Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.R Khanna v. Union Of India & Ors.

Delhi High Court
Sep 13, 2006
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged proceedings initiated by the ESI Corporation and Recovery Officer for recovery of dues from M/s. Black Eye Detection and Security Services Private Limited ("the Company"), where the petitioner was a Director and his son was the Managing Director. The Company failed to deposit ESI contributions for the period April 1995 to June 1997 despite notices and orders demanding payment with interest. Recovery proceedings were initiated against the Company and its Directors, including the petitioner. The petitioner resigned as Director in June 1997, with resignation accepted on 1.10.1997. Notices and arrest warrants were issued against the petitioner when payments were not made. The petitioner filed a suit for permanent injunction in ESI Court in January 1999, which was dismissed in 2004. Meanwhile, the petitioner filed this writ petition in December 2003 praying for quashing the recovery proceedings against him, stay of arrest and recovery, and compensation for mental agony and harassment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, as a Director of a Private Limited Company, can be held liable as a principal employer under the ESI Act for non-payment of ESI contributions deducted from employees' salaries.
  2. Whether recovery proceedings and arrest warrants issued against the petitioner were illegal and without jurisdiction, given his resignation and alleged non-involvement in the Company's affairs.
  3. Whether the corporate veil can be lifted to hold the petitioner and his son jointly and severally liable for the dues under the ESI Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner resigned as Director in June 1997, and his resignation was accepted on 1.10.1997, thus he was not liable for dues thereafter.
  • The Managing Director, petitioner’s son Mr. Ramesh Khanna, was the principal employer liable for payment of ESI contributions.
  • Recovery proceedings, notices, attachment of property, and arrest warrants against the petitioner were illegal and without jurisdiction.
  • The petitioner had appeared before the Recovery Officer and explained his situation; he was detained and released only after depositing Rs. 20,000/-.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Directors changed designations to evade liability; the ESI Act is a social beneficial legislation protecting employees.
  • Directors, including the petitioner, were responsible for deducting ESI contributions but failed to deposit them, constituting an offence under Section 85-A of the ESI Act and Sections 406-407 IPC.
  • The petitioner, as a Director of a Private Limited Company, was a principal employer and liable for payment of dues.
  • The resignation letters were fabricated; the company was a family concern and the petitioner and his son controlled it.
  • Recovery proceedings, including arrest and detention, were lawful under the provisions of the ESI Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kapila Hingorani v. State of Bihar, 2003-III-LLJ 31 Doctrine of lifting the corporate veil to identify persons liable where corporate entity is abused. The Court applied this principle to hold the petitioner and his son liable as principal employers despite corporate structure.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Renusagar Power Company, AIR 1988 SC 1737 Expanding doctrine of lifting the corporate veil when used for unjust or inequitable purposes. Supported the Court's approach to pierce the corporate veil in the present case for recovery of dues.
Industrial Salomon v. Salomon and Co., 1897 AC 22 Corporate personality is distinct from shareholders but doctrine can be revisited in certain circumstances. Referenced to explain the general principle, but Court emphasized exceptions in social welfare contexts.
Dal Chand v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Punjab, (1944) 12 ITR 458 Application of lifting corporate veil in revenue and taxation matters. Supported the Court’s reasoning on piercing corporate veil to hold individuals liable.
Juggilal Kamlapati v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1970 SC 529 Further authority on lifting corporate veil in taxation context. Reinforced the principle applied by the Court in the instant case.
CIT Madras v. Meenakshi Mills Ltd., 1967 SCR 934 Corporate veil can be pierced when opposed to justice, revenue interest or public interest. Used to justify holding directors liable to protect employees’ interests.
Workmen Employed in Associated Rubber Industry Ltd. v. Bhavnagar, AIR 1986 SC 1 Doctrine of lifting corporate veil to protect workmen’s rights. Supported social welfare objective of ESI Act and directors’ liability.
New Horizons Ltd. v. Union of India, (1995) 1 SCC 478 Corporate veil can be lifted to prevent misuse of corporate form. Applied to hold directors accountable for ESI dues.
Hussainbhai Calicut v. Alath Factory Thozhilai Union, AIR 1978 SC 1410 Corporate veil lifted in cases affecting workers’ interests. Referenced to emphasize protection of employees under social welfare legislation.
Secretary, HSEB v. Suresh, AIR 1999 SC 1160 Doctrine of piercing corporate veil for justice and public interest. Supported Court’s interpretation to hold directors liable for statutory dues.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts and found that the Company was a family-run Private Limited Company with the petitioner and his son as Directors living under the same roof. The petitioner’s son, the Managing Director, was untraceable and the petitioner failed to disclose his address despite Court’s request, indicating an attempt to evade responsibility. The Court applied the doctrine of lifting the corporate veil, relying on established precedents, to hold both the petitioner and his son jointly and severally liable as principal employers for the non-payment of ESI contributions deducted from employees’ salaries. The Court rejected the petitioner’s argument that resignation relieved him of liability, noting that resignation was accepted only after the period of default and that the petitioner never denied responsibility before the Recovery Officer. The Court emphasized the social welfare nature of the ESI Act and the necessity to interpret its provisions to protect employees’ rights and prevent unjust enrichment of company directors at the expense of poor employees. Consequently, recovery proceedings against the petitioner were held to be legal and justified.

