Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohd. Saleem And Ors. v. Naseer Ahmed.

Delhi High Court
Oct 10, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applications CM Nos. 11177/2006 and 11178/2006 were filed to bring on record the legal heirs of the deceased respondent, who passed away on 10-9-2005. The fact of the respondent's demise was not known earlier and only came to light during the court proceedings, prompting an application for condonation of delay. The legal heirs were served but none appeared. The court condoned the delay and allowed the legal heirs to be brought on record, amending the memo of parties accordingly.

In CM (M) No. 580/2003, the petitioners filed a suit for declaration, mandatory injunction, and damages against the respondent, who was the petitioners' step-brother. The suit property had been purchased by the petitioners in 1992. The respondent was residing in the property without payment and refused to vacate upon request. Issues were framed in the suit, but before evidence was led, the petitioners sought to amend the plaint to include a relief for possession. The trial court disallowed this amendment by an order dated 20-5-2003.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in disallowing the amendment of the plaint to include the relief of possession after framing of issues but before commencement of trial.
  2. What constitutes the commencement of trial for the purpose of allowing or disallowing amendments under Order 6, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
  3. Whether the delay in bringing the legal heirs on record after the death of the respondent should be condoned.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought to amend the plaint to incorporate the relief of possession as the respondent was in possession of the suit property and they sought possession from him.
  • The amendment was accompanied by payment of court-fee on the relief of possession.
  • The petitioners contended that the trial had not commenced merely because issues were framed, and thus the amendment should be allowed.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The original respondent’s counsel stated he had no instructions from the legal representatives of the deceased respondent.
  • The legal representatives were served but failed to appear and were proceeded against ex parte.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mrs. Suneel Sodhi v. Mr. M. L. Sodhi, AIR 2004 Delhi 99 Commencement of trial is the date fixed for trial, not merely framing of issues. The court relied on this to hold that trial begins after framing of issues and fixing of trial dates.
Neelakandan Nair v. Parameswara Karup, 2008 (2) KLT 943 ‘Trial’ means the stage involving examination of witnesses and production of evidence after framing issues. Supported the view that trial does not commence at framing of issues but at the stage of evidence.
Indian Bank v. Maharashtra State Co-operative Marketing Federation Ltd., (1998) 5 SCC 69, AIR 1998 SC 1962 ‘Trial’ in narrow sense means final hearing including examination of witnesses and filing of documents. Followed to define ‘trial’ as the final hearing stage, not earlier procedural stages.
Harish Chandra Baipai v. Triloki Singh, AIR 1957 SC 444 Definition of trial as final hearing with evidence and arguments. Reaffirmed the narrow meaning of trial consistent with Indian Bank case.
Baldev Singh v. Manohar Singh, (2006) 6 SCC 498, AIR 2006 SC 2832 Proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC disallows amendments only after trial commencement narrowly defined. Held that trial had not commenced as parties had not filed documentary evidence and allowed amendment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the scope of Order 6, Rule 17 CPC, which allows amendment of pleadings at any stage before trial commencement, and disallows amendments only after trial has begun unless due diligence prevented earlier raising of the matter. The court examined the meaning of “trial” and distinguished framing of issues from the actual trial stage. It relied on authoritative precedents and legal dictionaries to conclude that trial begins with the final hearing involving examination of witnesses, filing of evidence, and arguments, not merely upon framing of issues.

Since in the present case the trial had not commenced in the narrow legal sense — as no evidence had been filed or witnesses examined — the court found the trial court erred in disallowing the amendment on the ground that issues had been framed. The court therefore set aside the impugned order and allowed the amendment application.

Regarding the applications to bring legal heirs on record, the court condoned the delay due to the respondent’s death being unknown earlier and allowed the legal heirs to be brought on record despite their non-appearance after service.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the applications to bring the legal heirs of the deceased respondent on record and condoned the delay in filing.

Further, the court set aside the trial court’s order disallowing the amendment of the plaint and allowed the petitioners’ application to amend the plaint to include the relief of possession.

The decision clarifies that the commencement of trial for the purpose of amendments under Order 6, Rule 17 CPC is to be understood narrowly as the stage involving examination of witnesses and filing of evidence, not the mere framing of issues. This interpretation preserves the discretion of courts to allow amendments before the actual trial begins, thereby facilitating determination of real questions in controversy.

No new precedent was set beyond the application and reiteration of existing principles as cited.

Show all summary ...

CM Nos. 11177/2006 and 11178/2006

These applications have been filed to bring on record the legal heirs of the deceased respondent who passed away on 10-9-2005. The legal heirs are set out in para 2 of the application. Since the factum of the demise of the respondent was not known earlier and only came to be known in the proceedings in Court the application has been filed for condonation of delay.

The legal heirs have been served but none has put an appearance.

For the reasons stated in the application, the delay in filing the application is condoned and the legal heirs as set out in the application are brought on record.

Applications are allowed.

Amended Memo of parties is taken on record.

CM (M) No. 580/2003

1. The petitioners filed a suit for declaration, mandatory injunction and damages against the respondent alleging that the respondent is the step-brother of the petitioners. The suit property is stated to have been purchased by the petitioners in the year 1992. The original respondent herein was stated to be residing gratis in the suit property but failed to vacate the same on being asked to do so. Issues were framed in the suit but before evidence cou ld be led, the petitioners filed an application seeking to amend the plaint to incorporate the relief of possession. This amendment has been disallowed by the impugned order dated 20-5-2003.

2. Learned counsel for the original respondent Mr. R. K. Saini s tates that he has no instructions on behalf of the legal representatives. The legal representatives have been served but have failed to enter appearance and are thus proceeded ex parte.

