Court was stayed vide above Criminal Appeal. It is also submitted that this Court has already taken a different view and held that offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act was non-bailable. View of this Court was not brought to the notice of Mumbai High Court in Subhash Choudhary's case. This Court had held similar view in other two cases viz. Mohan Lal Thapar v. Y.P. Dabara 2002(1) JCC 460 and Inderjeet Nagpal v. Director of Revenue Intelligence ILR(2005) I Delhi 296. It is submitted that whether the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act 1962 was bailable or not is sub-judiced and no final decision has been given by Supreme Court after considering the judgments of various High Courts Delhi High Court has consistently held that offence was not bailable.
4. While dismissing the earlier application of the applicant vide its order dated 23rd July, 2007 under Section 439 Cr.P.C. this Court had categorically observed that the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) was not a bailable offence. This Court in Inderjit Nagpal's case had also laid down that the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act was a non-bailable offence, relying on Mohan Lal Thapar's case I find no reason to differ from the view taken by this Court earlier in three cases. In view of the fact that the SLP against the Mumbai High Court is pending and the decision of the Mumbai High Court holding that the offence is bailable has been stayed by Supreme Court and the order relied upon by the applicant was passed solely on the facts and the circumstances of the case, I consider that this Court cannot take a different view from what it has been already taken. The petitioner was at liberty to approach Supreme Court if he so desired against the order dated 23rd July, 2007 of this Court. The petitioner did not approach the Supreme Court.
5. Considering the merits of the case, the petitioner made an application for compounding of the offence. Order for compounding of offence was passed by Chief Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax Delhi Zone. The order reads as under:
DECISION Shri Lalit Goyal is allowed to compound the offence punishable under Section 132, 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, 1962 and Section 9(1)(C) of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and is granted immunity from prosecution under Rule 6 of the said Compounding Rules, 2005, subject to the acceptance of this order by the Hon'ble Court of ACMM, Patiala House, New Delhi, by paying the amount as mentioned below within 30 days of receiving this order:
The total amount in terms of Rule '5' of the said Custom and Central Excise Compounding Rules, 2005, comes to the tune of Rs.2,12,19,944/- (Rupees two crore twelve lac ninetten thousand nine hundred forty four only). Shri Lalit Goyal will also produce proof of having paid the compounding amount in the treasury, to the reporting authority i.e. the Commissioner, Central Excise, Delhi-I within 07 days of the depositing the above amount. This order is only with respect to the actions under the particular Sections of Customs Act, 1962 and Central Excise 1944 and is without prejudice to any other actions that may be taken against Shri Lalit Goyal.
Sd/-
Chief Commissioner C. Ex. And S.T (DZ) The counsel for the applicant submitted that petitioner did stupidity in filing the compounding application. The applicant was not obliged to compound the offence and pay the hefty compounding fee as asked by the Chief Commissioner.
6. Reverting to the facts the petitioner floated a proprietorship firm in the name of Pioneer Soap and Chemicals and obtained a Central Excise Registration Number for manufacturing of washing soap. He applied for import of non-edible crude palm oil used for manufacturing of washing soap, which was granted by the concerned authorities. The import of crude palm oil for manufacturing of washing soap is allowed at concessional duty of 20% as against the normal duty of 65%. Applicant availed this concessional duty and imported palm oil. It was found that applicant did not manufacture washing soap but diverted the entire palm oil to the market and sold the same to the ghee manufacturers of UP and Haryana. The statement of witnesses recorded showed that the consignments were directly diverted to ghee manufacturers. The applicant also fabricated records and entries in order to avail the advantage of concessional duty. He also undervalued the consignment. The total evasion of custom duty was more than Rs.1.25 Crore.
7. It is obvious that applicant indulged in white collar crime diverting non edible palm oil to the ghee manufacturers for use into the ghee, which is consumed by the common people. He obtained license for concessional import of crude palm oil by misrepresentation that it would be used for manufacture of washing soap, depriving the public exchequer of import duty of more than Rs. one crore. The applicant, first made an application for compounding of the offence, then flatly refused to compound the offence and refused to pay the amount. The counsel for the petitioner described act of making compounding application as a stupidity of the applicant.
8. Considering all these facts and the fact that the applicant is in jail and the trial may take some time the applicant is granted bail if the applicant deposits 50% of the amount levied as compounding fee as specified in above-produced order in para 05, with the Chief Commissioner of Central Excise without prejudice to the rights of the applicant. The applicant, if it is found after the trial, had not committed any offence shall be returned back this amount. If the evasion of duty is found, the amount shall be adjusted against duty payable and penalties levied as per law.
9. In case the applicant deposits the amount as indicated above, he be released on bail on his executing personal bond in the sum of Rs. One lac with one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the Trial Court concerned.
The application stands disposed of. dusty, if desired.
Alert