Holding and Implications

Writ petition dismissed.

The Court upheld the legality of the recovery proceedings against the petitioner, holding him liable jointly and severally with his son for ESI dues. This decision reinforces the principle that directors of a Private Limited Company, especially in closely held family companies, cannot evade liability for statutory dues by hiding behind the corporate veil or resignation after the period of default. The ruling underscores the social welfare objective of the ESI Act and affirms that directors must be held accountable to protect the interests of employees. No new precedent was created beyond the application of established principles to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Shiv Narayan Dhingra, J.— By this petition petitioner has prayed that the proceedings initiated by ESI Corporation and Recovery Officer under ESI Act for recovery of the amount due to the corporation from M/s. Black Eye Detection and Security Services Private Limited (for short the ‘Company’) be quashed and directions be given to ESI Corporation to do recovery from the principal employer and stay the arrest (and recovery proceedings) of the petitioner and award compensation of Rs. 20 lakh to the petitioner for causing mental agony, harassment.

2. Briefly, the facts are that the Company was incorporated as a Private Limited Company by family members of the petitioner. In this company petitioner was one of the Directors and his son Ramesh Khanna was the Managing Director. The Company was engaged in employing security guards and detectives and these security guards were deployed as per requirement of their clients. The Company was covered under the ESI Act. However, company failed to deposit the dues of ESI for the period April 1995 to June 1997. A notice was sent to the Company on 8th July, 1997 asking the Company that contribution of the employees towards ESI be deposited and challan of deposit be sent to the Division Officer of the Corporation within 15 days. Company was informed vide this notice that in case payment of contribution is not made, interest @ 12% per annum shall be liable to be paid. Despite the notice no payment of ESI contribution was made. An order under Section 45-A was passed by the Assistant Regional Director wherein it was stated that Mr. S.S Sharma, Manager, attended the office for personal hearing on 28.7.1997 and informed that he has deposited contribution from January 1997 to August 1997 only against the demand of the contribution from April 1996 to June 1997 for a sum of Rs. 4,28,278/-. The Assistant Regional Director considered the record and found that employer had not deposited regular ESI contribution from March 1993 to March 1997. The balance contribution payable for period April 1993 to March 1997 was finally determined as Rs. 3,74,220/-. An order was passed for payment of this contribution with interest @ 15% for each day of default up to the date of payment within a period of 15 days. The order was passed against Mr. Ramesh Khanna, Managing Director. Despite passing this order no amount was deposited. Thereafter Recovery Officer was directed by the Assistant Regional Director to effect the recovery of the due amount. A letter was written by ESI to Recovery Officer on 8.9.1997 for recovery of the dues for the period April 1995 to March 1997 amounting to Rs. 3,74,220/- plus interest of Rs. 73,619/-. In this letter written to the Recovery Officer, Mr. Ramesh Khanna was shown as the principal employer. Still no recovery could be made from this Company and thereafter notice were sent to other two Directors in February 1998 namely Mr. M.R Khanna and Mr. Ashok Verma for attending the office and payment of the dues. When show-cause notice was sent by the Recovery Officer to Mr. M.R Khanna and Mr. Ashok Verma, Mr. M.R Khanna wrote a letter to recovery officer on 15.12.1998 depicting that due to unavoidable circumstances such as payment of income tax, house tax and renovations of house, he could not pay monthly installment; the Managing Director was responsible for all liability of the Company, he (Mr. M.R Khanna) would however pay the instalment in first week of January 1999. One Mr. Satya Kam Saini was authorized by Mr. M.R Khanna to appear on his behalf before the Recovery Officer. Mr. S.K Saini, Advocate sought some time from Recovery Officer to deposit the due amount and he wrote to the Recovery Officer that as per the record of the Company the liability was of Rs. 85,000/- for the period from April 1995 to March 1997 and an amount of Rs. 53,000/- has already been deposited and another amount of Rs. 10,000/- was being deposited. He sought two months time to settle the dispute and deposit the due amount. Thereafter, again no amount was deposited and the interest on dues kept on mounting. The total amount recoverable in 1998 was Rs. 4,47,859/-. When the amount was not paid by any of the Directors and none of the Directors were available, warrant of arrest were issued by the Recovery Officer. Petitioner filed a suit for permanent injunction before ESI Court challenging the recovery in the January 1999 only when respondent Nos. 3 and 4 threatened the attachment of the house and bank accounts of the petitioner to affect the recovery. ESI Court asked the petitioner to deposit the 50% of the amount on an application for interim relief. Assurances were given to the ESI Court time and again for deposit of this amount but this amount was not deposited. On 11.11.1999 ESI Court further extended time for deposit of 50% of the amount within seven days. The petitioner availed interim injunction without depositing the amount. On 6.9.2000 Counsel for the petitioner assured the Court that 50% of the amount shall be deposited before the next hearing. The Court directed that in case 50% amount was not deposited till the next hearing, the interim order shall be vacated. Till 30.10.2000 petitioner did not deposit this amount, when the Court vacated the interim stay observing that the petitioner has misused the discretion exercised by the Court in his favour and ordered that respondent was at liberty to take action for recovery. The suit of the petitioner was dismissed by the ESI Court vide order dated 20.9.2004 In the meantime petitioner filed this writ petition in December 2003 with the above prayer.