3. On hearing learned counsel for the petitioner, I am of the considered view that the trial Court failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in it by law while dismissing the application for amendment of the plaint in terms of the impugned order. The suit as originally framed also was for mandatory injunction but the petitioner rightly sought to incorporate the relief of possession by paying court-fee on the same since it is the case of the petitioner that the original respondent was in possession and the petitioner was seeking possession from the respondent. The only reason given by the trial Court for rejection of the amendment is that the application has been filed after framing of issues and that trial is a consequence of framing of issues. The framing of issues was treated as a stage of trial in the suit.

4. The relevant provision in this behalf reads as under :

“ORDER VI

PLEADINGS GENERALLY

17. Amendment of pleadings.— The Court may at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or amend his pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may be just, and all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties :

Provided that no application for amendment shall be allowed after the trial has commenced, unless the Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of the due diligence, the party could not have raised the matter before the commencement of trial.”

5. A perusal of the aforesaid provision shows that the Court has the discretion at any stage of the proceedings to allow alteration of pleadings but no application for amendment is to be allowed after the trial is commenced unless the Court comes to be conclusion that in spite of the due diligence the party could not have raised the matter before the commencement of trial.

6. Settlement of issues finds place under Order 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the said Code’). Rule 1 of Order 14 of the said Code provides that issues on all material proposition of fact or law would be framed. Rule 4 of Order 14 of the said code permits a Court to examine witnesses or documents before framing of issues to facilitate such framing of issues. The next stage in the contended suit is provided under Order 16 for summoning and attendance of witnesses. Order 18 provides for the hearing of the suit and examination of witnesses while Order 19 provides for filing of affidavits of evidence.

7. In my considered view, the stage of the trial only begins after the framing of issues when the directions are passed and a date fixed for filing of affidavits of evidence. In fact, a learned single Judge of this Court in Mrs. Suneel Sodhi v. Mr. M. L. Sodhi, AIR 2004 Delhi 99 while considering this plea has taken the dates of trial fixed as the commencement of the trial.

8. I am fortified in this view by the judgment of learned single Judge of the Kerala High Court in Neelakandan Nair v. Parameswara Karup, 2008 (2) KLT 943. It has been held in the said judgment that the expression ‘trial’ has been employed in the proviso to Rule 17 of Order 6 of the said Code only in what the Supreme Court described as the narrow sense of examination of witnesses, production of documents in evidence and all stage subsequent to the same. After issues are settled under Order 14 of the said Code, an opportunity is given to the parties to take what is only prescribed as pre-trial and then only the suit is listed for trial.

9. In Indian Bank v. Maharashtra State Co-operative Marketing Federation Ltd. (1998) 5 SCC 69 : (AIR 1998 SC 1962, the Supreme Court followed its earlier decision in Harish Chandra Baipai v. Triloki Singh, AIR 1957 SC 444 holding that in a limited sense, ‘trial’ means only the final hearing of a petition consisting of examination of witnesses, filing of documents and addressing of arguments.

10. The word ‘trial’ as described in Black's Law Dictionary (7th Edition) at page 1510 means :—

“Trial : A formal judicial examination of evidence and determination of legal claims in an adversary proceeding.”

11. Similarly according to Ballentine's Law Dictionary (2nd Edition), ‘trial’ means, “an examination before a competent tribunal, according to the law of the land, of the facts or law put in issue in a cause, for the purpose of determining such issue. When a Court hours and determines any issue of fact or the purpose of determining the right of the parties, it may be consideed a trial.”

12. In Words and Phrases, Volume 7B, Collate Commodore, it has been stated as under :—

“The beginning of an opening statement, or, if there is no opening stateent, the administering of the oath of affirmation to the first witness, or the introduction of any evidence, is the “commencement of trial” within statutory provision allowing a dismissal by plaintiff by written request to the clerk at any time before the actual “commencement of trial”.”

13. The matter is really no more res integra in view of the observations of the Apex Court. recently made in Baldev Singh v. Manohar Singh, (2006) 6 SCC 498 : AIR 2006 SC 2832.

“17. Before we part with this order, we may also notice that proviso to Order 6, Rule 17 CPC provides that amendment of pleadings shall not be allowed when the trial of the suit has already commenced. For this reason, we have examined the records and find that, in fact, the trial has not yet commenced. It appears from the records that the parties have yet to file their documentary evidence in the suit. From the record, it also appears that the suit was not on the verge of conclusion as found by the High Coufrt and the trial Court. That apart, commencement of trial as used in the proviso to Order 6, Rul 17 in the Code of Civil Procedure must be understood in the limited sense as meaning the final hearing of the suit, examination of witnesses, filing of documents and addressing of arguments. As noted herein before, parties are yet to file their documents, we do not find any reason to reject the application for amendment of the written statement in view of proviso to Order 6, Rule 17, CPC which confers wide power and unfettered discretion to the Court to allow an amendment of the written statement at any stage of the proceedings.”

14. The conspectus of the aforesaid pronouncements and definitions as to when a commencement of trial takes place leaves no manner of doubt that it refers to a stage after framing of issues and after the hiatus period thereafter where steps have to be taken to start the trial by examination of witnesses whether in the form of filing of affidavit or otherwise.

15. In view of the aforesaid position, it cannot be said that on framing of issues itself the trial has commenced and thus the proviso to Rule 17 of Order 6 of the said Code would come into play.

16. It is also to be seen that the nature of amendment is really one of couching relief in the appropriate form in which is ought to have been made.

17. The impugned order is accordingly set aside and the application filed by the petitioner is allowed.

18. The petition is accordingly allowed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

CM No. 1207/2003

No further directions are called for in this application and the same stands disposed of.

Petition allowed.