3. It is submitted that petitioner had resigned from the post of Directorship in June 1997. His resignation was accepted by the Company on 1.10.1997 The plea of the petitioner is that respondent No. 3 had passed the order for recovery of due amount against the principal employer and it was the principal employer who was liable for the payment of the amount. Principal employer in this case was Managing Director of the company namely Mr. Ramesh Khanna. He was solely responsible for the payment of contribution and the petitioner had nothing to do with the affairs of the Company. The resignation of the petitioner and other Directors i.e Mr. M.R Khanna and Mr. Ashok Verma, had been accepted with effect from 1.10.1997 by Mr. Ramesh Khanna as Managing Director of the Company. Petitioner was, therefore, not at all concerned with the Company and no recovery be made from the petitioner. The order of the recovery and notice being sent to the petitioner and the proceedings initiated against the petitioner for attachment of the property and bank accounts and issuance of warrants were illegal and without jurisdiction. Petitioner had appeared before the Recovery Officer and informed him about the situation and respondent No. 4 detained the petitioner and he was released only when he deposited Rs. 20,000/-.

4. In the counter affidavit it is stated by the respondent that the Directors of the Company were changing designation for their convenience to escape the liability. ESI Act was a social beneficial legislation and was aimed to protect employees whenever they meet accident resulting in disability, etc. and when they fall ill or to give maternity benefit, etc. The Directors of the Company were guilty of deducting contribution from the salary of the employees and not depositing the same with the respondent corporation. It was an offence under Section 85-A of the ESI Act and under Sections 406-407 of IPC. It is submitted that principal employer includes the Directors of a Company when company is a Private Limited Company and the petitioner being one of the Directors was responsible for payment of the contribution. It is also stated in the counter affidavit that the resignation of Mr. M.R Khanna was a fabricated document. Since the company was a family concern, fabrication of resignation was a device to play fraud. Mr. Ramesh Khanna who is stated to be sole responsible person is untraceable. The action of the respondent for recovery was being taken as per the provisions of the Act and there was no illegality. The recovery could be made from the employer even by arrest or detention in prison. The petitioner being a Director was one of the employers.

5. During the argument, it was vehemently argued by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that Director of a Private Limited Company cannot be the principal employer and cannot be responsible to pay contributions of ESI.

6. On the other hand it is contended by learned Counsel for the respondent that the petitioner was one of the Directors of a Private Limited Company, a family concern of petitioner and his son and it was father and son who had deducted the ESI contribution from the salary of the employees and not paid the same to the Corporation.

7. It is undisputed fact that Black Eye was a family company and only family members of petitioners were share holders and Directors of the company. The address of Mr. Ramesh Khanna, who is son of the petitioner given in all his earlier correspondence with ESI is the same as that of the petitioner i.e H-89, Lajpat Nagar. The Company had opened office at 169, Defence Colony, Flyover Market. In a Private Limited Company share holders are either close friends or family members. Its shares are held closely by a well knit group.

8. In this case also the Company was being run by this family in which father and son were Directors living under the same roof.

9. In Kapila Hingorani v. State of Bihar, 2003-III-LLJ 31, Supreme Court held as under:

“25. It is now well-settled that the corporate veil can in certain situations be pierced or lifted. The principles behind the doctrine is a changing concept and it is expanding its horizon as was held in the State of Uttar Pradesh v. Renusagar Power Company, AIR 1988 SC 1737 : (1988) 4 SCC 59. The ratio of the said decision clearly suggests that whenever a corporate entity is abused for an unjust and inequitable purpose, the Court would not hesitate to lift the veil and took into the realists so as to identify the persons who are guilty and liable therefore.

26. The proposition that a company although may have only one shareholder will be distinct juristic person as adumbrated in Industrial Salomon v. Salomon and Co., 1897 AC 22, has time and again been visited the application of doctrine of lifting the corporate veil in revenue and taxation matters [See Dal Chand v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Punjab, (1944) 12 ITR 458 and Juggilal Kamlapati v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1970 SC 529 : (1969) 2 SCC 376].

27. The corporate veil indisputably can be pierced when the corporate personality is found to be opposed to justice, convenience and interest of the revenue or workman or against public interest [See CIT Madras v. Meenakshi Mills Ltd., 1967 SCR 934); Workmen Employed in Associated Rubber Industry Ltd. v. Bhavnagar, AIR 1986 SC 1 : (1985) 4 SCC 114; New Horizons Ltd. v. Union of India, (1995) 1 SCC 478; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Renusagar Power Co. (supra), Hussainbhai, Calicut v. Alath Factory Thozhilai Union, Kozhikode, AIR 1978 SC 1410 : (1978) 4 SCC 257: 1978-II-LLJ-397 and Secretary, HSEB v. Suresh, AIR 1999 SC 1160 : (1999) 3 SCC 601 : 1999-I-LLJ-1086].

10. I consider that in the present case also the Court has to lift the corporate veil and find out the reality. The petitioner and his son along with other family members opened a security company. They employed poor persons as security guards and from their salaries they deducted ESI contribution. This ESI contribution was to be paid to ESI for the benefit of the employees. Instead of paying ESI contribution to the employees this amount was swallowed by the company i.e by its Directors. Father and son were living together when notices were issued to them to deposit the amount of poor employees. Son was not available at the house. Father did not provide address of the son who allegedly was the Managing Director of the company. Even during the arguments in the Court, the petitioner was asked to disclose his son's address but he stated that his son has separated from him and he does not know the address of his son. It is clear that the petitioner, on one hand, himself was not willing to deposit ESI contribution and took pleas of his old age, retirement from Government service, etc. and on the other hand was protecting his son from the authorities by not disclosing his address. I consider that both father and son were principal employers and equally responsible to deposit the amount jointly or severally. The plea taken by the petitioner that he was only a Director and not responsible for payment of the dues of ESI must fail.

11. The documents filed by the petitioner show that he was represented through his Advocate before the Recovery Officer and stated that since he had spent amount on house renovation, payment of income tax, house tax he was not able to pay instalments so time be granted to him. He did not take plea that his son alone was responsible for payment of the amount. The plea of principal employer and occupier taken by the petitioner is not applicable in respect of a home grown organization which does not run a factory but runs only business of providing security guards to the clients. In case of such a company where only security guards are hired and deputed at the places of the clients, there can be no occupier of the factory. In such companies, mostly the directors are handling the entire work with the help of one or two staff persons.

12. It must be remembered that where a private limited company after deducting the ESI contribution of the employees does not pay the amount to the corporation for benefit of the employees and directors do not take responsibility for the payment, the Court must curb this attitude and directors must be held responsible jointly and severely for payment of such dues. Court cannot allow unjust enrichment of directors at the cost of poor employees and the amount deducted from salaries of employees and legal contributions must be recovered from directors. Justice does not demand that the statute should be interpreted in a manner to defeat the claim of poor employees. Justice demands that where a private limited company held by the family members whose Directors are father and son, does not pay ESI dues, the father and son should be held responsible jointly and severely for the dues.

13. I consider that in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case it cannot be said that recovery proceedings against Mr. M.R Khanna, petitioner, were unjust or illegal. The petitioner cannot be allowed to take the shield that he was not the principal employer, and his son, who is not traceable was the principle employer. ESI Act is a social beneficial legislation meant to protect the interest of the working class and an interpretation which defeat the very purpose of the ESI Act cannot be adopted. The provisions of a statute must be so interpreted so as to advance its social economic objective.

14. I, therefore, consider that recovery proceeding against the petitioner were not illegal. I find no force in the writ petition. Writ petition stands dismissed.

Writ Petition dismissed.